Validation of a Photoplethysmographic Heart Rate Monitor: Polar OH1

Abstract

This study assessed the validity of a photoplethysmographic heart rate (HR) monitor, the Polar OH1 in various sports performed in ecological conditions: running, cycling, soccer, kayaking, walking, tennis and fitness. Seventy trained athletes (56 males, 14 females) wore the Polar OH1 armband and the H7 chest belt during training. A total of 390 h and 38 min of recording were compared using a 20-bpm window to assess data quality, and Bland-Altman agreements and ICC analyses were used to test accuracy. Linear regression analyses evaluated the HR accuracy and correlation with skin tone. Training loads (TRIMPs) were compared for each session. Reliability was high for endurance sports (>99%) and lower for sports involving arm movements (92~95%). Biases were slightly negative for all sports, whereas widths of limits of agreement varied from 7–20bpm. Bland-Altman agreements were all under 5% except tennis, kayak and fitness. HR accuracy was positively correlated to skin tone (p<0.05). Finally, TRIMPs from the OH1 device were inferior to criterion’s (except walking and soccer), within a 3% range from reference. Hence, OH1 represents a valid tool to monitor instantaneous HR and training load, especially for endurance sports.

Key words

photoplethysmography - accuracy - exercise - Bland-Altman - training load - skin type

