Plant-Based Antimicrobial Studies – Methods and Approaches to Study the Interaction between Natural Products

Abstract

The therapeutic value of synergistic interactions has been known since antiquity, and many different cultural healing systems still rely on this principle in the belief that combination therapy may enhance efficacy. This paper intends to provide an overview, from an antimicrobial perspective, on the research undertaken and interactive principles involved in pharmacognosy studies. Methods used to determine antimicrobial interactions include basic combination studies, the sum of the fractional inhibitory concentration index (ΣFIC), isobole interpretations, and death kinetic (time-kill) assays. The various interactions are discussed with reference to molecules, different plant parts or fractions, different plant species, and combinations with nonbotanical antimicrobial agents. It is recommended for future development in the field of phytosynergy that consideration should be given to the selection criteria for the two inhibitors. A more conservative approach should be adopted when classifying synergy. When examining interactions in plant-based studies, antagonistic interactions should not be ignored. Combinations involving more than two test samples should be examined where applicable, and very importantly, the mechanism of action of synergistic interactions should be given precedence. It is encouraging to observe the upsurge in papers exploring the complex interactions of medicinal plants, and undoubtedly this will become increasingly important in our continued quest to understand the mechanism of action of phytotherapy. The scientific validation of efficacious antimicrobial combinations could lead to patentable entities making research in the field of phytosynergy not only academically rewarding but also commercially relevant.

Key words

additive - antagonistic - synergistic - interactions - antimicrobial - plant

References

• 1 Shealy C N. The illustrated encyclopaedia of healing remedies. Australia; Element Books 1998
• 2 Li R C, Schentag J J, Nix D E. The fractional maximal effect method: a new way to characterize the effect of antibiotic combinations and other nonlinear pharmacodynamic interactions.  Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 1993;  37 523-531
• 3 Inui T, Wang Y, Deng S, Smith D C, Franzblau S G, Pauli G F. Counter-current chromatography based analysis of synergy in an anti-tuberculosis ethnobotanical.  J Chromatogr A. 2007;  1151 211-215
• 4 Cottarel G, Wierzbowski J. Combination drugs, an emerging option for antibacterial therapy.  Trends Biotechnol. 2007;  12 547-555
• 5 Chou T-C. Theoretical basis, experimental design, and computerized simulation of synergism and antagonism in drug combination studies.  Pharmacol Rev. 2006;  58 623-642
• 6 Wagner H. Multitarget therapy-the future of treatment for more than just functional dyspepsia.  Phytomedicine. 2006;  13 SV122-SV129
• 7 Biavatti M W. Synergy: an old wisdom, a new paradigm for pharmacotherapy.  Braz J Pharm Sci. 2009;  45 371-378
• 8 Ma X H, Zheng C J, Han L Y, Xie B, Jia J, Cao Z W, Li Y X, Chen Y Z. Synergistic therapeutic actions of herbal ingredients and their mechanisms from molecular interaction and network perspectives.  Drug Discov Today. 2009;  14 581-588
• 9 Berenbaum M C. What is synergy?.  Pharmacol Rev. 1989;  41 93-141
• 10 Odds F C. Synergy, antagonism, and what the chequerboard puts between them.  J Antimicrob Chemother. 2003;  52 1-3
• 11 Lambert R J W, Lambert R. A model for the efficacy of combined inhibitors.  J Appl Microbiol. 2003;  95 734-743
• 12 Johnson M D, MacDougall C, Ostrosky-Zeichner L, Perfect J R, Rex J H. Combination antifungal therapy.  Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2004;  48 693-715
• 13 Bell A. Antimalarial drug synergism and antagonism: mechanistic and clinical significance.  FEMS Microbiol Lett. 2005;  253 171-184
• 14 ESCMID . Terminology relating to methods for the determination of susceptibility of bacteria to antimicrobial agents. The European Society of Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases Eucast Definitive document E.Def 1.2.  CMI. 2000;  6 503-515
