Animal models for studying homeopathy and high dilutions: Conceptual critical review

Introduction: This is a systematic review of the animal models used in studies of high dilutions. The objectives are to analyze methodological quality of papers and reported results, and to highlight key conceptual aspects of high dilution to suggest clues concerning putative mechanisms of action.

Methods: Papers for inclusion were identified systematically, from the Pubmed-Medline database, using ‘Homeopathy’ and ‘Animal’ as keywords. Only original full papers in English published between January 1999 and June 2009 were included, reviews, scientific reports, thesis, older papers, papers extracted from Medline using similar keywords, papers about mixed commercial formulas and books were also considered for discussion only. 31 papers describing 33 experiments were identified for the main analysis and a total of 89 items cited.

Results: Systematic analysis of the selected papers yielded evidence of some important intrinsic features of high dilution studies performed in animal models: a) methodological quality was generally adequate, some aspects could be improved; b) convergence between results and materia medica is seen in some studies, pointing toward to the possibility of systematic study of the Similia principle c) both isopathic and Similia models seem useful to understand some complex biological phenomena, such as parasite–host interactions; d) the effects of high dilutions seem to stimulate restoration of a ‘stable state’, as seen in several experimental models from both descriptive and mathematical points of view.

Keywords

Systematic review - animal - concepts - methodology - Similia principle - isopathy - steady state

• References

• 1 Walach H., Jonas W.B., Ives J., Van Wijk R., Weingärtner O. Research on homeopathy: state of the art. J Altern Complement Med 2005; 11 (05) 813-829.
• 2 Khuda-Bukhsh A.R. Laboratory research in homeopathy: pro. Integr Canc Ther 2006; 5 (04) 320-332.
• 3 Moffet J.R., Peethambaran A., Namboodiri M.A.A. Laboratory research in homeopathy: con. Integr Canc Ther 2006; 5 (04) 333-342.
• 4 Witt C.M., Bluth M., Albrecht H., Weibhuhn T.E.R., Baumgartner S., Willich S.N. The in vitro evidence for an effect of high homeopathic potencies – a systematic review of the literature. Complement Ther Med 2007; 15: 128-183.
• 5 Van Wijk R., Albrecht H. Classification of systems and methods used in biological basic research on homeopathy. Homeopathy 2007; 96: 247-251.
• 6 Van Wijk R., Albrecht H. Proving and therapeutic experiments in the HomBRex basic homeopathy research database. Homeopathy 2007; 96: 252-257.
• 7 Sukul N.C., Ghosh S., Sinhababu S.P., Sukul A. Strychnos nux-vomica extract and its ultra-high dilution reduce voluntary ethanol intake in rats. J Altern Complement Med 2001; 7 (02) 187-193.
• 8 Bertani S., Lussignoli S., Andrioli G., Bellavite P., Conforti A. Dual effects of a homeopathic mineral complex on carrageenan-induced oedema in rats. Br Homeopath J 1999; 88: 101-105.
• 9 Araújo Prado Neto J., Perazzo F.F., Cardoso L.G.V., Bonamin L.V., Tavares Carvalho J.C. Action of Causticum in inflammatory models. Homeopathy 2004; 93: 12-16.
• 10 Conforti A., Bellavite P., Bertani S., Chiarotti F., Menniti-Ippolito F., Raschetti R. Rat models of acute inflammation: a randomized controlled study on effects of homeopathic remedies. BMC Complement Altern Med 2007 10.1186/1472-6882-7-1.
• 11 Velkers F.C., te Loo A.J.H., Madin F., van Eck J.H.H. Isopathic and pluralist homeopathic treatment of commercial broilers with experimentally induced colibacillosis. Res Vet Sci 2005; 78: 77-83.
• 12 Berchieri Jr. A., Turco W.C.P., Paiva J.B., Oliveira G.H., Sterzo E.V. Evaluation of isopathic treatment of Salmonella enteritidis in poultry. Homeopathy 2006; 95: 4-97.