• References

• 1 Achten J, Jeukendrup AE. Heart rate monitoring: Applications and limitations. Sports Med 2003; 33: 517-538
• 2 Schneider C, Hanakam F, Wiewelhove T, Döweling A, Kellmann M, Meyer T, Pfeiffer M, Ferrauti A. Heart rate monitoring in team sports: a conceptual framework for contextualizing heart rate measures for training and recovery prescription. Front Physiol 2018; 9: 639
• 3 Cardinale M, Varley MC. Wearable training-monitoring technology: Applications, challenges, and opportunities. Int J Sports Physiol Perform 2017; 12: S2-55-S2-62
• 4 Hertzman AB. The blood supply of various skin areas as estimated by the photoelectric plethysmograph. American Journal of Physiology-Legacy Content 1938; 124: 328-340
• 5 Allen J. Photoplethysmography and its application in clinical physiological measurement. Physiol Meas 2007; 28: R1
• 6 Van Kampen EJ, Zijlstra WG. Determination of hemoglobin and its derivatives. Adv Clin Chem 1965; 8: 141-187
• 7 Lee J, Matsumura K, Yamakoshi K, Rolfe P, Tanaka S, Yamakoshi T. Comparison between red, green and blue light reflection photoplethysmography for heart rate monitoring during motion. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc 2013; 2013: 1724-1727
• 8 Maeda Y, Sekine M, Tamura T. Relationship between measurement site and motion artifacts in wearable reflected photoplethysmography. J Med Syst 2011; 35: 969-976
• 9 Spierer DK, Rosen Z, Litman LL, Fujii K. Validation of photoplethysmography as a method to detect heart rate during rest and exercise. J Med Eng Technol 2015; 39: 264-271
• 10 Gorny AW, Liew SJ, Tan CS, Müller-Riemenschneider F. Fitbit charge hr wireless heart rate monitor: Validation study conducted under free-living conditions. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2017; 5: e157
• 11 Parak J, Korhonen I. Evaluation of wearable consumer heart rate monitors based on photopletysmography. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc 2014; 2014: 3670-3673
• 12 Gillinov S, Etiwy M, Wang R, Blackburn G, Phelan D, Gillinov AM, Houghtaling P, Javadikasgari H, Desai MY. Variable accuracy of wearable heart rate monitors during aerobic exercise. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2017; 49: 1697-1703
• 13 Boudreaux BD, Hebert EP, Hollander DB, Williams BM, Cormier CL, Naquin MR, Gillan WW, Gusew EE, Kraemer RR. Validity of wearable activity monitors during cycling and resistance exercise. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2018; 50: 624-633
• 14 Horton JF, Stergiou P, Fung TS, Katz L. Comparison of polar m600 optical heart rate and ecg heart rate during exercise. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2017; 49: 2600
• 15 Shcherbina A, Mattsson CM, Waggott D, Salisbury H, Christle JW, Hastie T, Wheeler MT, Ashley EA. Accuracy in wrist-worn, sensor-based measurements of heart rate and energy expenditure in a diverse cohort. J Pers Med 2017; 7 3
• 16 Delgado-Gonzalo R, Parak J, Tarniceriu A, Renevey P, Bertschi M, Korhonen I. Evaluation of accuracy and reliability of PulseOn optical heart rate monitoring device. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc 2015; 2015: 430-433
• 17 Lin Z, Zhang J, Chen Y, Zhang Q. Heart rate estimation using wrist-acquired photoplethysmography under different types of daily life motion artifact. In 2015 IEEE International Conference on Communications (ICC); London: IEEE 2015: 489-494 Available at: http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/7248369/
• 18 Stahl SE, An H-S, Dinkel DM, Noble JM, Lee J-M. How accurate are the wrist-based heart rate monitors during walking and running activities? Are they accurate enough?. BMJ Open Sport Exerc Med 2016; 2: e000106
• 19 Jo E, Lewis K, Directo D, Kim MJ, Dolezal BA. Validation of biofeedback wearables for photoplethysmographic heart rate tracking. J Sports Sci Med 2016; 15: 540-547
• 20 Dooley EE, Golaszewski NM, Bartholomew JB. Estimating accuracy at exercise intensities: a comparative study of self-monitoring heart rate and physical activity wearable devices. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2017; 5: e34
• 21 Schubert MM, Clark A, ABDL Rosa. The Polar® OH1 optical heart rate sensor is valid during moderate-vigorous exercise. Sports Med Int Open 2018; 02: E67-E70
• 22 Abt G, Bray J, Benson AC. The validity and inter-device variability of the Apple WatchTM for measuring maximal heart rate. J Sports Sci 2018; 36: 1447-1452
• 23 Claes J, Buys R, Avila A, Finlay D, Kennedy A, Guldenring D, Budts W, Cornelissen V. Validity of heart rate measurements by the Garmin Forerunner 225 at different walking intensities. J Med Eng Technol 2017; 41: 480-485
• 24 Banister EW. Modeling elite athletic performance. In: Green HJ, McDougal JD, Wenger H (eds.). Physiological Testing of Elite Athletes. Human Kinetics, Champaign III; 1991: 403-424
• 25 Banister EW, Calvert TW. Planning for future performance: implications for long term training. Can J Appl Sport Sci 1980; 5: 170-176
• 26 Manzi V, Iellamo F, Impellizzeri F, D’Ottavio S, Castagna C. Relation between individualized training impulses and performance in distance runners. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2009; 41: 2090-2096
• 27 Busso T. Variable dose-response relationship between exercise training and performance. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2003; 35: 1188-1195
• 28 Fitzpatrick TB. The validity and practicality of sun-reactive skin types I through VI. Arch Dermatol 1988; 124: 869-871
• 29 Wang R, Blackburn G, Desai M, Phelan D, Gillinov L, Houghtaling P, Gillinov M. Accuracy of Wrist-Worn Heart Rate Monitors. JAMA Cardiol 2017; 2: 104-106
• 30 Harriss D, Macsween A, Atkinson G. Standards for ethics in sport and exercise science research: 2018 update. Int J Sports Med 2017; 38: 1126-1131
• 31 Bland JM, Altman DG. Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement. Lancet 1986; 1: 307-310
• 32 Bartko JJ. The intraclass correlation coefficient as a measure of reliability. Psychol Rep 1966; 19: 3-11
• 33 Koo TK, Li MY. A guideline of selecting and reporting intraclass correlation coefficients for reliability research. J Chiropr Med 2016; 15: 155-163
• 34 Parak J, Tarniceriu A, Renevey P, Bertschi M, Delgado-Gonzalo R, Korhonen I. Evaluation of the beat-to-beat detection accuracy of PulseOn wearable optical heart rate monitor. 37th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC); 2015: 8099-8102
• 35 Dondzila C, Lewis C, Lopez J, Parker T. Congruent accuracy of wrist-worn activity trackers during controlled and free-living conditions. Int J Exerc Sci 2018; 11: 575-584
• 36 Le Meur Y, Hausswirth C, Mujika I. Tapering for competition: A review. Sci Sports 2012; 27: 77-87
• 37 Terbizan DJ, Dolezal BA, Albano C. Validity of seven commercially available heart rate monitors. Meas Phys Educ Exerc Sci 2002; 6: 243-247
• 38 Sarwe A. Heart Rate and Motion Detection on Swimmers. Simultaneous monitoring of heart rate and motion of swimmers . Master thesis in Applied Physics, Department of Applied Physics, CHALMERS TEKNISKA HÖGSKOLA, Göteborg, Sverige 2014. Available at: http://publications.lib.chalmers.se/records/fulltext/209386/209386.pdf
• 39 Johnson JM. Exercise in a hot environment: the skin circulation. Scand J Med Sci Sports 2010; 20 (Suppl. 03) 29-39
• 40 Brage S, Westgate K, Franks PW, Stegle O, Wright A, Ekelund U, Wareham NJ. Estimation of free-living energy expenditure by heart rate and movement sensing: A doubly-labelled water study. PLoS One 2015; 10: e0137206
• 41 Andre D, Wolf DL. Recent advances in free-living physical activity monitoring: A review. J Diabetes Sci Technol 2007; 1: 760-767