Abstract
The objective of this randomized study was to compare a thermotherapy system, hyperthermia at 434 MHz and conventional ultrasound in the treatment of overuse sports tendinopathies. The study group consisted of 44 athletes, 33 males and 11 females (age 26 ± 4.56 years) affected by tendinopathies at lower extremities (patellar or achilles tendons). After elucidation of the kind of trial, 22 patients were randomly assigned to hyperthermia and 22 to ultrasound. The patients received after a pain measurement and ultrasound scanning 12 treatments, 3 times a week for 4 weeks. The same standardized examination was done at the end of treatment and 1 month after the end of treatment. The assessor physician was unaware of the treatment allocation . The patients were asked to rate the ultimate outcome on the base of pain resolution and return to sports activity. Both groups had a significant decrease of symptoms (P<0.001). Hyperthermia, however, demonstrated better effects on the reduction of VAS score and on the subjective overall satisfaction (77 %) of excellent and good results in comparison to the 33 % of ultrasound. In patients with chronic overuse tendinopathies hyperthermia at 434 MHz showed encouraging results, with short-term clinical improvement, safety and no side effects.
Key words
Overuse injury - ultrasound - physical therapy - microwave diathermy - achilles tendon - patellar tendon
References
-
1
Akyurekli D, Gerig L H, Raaphorst G P.
Changes in muscle blood flow distribution during hyperthermia.
Int J Hyperthermia.
1997;
13
481-496
-
2
Alfredson H.
In situ microdialysis in tendon tissue: High levels of glutamate but not prostaglandin E, in chronic Achilles tendon pain.
Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc.
1999;
7
378-381
-
3
Almekinders L C, Gurvinder D.
The effects of aging, antiinflammatory drugs and ultrasound on the in vitro response of tendon tissue.
Am J Sports Med.
1999;
27
417-421
-
4
Almekinders L C, Temple J.
Etiology, diagnosis, and treatment of tendonitis: an analysis of the literature.
Med Sci Sports Exerc.
1998;
30
1183-1190
-
5
Archambault J, Wiley J P, Bray R C.
Exercise loading of tendons and the development of overuse injuries.
Sports Med.
1995;
20
77-89
-
6
Astrom M, Rausing A.
Chronic Achilles tendinopathy: a survey of surgical and histopathologic findings.
Clin Orthop Rel Res.
1995;
316
151-164
-
7
Astrom M, Gentz C F, Nilsson P, Rausing A, Sjoberg S, Westlin N.
Imaging in chronic Achilles tendinopathy: a comparison of ultrasonography, magnetic resonance imaging and surgical findings in 27 histologically verified cases.
Skeletal Radiol.
1996;
25
615-620
-
8
Bandinelli I, Caserio M, Pasquetti P.
Trattamento della sindrome da conflitto della spalla (inpingement) nell'atleta mediante ipertermia.
Medicina dello Sport.
1994;
47
715-720
-
9
Bowman A F.
Heat transfer and thermal dosimetry.
J microwave power.
1981;
16
121-133
-
10
Clement D B, Taunton J, Smart G W.
Achilles tendinitis and peritendinitis: etiology and treatment.
Am J Sports Med.
1984;
12
179-184
-
11
Enwemeka C S.
The effects of therapeutic ultrasound on tendon healing: a biomechanical study.
Am J Phys Med Rehabil.
1989;
68
283-287
-
12
Enwemeka C S, Cohen-Kornberg F, Duswalt E P, Weber D M, Rodriguez I M.
Biomechanical effects of three different periods of Ga As laser photo stimulation on tenotomized tendons.
Laser Therapy.
1994;
6
181-188
-
13
Gabriele P, Amichetti M, Orecchia R, Valdagni R.
Radiation therapy and hyperthermia in advanced or recurrent parotid tumors.
Cancer.
1995;
75
908-913
-
14
Giombini A, Casciello G F, Di Cesare M C, Di Cesare A, Dragoni S, Sorrenti D.
A controlled study on the effects of hyperthermia at 434 MHz and conventional ultrasound upon muscle injuries in sport.
J Sports Med Phys Fitn.
2001;
41
521-527
-
15
Gum S L, Reddy G K, Stehno-Bittel L, Enwemeka C S.