• 13 Lira-Salazar G., Marines-Montiel E., Torres-Monzón J., Hernández-Hernández F., Salas-Benito J.S. Effects of homeopathic medications Eupatorium perfoliatum and Arsenicum album on parasitemia of Plasmodium bergheiinfected mice. Homeopathy 2006; 95: 223-228.
• 14 Almeida L.R., Campos M.C.O., Herrera H.M., Bonamin L.V., Fonseca A.H. Effects of homeopathy in mice experimentally infected with Trypanosoma cruzi . Homeopathy 2008; 97: 65-69.
• 15 Banerjee P., Biswas S.J., Belon P., Khuda-Bukhsh A.R. A potentized homeopathic drug, Arsenicum album 200, can ameliorate genotoxicity induced by repeated injections of arsenic trioxide in mice. J Vet Med A 2007; 54: 370-376.
• 16 Banerjee P., Bhattacharyya S.S., Pathak S., Boujedaini N., Belon P., Khuda-Bukhsh A.R. Evidences of protective potentials of microdoses of ultra-high diluted arsenic trioxide in mice receiving repeated injections of arsenic trioxide. Evid Based Alternat Complement Med 2009 10.1093/ecam/nen090.
• 17 Carmine T.C. Effects of high potencies of tumor necrosis factor alpha on H2O2 production in cultured neuroblastoma cells by enhanced luminol-dependent chemiluminescence (ECL). Br Homeopath J 1997; 86: 67-72.
• 18 Siqueira CM. Alterações celulares induzidas por um novo bioterápico do tipo nosodio vivo sobre linhagens MDCK e J774.G8. Dissertation for Master of Science Graduation. Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2009.
• 19 Macedo S.B., Ferreira L.R., Perazzo F.F., Tavares Carvalho J.C. Anti-inflammatory activity of Arnica montana 6CH: preclinical study in animals. Homeopathy 2004; 93: 84-87.
• 20 Pinto S.A.G., Bohland E., Coelho C.P., Morgulis M.S.F.A., Bonamin L.V. An animal model for the study of Chamomilla in stress and depression: pilot study. Homeopathy 2008; 97: 141-144.
• 21 Bengston W.F., Moga M. Resonance, placebo effects and type II errors: some implications from healing research for experimental methods. J Altern Complement Med 2007; 13 (03) 317-327.
• 22 Fernandes G.A. Immunological stress in rats induces bodily alterations in saline-treated conspecifics. Physiol Behav 2000; 69: 221-230.
• 23 Coelho C.P., D´Almeida V., Pedrazzolli-Neto M. et al. Therapeutic and pathogenetic animal models for Dolichos pruriens . Homeopathy 2006; 95: 136-143.
• 24 Jonas W.B. Do homeopathic nosodes protect against infection? An experimental test. Altern Ther Health Med 1999; 5 (05) 36-40.
• 25 Werkman C., Senra G.S., Rocha R.F., Brandão A.A.H. Comparative therapeutic use of Risodronate and Calcarea phosphorica – allopathy versus homeopathy – in bone repair in castrated rats. Braz Oral Res 2006; 20 (03) 196-201.
• 26 Ruiz-Vega G., Pérez-Ordaz L., Cortés-Galván L., Juárez-G F.M. A kinetic approach to caffeine – Coffea cruda interaction. Homeopathy 2003; 92: 19-29.
• 27 Ruiz-Vega G., Poitevin B., Pérez-Ordaz L. Histamine at high dilution reduces spectral density in delta band in sleeping rats. Homeopathy 2005; 94: 86-91.
• 28 Datta S., Mallick P., Bukhsh A.R. Efficacy of a potentized homoeopathic drug (Arsenicum album-30) in reducing genotoxic effects produced by arsenic trioxide in mice: comparative studies of pre-, post- and combined pre- and post-oral administration and comparative efficacy of two microdoses. Complement Ther Med 1999; 7 (02) 62-75.
