Midcarpal Arthrodesis with or without Excision of Triquetrum: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this systematic review is to compare the clinical outcomes of midcarpal arthrodesis with triquetrum excision against midcarpal fusion without the excision of triquetrum performed using modern osteosynthesis technology.

Materials and Methods A systematic review of publications in PubMed, Medline, EMBASE, and Cochrane Database of Systematic Review was conducted. The studies that utilized osteosynthesis techniques other than Kirshner wire, with at least 10 patients, and had a minimum one-year follow-up period in English language were included. The quality of studies were evaluated using validated tools for assessing observational studies. Union rate, functional outcomes and revision/complication rates were collected and analyzed.

Results A meta-analysis was not possible. Based on pooled data the flexion-extension arc improved by 6 degrees for midcarpal arthrodesis group with triquetrum excision, but decreased by 11 degrees in the group without. The radial-ulnar arc improved by 5 degrees in the triquetrum excision group, but decreased by 3 degrees in the triquetrum preserving group. Improvement in grip strength appears to be better in the triquetrum preserving group (10 kg as opposed to 1 kg), while there were no observable difference in pain score.

Conclusion The literature lacked good comparison studies to examine the role of triquetrum excision in midcarpal fusion. While midcarpal fusion with triquetrum excision appeared to yield better ROM in the pooled data, studies with direct comparison of the two techniques are required to fill in the gap.

Type of Study/Level of Evidence Therapeutic IV.

Keywords

two-corner fusion - capitolunate arthrodesis - three-corner arthrodesis - four corner arthrodesis - triquetrum excision

Note

All work was conducted at Dandenong Hospital, Monash Health, Victoria, Australia.

