Osteopathie und evidenzbasierte Medizin, Teil 3: Bedeutung der EBM für die Osteopathie

Teil 3 der Beitragsreihe zur evidenzbasierten Medizin (EBM) befasst sich mit der Frage der Übertragbarkeit und Anwendbarkeit der EBM auf die Osteopathie. Hierzu werden die Ideen der EBM Working Group mit den Ideen Stills verglichen, die derzeitige Osteopathie kritisch bewertet und schließlich einige Gedanken für eine Ausrichtung der Osteopathie der Zukunft formuliert.

Schlüsselwörter

Evidenzbasierte Medizin - Osteopathie und EBM

Publication History

Article published online:
03 July 2024

• Literatur

• 1 Beauchamp TL, Childress JF. Principles of Biomedical Ethics. 8. Aufl. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2019
• 2 Djulbegovic B, Guyatt GH, Ashcroft RE. Epistemologic inquiries in evidence-based medicine. Cancer Control 2009; 16: 158-168
• 3 Still AT. Autobiographie. In: Hartmann C. Das große Still-Kompendium. 2. Aufl. Pähl: Jolandos; 2002: 65-66
• 4 Walter GW. Der erste D.O. Dr. Andrew Taylor Still. In: Hartmann C. Erinnerungen an Andrew Taylor Still. Pähl: Jolandos; 2016: 49
• 5 Still AT. Forschung und Praxis. In: Hartmann C. Das große Still-Kompendium. 2. Aufl. Pähl: Jolandos; 2005: 19-65
• 6 Still AT. Forschung und Praxis. In: Hartmann C. Das große Still-Kompendium. 2. Aufl. Pähl: Jolandos; 2005: 6-11
• 7 Littlejohn JM. Ansprache zur Postgraduiertenklasse 1899 an der American School of Osteopathy, Kirksville. Journal of Osteopathy (V):421-431. In: Hartmann C. Das große Littlejohn-Kompendium. Pähl: Jolandos; 2009
• 8 Guyatt GH, Haynes B. Jaeschke et al. The philosophy of evidence-based medicine. In: Guyatt G, Rennie D. Users’ Guides to the Medical Literature. 3. Aufl. New York: McGraw Hill; 2014
• 9 Bastian H, Glasziou P, Chalmers I. Seventy-Five Trials and Eleven Systematic Reviews a Day: How Will We Ever Keep Up?. PLoS Med 2010; 7: e1000326
• 10 Cabanillas-Barea S, Jiménez-Del-Barrio S, Carrasco-Uribarren A. et al. Systematic review and meta-analysis showed that complementary and alternative medicines were not effective for infantile colic. Acta Paediatr 2023; 112: 1378-1388
• 11 Franke H, Prediger G. Und die Osteopathie wirkt doch! Eine Entgegnung zu dem Artikel „Dreimonatskoliken: Alternativmedizin ohne nachgewiesenen Effekt“ von Elke Oberhofer. Osteopath Med 2023; 24: 42-44
• 12 Franke H, Franke JD, Fryer G. Effectiveness of osteopathic manipulative treatment for pediatric conditions: A systematic review. J Bodyw Mov Ther 2022; 31: 113-133
• 13 www.foerderverein-osteopathie.de; Stand: 14.09.2023
• 14 www.d-os.de Stand: 13.09.2023
• 15 www.comecollaboration.org Stand: 14.09.2023
• 16 Kaiser T. Wir müssen zu einer besseren Evidenzgenerierung kommen. Interview mit Dr. Thomas Kaiser. Dtsch Arztebl 2023; 120: A1464-A1468
• 17 Altman DG. The scandal of poor medical research. BMJ 1994; 308: 283-284
• 18 Moustgaard H, Clayton GL, Jones HE. et al. Impact of blinding on estimated treatment effects in randomised clinical trials: meta-epidemiological study. BMJ 2020; 368: l6802
• 19 Worral J. Why There’s No Cause to Randomize. Brit J Phil Sci 2007; 58: 451-488
• 20 La Caze A. The Randomized Controlled Trial: Internal and External Validity. In: Solomon M, Simon JR, Kincaid H. The Routledge Companion to Philosophy of Medicine. New York: Taylor and Francis; 2017: 195-208
• 21 Worrall J. What Evidence in Evidence-Based Medicine?. Philos Sci 2002; 69: 316-330
• 22 Urbach P. The value of randomization and control in clinical trials. Stat Med 1993; 12: 1421-1431
• 23 Berwick DM. Broadening the view of evidence-based medicine. Qual Saf Health Care 2005; 14: 315-316
• 24 Brock WA, Nolan KM, Nolan TW. Pragmatic science: accelerating the improvement of critical care. New Horiz 1998; 6: 61-68
