Postoperative Monitoring of Free Flaps in Autologous Breast Reconstruction: A Multicenter Comparison of 398 Flaps Using Clinical Monitoring, Microdialysis, and the Implantable Doppler Probe

ABSTRACT

Many techniques for flap monitoring following free tissue transfer have been described; however, there is little evidence that any of these techniques allow for greater rates of flap salvage over clinical monitoring alone. We sought to compare three established monitoring techniques across three experienced microsurgical centers in a comparable cohort of patients. A retrospective, matched cohort study of 398 consecutive free flaps in 347 patients undergoing autologous breast reconstruction was undertaken across three institutions during the same 3-year period, with a single form of postoperative monitoring used at each institution: clinical monitoring alone, the Cook-Swartz implantable Doppler probe, or microdialysis. Both objective and subjective measures of efficacy were assessed. Clinical monitoring alone, the implantable Doppler probe, and microdialysis showed statistically similar rates of flap salvage. False-negative rates were also statistically similar (only seen in the clinically monitored group). However, there was a statistically significant increase in false-positive alarms causing needless take-backs to theater in the microdialysis and implantable Doppler arms, p < 0.001. This study did not find any technique superior to clinical monitoring alone. New monitoring technologies should be compared objectively with clinical monitoring as the current standard in postoperative flap monitoring.

KEYWORDS

Breast reconstruction - deep inferior epigastric artery - DIEP flap - perforator flap - superficial inferior epigastric artery perforator flap - Cook probe