• 15 Williamson E M. Synergy and other interactions in phytomedicines.  Phytomedicine. 2001;  8 401-409
• 16 White R L, Burgess D S, Manduru M, Bosso J A. Comparison of three different in vitro methods of detecting synergy: time-kill, checkerboard and Etest.  Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 1996;  40 1914-1918
• 17 Wu M, Woolson R F. A comparison of several tests for drug synergy.  Commun Statist Simula. 1998;  27 303-327
• 18 Bonapace C R, White R L, Friedrich L V, Basso J A. Evaluation of antibiotic synergy against Acinetobacter baumannii: a comparison with Etest, time-kill and checkerboard methods.  Diagn Micro Infect Dis. 2000;  38 43-50
• 19 Lewis R E, Diekema D J, Messer S A, Pfaller M A, Klepser M E. Comparison of Etest, chequerboard dilution and time-kill studies for the detection of synergy or antagonism between antifungal agents tested against Candida species.  J Antimicrob Chemother. 2002;  49 345-351
• 20 Ryan R W, Kwasnik I, Tilton R C. Methodological variation in antibiotic synergy test against enterococci.  J Clin Microbiol. 1981;  13 73-75
• 21 Paull A, Marks J. A new method for the determination of bactericidal antibiotic synergy.  J Antimicrob Chemother. 1987;  20 831-838
• 22 Rand K H, Houck H J, Brown P, Bennett D. Reproducibility of the microdilution checkerboard method for antibiotic synergy.  Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 1993;  37 613-615
• 23 Mackay M L, Milne K, Gould I M. Comparison of methods for assessing synergistic antibiotic interactions.  Int J Antimicrob Agents. 2000;  15 125-129
• 24 White D B, Faessel H M, Slocum H K, Khinkis L, Greco W R. Nonlinear response surface and mixture experiment methodologies applied to the study of synergism.  Biom J. 2004;  46 56-71
• 25 Tallarida R J. An overview of drug combination analysis with isobolograms.  J Pharmacol Exp Ther. 2006;  319 1-7
• 26 Boucher A N, Tam V H. Mathematical formulation of additivity for antimicrobial agents.  Diagn Micro Infect Dis. 2006;  55 319-325
• 27 Tam V H, Schilling A N, Nikolaou M. Modelling time-kill studies to discern the pharmacodynamics of meropenem.  J Antimicrob Chemother. 2005;  55 699-706
• 28 Jain S R, Kar A. The antibacterial activity of some essential oils and their combinations.  Planta Med. 1971;  20 118-123
• 29 Geda A K. Antibacterial activity of essential oils and their combinations.  Fat Sci Technol. 1995;  12 458-460
• 30 Sato M, Tanaka H, Yamaguchi R, Kato K, Etoh H. Synergistic effects of mupirocin and an isoflavanone isolated from Erythrina variegata on growth and recovery of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus.  Int J Antimicrob Agents. 2004;  24 241-246
• 31 Braga L C, Leite A A M, Xavier K G S, Takahashi J A, Bemquerer M P, Chartone-Souza E, Nascimento A M A. Synergistic interaction between pomegranate extract and antibiotics against Staphylococcus aureus.  Can J Microbiol. 2005;  51 541-547
• 32 Lee Y S, Kang O H, Choi J G, Oh Y C, Chae H S, Kim J H, Park H, Sohn D H, Wang Z-T, Kwon D Y. Synergistic effects of the combination of galangin with gentamicin against methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus.  J Microbiol. 2008;  46 283-288
• 33 Van Vuuren S F, du Toit L C, Parry A, Pillay V, Choonara Y E. Encapsulation of essential oils within a polymeric liposomal formulation for enhancement of antimicrobial efficacy.  Nat Prod Commun. 2010;  5 1401-1408
• 34 Christoph F, Stahl-Biskup E. Death kinetics of Staphylococcus aureus, exposed to commercial tea tree oils.  J Essent Oil Res. 2001;  13 98-102
• 35 Viljoen A M, van Vuuren S F, Ernst E, Klepser M, Demirci B, Başer K H C, van Wyk B E. Osmitopsis asteriscoides (Asteraceae) – the antimicrobial activity and essential oil composition of a Cape-Dutch remedy.  J Ethnopharmacol. 2003;  88 137-143
• 36 Lin Y T, Labbe R G, Shetty K. Inhibition of Vibrio parahaemolyticus in seafood systems using oregano and cranberry phytochemical synergies and lactic acid.  Innovat Food Sci Emerg Technol. 2005;  6 453-458
• 37 Viljoen A M, van Vuuren S F, Gwebu L, Demirci B, Başer K H C. The geographical variation and antimicrobial activity of African Wormwood (Artemisia afra Jacq.) essential oil.  J Essent Oil Res. 2006;  18 19-25