• 25 Eichler M, Pokora R, Schwentner L. et al. Evidenzbasierte Medizin: Möglichkeiten und Grenzen. Dtsch Arztebl. 2015 112. A2190-A2192
• 26 Smith R. Thoughts for new medical students at a new medical school. BMJ 2003; 327: 1430-1433
• 27 Hall JC, Platell C. Half-life of truth in surgical literature. Lancet 1997; 350: 1752
• 28 Poynard T, Munteanu M, Ratziu V. et al. Truth survival in clinical research: an evidence-based requiem?. Ann Intern Med 2002; 136: 888-895
• 29 Sauerland S, Waffenschmidt S. Welche Halbwertszeit hat medizinisches Wissen?. KVH-Journal 2018; 6: 20-22
• 30 Shekelle PG, Ortiz E, Rhodes S. et al. Validity of the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality clinical practice guidelines: how quickly do guidelines become outdated?. JAMA 2001; 286: 1461-1467
• 31 Alderson LJ, Alderson P, Tan T. Median life span of a cohort of National Institute for Health and Care Excellence clinical guidelines was about 60 months. J Clin Epidemiol 2014; 67: 52-55
• 32 Graesser AC, Fiore SM, Greiff S. et al. Advancing the science of collaborative problem solving. Psychol Sci Public Interest 2018; 19: 59-92
• 33 Antes G. Evidence-Based Medicine. Der Internist 1998; 39: 899-908
• 34 Draper-Rodi J, Vaucher P, Hohenschurz-Schmidt D. et al. 4 M's to make sense of evidence – Avoiding the propagation of mistakes, misinterpretation, misrepresentation and misinformation. Int J Osteopath Med 2022; 44: 29-35
• 35 Ioannidis JPA. All science should inform policy and regulation. PLoS Med 2018; 15: e1002576
• 36 Blum HE. Eine vorsätzliche, gut gemachte Fälschung kann man nicht erkennen. Pressemitteilung von der 79. Jahrestagung der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Kardiologie am 04.04.2013. https://dgk.org/daten/Blum_Herausgeber.pdf Stand: 12.11.2023
• 37 Cerritelli F, Iacopini A, Galli M. et al. Evidence-based practice among Italian osteopaths: a national cross-sectional survey. BMC Complement Med Ther 2021; 21: 252
• 38 Leach MJ, Shaw R, Austin P. et al. Attitudes, skills, and use of evidence-based practice: A cross-sectional survey of Swedish osteopaths. Int J Osteopath Med 2020; 38: 41-49
• 39 Leach MJ, Sundberg T, Fryer G. et al. An investigation of Australian osteopaths' attitudes, skills and utilisation of evidence-based practice: a national cross-sectional survey. BMC Health Serv Res 2019; 19: 498
• 40 Sundberg T, Leach MJ, Thomson OP. et al. Attitudes, skills and use of evidence-based practice among UK osteopaths: a national cross-sectional survey. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2018; 19: 439
• 41 Ramírez-Vélez R, Bagur-Calafat MC, Correa-Bautista JE. et al. Barriers against incorporating evidence-based practice in physical therapy in Colombia: current state and factors associated. BMC Med Educ 2015; 15: 220
• 42 Critical Appraisals Skills Programme. CASP Checklists https://casp-uk.net/casp-tools-checklists/ Stand: 13.09.2023
• 43 https://ostlib.de/; Stand: 13.09.2023
• 44 Pastor-Pons I, Hidalgo-García C, Lucha-López MO. et al. Effectiveness of pediatric integrative manual therapy in cervical movement limitation in infants with positional plagiocephaly: a randomized controlled trial. Ital J Pediatr 2021; 47: 41
• 45 Hart D. Evidenz-basierte Medizin (EBM) und Gesundheitsrecht. Überlegungen zu rechtlichen Konsequenzen der Verwissenschaftlichung der Medizin. Medizinrecht 2000; 18: 1-5
• 46 Vogd W. Professionalisierungsschub oder Auflösung ärztlicher Autonomie. Die Bedeutung von Evidence Based Medicine und der neuen funktionalen Eliten in der Medizin aus system- und interaktionstheoretischer Perspektive. Zeitschrift für Soziologie 2002; 31: 294-315
