Towards Open Collaborative Health Informatics - The Role of Free/Libre Open Source Principles

Summary

Objectives

To analyze the contribution of Free/Libre Open Source Software in health care (FLOSS-HC) and to give perspectives for future developments.

Methods

The paper summarizes FLOSS-related trends in health care as anticipated by members of the IMIA Open Source Working Group. Data were obtained through literature review and personal experience and observations of the authors in the last two decades. A status quo is given by a frequency analysis of the database of Medfloss.org, one of the world’s largest platforms dedicated to FLOSS-HC. The authors discuss current problems in the field of health care and finally give a prospective roadmap, a projection of the potential influences of FLOSS in health care.

Results

FLOSS-HC already exists for more than 2 decades. Several projects have shown that FLOSS may produce highly competitive alternatives to proprietary solutions that are at least equivalent in usability and have a better total cost of ownership ratio. The Medfloss.org database currently lists 221 projects of diverse application types.

Conclusions

FLOSS principles hold a great potential for addressing several of the most critical problems in health care IT. The authors argue that an ecosystem perspective is relevant and that FLOSS principles are best suited to create health IT systems that are able to evolve over time as medical knowledge, technologies, insights, workflows etc. continuously change. All these factors that inherently influence the development of health IT systems are changing at an ever growing pace. Traditional models of software engineering are not able to follow these changes and provide up-to-date systems for an acceptable cost/value ratio. To allow FLOSS to positively influence Health IT in the future a "FLOSS-friendly" environment has to be provided. Policy makers should resolve uncertainties in the legal framework that disfavor FLOSS. Certification procedures should be specified in a way that they do not raise additional barriers for FLOSS.