• 38 Apostolidis E, Kwon Y I, Shetty K. Inhibition of Listeria monocytogenes by oregano, cranberry and sodium lactate combination in broth and cooked ground beef systems and likely mode of action through proline metabolism.  Int J Food Microbiol. 2008;  128 317-324
• 39 Kamatou G P P, Viljoen A M, van Vuuren S F. In vitro evidence of antimicrobial synergy between Salvia chamelaeagnea and Leonotis leonurus.  S Afr J Bot. 2006;  72 634-636
• 40 Van Vuuren S F. The antimicrobial activity and essential oil composition of medicinal aromatic plants used in African traditional healing [PhD thesis]. South Africa; University of the Witwatersrand 2007
• 41 Van Vuuren S F, Viljoen A M. In vitro evidence of phyto-synergy for plant part combinations of Croton gratissimus (Euphorbiaceae) used in African traditional healing.  J Ethnopharmacol. 2008;  119 700-704
• 42 Iten F, Saller R, Abel G, Reichling J. Additive antimicrobial effects of the active components of the essential oil of Thymus vulgaris-chemotype carvacrol.  Planta Med. 2009;  75 1-6
• 43 Romano C, Abadi K, Repetto V, Vojnov A A, Moreno S. Synergistic antioxidant and antibacterial activity of rosemary plus butylated derivatives.  Food Chem. 2009;  115 456-461
• 44 Janssen A M, Scheffer J J C, Svendsen A B. Antimicrobial activity of essential oils: a 1976–1986 literature review. Aspects of the test methods.  Planta Med. 1987;  53 395-398
• 45 Hewitt W, Vincent S. Theory and application of microbiological assay. London; Academic Press (Inc.) 2003
• 46 Eloff J N. A sensitive and quick microplate method to determine the minimal inhibitory concentration of plant extracts for bacteria.  Planta Med. 1998;  64 711-713
• 47 NCCLS .Methods for dilution antimicrobial susceptibility tests for bacteria, 6th edition. Wayne; Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute 2003
• 48 Beale A S, Sutherland R. Measurement of combined antibiotic action in antibiotics: Assessment of antimicrobial activity and resistance. London, UK; Academic Press (Inc.) 1983
• 49 Dufour M, Simmonds R S, Bremer P J. Development of a method to quantify in vitro the synergistic activity of “natural” antimicrobials.  Int J Food Microbiol. 2003;  85 249-258
• 50 Berenbaum M C. A method for testing for synergy with any number of agents.  J Infect Dis. 1978;  137 122-130
• 51 Critchley I A, Sahm D F, Kelly L J, Karlowsky J A. In vitro synergy studies using aztreonam and fluoroquinolone combinations against six species of Gram-negative bacilli.  Chemotherapy. 2003;  49 44-48
• 52 Santiesteban-López A, Palou E, López-Malo A. Susceptibility of food-borne bacteria to binary combinations of antimicrobials at selected a(w) and pH.  J Appl Microbiol. 2007;  102 486-497
• 53 Schelz Z, Molnar J, Hohmann J. Antimicrobial and antiplasmid activities of essential oils.  Fitoterapia. 2006;  77 279-285
• 54 Netikul T, Leelaporn A, Leelarasmee A, Kiratisin P. In vitro activities of fosfomycin and carbapenem combinations against carbapenem non-susceptible Escherichia coli and Klebsiella pneumoniae.  Int J Antimicrob Agents. 2010;  35 609-610
• 55 De Oliveira C E V, Stamford T L M, Neto N J G, de Souza E L. Inhibition of Staphylococcus aureus in broth and meat broth using synergies of phenolics and organic acids.  Int J Food Microbiol. 2010;  137 312-316
• 56 Berenbaum M C. Correlations between methods for measurements of synergy.  J Infect Dis. 1980;  142 476-478
• 57 Acar J F. Antibiotic synergy and antagonism. Antibiotic therapy.  Med Clin N Am. 2000;  84 1391-1406
• 58 Harris R. Synergism in the essential oil world.  Int J Aromather. 2002;  12 179-186
• 59 Pattnaik S, Subramanyam V R, Bapaji M, Kole C R. Antibacterial and antifungal activity of aromatic constituents of essential oils.  Microbiology. 1997;  89 39-46
• 60 Lachowicz K J, Jones G P, Briggs D R, Bienvenu F E, Wan J, Wilcock A, Coventry M J. The synergistic preservative effects of the essential oils of sweet basil (Ocimum basilicum L.) against acid-tolerant food microflora.  Lett Appl Microbiol. 1998;  26 209-214
