Left Ventricular Morphology and Function in Female Athletes: A Meta-Analysis

Abstract

The purpose of the present study was to examine the impact of physical training upon cardiac structure and function, and identify physiologic upper limits in female athletes. Meta-analytical techniques were applied to 13 published echocardiographic studies examining cardiac structure and function in female athletes. The study group included 890 athletes and 333 controls. For comparison of sporting discipline, studies were partitioned into 3 categories (endurance, strength/sprint, team). Significant (p < 0.05) effect sizes were observed for all structural measures between athletes and controls. Significant effect size differences existed between sporting groups for LVIDd and LVM only, with endurance and team game athletes demonstrating the largest effect sizes compared to strength trained athletes. No significant effect of training was observed for left ventricular diastolic or systolic function, with the exception of stroke volume where a significant effect size difference was observed between athletes and controls with no observed difference between sporting groups. Maximum reported upper limits for LV wall thickness and LVIDd in female athletes were 12 mm and 66 mm respectively. Chronic exercise training results in cardiac enlargement in female athletes. The nature of physiologic adaptation is similar to that observed in male athletes. LV wall thickness values greater than 12 mm in female athletes should be viewed with caution and indicate a more comprehensive evaluation to establish a physiological or pathological basis for the observed left ventricular enlargement.

Key words

Female athlete - echocardiography - athlete's heart

References

• 1 Batterham A M, George K P, Whyte G, Sharma S, McKenna W. Scaling cardiac structural data by body dimensions: A review of theory, practice and problems.  Int J Sports Med. 1999;  20 495-502
• 2 Bjornstad H, Smith G, Storstein L, Meen H, Hals O. Electrocardiographic and echocardiographic findings in top athletes, athletic students and sedentary controls.  Cardiology. 1993;  82 66-74
• 3 Clifford P, Hanel B, Secher N. Arterial blood pressure response to rowing.  Med Sci Sports Ex. 1994;  26 715-719
• 4 Crouse S F, Rohack J J, Jacobsen D J. Cardiac structure and function in women basketball athletes: seasonal variation and comparisons with normal controls.  Res Quart Sports Ex. 1992;  63 393-401
• 5 Fagard R H. Impact of different sports and training on cardiac structure and function.  Cardiol Clin. 1997;  15 397-412
• 6 Fagard R H. Athlete's heart: A meta-analysis of the echocardiographic experience.  Int J Sports Med. 1996;  17 140-144
• 7 Fagard R, Van Den Broeke C, Vanhees L, Staessen J, Amery A. Noninvasive assessment of systolic and diastolic left ventricular function in female runners.  Eur Heart J. 1987;  8 1305-1311
• 8 George K, Gates P, Whyte G, Fenoglio R, Lea R. Echocardiographic examination of cardiac structure in elite cross-trained male and female alpine skiers.  Brit J Sports Med. 1999;  33 93-99
• 9 George K, Gates P, Birch K, Campbell I. Left ventricular morphology and function in endurance-trained female athletes.  J Sports Sci. 1999;  17 633-642
• 10 George K, Batterham A, Jones B. Echocardiographic evidence of concentric left ventricular enlargement in female weight lifters.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1998;  79 88-92
• 11 George K, Wolfe L, Burggraf G, Norman R. Electrocardiographic and echocardiographic characteristics of female athletes.  Med Sci Sports Ex. 1995;  27 1362-1370
• 12 George K P, Wolfe L A, Burggraf G W. The “athletic heart syndrome”.  Sports Med. 1991;  11 300-330
• 13 Henriksen E, Landeliu J, Kangro T, Jonason T, Hedberg P, Wesslen L, Rosander C, Rolf C, Ringqvist I, Friman G. An echocardiographic study of right and left ventricular adaptation to physical exercise in elite female orienteers.  Eur Heart J. 1999;  20 309-316
• 14 Maron B. Structural features of the athletes heart as defined by echocardiography.  J Am Coll Cardiol. 1986;  7 190-203
• 15 McDougall J, Tilxen D, Sale D, Moriz J, Sutton J. Arterial blood pressure response to heavy resistance exercise.  J Appl Physiol. 1985;  58 785-790
• 16 Nixon J, Wright A, Porter T, Roy V, Arrowood J. Effects of exercise on left ventricular diastolic performance in trained athletes.  Am J Cardiol. 1991;  68 945-949
• 17 Pelliccia A, Maron B, Culasso F, Spataro A, Caselli G. Athlete's heart in women. Echocardiographic characterisation of highly trained elite female athletes.  J Am Med Assoc. 1996;  276 211-215
• 18 Pelliccia A, Maron B J, Spataro A, Proschan M, Spirito P. The upper limits of physiologic cardiac hypertrophy in highly trained athletes.  New Engl J Med. 1991;  324 295-301
• 19 Pluim B, Zwinderman A, van der Laarse A, van der Wall E. The athlete's heart: A meta-analysis of cardiac structure and function.  Circ. 1999;  100 336-344
• 20 Rodriguez R, Iglesias G, Lopez J, Terrados N, Gonzalez V, Cortina R, Cortina A. Prevalence and upper limit of cardiac hypertrophy in professional cyclists.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1995;  70 375-378
• 21 Rubal B, Al-Muhailani A, Rosentsweig J. Effects of physical conditioning on the heart size and wall thickness of college women.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1987;  19 423-429
• 22 Sharma S, Whyte G, McKenna W J. Sudden cardiac death in young athletes - fact or fiction?.  Brit J Sports Med. 1997;  31 269-276
• 23 Urhausen A, Monz T, Kindermann W. Sports-specific adaptation of left ventricular muscle mass in athlete's heart. An echocardiographic study with combined isometric and dynamic exercise trained athletes (male and female rowers).  Int J Sports Med. 1996;  17 145-151
• 24 Whyte G, George K, Sharma S, Martin L, Draper N, McKenna W. Left ventricular structure and function in elite judo players.  Clin Exp Physiol. 2000;  2 204-208