• 29 Datta S., Mallick P., Bukhsh A.R. Efficacy of a potentized homeopathic drug (Arsenicum album-30) in reducing genetoxic effects produced by arsenic trioxide in mice: II. Comparative efficacy of an antibiotic, actinomycin D alone and in combination with either of two microdoses. Complementary Therapy in Medicine 1999; 7 (03) 156-163.
• 30 Mitra K., Kundu S.N., Khuda Bukhsh A.R. Efficacy of a potentized homoeopathic drug (Arsenicum album-30) in reducing toxic effects produced by arsenic trioxide in mice: II. On alterations in body weight, tissue weight and total protein. Complementary Therapies in Medicine 1999; 7 (01) 24-34.
• 31 Kundu S.N., Mitra K., Khuda Bukhsh A.R. Efficacy of a potentized homeopathic drug (Arsenicum album 30) in reducing cytotoxic effects produced by arsenic trioxide in mice: III. Enzymatic changes and recovery of tissue damage in liver. Complementary Therapies in Medicine 2000; 8: 76-81.
• 32 Mallick P., Chakrabarti Mallick J., Guha B., Khuda-Bukhsh A.R. Ameliorating effect of microdoses of a potentized homeopathic drug, Arsenicum album, on arsenic-induced toxicity in mice. BMC Complement Altern Med 2003; 3: 7 On line http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6882/3/7.
• 33 Bonamin L.V., Martinho K.S., Nina A.L., Caviglia F., Do Rio R.G.W. Very high dilutions of dexamethasone inhibit its pharmacological effects in vivo . Br Homeopath J 2001; 90: 198-203.
• 34 Youbicier-Simo B.J., Boudard F., Guellati M., Mekaouche M., Baylé J.D., Bastide M. The role of the Bursa de Fabricius and highly dilute bursin in immunoendocrine interactions in the chickens. In: Bastide M. Signal and Images. 1997. Dordrecht: Kluwer; 121-148.
• 35 Walchli C., Baumgartner S., Bastide M. Effect of low doses and high homeopathic potencies in normal and cancerous human lymphocytes: an in vitro isopathic study. J Altern Complement Med 2006; 12 (05) 421-427.
• 36 Pedalino C.M.V., Perazzo F.F., Carvalho J.C.T., Martinho K.S., Massoco C.O., Bonamin L.V. Effect of Atropa belladonna and Echinacea angustifolia in homeopathic dilution on experimental peritonitis. Homeopathy 2004; 93: 193-198.
• 37 Santos A.L., Perazzo F.F., Cardoso L.G.V., Carvalho J.C.T. In vivo study of the anti-inflammatory effect of Rhus toxicodendron . Homeopathy 2007; 96: 95-101.
• 38 Bonamin L.V. Arnica Montana and behavior of connective tissue. In: Bonamin L.V. Signal and Images, Contributions and Contradictions about High Dilution Research. 2008. Dordrecht: Springer; 113-126.
• 39 Kuzeff R.M., Topashka-Ancheva M.N., Mecheva R.P. Inhibition of (-)-trans-(1S, 2S)-U50488 hydrochloride by its enantiomer in white mice – a placebo-controlled, randomized study. Forschende Komplementarmedizin Klass Naturheilkd 2004; 11 (03) 144-149.
• 40 Kuzeff R.M., Mecheva R.P., Topashka-Ancheva M.N. Inhibition of (-)-propanolol hydrochloride by its enantiomer in white mice – a placebo-controlled randomized study. Forschende Komplementarmedizin Klass Naturheilkd 2004; 11 (01) 14-19.
• 41 Zausner C., Lassnig H., Endler P.C. et al. Die Wirkung von “homöopathisch” zubereitetem thyroxin auf die metamorphose von hochlandamphibien – ergebnisse einer multizentrischen kontrollstudie. Perfusion 2002; 17: 268-276.