• 61 Pina-Vaz C, Gonçalves Rodrigues A, Pinto E, Costa-de-Oliveira S, Tavares C, Salgueiro L, Cavaleiro C, Gonçalves M J, Martinez-de-Oliveira J. Antifungal activity of Thymus oils and their major compounds.  J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2004;  18 73-78
• 62 Michiels J, Missotten J, Fremaut D, De Smet S, Dierick N. In vitro dose-response of carvacrol, thymol, eugenol and trans-cinnamaldehyde and interaction of combinations for the antimicrobial activity against the pig gut flora.  Livest Sci. 2007;  109 157-160
• 63 Van Zyl R, Seatlholo S T, van Vuuren S F, Viljoen A M. Pharmacological interactions of essential oil constituents on the viability of micro-organisms.  Nat Prod Commun. 2010;  5 1381-1386
• 64 Tzakou O, Pitarokili D, Chinou I O, Harvala C. Composition and antimicrobial activity of the essential oil of Salvia ringens.  Planta Med. 2001;  67 81-83
• 65 Aggarwal K K, Khanuja S P S, Ahmad A, Kumar T R S, Gupta V K, Kumar S. Antimicrobial activity profiles of the two enantiomers of limonene and carvone isolated from the oils of Mentha spicata and Anethus sowa.  Flavour Fragr J. 2002;  17 59-63
• 66 Setzer W, Vogler B, Schmidt J, Leahy J, Rives R. Antimicrobial activity of Artemisia douglasiana leaf essential oil.  Fitoterapia. 2004;  75 192-200
• 67 Jirovetz L, Buchbauer G, Denkova Z, Stoyanova A, Murgov I, Schmidt E, Geissler M. Antimicrobial testings and gas chromatographic analysis of pure oxygenated monoterpenes 1,8-cineole, α-terpineol, terpinin-4-ol and camphor as well as target compounds in essential oils of pine (Pinus pinaster), rosemary (Rosmarinus officinalis), tea tree (Melaleuca alternifolia).  Sci Pharm. 2005;  73 27-39
• 68 Bakkali F, Averbeck S, Averbeck D, Idaomar M. Biological effects of essential oils – A review.  Food Chem Toxicol. 2008;  46 446-475
• 69 Radulović N, Mišić M, Aleksić J, Doković D, Palić R, Stojanović G. Antimicrobial synergism and antagonism of salicylaldehyde in Filipendula vulgaris essential oil.  Fitoterapia. 2007;  78 565-570
• 70 Chalchat J C, Garry R. Correlation between chemical composition and antimicrobial activity. VI. Activity of some African essential oils.  J Essent Oil Res. 1997;  9 67-75
• 71 Yen T-B, Chang S-T. Synergistic effects of cinnamaldehyde in combination with eugenol against wood decay fungi.  Bioresour Technol. 2008;  99 232-236
• 72 Dilika F, Bremner P D, Meyer J J M. Antibacterial activity of linoleic- and oleic acid isolated from Helichrysum pedunculatum, a plant used during circumcision rites.  Fitoterapia. 2000;  71 450-452
• 73 Galindo L A, Pultrini Ad M, Costa M. Biological effects of Ocimum gratissimum L. are due to synergic action among multiple compounds present in essential oil.  J Nat Med. 2010;  64 436-441
• 74 Tyler V E. Phytomedicines: back to the future.  J Nat Prod. 1999;  62 1589-1592
• 75 Watt J M, Breyer-Brandwijk M G. The medicinal and poisonous plants of southern and eastern Africa, 2nd edition. London, UK; Livingstone 1962
• 76 Hutchings A, Scott A H, Lewis G, Cunningham A B. Zulu medicinal plants – an inventory. Pietermaritzburg, South Africa; University of Natal Press 1996
• 77 Van Wyk B E, van Oudtshoorn B, Gericke N. Medicinal plants of South Africa. Pretoria, South Africa; Briza 1997
• 78 Von Koenen E. Medicinal poisonous and edible plants in Namibia. Windhoek, Namibia; Klaus Hess 2001
• 79 Ngwenya M A, Koopman A, Williams R. Zulu botanical knowledge: An introduction. Durban, South Africa; National Botanical Institute 2003
• 80 Caceres A, Alvarez A V, Ovando A E, Samayoa B E. Plants used in Guatemala for the treatment of respiratory diseases. Screening of 68 plants against gram-positive bacteria.  J Ethnopharmacol. 1991;  31 193-208
• 81 Vlietinck A J, van Hoof L, Totté J, Lasure A, van den Berghe D, Rwangabo P C, Mvukiyumwami J. Screening of hundred Rwandese medicinal plants for antimicrobial and antiviral properties.  J Ethnopharmacol. 1995;  46 31-47
• 82 Rabe T, van Staden J. Antibacterial activity of South African plants used for medicinal purposes.  J Ethnopharmacol. 1997;  56 81-87
• 83 Lin J, Opoku A R, Geheeb-Keller M, Hutchings A D, Terblanche S E, Jäger A K, van Staden J. Preliminary screening of some traditional Zulu medicinal plants for anti-inflammatory and anti-microbial activities.  J Ethnopharmacol. 1999;  68 267-274