• 47 Thomson OP, Petty NJ, Moore AP. A qualitative grounded theory study of the conceptions of clinical practice in osteopathy – a continuum from technical rationality to professional artistry. Man Ther 2014; 19: 37-43
• 48 Howell JD. The paradox of osteopathy. N Engl J Med 1999; 341: 1465-1468
• 49 Rumney IC. The History of the developmental term ’somatic dysfunction’. Osteopathic Annals 1979; 7: 26-30
• 50 Esteves JE, Zegarra-Parodi R, van Dun R. et al. Models and theoretical frameworks for osteopathic care – A critical view and call for updates and research. Int J Osteopath Med 2020; 35: 1-4
• 51 Moran R. Somatic dysfunction – conceptually fascinating, but does it help us address health needs?. Int J Osteopath Med 2016; 22: 1-2
• 52 Wührl P. Den Fluch der somatischen Dysfunktion überwinden. DO 2011; 9: 35-37
• 53 Fryer G. Somatic dysfunction: an osteopathic conundrum. Int J Osteopath Med 2016; 22: 52-63
• 54 Zegarra-Parodi R, Draper-Rodi J, Haxton J. et al. The Native American heritage of the body-mind-spirit paradigm in osteopathic principles and practices. Int J Osteopath Med 2019; 33: 31-37
• 55 Thomson OP, Mac Millan A. Commentary. What’s wrong with osteopathy?. Int J Osteopath Med 2023; 48: 100659
• 56 Stilwell P, Harman K. An enactive approach to pain: Beyond the biopsychosocial model. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 2019; 18: 637-665
• 57 Zegarra-Parodi R, Draper-Rodi J, Cerritelli F. Refining the Biopsychosocial Model for Musculoskeletal Practice by Introducing Religion and Spirituality Dimensions into the Clinical Scenario. Int J Osteopath Med 2019; 32: 44-48
• 58 Barry MJ, Edgman-Levitan S. Shared decision making--pinnacle of patient-centered care. N Engl J Med 2012; 366: 780-781
• 59 Bonelli J. Sinnorientierte Medizin. Imago Hominis 2004; 11: 251-264
• 60 Nawroth PP. Krise der modernen Heilkunst: Mehr sinnorientiere Medizin wagen. Tagesspiegel 31.01.2020. www.tagesspiegel.de/wissen/mehr-sinnorientiere-medizin-wagen-4134739.html Stand: 13.09.2023
• 61 Vaughan B, Fleischmann M. A guide to writing a case report of an osteopathic patient. Int J Osteopath Med 2020; 37: 34-39
• 62 Riley DS, Barber MS, Kienle GS. et al. CARE guidelines for case reports: explanation and elaboration document. J Clin Epidemiol 2017; 89: 218-235
• 63 Green BN, Johnson CD. How to write a case report for publication. J Chiropr Med 2006; 5: 72-82
• 64 White A, Ernst E. The case for uncontrolled clinical trials: a starting point for the evidence base for CAM. Complement Ther Med 2001; 9: 111-116
• 65 Morin C, Gaboury I. Osteopathic empirical research: a bibliometric analysis from 1966 to 2018. BMC Complement Med Ther 2021; 21: 1-9
• 66 Vogel S, Draper-Rodi J. The importance of pilot studies, how to write them and what they mean. Int J Osteopath Med 2017; 23: 2-3
• 67 Wieringa S, Greenhalgh T. 10 years of mindlines: a systematic review and commentary. Implement Sci 2015; 10: 45
• 68 Gabbay J, le May A. Evidence based guidelines or collectively constructed ’mindlines’? Ethnographic study of knowledge management in primary care. BMJ 2004; 329: 1013
• 69 Liem T, Neuhuber W. Kritik an der Polyvagaltheorie. DO 2021; 19: 34-37
• 70 Schalkhaußer A. Schließung und Mobilität der Synchondrosis sphenobasilaris. DO-Arbeit. 2000 COE
• 71 Lakatos I. Proofs and Refutations – The Logic of Mathematical Discovery. Cambridge: Cambridge University; 1976
• 72 Box GEP, Draper NR. Empirical Model-Building and Response Surfaces. New York: John Wiley & Sons; 1987
• 73 Skogen MD, Ji R, Akimova A, Daewel U. et al. Disclosing the truth: Are models better than observations?. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 2021; 680: 7-13
