Reliability of Resting and Postexercise Heart Rate Measures

Abstract

In this study, we compared the reliability of short-term resting heart rate (HR) variability (HRV) and postexercise parasympathetic reactivation (i. e., HR recovery (HRR) and HRV) indices following either submaximal or supramaximal exercise. On 4 different occasions, beat-to-beat HR was recorded in 15 healthy males (21.5±1.4 yr) during 5 min of seated rest, followed by submaximal (Sub) and supramaximal (Supra) exercise bouts; both exercise bouts were followed by 5 min of seated recovery. Reliability of all HR-derived indices was assessed by the typical error of measurement expressed as a coefficient of variation (CV,%). CV for HRV indices ranged from 4 to 17%, 7 to 27% and 41 to 82% for time domain, spectral and ratio indices, respectively. The CV for HRR ranged from 15 to 32%. Spectral CVs for HRV were lower at rest compared with Supra (e. g., natural logarithm of the high frequency range (LnHF); 12.6 vs. 26.2%; p=0.02). HRR reliability was not different between Sub and Supra (25 vs. 14%; p=0.10). The present study found discrepancy in the CVs of vagal-related heart rate indices; a finding that should be appreciated when assessing changes in these variables. Further, Supra exercise was shown to worsen the reliability of HRV-spectral indices.

Key words

heart rate variability - heart rate recovery - typical error - repeatability - autonomic nervous system - vagal-related indices