• 84 Drewes S E, Khan F, van Vuuren S F, Viljoen A M. Simple 1, 4-benzoquinones with antibacterial activity from stems and leaves of Gunnera perpensa.  Phytochemistry. 2005;  66 1812-1816
• 85 Eldeen I M S, Elgorashi E E, van Staden J. Antibacterial, anti-inflammatory, anti-cholinesterase and mutagenic effects of extracts obtained from some trees used in South African traditional medicine.  J Ethnopharmacol. 2005;  102 457-464
• 86 Kamatou G P P, van Zyl R L, Davids H, van Vuuren S F, Viljoen A M. Synergistic and antagonistic interactions of essential oils on the biological activities of the solvent extracts from three Salvia species.  Nat Prod Commun. 2008;  3 1111-1115
• 87 Van Vuuren S F, Viljoen A M. Interaction between the non-volatile and volatile fractions on the antimicrobial activity of Tarchonanthus camphoratus.  S Afr J Bot. 2009;  75 505-509
• 88 Lee O H, Lee B Y. Antioxidant and antimicrobial activities of individual and combined phenolics in Olea europaea leaf extract.  Bioresour Technol. 2010;  101 3751-3754
• 89 Chung I, Kwon S H, Shim S T, Kyung K H. Synergistic anti-yeast activity of garlic oil and allyl alcohol derived from alliin in garlic.  J Food Sci. 2007;  72 437-440
• 90 Van Vuuren S F, Viljoen A M, van Zyl R L, van Heerden F R, Başer K H C. The antimicrobial, antimalarial and toxicity profiles of helihumulone, leaf essential oil and extracts of Helichrysum cymosum (L.) D. Don subsp. cymosum.  S Afr J Bot. 2006;  72 287-290
• 91 Van Vuuren S F. Antimicrobial activity of South African medicinal plants.  J Ethnopharmacol. 2008;  119 462-472
• 92 Lalli J Y, Viljoen A M, van Vuuren S F. Potential interaction between the volatile and non-volatile fractions on the in vitro antimicrobial activity of three South African Pelargonium (Geraniaceae) species.  Nat Prod Commun. 2010;  5 1401-1408
• 93 Cano J H, Volpato G. Herbal mixtures in the traditional medicine of eastern Cuba.  J Ethnopharmacol. 2004;  90 293-316
• 94 Al-Bayati F A. Synergistic antibacterial activity between Thymus vulgaris and Pimpinella anisum essential oils and methanol extracts.  J Ethnopharmacol. 2008;  116 403-406
• 95 Cassella S, Cassella J P, Smith I. Synergistic antifungal activity of tea tree (Melaleuca alternifolia) and lavender (Lavandula angustifolia) essential oils against dermatophyte infection.  Int J Aromather. 2002;  12 2-14
• 96 Thring T S A, Weitz F M. Medicinal plant use in the Bredasdorp/Elim region of the southern Overberg in the Western Cape Province of South Africa.  J Ethnopharmacol. 2006;  103 261-275
• 97 Van Wyk B E. A broad review of commercially important southern African medicinal plants.  J Ethnopharmacol. 2008;  119 342-355
• 98 Van Wyk B E, Gericke N. People's plants. A guide to useful plants of southern Africa, 1st edition. Pretoria, South Africa; Briza 2000
• 99 Suliman S, van Vuuren S F, Viljoen A M. Validating antimicrobial combination therapy in African traditional medicines-a case for Artemisia afra.  S Afr J Bot. 2010;  76 655-661
• 100 Hsieh P C, Mau J L, Huang S H. Antimicrobial effect of various combinations of plant extracts.  Food Microbiol. 2001;  18 35-43
• 101 Delaquis P J, Stanich K, Girard B, Mazza G. Antimicrobial activity of individual and mixed fractions of dill, cilantro, coriander and eucalyptus essential oils.  Int J Food Microbiol. 2002;  74 101-109
• 102 Gutierrez J, Barry-Ryan C, Bourke P. Antimicrobial activity of plant essential oils using food model media: efficacy, synergistic potential and interactions with food components.  Food Microbiol. 2009;  26 142-150
• 103 Vattem D A, Lin Y T, Ghaedian R, Shetty K. Cranberry synergies for dietary management of Helicobacter pylori infections.  Process Biochem. 2005;  40 1583-1592
• 104 Fu Y J, Zu Y G, Chen L Y, Shi X G, Wang Z, Sun S, Efferth T. Antimicrobial activity of clove and rosemary essential oils alone and in combination.  Phytother Res. 2007;  21 989-994
• 105 Ubalua A O, Oti E. Evaluation of antimicrobial properties of some medicinal plants for fresh cassava roots preservation.  Pakistan J Nutr. 2008;  7 679-681
• 106 Gutierrez J, Barry-Ryan C, Bourke P. The antimicrobial efficacy of plant essential oil combinations and interactions with food ingredients.  Int J Food Microbiol. 2008;  124 91-97
