Isolation to Interface to Integration

Summary

Objectives: Over thirty years both divergence and synergy have been seen in the health informatics (HI) domain; to the point where aspiration is towards a collective environment recognising HI as a mature discipline internationally. The author considers catalysts and inhibitors to this goal over 30 years, and asks the question – is one professional identity achievable and desirable?

This review of development of HI aims to promote reflection of the status, value and attributable influence with a view to recognising an internationally entity. Aspects of professionalism, practice, regulation and registration can then be refined to produce a universally understood inclusive community without loss of distinction to sub-specialties within it.

Methods: The author utilised literature searches, research studies, domain knowledge and cooperative inquiries as context. Evaluation of issues is grounded in learned society investigations of professionalism and commitment to development of professional registration of those in informatics for the care domain.

Results : Transition from isolated applications through interfaced ‘best of breed’ solutions working together to integrated closely coupled single-vendor solutions is mirrored by professional groups, established through special interests, working together on big initiatives and then formally benefiting from a cohesive group. Phasing of such staged development is different by country or by focus/topic.

Conclusions: The global HI situation will never again be as diverse as historically it was. Recognition of the lifecycle of the interacting factors explored in this paper will help HI to assume a world-wide brand identity whilst sustaining the subsidiarity of specialist cohorts within it.

Keywords

Health informatics - fragmentation - history - organisation - maturity

• References

• 1 Klar R. Selected impressions on the beginning of the electronic medical record and patient information. Methods Inf Med 2004; 43 (05) 537-42.
• 2 Harvey P, Roberts J. Problems of Transferring Software: A Medical Case History. Medical Informatics 1979; 4: 4.
• 3 NHS. National Programme for IT. www.connectingforhealth.nhs.uk accessed January 2006
• 4 de Dombal FT, Leaper DJ, Staniland JR, McCann AP, Horrocks JC. Computer aided diagnosis of acute abdominal pain. BMJ 1972; 2: 9-13.
• 5 Scholes M, Bryant Y, Barber B. The Use of Computers in Nursing. North Holland, Amsterdam: Elsevier 1985
• 6 British Computer Society Health Informatics Forum. www.bcshif.org accessed February 2006
• 7 UK Council for Health Informatics Professions. www.ukchip.org.uk accessed February 2006
• 8 Mantas J, Hovenga E. (eds.) Globalisation of Health Informatics Education: associated issues. IOS Press for IMIA, September 2004
• 9 European Heath Telematics Observatory. www.ehto.org/aim/volume1/annex.html accessed March 2005
• 10 Kluge E-H. A Handbook of Ethics for Health Informatics Professionals. IMIA/BCSHIC 2003
• 11 Balas A, Boren S. (eds.) Transferring Research to Practice for Health Care Improvement: Information Technology Strategies from the United States and the European Union. IOS Press (Health Technology and Informatics series 076), May 2000