• 74 Steele JM. Models: Masterpieces and Lame Excuses. www-stat.wharton.upenn.edu/~steele/Rants/ModelsMandLE.html; Stand 13: 09 2023;
• 75 Gelman A. Some thoughts on the saying, All models are wrong, but some are useful. https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2008/06/12/all_models_are/ Stand: 13.09.2023
• 76 Bhise V, Rajan SS, Sittig DF. et al. Defining and Measuring Diagnostic Uncertainty in Medicine: A Systematic Review. J Gen Intern Med 2018; 33: 103-115
• 77 Luthin D. Wie viel Differenzialdiagnostik braucht die Osteopathie?. DO 2012; 10: 22-23
• 78 Logan RL, Scott PJ. Uncertainty in clinical practice: implications for quality and costs of health care. Lancet 1996; 347: 595-598
• 79 Bublack R. Offene Kommunikation schafft Vertrauen. Interview mit Prof. Klaus Weckberger. MMW Fortschr Med 2023; 165: 14
• 80 Kassirer JP. Our stubborn quest for diagnostic certainty. A cause of excessive testing. N Engl J Med 1989; 320: 1489-1491
• 81 Oskamp S. Overconfidence in case-study judgments. Journal of Consulting Psychology 29: 261-265
• 82 Lichtenstein S, Fischhoff B. Do those who know more also know more about how much they know? Organizational Behavior &. Human Performance 1977; 20: 159-183
• 83 Moskowitz AJ, Kuipers BJ, Kassirer JP. Dealing with uncertainty, risks, and tradeoffs in clinical decisions. A cognitive science approach. Ann Intern Med 1988; 108: 435-449
• 84 Detsky AS, Redelmeier D, Abrams HB. What's wrong with decision analysis? Can the left brain influence the right?. J Chronic Dis 1987; 40: 831-838
• 85 Basile F, Scionti R, Petracca M. Diagnostic reliability of osteopathic tests: a systematic review. Int J Osteopath Med 2017; 25: 21-29
• 86 Fritz JM, Wainner RS. Examining diagnostic tests: an evidence-based perspective. Phys Ther 2001; 81: 1546-1564
• 87 Lichtstein DM. Strategies to Deal with Uncertainty in Medicine. Am J Med 2023; 136: 339-340
• 88 Santhosh L, Chou CL, Connor DM. Diagnostic uncertainty: from education to communication. Diagnosis 2019; 6: 121-126
• 89 Braun RN, Mader FH. Programmierte Diagnostik in der Allgemeinmedizin. Heidelberg: Springer; 2005
• 90 Armstrong K. If You Can't Beat It, Join It: Uncertainty and Trust in Medicine. Ann Intern Med 2018; 168: 818-819
• 91 Gabutti M, Draper-Rodi J. Osteopathic decapitation: why do we consider the head differently from the rest of the body? New perspectives for an evidence-informed osteopathic approach to the head. Int J Osteopath Med 2014; 17: 256-262
• 92 Binswanger M. Sinnlose Wettbewerbe. Freiburg: Herder; 2012
• 93 Cervellin G, Borghi L, Lippi G. Do clinicians decide relying primarily on Bayesian principles or on gestalt perception? Some pearls and pitfalls of gestalt perception in medicine. Intern Emerg Med 2014; 9: 513-519
• 94 Custers EJ. Medical education and cognitive continuum theory: an alternative perspective on medical problem solving and clinical reasoning. Acad Med 2013; 88: 1074-1080
• 95 O'Brien BC, Harris IB, Beckman TJ. et al. Standards for reporting qualitative research: a synthesis of recommendations. Acad Med 2014; 89: 1245-1251
• 96 Greenhalgh T. Will COVID-19 be evidence-based medicine's nemesis?. PLoS Med 2020; 17: e1003266
• 97 Ogilvie D, Adams J, Bauman A. et al. Using natural experimental studies to guide public health action: turning the evidence-based medicine paradigm on its head. J Epidemiol Community Health 2020; 74: 203-208
• 98 Subbiah V. The next generation of evidence-based medicine. Nat Med 2023; 29: 49-58
• 99 Hobgen L, Sim M. The self-controlled and self-recorded clinical trial for low-grade morbidity. Br J Prev Soc Med 1953; 7: 163-179