• 107 Kang R, Helms R, Stout M J, Jaber H, Chen Z, Nakatzu T. Antimicrobial activity of the volatile constituents of Perilla frutescens and its synergistic effects with polygodial.  J Agric Food Chem. 1992;  40 2328-2330
• 108 Himejima M, Kubo I. Antimicrobial agents from Licaria puchuri-major and their synergistic effect with polygodial.  J Nat Prod. 1992;  55 620-625
• 109 Stermitz F R, Lorenz P, Tawara J N, Zenewicz L A, Lewis K. Synergy in a medicinal plant: antimicrobial action of berberine potentiated by 5′-methoxyhydnocarpin, a multidrug pump inhibitor.  Appl Biol Sci. 2000;  97 1433-1437
• 110 Zhao F R, Maoa H P, Zhang H, Hua L M, Wanga H, Wang Y F, Yanagihara N, Gao X M. Antagonistic effects of two herbs in Zuojin Wan, a traditional Chinese medicine formula, oncatecholamine secretion in bovine adrenal medullary cells.  Phytomedicine. 2010;  17 659-668
• 111 Van Vuuren S F, Suliman S, Viljoen A M. The antimicrobial activity of four commercial essential oils in combination with conventional antimicrobials.  Lett Appl Microbiol. 2009;  48 440-446
• 112 Cuzzolin L, Zaffani S, Benoni G. Safety implications regarding use of phytomedicines.  Eur J Clin Pharmacol. 2006;  62 37-42
• 113 Lee Y S, Han C H, Kang S H, Lee S-J, Kim S W, Shin O R, Sim Y C, Lee S J, Cho Y H. Synergistic effect between catechin and ciprofloxacin on chronic bacterial prostatis rat model.  Int J Urol. 2005;  12 383-389
• 114 Kurita N, Koike S. Synergistic antimicrobial effect of ethanol, sodium chloride, acetic acid and essential oil components.  Agric Biol Chem. 1983;  47 67-75
• 115 Tunc S, Chollet E, Chalier P, Preziosi-Belloy L, Gontard N. Combined effect of volatile antimicrobial agents on the growth of Penicillium notatum.  Int J Food Microbiol. 2007;  113 263-270
• 116 Nostro A, Cannatelli M A, Morelli I, Cioni P L, Bader A, Marino A, Alonzo V. Preservative properties of Calamintha officinalis essential oil with and without EDTA.  Lett Appl Microbiol. 2002;  35 385-389
• 117 Gibbons S. Plants as a source of bacterial resistance modulators.  Phytochem Rev. 2005;  4 63-78
• 118 Fujimura S, Takane H, Nakano Y, Watanabe A. In vitro synergy studies based on tazobactam/piperacillin against clinical isolates of metallo-beta-lactamase-producing Pseudomonas aeruginosa.  J Antimicrob Chemother. 2009;  64 1115-1116
• 119 Ednie L M, Credito K L, Khantipong M, Jacobs M R, Appelbaum P C. Synergic activity, for anaerobes, of trovafloxacin with clindamycin or metronidazole: chequerboard and time-kill methods.  J Antimicrob Chemother. 2000;  45 633-638
• 120 Gilbert B, Alves L F. Synergy in plant medicines.  Curr Med Chem. 2003;  10 13-20
• 121 Wagner H, Ulrich-Merzenich G. Synergy research: approaching a new generation of phytopharmaceuticals.  Phytomedicine. 2009;  16 97-110
• 122 Hemaiswarya S, Kruthiventi A K, Doble M. Synergism between natural products and antibiotics against infectious diseases.  Phytomedicine. 2008;  15 639-652
• 123 Yamazaki K, Yamamoto T, Kawai Y, Inoue N. Enhancement of antilisterial activity of essential oils constituents by nisin and diglycerol fatty acid ester.  Food Microbiol. 2004;  21 283-289
• 124 Rios J L, Recio M. Medicinal plants and antimicrobial activity.  J Ethnopharmacol. 2005;  100 80-84
• 125 Hendry E R, Worthington T, Conway B R, Lambert P A. Antimicrobial efficacy of eucalyptus oil and 1,8-cineole alone and in combination with chlorhexidine digluconate against microorganisms grown in planktonic and biofilm cultures.  J Ethnopharmacol. 2009;  64 1219-1225
• 126 Filoche S K, Soma K, Sissons C H. Antimicrobial effects of essential oils in combination with chlorhexidine digluconate.  Oral Microbiol Immun. 2005;  20 221-225
• 127 Karpanen T J, Worthington T, Hendry E R, Conway B R, Lambert P A. Antimicrobial efficacy of chlorhexidine digluconate alone and in combination with eucalyptus oil, tea tree oil and thymol against planktonic and biofilm cultures of Staphylococcus epidermidis.  J Ethnopharmacol. 2008;  62 1031-1036
• 128 Walencka E, Rozalska S, Wysokinska H, Rozalski M, Kuzma L, Rozalska B. Salvipisone and aethiopinone from Salvia sclarea hairy roots modulate staphylococcal antibiotic resistance and express anti-biofilm activity.  Planta Med. 2007;  73 545-551