• 42 Welles S.U., Endler P.C., Scherer-Pongratz W. et al. Pretreatment with thyroxin 10e-8 and the effect of homeopathically prepared thyroxin 10⁻³⁰ on highland frogs – a multi researcher study. Forsch Komplementärmed/Res Compl Med 2007; 14: 353-357.
• 43 Weber S., Endler P.C., Welles S.U. et al. The effect of homeopathically prepared thyroxine on highland frogs: influence of electromagnetic fields. Homeopathy 2008; 97: 3-9.
• 44 Guedes J.R.P., Ferreira C.M., Guimarães H.M.B., Saldiva P.H.N., Capelozzi V.L. Homeopathically prepared dilution of Rana catesbeiana thyroid glands modifies its rate of metamorphosis. Homeopathy 2004; 93: 132-137.
• 45 Endler P.C., Lüdtke R., Heckmann C. et al. Pretreatment with thyroxine (10–8 parts by weight) enhances a curative effect of homeopathically prepared thyroxine (10–13) on lowland frogs. Forschende Komplementärmedizin Klass Naturheilkd 2003; 10: 137-142.
• 46 Ruiz-Vega G., Estevez-Salgado G. Non-linearity modeling of Ultra-dilutions: the histamine disturbances case. In: Bonamin L.V. Signal and Images, Contributions and Contradictions about High Dilution Research. 2008. Dordrecht: Springer; 67-82.
• 47 Jonas W., Lin Y., Tortella F. Neuroprotection from glutamate toxicity with ultra-low dose glutamate. Neuroreport 2001; 12 (02) 335-339.
• 48 Toledo R.L. Associação timulina – isoterápico de ciclofosfamida no tratamento de camundongos portadores de tumor de Ehrlich. Dissertation for Master of Science Graduation. Brazil: Universidade Paulista; 2005.
• 49 Zalla Neto R. Resposta linfóide e granulomatosa de camundongos inoculados com BCG frente ao tratamento com timulina ultradiluída. Dissertation for Master of Science Graduation. Universidade Paulista, Brazil, 2007.
• 50 Sato C. Desenvolvimento de frangos de corte tratados com timulina homeopática. Monograph in Veterinary Medicine. Brazil: Universidade Paulista; 2008.
• 51 Almeida N.T., D´Almeida V., Pustiglione M. The effect of fluorine and homeopathic medicines in rats fed cariogenic diet. Homeopathy 2004; 93: 138-143.
• 52 Ruiz-Vega G., Pérez-Ordaz L., Proa-Flores P., Aguilar- Diaz Y. An evaluation of Coffea cruda effect on rats. Br Homeopath J 2000; 89: 122-126.
• 53 Ruiz-Vega G., Perez-Ordaz L., Leon-Huéramo O., Cruz-Vázquez E., Sánchez-Diaz N. Comparative effect of Coffea cruda potencies on rats. Homeopathy 2002; 91: 80-84.
• 54 Meyer D.L. Rhythmical electrical events as indicators for biological actions of homeopathic remedies. Forschende Komplementärmed Klass Naturheilkd 1999; 6 (01) 37.
• 55 Lussignoli S., Bertani S., Metalmann H., Bellavite P., Conforti A. Effect of Traumeel S, a homeopathic formulation, on blood-induced inflammation in rats. Complement Ther Med 1999; 7 (04) 225-230.
• 56 Bastide M., Lagache A. Communication process: a new paradigm applied to high-dilution effects on the living body. Altern Ther Health Med 1997; 3 (04) 35-39.
• 57 Barbieri M. Introduction to Biosemiotics – the New Biological Synthesis. 2007. Dordrecht: Springer.;
• 58 Bonamin L.V., Lagache A., Bastide M. Research on ultra dilutions and the theory of corporeal signifiers: the follow up. In: Bonamin L.V. Signal and Images: Contributions and Contradictions about High Dilution Research. 2008. Dordrecht: Springer; 3-28.