References

• 1 Atkinson G, Nevill AM. Statistical methods for assessing measurement error (reliability) in variables relevant to sports medicine.  Sports Med. 1998;  26 217-238
• 2 Billman G. Aerobic exercise conditioning: a nonpharmacological antiarrhythmic intervention.  J Appl Physiol. 2002;  92 446-454
• 3 Blain G, Meste O, Bermon S. Influences of breathing patterns on respiratory sinus arrhythmia in humans during exercise.  Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol. 2005;  288 887-895
• 4 Bloomfield D, Magnano A, Bigger JJ, Rivadeneira H, Parides M, Steinman RC. Comparison of spontaneous vs. metronome-guided breathing on assessment of vagal modulation using RR variability.  Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol. 2001;  280 1145-1150
• 5 Bosquet L, Gamelin FX, Berthoin S. Reliability of postexercise heart rate recovery.  Int J Sports Med. 2008;  29 238-243
• 6 Buchheit M, Al Haddad H, Millet G, Lepretre PM, Newton M, Ahmaidi S. Cardiorespiratory and cardiac autonomic responses to 30–15 intermittent fitness test in team sport players.  J Strength Cond Res. 2009;  23 93-100
• 7 Buchheit M, Chivot A, Parouty J, Mercier D, Al Haddad H, Laursen PB, Ahmaidi S. Monitoring endurance running performance using cardiac parasympathetic function.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 2010;  108 1153-1167
• 8 Buchheit M, Gindre C. Cardiac parasympathetic regulation: respective associations with cardiorespiratory fitness and training load.  Am J Physiol. 2006;  291 H451-H458
• 9 Buchheit M, Laursen PB, Ahmaidi S. Parasympathetic reactivation after repeated sprint exercise.  Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol. 2007;  293 133-141
• 10 Buchheit M, Millet G, Parisy A, Pourchez S, Laursen PB, Ahmaidi S. Supramaximal training and post-exercise parasympathetic reactivation in adolescents.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2008;  40 362-371
• 11 Buchheit M, Papelier Y, Laursen P, Ahmaidi S. Noninvasive assessment of cardiac parasympathetic function: post-exercise heart rate recovery or heart rate variability?.  Am J Physiol. 2007;  23 H8-H10
• 12 Goldberger J, Challapalli S, Tung R, Parker M, Kadish A. Relationship of heart rate variability to parasympathetic effect.  Circulation. 2001;  103 1977-1983
• 13 Goldberger J, Le FK, Lahiri M, Lahiri M, Kannankeril PJ, Ng J, Kadish AH. Assessment of parasympathetic reactivation after exercise.  Am J Physiol. 2006;  290 H2446-H2452
• 14 Goulopoulou S, Heffernan K, Fernhall B, Yates G, Baxter-Jones AD, Unnithan VB. Heart rate variability during recovery from a Wingate test in adolescent males.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2006;  38 875-881
• 15 Harriss DJ, Atkinson G. International Journal of Sports Medicine – Ethical Standards in Sport and Exercise Science Research.  Int J Sports Med. 2009;  30 701-702
• 16 Hopkins WG. Measures of reliability in sports medicine and science.  Sports Med. 2000;  30 1-15
• 17 Hopkins WG. Reliability from consecutive pairs of trials (Excel spreadsheet).  Sportscience. 2000;  http://sportsci.org/
• 18 Hopkins WG, Hawley JA, Burke LM. Design and analysis of research on sport performance enhancement.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1999;  31 472-485
• 19 Hopkins WG, Marshall SW, Batterham AM, Hanin J. Progressive statistics for studies in sports medicine and exercise science.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2009;  41 3-13
• 20 Hopkins WG, Schabort EJ, Hawley JA. Reliability of power in physical performance tests.  Sports Med. 2001;  31 211-234
• 21 Imai K, Sato H, Hori M, Kusuoka H, Ozaki H, Yokoyama H, Takeda H, Inoue M, Kamada T. Vagally mediated heart rate recovery after exercise is accelerated in athletes but blunted in patients with chronic heart failure.  J Am Coll Cardiol. 1994;  24 1529-1535
• 22 Inbar O, Bar-Or O, Skinner J. The Wingate Anaerobic Test.. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics; 1996
• 23 Kiviniemi AM, Hautala AJ, Kinnunen H, Tulppo MP. Endurance training guided individually by daily heart rate variability measurements.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 2007;  101 743-751
• 24 Kobayashi H. Does paced breathing improve the reproducibility of heart rate variability measurements?.  J Physiol Anthropol. 2009;  28 225-230
• 25 Lamberts RP, Lemmink KA, Durandt JJ, Lambert MI. Variation in heart rate during submaximal exercise: implications for monitoring training.  J Strength Cond Res. 2004;  18 641-645
• 26 Lamberts RP, Swart J, Capostagno B, Noakes TD, Lambert MI. Heart rate recovery as a guide to monitor fatigue and predict changes in performance parameters.  Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2010;  20 449-457
• 27 Leicht AS, Allen GD. Moderate-term reproducibility of heart rate variability during rest and light to moderate exercise in children.  Braz J Med Biol Res. 2008;  41 627-633
• 28 Maeder MT, Ammann P, Rickli H, Brunner-La Rocca HP. Impact of the exercise mode on heart rate recovery after maximal exercise.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 2009;  105 247-255
• 29 Nunan D, Donovan G, Jakovljevic D, Hodges LD, Sandercock GR, Brodie DA. Validity and reliability of short-term heart-rate variability from the Polar S810.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2009;  41 243-250
• 30 Parouty J, Al Haddad H, Quod M, Leprêtre PM, Ahmaidi S, Buchheit M. Effect of cold water immersion on 100-m sprint performance in well-trained swimmers.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 2010;  109 483-490
• 31 Penttila J, Helminen A, Jartti T, Kuusela T, Huikuri HV, Tulppo MP, Coffeng R, Scheinin H. Time domain, geometrical and frequency domain analysis of cardiac vagal outflow: effects of various respiratory patterns.  Clin Physiol. 2001;  21 365-376
• 32 Salo TM, Voipio-Pulkki LM, Jalonen JO, Helenius H, Viikari JS, Kantola I. Reproducibility of abnormal heart rate variability indices: the case of hypertensive sleep apnoea syndrome.  Clin Physiol. 1999;  19 258-268
• 33 Sandercock GR, Bromley PD, Brodie DA. The reliability of short-term measurements of heart rate variability.  Int J Cardiol. 2005;  103 238-247
• 34 Sinnreich R, Kark JD, Friedlander Y, Sapoznikov D, Luria MH. Five minute recordings of heart rate variability for population studies: repeatability and age-sex characteristics.  Heart. 1998;  80 156-162
• 35 Task Force . Heart rate variability: standards of measurement, physiological interpretation and clinical use. Task Force of the European Society of Cardiology and the North American Society of Pacing and Electrophysiology.  Circulation. 1996;  93 1043-1065
• 36 Weir JP. Quantifying test-retest reliability using the intraclass correlation coefficient and the SEM.  J Strength Cond Res. 2005;  19 231-240

Correspondence