Combined ultrasound, electrical stimulation and laser promote collagen synthesis with moderate changes in tendon biomechanics.
Am J Med Rehabil.
1997;
76
288-296
-
16
Guy A W, Lehmann J F, Stonebridge J B.
Therapeutic applications of electromagnetic power.
Proc IEEE.
1974;
62
65-75
-
17 Jozsa L, Kannus P. Human tendons. Anatomy, Physiology and Pathology. Champaign (IL); Human Kinetics 1997 576: 4-95
-
18
Huskisson E C.
Measurement of pain.
Lancet.
1974;
2
1127-1131
-
19
Kannus P, Natri A, Jozsa L.
Aetiology and pathogenesis of chronic tendon injuries in sports.
Bailliere's Clinical Orthopaedics;.
1997;
2
1
-
20
Khan K M, Cook J L, Taunton J E, Bonar F.
Overuse tendinosis, not tendinitis. Part 1: A new paradigm for a difficult clinical problem.
Phys Sports Med.
2000;
28
38-48
-
21
Kramer J F.
Ultrasound: evaluation of its mechanical and thermal effects.
Arch Phys Med Rehabil.
1984;
66
223-227
-
22
Larsson S E, Cai H, Oberg P A.
Continuous percutaneous measurement by laser-doppler flowmetry of skeletal muscle microcirculation at varying levels of contraction force determined electromyographically.
Eur J Appl Physiol.
1993;
66
477-482
-
23 Lehmann J F, Delateur B J. Therapeutic heat. In: Lehmann JF (ed) Therapeutic Heat and Cold. Baltimore; Williams and Wilkins 1990 4th ed: 417-581
-
24
Marini P, Guiot C, Baiotto B, Gabriele P.
The influence of the circulating water bolus on the temperature and the thermal estimation of the penetration depth of a MW applicator in a muscle equivalent phantom.
Physics Med Biol.
2001;
In press
-
25
Overgaard J, Gonzalez F, Hulshof M CMM, Arcangeli J, Dahl O, Mella O.
Randomized trial of hypertheria as adjuvant to radiotherapy for recurrent or metastatic malignant melanoma.
Lancet.
1995;
345
540-543
-
26
Patrick M K.
Applications of therapeutic pulsed ultrasound.
Physiotheraphy.
1972;
64
103-104
-
27
Reddy G K, Gum S, Stehno-Bittel L, Enwemeka C S.
Biochemistry and biomechanics of healing tendon: part II. Effect of combined laser therapy and electrical stimulation.
Med Sci Sports Exerc.
1998;
30
794-800
-
28
Rivenburgh D W.
Physical modalities in the treatment of tendon injuries.
Clin Sports Med.
1992;
11
645-659
-
29
Robinson S E, Buono M J.
Effect of continuous wave ultrasound on blood flow in skeletal muscle.
Phys Therapy.
1995;
75
145-150
-
30
Sekins K M, Lehmann J F, Esselman P, Dundore D, Emery A F, Delateur B J, Nelp W P.
Local muscle blood flow and temperature responses to 915 MHz diathermy as simultaneously measured and numerically predicted.
Arch Phys Med Rehabil.
1984;
65
1-7
-
31
Sekins K M, Emery A F, Lehmann J F, McDougall J A.
Determination of perfusion field during local hyperthermia with the aid of finite element thermal models.
J Biom Engineering.
1982;
104
272-279
-
32
Song C W.
Effect of local hyperthermia on blood flow and microenvironment: a review.
Cancer Res.
1984;
44
4721-4730
-
33
Torstensen E T, Bray R C, Wiley J P.
Patellar tendinitis: a review of current concepts and treatment.
Clin J Sports Med.
1994;
4
77-82
-
34
Williams J GP.
Achilles tendon lesions in sport.
Sports Med.
1986;
3
114-135
-
35
Wyper D J, McNiven D R, Donnelly T J.
Therapeutic ultrasound and muscle blood flow.
Physiotherapy.
1978;
64
321-322
A. Giombini
Institute of Sport Science
Via dei Campi Sportivi 46 · 00197 Rome · Italy ·
Phone: +39 (6)36859106
Fax: +39 (6)368592256
Email: agiombo@hotmail.com
