The Use of Knowledge-based Systems in Medicine in Developing Countries: A Luxury or a Necessity?

Abstract:

Knowledge-based systems (KBSs) in medicine have received much attention over the past two decades, mainly because of the potential benefits that can be gained from using them. They may facilitate in increasing productivity in a medical environment, support the making of diagnoses and other types of medical decisions, assist in the training of medical professionals, and can even handle some routine tasks in a medical environment. However, some critical problems in this field have also been identified. For example, research indicated that some problems can be solved partially, but not completely, with existing artificial intelligence techniques. Another problem is that many of the existing medical information systems do not support the integration of KBSs in a natural way. Furthermore, the routine use of a medical KBS is complicated by legal issues. These and other problems contribute to what we experience today: a large proportion of the medical KB applications that are developed is never actually used in practice. This justifies questions such as: Should developing countries, having limited infrastructure and research resources, invest in medical KBSs research and development, or should this field be regarded as a luxury that only belongs to developed countries?, and: Can developing countries really benefit from the use of these systems? These questions are discussed in this paper. We highlight the main problems surrounding the development and use of medical KBSs. With the focus on developing countries we discuss potential benefits that could be obtained by investing in these systems and we offer guidelines for focusing research and development of medical KBSs.

Keywords:

Knowledge-based Systems - Developing Countries - Artificial Intelligence in Medicine

• References

• 1 Shortliffe EH. The adolescence of AI in medicine: Will the field come of age in the ’90s?. Artif Intell Med 1993; 5: 93-106.
• 2 Green A. An introduction to health planning in developing countries. Oxford University Press; 1994
• 3 Lee K, Mills A, Hoare G. Health economics research in developing countries: an overview. In: Mills A, Lee K. eds. Health Economics Research in developing countries. Oxford University Press; 1993: 1-16.
• 4 Mäkelä M, Banerji D. Levels of health care. In: Lankinen KS, Bergström S, Mäkelä PH, Peltomaa M. eds. Health and diseases in developing countries. MacMillan; 1994: 393-401.
• 5 Juva K, Mäkelä PH. Training of Health Workers. In: Lankinen KS, Bergström S, Mäkelä PH, Peltomaa M. eds. Health and diseases in developing countries. Macmillan; 1994: 427-32.
• 6 Porenta G, Pfahringer B, Hoberstorfer M, Trappl R. A decision support system for village health workers in developing countries. In: Mann CK, Ruth SR. eds. Expert systems in developing countries: practice and promise. Westview Press; 1992: 193-207.
• 7 Cibulskis RE. Knowledge-based systems for monitoring and evaluation of health services in developing countries. Lancet 1992; 33: 310.
• 8 Bertrand WE. Information as a primary health care intervention: The impact of new technology on improving health for all. In: Wilson RG, Echols BE, Bryant JH, Abrantes A. eds. Management information systems and microcomputers in primary health care. Escola Nacional de Saude Publica; 1988: 21-6.
• 9 Schware R. Management information systems and microcomputers in primary health care: Issues and challenges. In: Wilson RG, Echols BE, Bryant JH, Abrantes A. eds. Management information systems and microcomputers in primary health care. Escola Nacional de Saude Publica; 1988: 17-20.
• 10 Bainbridge DI. Computer-aided diagnosis and negligence. Med Sci Law 1991; 2: 127-36.
• 11 Monippallil M. The application of strict liability to defective expert systems. In: Turban E, Liebowitz J. eds. Managing expert systems. Idea Group Publishing; 1992: 211-28.
• 12 Tolmie CJ. The Development of an expert system for the interpretation of complete blood count results at a private pathology firm. Ph. O. dissertation Bloemfontein: University of the Orange Free State; 1993
• 13 Clayton PD, Hripesak G. Decision support in healthcare. Int J Biomed Comput 1995; 39: 59-66.
• 14 Wilson RG, Echols BE, Bryant JH, Abrantes A. eds. Management information systems and microcomputers in primary health care. Escola Nacional de Saude Publica; 1988
• 15 Hedberg SR. Intelligent agents: The first harvest of softbots looks promising. IEEE Expert; 1995. August: 6–9.
• 16 Weld DS, Marks J, Bobrow DG. eds. The role of intelligent systems in the national information infrastructure. AI Magazine 1995; Fall: 45-64.
• 17 Bouche M, Plauchu V, Retour D. Troubleshooting expert systems for industrial maintenance: Pre-development guidelines. Expert Systems 1990; 3: 142-8.
• 18 Mizoguchi R, Motoda H. Expert systems research in Japan. IEEE Expert; 1995. August: 14–23.
• 19 Folley Jr JD, Hritz RJ. Embedded AI expert systems troubleshoots automated assembly. IE; 1987. April: 32–6.
• 20 Powers L W. Diagnostic hematology: Clinical and technical principles. Mosby: 1989
• 21 Burgess PR, Kershaw GW, Coleman RH, Robin H, Coad CD, Gibson J, Kronenberg H. A computerized expert system for handling the output of the technicon H1 haematology analyser. Clin Lab Haematol 1993; 15: 21-32.
• 22 Kersten GE, Tolmie CJ. Artificial Intelligence: An overview of the field and its applications in medicine and health services. In: International Seminar on the Challenges of the Information Era: Agents and Users. Sao Paulo: 1994. (CD-ROM).
• 23 Weghorst S. Virtual reality in medicine. Artif Intel in Med 1994; 6: 277-9.
• 24 Kwa HY, van der Lei J, Kors JA. Expert systems integrated with information systems. Comput Methods Programs Biomed 1987; 25: 327-32.
• 25 Tolmie CJ, du Plessis JP. Embedding an expert system in a laboratory information system – experience with a real world application. In: Liebowitz J. Moving Towards Expert Systems Globally in the 21st Century. 1994. MacMillan; (CD-ROM).
• 26 Harmon P, Sawyer B. Creating expert systems for business and industry. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.; 1990
• 27 The intelligent software development tools market – Part L Intelligent Software Strategies. Cutter Information Corporation 1996; 2: 1-12.
• 28 DeBrota DJ. In front of us. Int J Biomed Comput 1994; 34: 131-5.
• 29 Diamond LW, Mishka V, Seal AH, Nguyen D. Are normative expert systems appropriate for diagnostic pathology?. J Am Med Inform Assoc 1995; 2: 85-93.
• 30 Tolrnie CJ. The use of proto typing for the development of a system with both a knowledge-based component and a software-based component. Inform Decision Technol 1994; 19: 267-75.