REFERENCES

• 1 Disa J J, Cordeiro P G, Hidalgo D A. Efficacy of conventional monitoring techniques in free tissue transfer: an 11-year experience in 750 consecutive cases.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 1999;  104 97-101
• 2 Gill P S, Hunt J P, Guerra A B et al.. A 10-year retrospective review of 758 DIEP flaps for breast reconstruction.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 2004;  113 1153-1160
• 3 Bui D T, Cordeiro P G, Hu Q Y, Disa J J, Pusic A, Mehrara B J. Free flap reexploration: indications, treatment, and outcomes in 1193 free flaps.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 2007;  119 2092-2100
• 4 Heller L, Levin L S, Klitzman B. Laser Doppler flowmeter monitoring of free-tissue transfers: blood flow in normal and complicated cases.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 2001;  107 1739-1745
• 5 de la Torre J, Hedden W, Grant III J H, Gardner P M, Fix R J, Vásconez L O. Retrospective review of the internal Doppler probe for intra- and postoperative microvascular surveillance.  J Reconstr Microsurg. 2003;  19 287-290
• 6 Rozen W M, Ashton M W, Stella D L, Phillips T J, Taylor G I. The accuracy of computed tomographic angiography for mapping the perforators of the DIEA: a cadaveric study.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 2008;  122 363-369
• 7 Holm C, Mayr M, Höfter E, Raab N, Ninkovic M. Interindividual variability of the SIEA Angiosome: effects on operative strategies in breast reconstruction.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 2008;  122 1612-1620
• 8 Holm C, Mayr M, Höfter E, Ninkovic M. The versatility of the SIEA flap: a clinical assessment of the vascular territory of the superficial epigastric inferior artery.  J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2007;  60 946-951
• 9 Whitaker I S, Gulati V, Ross G L, Menon A, Ong T K. Variations in the postoperative management of free tissue transfers to the head and neck in the United Kingdom.  Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2007;  45 16-18
• 10 Whitaker I S, Oliver D W, Ganchi P A. Postoperative monitoring of microvascular tissue transfers: current practice in the United Kingdom and Ireland.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 2003;  111 2118-2119
• 11 Jallali N, Ridha H, Butler P E. Postoperative monitoring of free flaps in UK plastic surgery units.  Microsurgery. 2005;  25 469-472
• 12 May Jr J W, Chait L A, O'Brien B M, Hurley J V. The no-reflow phenomenon in experimental free flaps.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 1978;  61 256-267
• 13 Smit J M, Zeebregts C J, Acosta R. Timing of presentation of the first signs of vascular compromise dictates the salvage outcome of free flap transfers.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 2008;  122 991-992
• 14 Smit J M, Acosta R, Zeebregts C J, Liss A G, Anniko M, Hartman E H. Early reintervention of compromised free flaps improves success rate.  Microsurgery. 2007;  27 612-616
• 15 Hofer S O, Damen T H, Mureau M A, Rakhorst H A, Roche N A. A critical review of perioperative complications in 175 free deep inferior epigastric perforator flap breast reconstructions.  Ann Plast Surg. 2007;  59 137-142
• 16 Chen K T, Mardini S, Chuang D C et al.. Timing of presentation of the first signs of vascular compromise dictates the salvage outcome of free flap transfers.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 2007;  120 187-195
• 17 Creech B, Miller S. Evaluation of circulation in skin flaps. In: Grabb WC, Myers MB Skin Flaps. Boston, MA; Little Brown 1975: 21-38
• 18 Rozen W M, Chubb D, Whitaker I S, Acosta R. The efficacy of postoperative monitoring: a single surgeon comparison of clinical monitoring and the implantable Doppler probe in 547 consecutive free flaps.  Microsurgery. 2009;  30 105-110
• 19 Mathes S J, Nahai F. Flap selection. Fascia/fasciocutaneous vascular classification.  In: Reconstructive Surgery Principles, Anatomy and Technique. Vol. 1. New York; Churchill Livingstone 1997: 47-50
• 20 Whitney T M, Lineaweaver W C, Billys J B et al.. Improved salvage of complicated microvascular transplants monitored with quantitative fluorometry.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 1992;  90 105-111
• 21 Lineaweaver W C. The implantable Doppler probe.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 1988;  82 1099-1100
• 22 Whitaker I S, Smit J M, Acosta R. A simple method of implantable Doppler cuff attachment: experience in 150 DIEP breast reconstructions.  J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2008;  61 1251-1252
• 23 Swartz W M, Izquierdo R, Miller M J. Implantable venous Doppler microvascular monitoring: laboratory investigation and clinical results.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 1994;  93 152-163
• 24 Solomon G A, Yaremchuk M J, Manson P N. Doppler ultrasound surface monitoring of both arterial and venous flow in clinical free tissue transfers.  J Reconstr Microsurg. 1986;  3 39-41
• 25 Smit J M, Whitaker I S, Liss A G, Audolfsson T, Kildal M, Acosta R. Post operative monitoring of microvascular breast reconstructions using the implantable Cook-Swartz doppler system: a study of 145 probes & technical discussion.  J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2008;  62 1286-1292
• 26 Pryor S G, Moore E J, Kasperbauer J L. Implantable Doppler flow system: experience with 24 microvascular free-flap operations.  Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2006;  135 714-718
• 27 Kind G M, Buntic R F, Buncke G M, Cooper T M, Siko P P, Buncke Jr H J. The effect of an implantable Doppler probe on the salvage of microvascular tissue transplants.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 1998;  101 1268-1273 discussion 1274-1275
• 28 Oliver D W, Whitaker I S, Giele H, Critchley P, Cassell O. The Cook-Swartz venous Doppler probe for the post-operative monitoring of free tissue transfers in the United Kingdom: a preliminary report.  Br J Plast Surg. 2005;  58 366-370
• 29 Parker P M, Fischer J C, Shaw W W. Implantable pulsed Doppler cuff for long-term monitoring of free flaps: a preliminary study.  Microsurgery. 1984;  5 130-135
• 30 Swartz W M, Jones N F, Cherup L, Klein A. Direct monitoring of microvascular anastomoses with the 20-MHz ultrasonic Doppler probe: an experimental and clinical study.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 1988;  81 149-161
• 31 Rosenberg J J, Fornage B D, Chevray P M. Monitoring buried free flaps: limitations of the implantable Doppler and use of color duplex sonography as a confirmatory test.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 2006;  118 109-113 discussion 114-115
• 32 Udesen A, Løntoft E, Kristensen S R. Monitoring of free TRAM flaps with microdialysis.  J Reconstr Microsurg. 2000;  16 101-106
• 33 Edsander-Nord A, Röjdmark J, Wickman M. Metabolism in pedicled and free TRAM flaps: a comparison using the microdialysis technique.  Plast Reconstr Surg. 2002;  109 664-673
• 34 Jyränki J, Suominen S, Vuola J, Bäck L. Microdialysis in clinical practice: monitoring intraoral free flaps.  Ann Plast Surg. 2006;  56 387-393
• 35 Sorensen H B. Free jejunal flaps can be monitored by use of microdialysis.  J Reconstr Microsurg. 2008;  24 443-448
• 36 Whitaker I S, Karoo R OS, Oliver D W, Ganchi P A, Gulati V, Malata C M. Current techniques in the post-operative monitoring of microvascular free-tissue transfers.  Eur J Plast Surg. 2005;  27 315-321