Publikationsverlauf

Eingereicht: 22. Januar 2024

Angenommen: 21. März 2024

Artikel online veröffentlicht:
26. Juni 2024

• References

• 1 Mulford JS, Ceulemans LJ, Nam D, Axelrod TS. Proximal row carpectomy vs four corner fusion for scapholunate (SLAC) or scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse (SNAC) wrists: a systematic review of outcomes. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2009; 34 (02) 256-263
• 2 Ahmadi AR, Duraku LS, van der Oest MJW, Hundepool CA, Selles RW, Zuidam JM. The never-ending battle between proximal row carpectomy and four corner arthrodesis: a systematic review and meta-analysis for the final verdict. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg 2022; 75 (02) 711-721
• 3 Wall LB, Didonna ML, Kiefhaber TR, Stern PJ. Proximal row carpectomy: minimum 20-year follow-up. J Hand Surg Am 2013; 38 (08) 1498-1504
• 4 Hayes E, Cheng Y, Sauder D, Sims L. Four-corner arthrodesis with differing methods of osteosynthesis: a systematic review. J Hand Surg Am 2022; 47 (05) 477.e1-477.e9
• 5 Calandruccio JH, Gelberman RH, Duncan SFM, Goldfarb CA, Pae R, Gramig W. Capitolunate arthrodesis with scaphoid and triquetrum excision. J Hand Surg Am 2000; 25 (05) 824-832
• 6 Bain GI, Sood A, Ashwood N, Turner PC, Fogg QA. Effect of scaphoid and triquetrum excision after limited stabilisation on cadaver wrist movement. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2009; 34 (05) 614-617
• 7 Ferreres A, Garcia-Elias M, Plaza R. Long-term results of lunocapitate arthrodesis with scaphoid excision for SLAC and SNAC wrists. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2009; 34 (05) 603-608
• 8 Dargai F, Hoel G, Safieddine M. et al. Ten-year radiological and clinical outcomes of capitolunate arthrodesis with scaphoid and triquetrum excision for advanced degenerative arthritis in the wrist: single-center, retrospective case series with 10 patients. Hand Surg Rehabil 2020; 39 (01) 41-47
• 9 Porto SAG, Leira MÁC, Rodríguez AG, Jorge ÁÁ. Capitolunate arthrodesis versus four-corner arthrodesis in scaphoin nonunion advanced collapsed wrist treatment. Rev Iberoam Cirugía Mano 2019; 47: 32-38
• 10 Siegel JM, Ruby LK. A critical look at intercarpal arthrodesis: review of the literature. J Hand Surg Am 1996; 21 (04) 717-723
• 11 Goubier JN, Teboul F. Capitolunate arthrodesis with compression screws. Tech Hand Up Extrem Surg 2007; 11 (01) 24-28
• 12 Dunn JC, Polmear MM, Scanaliato JP, Orr JD, Nesti LJ. Capitolunate arthrodesis: a systematic review. J Hand Surg Am 2020; 45 (04) 365.e1-365.e10
• 13 Liberati A, Altman DG, Tetzlaff J. et al. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: explanation and elaboration. BMJ 2009; 339: b2700
• 14 Gauci MO, Waitzenegger T, Chammas PE, Coulet B, Lazerges C, Chammas M. Comparison of clinical outcomes of three-corner arthrodesis and bicolumnar arthrodesis for advanced wrist osteoarthritis. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2020; 45 (07) 679-686
• 15 Delattre O, Goulon G, Vogels J, Wavreille G, Lasnier A. Three-corner arthrodesis with scaphoid and triquetrum excision for wrist arthritis. J Hand Surg Am 2015; 40 (11) 2176-2182
• 16 Singh HP, Dias JJ, Phadnis J, Bain G. Comparison of the clinical and functional outcomes following 3- and 4-corner fusions. J Hand Surg Am 2015; 40 (06) 1117-1123
• 17 Abdelaziz AM, Aldahshan W, Elsherief FAH. et al. Scaphoid excision with lunatocapitate fusion for the treatment of scaphoid nonunion with advanced collapsed wrist. Int Orthop 2020; 44 (06) 1153-1157
• 18 Yao YC, Wang JP, Huang TF, Chang MC, Huang YC. Lunocapitate fusion with scaphoid excision for the treatment of scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse or scapho-lunate advanced collapse wrist. J Chin Med Assoc 2017; 80 (02) 117-120
• 19 Hegazy G. Capitolunate arthrodesis for treatment of scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse (SNAC) wrist arthritis. J Hand Microsurg 2015; 7 (01) 79-86
• 20 Munn Z, Barker TH, Moola S. et al. Methodological quality of case series studies: an introduction to the JBI critical appraisal tool. JBI Evid Synth 2020; 18 (10) 2127-2133
• 21 Athlani L, Sabau S, Pauchard N, Dap F, Dautel G. Four-corner arthrodesis with a dorsal locking plate: 4-9-year follow-up. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2020; 45 (07) 673-678
• 22 Ferrero M, di Summa PG, Giacalone F, Senesi L, Sapino G, Battiston B. Salvage of advanced carpal collapse: proximal row carpectomy with pyrocarbon resurfacing of the capitate versus four-corner arthrodesis. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2020; 45 (07) 687-692
