Economic Analysis of “Liquid” versus Surgical Face-lift: Are Large-Volume Facial Soft Tissue Filler Injection Treatments a Viable Alternative to Rhytidectomy?

ABSTRACT

For many years, rhytidectomy has been the mainstay of facial rejuvenative treatment, and continued improvement of our understanding of the anatomy, aesthetics, and aging of the face has allowed the development of safer, longer lasting, and more natural surgical techniques. However, the renaissance of soft tissue augmentation that began at the start of the new millennium now offers office-based rejuvenative procedures that have been touted as equivalent to traditional surgical procedures, including the “injectable rhinoplasty” and, more commonly, the “injectable face-lift.” Although injectable filler treatments cannot exactly simulate the benefits of surgical rhytidectomy, they can significantly rejuvenate the face and obviate or delay the need for surgery. These are touted as simpler as well as easier and cheaper for the patient. But are they? No cost-effectiveness study of these “filler face-lifts” has ever been published, and the need for repeat treatments suggests that at some point in time, patient costs for these procedures may exceed those for a single surgical procedure. This study examines common scenarios for large-volume soft tissue filler facial rejuvenation and compares the costs of these treatments with those of traditional face-lift surgery.

KEYWORDS

Soft tissue fillers - rhytidectomy - face-lift - cost minimization - outcome measures

REFERENCES

• 1 Taub A F, Sarnoff D, Gold M, Jacob C. Effect of multisyringe hyaluronic acid facial rejuvenation on perceived age.  Dermatol Surg. 2010;  36 322-328
• 2 Narins R S, Dayan S H, Brandt F S, Baldwin E K. Persistence and improvement of nasolabial fold correction with nonanimal-stabilized hyaluronic acid 100,000 gel particles/mL filler on two retreatment schedules: results up to 18 months on two retreatment schedules.  Dermatol Surg. 2008;  34(Suppl 1) S2-S8; discussion S8
• 3 Wang F, Garza L A, Kang S et al.. In vivo stimulation of de novo collagen production caused by cross-linked hyaluronic acid dermal filler injections in photodamaged human skin.  Arch Dermatol. 2007;  143 155-163
• 4 American Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery .Cosmetic Surgery National Data Bank Statistics. 2009. Available at: http://asaps.org/sites/default/files/2009stats.pdf Accessed April 17, 2010