• 59 Palermo C., Filanti C., Poggi S., Manduca P. Osteogenesis in vitro in rat tíbia-derived osteoblasts is promoted by the homeopathic preparation, FMS*Calciumfluor. Cell Biol Int 1999; 23 (01) 31-40.
• 60 Sukul N.C., Ghosh S., Sinhababu S.P. Reduction in the number of infective Trichinella spiralis larvae in mice by use of homeopathic drugs. Forschende Komplementärmed Klass Naturheilkd 2005; 12 (04) 202-205.
• 61 Pereira W.K.V., Lonardoni M.V.C., Grespan R., Caparroz-Assef S.M., Cuman R.K.N., Bersani-Amado C.A. Immunomodulatory effect of Canova medication on experimental Leishmania amazonensis infection. J Infect 2005; 51: 157-164.
• 62 Aleixo D.L., Ferraz F.N., Melo C.S., Gomes M.L., Toledo M.J., Kaneshima E.N., Bersani-Amado C.A., Araújo S.M. Changes of RAPD profile of Trypanosoma cruzi II with Canova and Benznidazole. Homeopathy 2008; 97: 59-64.
• 63 Sukul A., Sarkar P., Sinhababu S.P., Sukul N.C. Altered solution structure of alcoholic medium of potentized Nux vomica underlies its antialcoholic effect. Br Homeopath J 2000; 89 (02) 73-77.
• 64 Sukul A., Sinhababu S.P., Sukul N.C. Reduction of alcohol induced sleep time in albino mice by potentized Nux vomica prepared with 90% ethanol. Br Homeopath J 1999; 88 (02) 58-61.
• 65 Cristea A., Teodorescu-Negres S., Darie V. Chamomilla homeopathic diluition effect on central nervous system. In: Bastide M. Signals and Images. 1997. Dordrecht: Kluwer; 171-178.
• 66 Rocha M.P.S., Soares F.M., Martini L.C., Bonamin L.V. Behavior of rats treated with Rhus toxicodendron 200cH. International Journal of High Dilution Research 2008; 7 (22) 3-6.
• 67 Soares F.M. Atividade geral de ratos tratados com Bryonia alba 200CH. Monograph in Pharmacy. Brazil: Universidade de Santo Amaro; 2007.
• 68 Bellavite P., Magnani P., Zanolin M.E., Conforti A. Homeopathic doses of Gelsemium sempervirens improve the behavior of mice in response to novel environments. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 2009 10.1093/ecam/nep139.
• 69 Bousta D., Soulimani R., Jarmouni I. et al. Neurotropic immunological and gastric effects of low doses of Atropa belladonna L. Gelsemium sempervirens L and Poumon histamine in stressed mice. J Ethnopharmacol 2001; 74 (03) 205-215.
• 70 Venard C., Boujedaini N., Mensah-Nyagan A.G., Patte-Mensah C. Comparative analysis of Gelsemine and Gelsemium sempervirens activity on neurosteroid allopregnanolone formation in the spinal cord and limbic system. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 2009 10.1093/ecam/nep083.
• 71 Martinho K.S., Bento V.B., Benvenga G.U., Marcondes V.A., Bonamin L.V. Hepatic cell growth models for the study of ultra high dilutions. In: Bonamin L.V. Signal and Images: Contributions and Contradictions about High Dilution Research. 2008. Dordrecht: Springer; 83-96.
• 72 Bonamin L.V. Modulação da regeneração hepática por ultra-diluições de dexametasona: estudo histoquímico. Research Report. Brazil: Universidade Paulista; 2009.
• 73 Almeida J.D., Arisawa E.A.L., Balducci I., Rocha R.F., Carvalho Y.R. Homeopathic treatment for bone regeneration: experimental study. Homeopathy 2009; 98: 92-96.
• 74 Chakrabarti J., Biswas S.J., Khuda-Bukhsh A.R. Cytogenetical effects of sonication in mice and their modulations by actinomycin D and a homeopatic drug, Arnica 30. Indian J Exp Biol 2001; 39 (12) 1235-1242.
