Thermo-Mineral Baths in the First Half XIX Century: The Case of Ludwig Van Beethoven

Abstract

Background The great German composer Ludwig van Beethoven suffered almost all his life from progressive deafness and diseases of the digestive system. The state of his health strongly influenced his work. Balneotherapy is the only aspect of Beethoven’s disease history that has not yet been thoroughly studied. While water treatment in the first half of the XIX century was the most important part of the therapeutic arsenal of doctors and was actively used in the treatment of Beethoven.

Objectives To study the use of thermo-mineral baths in the treatment of Ludwig van Beethoven in the first half of the XIX century.

Methods Scopus, WebOfScience, MedLine and PubMed databases, electronic archives were searched without time restriction for information on the use of thermo-mineral baths in European spa resorts in the first half of the 19^th century. An analysis was also made of Beethoven’s letters and the work of his most respected biographers in order to identify information about thermal-mineral baths in his treatment.

Results Since 1796, Beethoven suffered chronic enterocolitis and progressive hearing impairment, since 1820 portalcirrhosis of the liver. Thermo-mineral baths were the main part of Beethovens treatment from 1799 until his death in 1827.

Conclusions The Beethoven’s physicians appointed him a treatment that corresponded to the advanced achievements of balneology of the first half of the 19^th century. The composer spent annually at spa resorts up to 6 months, water treatment became part of his life. Beethoven until the last days of his life sincerely believed in the healing power of thermo-mineral baths.

Zusammenfassung

Hintergrund Der größte Deutscher Komponist Ludwig van Beethoven litt fast sein ganzes Leben lang an aggressiver Taubheit und an Krankheiten der Verdauungsorgane. Der Zustand seiner Gesundheit beeinflusste sehr stark sein Schaffensvermögen. Balneotherapie ist der einzige Aspekt in Beethovens Krankengeschichte, welche noch nicht ausreichend erforscht wurde. Während Balneotherapie in der ersten Hälfte des XIX. Jahrhunderts der wichtigste Teil des therapeutischen Arsenals der Ärzte war und aktiv bei der Behandlung von Beethoven eingesetzt wurde.

Ziele Untersuchung der Verwendung von Thermomineralbädern bei der Behandlung von Ludwig van Beethoven Methoden In den Datenbanken Scopus, WebOfScience, MedLine und PubMed wurden elektronische Archive ohne zeitliche Einschränkung nach Informationen über die Nutzung von Thermomineralbädern in europäischen Kurorten in der ersten Hälfte des XIX. Jahrhunderts durchsucht. Außerdem wurden die Briefe Beethovens und die Arbeiten seiner angesehensten Biografen analysiert, um Informationen über Thermomineralbäder in seiner Behandlung zu ermitteln.

Ergebnisse Seit 1796 litt Beethoven an chronischerEnterokolitis und fortschreitender Schwerhrigkeit, seit 1820 portale Leberzirrhose. Thermomineralbder waren von 1799bis zu Beethovens Tod im Jahr 1827 der Hauptbestandteil seiner Behandlung.

Schlussfolgerungen Die Ärzte Beethovens verordneten ihm eine Behandlung, die den fortschrittlichen Errungenschaften der Balneologie der ersten Hälfte des XIX. Jahrhunderts entsprach. Der Komponist verbrachte jährlich bis zu 6 Monate in Kurorten, die Wasserbehandlung wurde zum Teil seines Lebens. Beethoven glaubte bis in die letzten Tage seines Lebens aufrichtig an die Heilkraft der Thermomineralbäde.

Key words

thermo-mineral baths - history of balneotherapy - history of spa resorts in Europe - Ludwig van Beethoven

Schlüsselwörter

Ludwig van Beethoven - Thermomineralbäder - Geschichte der Balneotherapie - Geschichte der Kurorte in Europa