• 100 Mirza RD, Punja S, Vohra S. et al. The history and development of N-of-1 trials. J R Soc Med 2017; 110: 330-340
• 101 Liu F, Panagiotakos D. Real-world data: a brief review of the methods, applications, challenges, and opportunities. BMC Med Res Methodol 2022; 22: 287
• 102 Köbberling J. Der Zweifel als Triebkraft des Erkenntnisgewinns in der Medizin. In: Kunz R, Ollenschläger G, Raspe H et al. Lehrbuch Evidenz-basierte Medizin in Klinik und Praxis. 2. Aufl. Köln: Deutscher Ärzte-Verlag; 2007
• 103 He Y, Vinci RJ. Uncertainty in the COVID-19 Pandemic and the Art of Medicine. Pediatrics 2021; 147: e2020042937
• 104 Simpkin AL, Schwartzstein RM. Tolerating Uncertainty – The Next Medical Revolution?. N Engl J Med 2016; 375: 1713-1715
• 105 Bean RB, Bean WB. Sir William Osler: aphorisms from his bedside teachings and writings. New York: Henry Schuman; 1950
• 106 Battista RN, Hodge MJ. Clinical practice guidelines: between science and art. CMAJ 1993; 148: 385-389
• 107 Pope C. Resisting Evidence: The Study of Evidence-Based Medicine as a Contemporary Social Movement. Health 2003; 7: 267-282
• 108 Cotton A. Osteopathic principles in the modern world. Int J Osteopath Med 2013; 16: 17-24
• 109 Figg-Latham J, Rajendran D. Quiet dissent: The attitudes, beliefs and behaviours of UK osteopaths who reject low back pain guidance – A qualitative study. Musculoskelet Sci Pract 2017; 27: 97-105
• 110 Thomson OP, Petty NJ, Moore AP. Reconsidering the patient-centeredness of osteopathy. Int J Osteopath Med 2013; 16: 25-32
• 111 King L, Kremser S, Deam P. et al. Clinical reasoning in osteopathy: Experiences of novice and experienced practitioners. Int J Osteopath Med 2018; 28: 12-19
• 112 Sidler S. Relevanz der Intuition in der Osteopathie – Überlegungen und ein Literaturüberblick. Osteopath Med 2010; 11: 4-9
• 113 Liem T. Intuitive Judgement in the Context of Osteopathic Clinical Reasoning. J Osteopath Med 2017; 117: 586-594
• 114 Esteves JE. Diagnostic palpation in osteopathic medicine: a putative neurocognitive model of expertise. Thesis for PHD; Oxford Brookes University. 2011
• 115 McIntyre C, Lathlean J, Esteves JE. Osteopathic clinical reasoning: An ethnographic study of perceptual diagnostic judgments, and metacognition. Int J Osteopath Med 2018; 28: 30-41
• 116 Chassy P, Gobet F. A hypothesis about the biological basis of expert intuition. Rev Gen Psychol 2011; 15: 198-212
• 117 Barrows HS, Feltovich PJ. The clinical reasoning process. Med Educ 1987; 21: 86-91
• 118 Kahneman D. A perspective on judgment and choice: mapping bounded rationality. Am Psychol 2003; 58: 697-720
• 119 Zeuch A. Ärztliche Intuition. Teil I: Intuition verstehen und als wertvolle Ressource nutzen. Frauenarzt 2008; 49: 280-282
• 120 Dreyfus HL, Dreyfus SE. Mind Over Machine: The Power of Human Intuition and Expertise in the Era of the Computer. New York: Free; 1986
• 121 Dreyfus SE. The Five-Stage Model of Adult Skill Acquisition. Bulletin of Science. Technology & Society 2004; 24: 177-181
• 122 Greenhalgh T, Howick J, Maskrey N. (for the Evidence Based Medicine Renaissance Group) Evidence based medicine: a movement in crisis?. BMJ 2014; 348: g3725
• 123 Spadaccini J, Esteves JE. Intuition, analysis, and reflection: an experimental study into the decision-making processes and thinking dispositions of osteopathy students. Int J Osteopath Med 2014; 17: 263-271
• 124 Ermann M. Intuition. Die unbewusste Intelligenz. Psychotherapeut 2013; 58: 136-142
• 125 Schwartz A, Elstein AS. Clinical reasoning in medicine. In: Higgs J, Jones MA, Loftus S et al. Clinical reasoning in the health professions. 3. Aufl. Philadelphia: Elsevier; 2008
• 126 Flavell JH. Metacognition and cognitive monitoring: A new area of cognitive-developmental inquiry. American Psychologist 1979; 34: 906-911