• 75 Biswas S.J., Khuda-Bukhsh A.R. Effect of a homeopathic drug, Chelidonium, in amelioration of p-DAB induced hepatocarcinogenesis in mice. BMC Complement Altern Med 2002 On line http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6882/2/4.
• 76 Biswas S.J., Khuda-Bukhsh A.R. Evaluation of protective potentials of a potentized homeopathic drug, Chelidonium majus, during azo dye induced hepatocarcinogenesis in mice. Indian J Exp Biol 2004; 42 (07) 698-714.
• 77 Biswas S.J., Pathak S., Bhattacharjee N., Das J.K., Khuda-Bukhsh A.R. Efficacy of the potentized homeopathic drug, Carcinosin 200, fed alone and combination with another drug, Chelidonium 200, in amelioration of p- Dimethylaminoazobenzene-induced hepatocarcinogenesis in mice. J Altern Complement Med 2005; 11 (05) 839-854.
• 78 Pathak S., Kumar Das J., Jyoti Biswas S., Khuda-Bukhsh A.R. Protective potentials of a potentized homeopathic drug, Lycopodium-30, in ameliorating azo dye induced hepatocarcinogenesis in mice. Mol Cell Biochem 2006; 285 (01/02) 121-131.
• 79 Pathak S., Bhattacharjee N., Das J.K. et al. Supportive evidence for the anticancerous potential of alternative medicine against hepatocarcinogenesis in mice. Forsch.Komplementarmed 2007; 14 (03) 148-156.
• 80 Thangapazham R.L., Gaddipati J.P., Rajeshkumar N.V. et al. Homeopathic medicines do not alter growth and gene expression in prostate and breast cancer cells in vitro . Integr Cancer Ther 2006 10.1177/1534735406294224.
• 81 MacLaughlin B.W., Gutsmuths B., Pretner E. et al. Effects of homeopathic preparations on human prostate cancer growth in cellular and animal models. Integr Cancer Ther 2006 10.1177/1534735406295350.
• 82 Es S., Kuttan G., Kuttan R. Effect of homeopathic medicines on transplanted tumors in mice. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev 2007; 8 (03) 390-394.
• 83 Preethi K.C., Kuttan G., Kuttan R. Anti-tumour activity of Ruta Graveolens extract. Asian Pacific J Cancer Prev 2006; 7: 439-443.
• 84 Kumar K.B., Sunila E.S., Kuttan G., Preethi K.C., Venugopal C.N., Kuttan R. Inhibition of chemically induced carcinogenesis by drugs used in homeopathic medicine. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev 2007; 8 (01) 98-102.
• 85 Sato D.Y., Wal R., Oliveira C.C. et al. Histopathological and immunophenotyping studies on normal and sarcoma 180-bearing mice treated with a complex homeopathic medication. Homeopathy 2005; 94 (01) 26-32.
• 86 Cristea A., Nicula S., Darie V. Pharmacodynamic effects of very high dilutions of Belladonna on the isolated rat duodenum. In: Bastide M. Signals and Images. 1997. Dordrecht: Kluwer; 161-170.
• 87 Brown V., Ennis M. Flow-cytometric analysis of basophil activation: inhibition by histamine at conventional and homeopathic concentrations. Inflamm Res 2001; 50 (Suppl. 02) S47-S48.
• 88 Lorenz I., Scheider E.M., Stolz P., Brack A., Strube J. Sensitive flow cytometric method to test basophil activation influenced by a homeopathic histamine dilutions. Forschende Komplementärmed Klass Naturheilkd 2003; 10: 316-324.
• 89 Chirumbolo S., Brizzi M., Ortolani R., Vella A., Bellavite P. Inhibition of CD203c membrane up-regulation in human basopils by high dilutions of histamine: a controlled replication study. Inflamm Res 2009; 58 (11) 755-764.