Keywords

Open source software - health information systems - health informatics policies

• References

• 1 The Free Software Definition. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html
• 2 The Open Source Definition (Annotated). Version 1.9. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.opensource.org/osd.html
• 3 Riehle D. The Commercial Open Source Business Model. In: Nelson ML, Shaw MJ, Strader TJ. editors. Value Creation in EBusiness Management. Springer Berlin Heidelberg; 2009: 18-30.
• 4 Commissioned Study Shows Open Source Paves The Way For The Next Generation Of Enterprise IT. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.wcm.bull.com/internet/pr/rend.jsp?DocId=412289&lang=en
• 5 Gartner Highlights Key Predictions for IT Organisations and Users in 2008 and Beyond. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.gartner.com/it/page.jsp?id=593207
• 6 Valdes I. Free and Open Source Software in Healthcare 1.0. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: https://www.amia.org/f iles/Final-OS-WG%20White%20Paper_11_19_08.pdf
• 7 Medfloss.org - Medical Free/Libre and Open Source Software. [2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.medfloss.org/
• 8 Schmuhl H. Medfloss.org - A comprehensive platform for medical free/libre and open source software. 2010 [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.apfelkraut.org/download/Medfloss_Med-e-Tel_2010_H_Schmuhl.pdf
• 9 Schmuhl H. What Else Is Going On? – Building a Project Database. 2008 [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.apfelkraut.org/download/med-e-tel_oss_db_h_schmuhl.pdf
• 10 Demski H, Hildebrand C, Jossif A, Engelbrecht R. editors. Information on Open Source Solutions in Healthcare the OSSHealth Repository. Med-E-Tel. 2010. Luxembourg.;
• 11 Haux R. Strategic information management in hospitals : an introduction to hospital information systems. New York: Springer; 2003
• 12 Statistics about medfloss.org. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.medfloss.org/node/474
• 13 Flores AEZuniga, Win KT, Susilo W. Functionalities of free and open electronic health record systems. Int J Technol Assess Health Care 2010; Oct; 26 (04) 382-9.
• 14 OpenMRS - Open source health IT for the planet. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://openmrs.org/
• 15 The Indivo Personally Controlled Health Record. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://indivohealth.org/
• 16 OsiriX Imaging Software. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.osirix-viewer.com/
• 17 OSCAR Canada Users Society. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.oscarcanada.org/
• 18 Mirth Connect - Mirth Corporation. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.mirthcorp.com/community/mirth-connect
• 19 Mars M. Health capacity development through telemedicine in Africa. Yearb Med Inform 2010; 87-93.
• 20 Haux R. Medical informatics: past, present, future. Int J Med Inform 2010; September; 79 (09) 599-610.
• 21 Seebregts CJ, Mamlin BW, Biondich PG, Fraser HSF, Wolfe BA, Jazayeri D. et al. Human Factors for Capacity Building. Lessons learned from the OpenMRS Implementers Network. Yearb Med Inform 2010; 13-20.
• 22 Akter S, Ray P. mHealth - an Ultimate Platform to Serve the Unserved. Yearb Med Inform 2010; 94-100.
• 23 Open Health Tools. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.openhealthtools.org/
• 24 Open eHealth Integration Platform. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://repo.openehealth.org/
• 25 NHIN CONNECT Community Portal. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.connectopensource.org/
• 26 Open World Forum 2010. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.openworldforum.org
• 27 Portal do Software Público Brasileiro. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.softwarepublico.gov.br/
• 28 OSOR.eu - Open Source Observatory and Repository. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.osor.eu/
• 29 Report on the International Status of Open Source Software 2010. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://observatorio.cenatic.es/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=666:reporton-the-international-status-of-open-source-software-2010&catid=13:empresas&Itemid=23
• 30 RapidSMS /SMS Application Framework. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.rapidsms.org/
• 31 Medical - The Universal Hospital and Health Information System. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://medical.sourceforge.net/
• 32 GNU Solidario: Making a difference with Free Software. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.gnusolidario.org/en/index.html
• 33 VistA - Vistapedia. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://vistapedia.net/
• 34 Byrne CM, Mercincavage LM, Pan EC, Vincent AG, Johnston DS, Middleton B. The value from investments in health information technology at the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. Health Affairs (Project Hope) 2010; April; 29 (04) 629-38.
• 35 Perens B. Bruce Perens - The Emerging Economic Paradigm of Open Source. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://perens.com/works/articles/Economic.html
• 36 Riehle D. The Economic Motivation of Open Source Software: Stakeholder Perspectives. Computer 2007; April;40: 25-32.
• 37 Riehle D. The Single-Vendor Commercial Open Source Business Model. Information Systems and e-Business Management. Springer Verlag; 2011
• 38 PERSONA Project Portal. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.aal-persona.org/
• 39 OASIS - Open architecture for Accessible Services Integration and Standardization. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.oasis-project.eu
• 40 MPOWER. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.sintef.no/mpower
• 41 MonAMI. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.monami.info/
• 42 SOPRANO - Service-oriented Programmable Smart Environments for Older Europeans. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.sopranoip.org/
• 43 Vaalid - Accessibility and Usability Validation Framework for AAL Interaction Design Process. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.vaalid-project.org/
• 44 UniversAAL. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.universaal.org/
• 45 AAL Open Association - AALOA. Available from: http://www.aaloa.org/
• 46 Heinze O, Bergh B. Establishing a Personal Electronic Health Record in the Rhein-Neckar Region. Slovenian Medical Informatics Association 2009; 14 (1-2): 3-9.
• 47 Sfakianakis S, Chronaki CE, Chiarugi F, Conforti F, Katehakis DG. Reflections on the role of open source in health information system interoperability. Yearb Med Inform 2007; 50-60.
• 48 Moodle.org: open-source community-based tools for learning. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://moodle.org/
• 49 iPath-Network. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.ipath-network.com/
• 50 International Workshop on e-Health in Emerging Economies. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.iweee.org/
• 51 The First International Workshop on Open Source in European Health Care: The Time is Ripe OSEHC 2009. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.biostec.org/Biostec2009/OSEHC.htm
• 52 2nd International Workshop on Open Source in European Health Care: Crossing the Borders OSEHC 2010. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.biostec.org/Biostec2010/OSEHC.htm
• 53 EFMI STC 2008: Open Source and Healthcare in Europe - Time for Leading Edge Ideas?. September 2008, London, UK: [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.differance-engine.net/efmistc2008/index.php
• 54 Special track on FLOSS-HC projects and initiatives at Med-e-Tel 2010. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.medetel.lu/index.php?rub=educational_program&page=benefits_of_open_source_software_in_health_care
• 55 Special track on FLOSS-HC projects and initiatives at Med-e-Tel 2011. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.medetel.lu/index.php?rub=educational_program&page=benefits_of_open_source_software_in_health_care_2011
• 56 Murray PJ, Wright G, Karopka T, Betts H, Orel A. Open source and healthcare in Europe - time to put leading edge ideas into practice. Stud Health Technol Inform 2009; 150: 963-7.
• 57 CrisisCommons. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://crisiscommons.org/
• 58 MobileActive.org | A global network of people using mobile technology for social impact. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.mobileactive.org/
• 59 List of open source healthcare software - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_open_source_healthcare_software
• 60 SourceForge.net: Software Search “Medical Science Apps.” [cited 2011/01/29]. Available from: http://sourceforge.net/softwaremap/?&fq[]=trove%3A266
• 61 Janamanchi B, Katsamakas E, Raghupathi W, Gao W. The state and profile of open source software projects in health and medical informatics. Int J Med Inform 2009; Jul; 78 (07) 457-72.
• 62 Debian Med. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://www.debian.org/devel/debian-med/
• 63 Debian Med Task Page. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://debian-med.alioth.debian.org/tasks/
• 64 Portal:Medical OpenSUSE. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://en.opensuse.org/Portal:Medical
• 65 SIGs/FedoraMedical-FedoraProject. [cited 2011/01/29]; Available from: http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/SIGs/FedoraMedical
• 66 Pare G, Wybo MD, Delannoy C. Barriers to open source software adoption in Quebec’s health care organizations. J Med Syst 2009; Feb; 33 (01) 1-7.