• 23 Rimokh J, Benazech B, Lebeau N, Haddad B, Moughabghab M, David E. Clinical and radiological outcomes of 40 cases of SLAC and SNAC wrist treated by four-corner arthrodesis with locking plate. Hand Surg Rehabil 2020; 39 (01) 36-40
• 24 Zenke Y, Oshige T, Menuki K. et al. Four-corner fusion method using a bioabsorbable plate for scapholunate advanced collapse and scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse wrists: a case series study. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2020; 21 (01) 683
• 25 Elgammal A, Deglmann CJ, Celigoj V, Lukas B. Midterm results of four-corner fusion using dorsal circular plate fixation. J Wrist Surg 2018; 7 (03) 262-266
• 26 Odella S, Querenghi AM, Locatelli FM, Dacatra U, Creta E, Tos P. Locking dorsal plate in four-bone arthrodesis in SLAC and SNAC 3 wrist. Joints 2018; 6 (01) 37-41
• 27 Reissner L, Hensler S, Kluge S, Marks M, Herren DB. Treatment outcomes of 4-corner arthrodesis for patients with advanced carpal collapse: an average of 4 years' follow-up comparing 2 different plate types. J Hand Surg Am 2018; 43 (05) 487.e1-487.e6
• 28 Żyluk A, Mazur-Grzesiuk A. Outcomes after scaphoid excision and midcarpal arthrodesis for SNAC and SLAC wrist arthritis. Ortop Traumatol Rehabil 2018; 20 (05) 389-399
• 29 Tielemans A, Van Innis F, Troussel S, Detrembleur C, Libouton X, Lequint T. Effect of four-corner fusion with locking plate without bone graft on functional recovery of the wrist: new treatment guidelines. Hand Surg Rehabil 2017; 36 (03) 186-191
• 30 Lamas Gomez C, Proubasta Renart I, Llusa Perez M. Relationship between wrist motion and capitolunate reduction in four-corner arthrodesis. Orthopedics 2015; 38 (11) e1040-e1045
• 31 Le Corre A, Ardouin L, Loubersac T, Gaisne E, Bellemère P. Retrospective study of two fixation methods for 4-corner fusion: shape-memory staple vs. dorsal circular plate. Chir Main 2015; 34 (06) 300-306
• 32 Pauchard N, Lecoanet-Strugarek C, Segret J, De Gasperi M, Dap F, Dautel G. Dorsal locking plates versus staples in four-corner fusion: a comparative clinical and radiological study. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res 2014; 100 (06) 593-597
• 33 Xu YQ, Zhu YL, Wang Y. The memory plate for four-corner fusion of scaphoid non-union advanced collapse. J Plast Surg Hand Surg 2013; 47 (06) 442-445
• 34 Luegmair M, Houvet P. Effectiveness of four-corner arthrodesis with use of a locked dorsal circular plate. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2012; 470 (10) 2764-2770
• 35 Mantovani G, Mathoulin C, Fukushima WY, Cho AB, Aita MA, Argintar E. Four corner arthrodesis limited to the centre using a scaphoid one piece graft and a dorsal circular plate. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2010; 35 (01) 38-42
• 36 Espinoza DP, Schertenleib P. Four-corner bone arthrodesis with dorsal rectangular plate: series and personal technique. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2009; 34 (05) 609-613
• 37 Merrell GA, McDermott EM, Weiss APC. Four-corner arthrodesis using a circular plate and distal radius bone grafting: a consecutive case series. J Hand Surg Am 2008; 33 (05) 635-642
• 38 Chung KC, Watt AJ, Kotsis SV. A prospective outcomes study of four-corner wrist arthrodesis using a circular limited wrist fusion plate for stage II scapholunate advanced collapse wrist deformity. Plast Reconstr Surg 2006; 118 (02) 433-442
• 39 Vance MC, Hernandez JD, Didonna ML, Stern PJ. Complications and outcome of four-corner arthrodesis: circular plate fixation versus traditional techniques. J Hand Surg Am 2005; 30 (06) 1122-1127
• 40 Garcia-López A, Perez-Ubeda MJ, Marco F, Molina M, López-Duran L. A modified technique of four-bone fusion for advanced carpal collapse (SLAC/SNAC wrist). J Hand Surg Br 2001; Aug; 26 (04) 352-354
• 41 Gaston RG, Greenberg JA, Baltera RM, Mih A, Hastings H. Clinical outcomes of scaphoid and triquetral excision with capitolunate arthrodesis versus scaphoid excision and four-corner arthrodesis. J Hand Surg Am 2009; 34 (08) 1407-1412
• 42 Watson HK, Ballet FL. The SLAC wrist: scapholunate advanced collapse pattern of degenerative arthritis. J Hand Surg Am 1984; 9 (03) 358-365
• 43 Kirschenbaum D, Schneider LH, Kirkpatrick WH, Adams DC, Cody RP. Scaphoid excision and capitolunate arthrodesis for radioscaphoid arthritis. J Hand Surg Am 1993; 18 (05) 780-785
• 44 van Riet RP, Bain GI. Three-corner wrist fusion using memory staples. Tech Hand Up Extrem Surg 2006; 10 (04) 259-264
• 45 Cohen MS, Werner FW, Sutton LG, Short WH. Scaphoid excision and midcarpal arthrodesis: the effect of triquetral excision—a biomechanical study. J Hand Surg Am 2012; 37 (03) 493-499
• 46 Scobercea RG, Budoff JE, Hipp JA. Biomechanical effect of triquetral and scaphoid excision on simulated midcarpal arthrodesis in cadavers. J Hand Surg Am 2009; 34 (03) 381-386