• 127 Veenman MVJ, Van Hout-Wolters BHAM, Afflerbach P. Metacognition and learning: conceptual and methodological considerations. Metacogn Learning 2006; 1: 3-14
• 128 Krieger F, Azevedo R, Graesser AC. et al. Introduction to the special issue: the role of metacognition in complex skills – spotlights on problem solving, collaboration, and self-regulated learning. Metacognition Learning 2022; 17: 683-690
• 129 Still AT. Philosophy of osteopathy. Kirksville. MO: 1899
• 130 van Elk M, Aleman A. Brain mechanisms in religion and spirituality: An integrative predictive processing framework. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 2017; 73: 359-378
• 131 D'Alessandro G, Cerritelli F, Cortelli P. Sensitization and Interoception as Key Neurological Concepts in Osteopathy and Other Manual Medicines. Front Neurosci 2016; 10: 100
• 132 McGlone F, Cerritelli F, Walker S. et al. The role of gentle touch in perinatal osteopathic manual therapy. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 2017; 72: 1-9
• 133 Thibodeau PH, Hendricks RK, Boroditsky L. How linguistic metaphor scaffolds reasoning. Trends Cogn Sci 2017; 21: 852-863
• 134 Zegarra-Parodi R, Esteves JE, Lunghi C. et al. The legacy and implications of the body-mind-spirit osteopathic tenet: A discussion paper evaluating its clinical relevance in contemporary osteopathic care. Int J Osteopath Med 2021; 41: 57-65
• 135 Miles A, Loughlin M. Models in the balance: evidence-based medicine versus evidence-informed individualized care. J Eval Clin Pract 2011; 17: 531-536
• 136 Consorti G, Marchetti A, De Marinis MG. What Makes an Osteopathic Treatment Effective from a Patient's Perspective: A Descriptive Phenomenological Study. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2020; 43: 882-890
• 137 Gigerenzer G, Muir Gray JA. Better doctors, better patients, better decisions. Envisioning health care 2020. Cambridge: MIT; 2011
• 138 Vogel S. W(h)ither osteopathy: A call for reflection; a call for submissions for a special issue. Int J Osteopath Med 2021; 41: 1-3
• 139 Hartmann C. Historisch reflektierte Osteopathie. 2. Aufl. Pähl: Jolandos; 2022
• 140 Rogers FJ, D'Alonzo GE, Glover JC. et al. Proposed tenets of osteopathic medicine and principles for patient care. J Am Osteopath Assoc 2002; 102: 63-65
• 141 Smith D. Reflecting on new models for osteopathy: it's time for change. Int J Osteopath Med 2019; 31: 15-20
• 142 Carnes D, Mars T, Plunkett A. et al. A mixed methods evaluation of a third wave cognitive behavioural therapy and osteopathic treatment programme for chronic pain in primary care (OsteoMAP). Int J Osteopath Med 2017; 24: 12-17
• 143 Esteves JE, Cerritelli F, Kim J. et al. Osteopathic Care as (En)active Inference: A Theoretical Framework for Developing an Integrative Hypothesis in Osteopathy. Front Psychol 2022; 13: 812926
• 144 Liem T, Lunghi C. Osteopathie als personenzentrierte und integrierende Behandlungsmethode (Teil 2). Osteopath Med 2022; 23: 14-19
• 145 Banton A, Vogel S. Relational clinical practice: A hermeneutic, enactive, intersubjective model of osteopathy. Int J Osteopath Med 2023; 51: 100707
• 146 Shaw R, Abbey H, Casals-Gutiérrez S. et al. Reconceptualizing the therapeutic alliance in osteopathic practice: Integrating insights from phenomenology, psychology and enactive inference. Int J Osteopath Med 2022; 46: 36-44
• 147 Thomson OP, MacMillan A. Saying it doesnʼt make it so – a reply to Espírito Santo et al. Int J Osteopath Med 2024; 51: 100693
• 148 Cerritelli F, Esteves JE. An Enactive-Ecological Model to Guide Patient-Centered Osteopathic Care. Healthcare (Basel) 2022; 10: 1092