• References

• 1 Clarke A. An essay on warm, cold, and vapour bathing: with practical observations on sea bathing, diseases of the skin, bilious, liver complaints, and dropsy. London: H. Colburn and Co.; 1820: 256
• 2 Aidall I. The German nature-cure, and how to practice it. London: Nichols & Co.; 1897: 232
• 3 Osann E. Physikalisch-medicinische Darstellung der bekannten Heilquellen der vorzüglichsten Länder Europaʼs. Volume 2. Berlin: F. Dümmler; 1829: 1100
• 4 Granville AB. The spas of Germany. Vol. 1. Brussels: Hauman and Co.; 1838, 448
• 5 Granville AB. The spas of Germany. Vol. 2. Brussels: Hauman and Co.; 1838, 538
• 6 Hutton Ch. Cursory observations on the mineral water of Baden By Royal College of Physicians of London Carlsruhe: D.R. Marx; 1838, 40
• 7 Thayer AW. The Life of Ludwig van Beethoven. Edited, revised and amended from the original English manuscript and the German editions of H. Deiters and H. Riemann, concluded, and all the documents newly translated by. H. E. Krehbiel. Volume I. New York: G. Schirmer, Inc; 1921: 371
• 8 Beethoven’s letters A critical edition with explanatory notes by Dr. A. C. Kalischer. Translated with preface by J. S. Shedlock. Vol. One. London: J M Dent and Co.; 440
• 9 Thayer AW. The Life of Ludwig van Beethoven. Edited, revised and amended from the original. English manuscript and the German editions of H. Deiters and H. Riemann, concluded, and all the documents newly translated by H. E. Krehbiel. Volume III. New York: G. Schirmer, Inc; 1921: 350
• 10 Fischer GA. Beethoven, a character study together with Wagner’s indebtedness to Beethoven. New York: Dodd, Mead; 1905: 278
• 11 Schindler A. The life of Beethoven Edited by Ignaz Moscheles to which are added Beethoven’s letters to friends, the life and characteristics of Beethoven by dr. Heinrich Doring and a list of Beethoven’s works. Boston: Ditson. 1900: 390
• 12 Floyer J, Baynard E. Psychrolousia, or, The history of cold bathing: both ancient and modern: in two parts. London: W. Innys and R. Manby; 1732: 562
• 13 Floyer J. The ancient psychrolousia revived: or, An essay to prove cold bathing both safe and useful: in four letters. London: S. Smith and B. Walford; 1702: 364
• 14 Kentish E. Essay on warm and vapour baths: with hints for a new mode of applying heat and cold, for the cure of disease, and the preservation of health. London: J Mawman; 1809: 124
• 15 Baynard Edward. History of cold bathing, both ancient and modern. London: R Groomsbridge; 1844: 116
• 16 Thayer AW. The Life of Ludwig van Beethoven. Edited, revised and amended from the original English manuscript and the German editions of H. Deiters and H. Riemann, concluded, and all the documents newly translated by H. E. Krehbiel. Volume II. New York: G. Schirmer, Inc; 1921: 416
• 17 Monro D. A treatise on mineral waters, Vol. II. London: D. Wilson & G. Nichol; 1770: 440
• 18 Mai FM. Diagnosing genius. Montreal: McGill-Queenʼs University Press; 2007: 273
• 19 Schindler A, MacArdle DW. Beethoven as I knew him, a biography. New York: W. W. Norton; 1972: 550
• 20 Beethovenʼs letters A critical edition with explanatory notes by Dr. A. C. Kalischer. Translated with preface by J. S. Shedlock. Vol. Two. London: J M Dent and Co.; 486
• 21 Otte AP, Wink K, Otte K. Kerners Krankheiten großer Musiker: Die Neubearbeitung. Stuttgart: Schattauer; 2008: 451
• 22 Spry JH. A practical treatise on the Bath waters tending to illustrate their beneficial effects in chronic diseases. London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme, and Brown; 1822: 442
• 23 Murray J. A handbook for travelers in Southern Germany. Being a guide to Bavaria, Austria, &c., the Austrian and Bavarian Alps, and the Danube from Ulm to the Black Sea: including descriptions of the most frequented baths and watering places, etc. London: J Murray; 1843: 534
• 24 Thayer AW, Forbes E, Deiters H. et al. Thayerʼs life of Beethoven. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 1970: 1141
• 25 Wawruch AI. Medical Review on the Final Stage of L. van Beethovenʼs Life. The Beethoven Journal 2007; 22: 87-91
• 26 Lambert TS. Bathing and the bath: simple and medicated: its history, effect and mode of application. N.Y.: J.C. Kneeland; 1845: 76