• 129 Berenbaum M C. The expected effect of a combination of agents: the general solution.  J Theor Biol. 1985;  114 413-431
• 130 Greco W R, Bravo G, Parsons J C. The search for synergy: A critical review from a response surface perspective.  Pharmacol Rev. 1995;  47 332-382
• 131 Burfield T, Reekie S-L. Mosquitoes, malaria and essential oils.  Int J Aromather. 2005;  15 30-41
• 132 Lambert R J W, Johnston M D, Hanlon G W, Denyer S P. Theory of antimicrobial combinations: biocide mixtures – synergy or addition?.  J Appl Microbiol. 2003;  94 747-759
• 133 Kerry D W, Hamilton-Miller J M T, Brumfitt W. Trimethoprim and rifampicin: in vitro activities separately and in combination.  J Antimicrob Chemother. 1975;  1 417-427
• 134 Norden C W, Wentzel H, Keleti E. Comparison of techniques for measurements of in vitro antibiotic synergism.  J Infect Dis. 1979;  140 629-633
• 135 Eliopoulos G M, Moellering Jr R C. Antimicrobial combinations. Antibiotics in laboratory medicine, 3rd edition. Baltimore; Williams and Wilkins 1991
• 136 Moody J A. Synergism testing: Broth microdilution checkerboard and broth microdilution. In: Isenberg HD, editor. Clinical microbiology procedures handbook, 1st edition. Washington, DC.  American Society for Microbiology. 2003;  18 1-28
• 137 Krishnan-Natesan S, Chandrasekar P H, Manavathu E K, Revankar S G. Successful treatment of primary cutaneous Aspergillus ustus infection with surgical debridement and a combination of voriconazole and terbinafine.  Diagn Microbiol Infect Dis. 2008;  62 443-446
• 138 Goñi P, López P, Sánchez C, Gómez-Lus R, Becerril R, Nerín C. Antimicrobial activity in the vapour phase of a combination of cinnamon and clove essential oils.  Food Chem. 2009;  116 982-989
• 139 Suresh B, Sriram S, Dhanaraj S A, Elango K, Chinnaswamy K. Anticandidal activity of Santolina chamaecyparissus volatile oil.  J Ethnopharmacol. 1997;  55 151-159
• 140 Shin S, Kang C A. Antifungal activity of the essential oil of Agastache rugosa Kuntze and its synergism with ketoconazole.  Lett Appl Microbiol. 2003;  36 111-115
• 141 Ibezim E C, Esimone C O, Nnamani P O, Onyishi I V, Brown S A, Obodo C E. In vitro study of the interaction between some fluoroquinolones and extracts of kola nitida seed.  Afr J Biotechnol. 2006;  5 1781-1784
• 142 Ali N H, Kazmi S U, Faizi S. Activity of synergistic combination Amoxy-cassia against Salmonella.  Pakistan J Pharm Sci. 2007;  20 140-145
• 143 Shin S. Anti-Aspergillus activities of plant essential oils and their combination effects with ketoconazole or amphotericin B.  Arch Pharm Res. 2003;  26 389-393
• 144 Rosato A, Vitali C, De Laurentis N, Armenise D, Milillo M A. Antibacterial effect of some essential oils administered alone or in combination with norfloxacin.  Phytomedicine. 2007;  14 727-732
• 145 Pyun M S, Shin S. Antifungal effects of the volatile oils from Allium plants against Trichophyton species and synergism of the oils with ketoconazole.  Phytomedicine. 2006;  13 394-400
• 146 Sakagami Y, Iinuma M, Piyasena K G, Dharmaratne H R. Antibacterial activity of α-mangostin against vancomycin resistant Enterococci (VRE) and synergism with antibiotics.  Phytomedicine. 2005;  12 203-208
• 147 Al-hebshi N, Al-haroni M, Skaug N. In vitro antimicrobial and resistance-modifying activities of aqueous crude khat extracts against oral microorganisms.  Arch Oral Biol. 2006;  51 183-188
• 148 Yang Z C, Wang B C, Yang X S, Wang Q, Ran L. The synergistic activity of antibiotics combined with eight traditional Chinese medicines against two different strains of Staphylococcus aureus.  Colloids Surf B Biointerfaces. 2005;  41 79-81
• 149 Cha J D, Jeong M R, Jeong S I, Lee K Y. Antibacterial activity of sophoraflavanone G isolated from the roots of Sophora flavescens.  J Microbiol Biotechnol. 2007;  17 858-864
• 150 Ahmed I, Aqil F. In vitro efficacy of bioactive extracts of 15 medicinal plants against ESβL-producing multidrug-resistant enteric bacteria.  Microbial Res. 2007;  162 264-275
• 151 Rosato A, Vitali C, Gallo D, Balenzano L, Mallamaci R. The inhibition of Candida species by selected essential oils and their synergism with amphotericin B.  Phytomedicine. 2008;  15 635-638
• 152 Toroglu S. In vitro antimicrobial activity and antagonistic effect of essential oils from plant species.  J Environ Biol. 2007;  28 551-559
• 153 Adwan G M, Abu-shanab B A, Adwan K M. In vitro activity of certain drugs in combination with plant extracts against Staphylococcus aureus infections.  Pakistan J Med Sci. 2008;  24 541-544
• 154 Rodrigues F F, Costa J G, Coutinho H D. Synergy effects of the antibiotics gentamicin and the essential oil of Croton zehntneri.  Phytomedicine. 2009;  16 1052-1055
• 155 Kumar A S, Venkateshwaran K, Vanitha J, Saravanan V S, Ganesh M, Vasudevan M, Sivakumar Bangladesh T. Synergistic activity of methanolic extract of Thespesia populnea. (Malvaceae) flowers with oxytetracycline.  J Pharmacol. 2009;  4 13-16
• 156 Rosato A, Vitali C, Piarulli M, Mazzotta M, Argentieri M P, Mallamaci R. In vitro synergic efficacy of the combination of nystatin with the essential oils of Origanum vulgare and Pelargonium graveolens against some Candida species.  Phytomedicine. 2009;  16 972-975
• 157 Adwan G, Abu-Shanab B, Adwan K. Antibacterial activities of some plant extracts alone and in combination with different antimicrobials against multidrug-resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa strains.  Asian Pacific J Trop Med. 2010;  24 266-269
• 158 Amber K, Aijaz A, Immaculata X, Luqman K A, Nikhat M. Anticandidal effect of Ocimum sanctum essential oil and its synergy with fluconazole and ketoconazole.  Phytomedicine. 2010;  17 921-925
• 159 D'Arrigo M D, Ginestra G, Mandalari G, Furneri P M, Bisignano G. Synergism and postantibiotic effect of tobramycin and Melaleuca alternifolia (tea tree) oil against Staphylococcus aureus and Escherichia coli.  Phytomedicine. 2009;  17 317-322
• 160 Endo E H, Cortez D A C, Ueda-Nakamura T, Nakamura C V, Filho B P D. Potent antifungal activity of extracts and pure compound isolated from pomegranate peels and synergism with fluconazole against Candida albicans.  Res Microbiol. DOI: 10.1016/j.resmic.2010.05.002 , advance online publication 21 June 2010
  
• 161 Palaniappan K, Holley R A. Use of natural antimicrobials to increase antibiotic susceptibility of drug resistant bacteria.  Int J Food Microbiol. 2010;  140 164-168
• 162 Mahboubi I M, Bidgoli F G. In vitro synergistic efficacy of combination of amphotericin B with Myrtus communis essential oil against clinical isolates of Candida albicans.  Phytomedicine. 2010;  17 771-774
• 163 Saad A, Fadli M, Bouaziz M, Benharref A, Mezrioui N-E, Hassani L. Anticandidal activity of the essential oils of Thymus maroccanus and Thymus broussonetii and their synergism with amphotericin B and fluconazol.  Phytomedicine. DOI: 10.1016/j.phymed.2010.03.020 , advance online publication 18 June 2010
  
• 164 Nazer A I, Kobilinsky A, Tholozan J L, Dubois-Brissonnet F. Combinations of food antimicrobials at low levels to inhibit the growth of Salmonella sv. typhimurium: a synergistic effect?.  Food Microbiol. 2005;  22 391-398
• 165 Fyfe L, Armstrong F, Stewart J. Inhibition of Listeria monocytogenes and Salmonella enteriditis by combinations of plant oils and derivatives of benzoic acid: the development of synergistic antimicrobial combinations.  Int J Antimicrob Agents. 1998;  9 195-199
• 166 Dimitrijević S I, Mihajlovski K R, Antonović D G, Milanović-Stevanović M R, Mijin D Z. A study of the synergistic antilisterial effects of a sub-lethal dose of lactic acid and essential oils from Thymus vulgaris L., Rosmarinus officinalis L. and Origanum vulgare L.  Food Chem. 2007;  104 774-782
• 167 Molinos A C, Abriouel H, López R L, Omar N B, Valdivia E, Gálvez A. Enhanced bactericidal activity of enterocin AS-48 in combination with essential oils, natural bioactive compounds and chemical preservatives against Listeria monocytogenes in ready-to-eat salad.  Food Chem Toxicol. 2009;  47 2216-2223
• 168 Govaris A, Solomakos N, Pexara A, Chatzopoulou P S. The antimicrobial effect of oregano essential oil, nisin and their combination against Salmonella enteritidis in minced sheep meat during refrigerated storage.  Int J Food Microbiol. 2010;  137 175-180