MONARCH Inventory for Causal Attribution in Homeopathy Case Reports: Explanation and Elaboration

Abstract

Background The Modified Naranjo Criteria for Homeopathy (MONARCH) inventory is a novel and useful tool for assessing the likelihood of a causal relationship between the homeopathic intervention and the ultimate clinical outcome.

Objectives To explain and elaborate on the use of the MONARCH inventory to improve its consistency of use and thereby elevate the overall quality and evidentiary value of homeopathy case reports.

Explanation and Elaboration Each of the 10 MONARCH inventory domains is explained and elaborated with the aid of references from published literature and hypothetical clinical situations. The MONARCH total score can range from −6 to +13; within that range, an arithmetic total of +6 is available from the scores of four critical domains, which should be given prominence in the overall consideration of causality. In reporting a clinical case, great importance should be placed on the narrative of the MONARCH evaluation process, domain by domain.

Conclusion The application of MONARCH allows us to evaluate the likelihood of a causal relationship between the intervention and the observed clinical outcomes in successfully treated cases, thereby augmenting their evidentiary value.

Keywords

MONARCH inventory - causal relationship - homeopathic intervention - clinical outcome - case reports

Authors' Contributions

Chetna Deep Lamba, Vishwa Kumar Gupta, Robbert van Haselen and Nidhi Mahajan conceptualized the study; Chetna Deep Lamba and Nidhi Mahajan drafted the manuscript; Vishwa Kumar Gupta, Robbert van Haselen, Lex Rutten, Michael Teut, Lefteris Tapakis, Todd Hoover, Anna Gerstenhoefer, Yuen Ying Yvonne Fok and Rajkumar Manchanda critically reviewed the manuscript. All authors reviewed and provided approval of the final version of the manuscript that became accepted for publication.

^# Contributed equally.

Publikationsverlauf

Eingereicht: 12. März 2024

Angenommen: 24. August 2024

Artikel online veröffentlicht:
19. Dezember 2024

• References

• 1 Gopikrishna V. A report on case reports. J Conserv Dent 2010; 13: 265-271
• 2 Gagnier JJ, Kienle G, Altman DG. et al The CARE guidelines: consensus-based clinical case reporting guideline development. Glob Adv Health Med 2013; 2: 38-43
• 3 Riley DS, Barber MS, Kienle GS. et al. CARE guidelines for case reports: explanation and elaboration document. J Clin Epidemiol 2017; 89: 218-235
• 4 van Haselen RA. Homeopathic clinical case reports: development of a supplement (HOM-CASE) to the CARE clinical case reporting guideline. Complement Ther Med 2016; 25: 78-85
• 5 Naranjo CA, Busto U, Sellers EM. et al. A method for estimating the probability of adverse drug reactions. Clin Pharmacol Ther 1981; 30: 239-245
• 6 Rutten LA. The importance of case histories for accepting and improving homeopathy. Complement Ther Med 2013; 21: 565-570
• 7 Rutten L. Data collection: treat every variable as a treasure. Homeopathy 2015; 104: 190-196
• 8 Lamba CD, Gupta VK, van Haselen R. et al. Evaluation of the Modified Naranjo Criteria for assessing causal attribution of clinical outcome to homeopathic intervention as presented in case reports. Homeopathy 2020; 109: 191-197 [published erratum appears in Homeopathy 2020;109:e1–e2]
• 9 Ramanan VE, Radhakrishnan R. Non-invasive resolution of pathological ovarian masses with homeopathic treatment – a case series. Homeopathy 2022; 111: 194-201
• 10 Parveen S, Das S. Homeopathic treatment in patients with polycystic ovarian syndrome: a case series. Homeopathy 2021; 110: 186-193
• 11 Ved M, Bhasme A, Malvade S. Cervical spondylosis managed with homoeopathy: a case report. Altern Ther Health Med 2022; 28: 184-187
• 12 Lamba P, Gupta AK. A case report of multiple renal calculi treated with individualized homoeopathy. Altern Ther Health Med 2023; 29: 473-477
• 13 Bhasme A, Lamba P, Sajjan U. A case report of tonsillolith treated with individualized homoeopathy. Altern Ther Health Med 2023; 29: 88-91
• 14 Chand KS, Kapoor P. Two case reports of integrated management of antibiotic-resistant urinary tract infection. Homeopathy 2020; 109: 97-106
• 15 Carvalho JF, Ribeiro MFLDS. Successful treatment of a fibromyalgia patient using a homeopathic preparation of Cannabis sativa . Homeopathy 2024; 113: 186-189
• 16 Lamba P, Sharma D, Sinnarkar VV. Polycystic ovarian syndrome treated with individualized homeopathy: a case report. Altern Ther Health Med 2022; 28: 60-64
• 17 Nayak C, Sahoo AR, Nayak C. Thlaspi bursa pastoris in treatment of urinary stones: a case series. Homeopathy 2020; 109: 238-242
• 18 Glas KL. Individualised homeopathic treatment of nausea and vomiting in the first trimester and of COVID-19 in the third trimester of pregnancy – a case report. Homeopathy 2022; 111: 202-209
• 19 Tayade KR, Mahajan PS, Sangtani R. Evidence-based study of enlarged adenoid treated with homoeopathic medicine: a case report. Altern Ther Health Med 2024; 30: 58-61
• 20 Lamba P, Bhasme A, Kumar A. A case report of alopecia areata treated with individualized homoeopathy. Altern Ther Health Med 2023; 29: 478-481
• 21 Balbueno MCS, Martins JA, Coelho CP. Action of Folliculinum 6cH on folliculogenesis in the snake Python Regius (Shaw, 1802) – two case reports. Homeopathy 2023; 112: 275-279
• 22 Bagot JL, Stahl G. A case of recurrent urinary tract infection successfully treated during homeopathic supportive care in oncology. Homeopathy 2023; 112: 205-212
• 23 Ramanan VE, Sathyanandhan S. A case report of idiopathic OAT syndrome, associated with necrospermia and hypospermia, reversed with individualized homeopathy. Homeopathy 2022; 111: 301-306
• 24 Mallangi J, Chaudhuri J, Varanasi R, Oberai P. Multimorbidity in a 35-year-old female patient treated with homeopathy: a case report. Homeopathy 2023; 112: 135-142
• 25 Prusty AK, Bhandari P. A co-morbid condition of warts and vitiligo treated with individualized homeopathy: an evidence-based case report. Homeopathy 2022; 111: 139-146
• 26 Mahesh S, Mallappa M, Habchi O. et al. Appearance of acute inflammatory state indicates improvement in atopic dermatitis cases under classical homeopathic treatment: a case series. Clin Med Insights Case Rep 2021; 14: 1179547621994103
• 27 Bhasme A, Lamba P, Sajjan U. A case report of alopecia areata treated with individualized homoeopathy. Altern Ther Health Med 2023; 29: 92-96
• 28 Martins JA, Balbueno MCS, Coelho CP. Action of Carduus marianus 6cH on hepatopathy and gallstone in Ambystoma mexicanum (axolotl): case report. Homeopathy 2024; ; Feb 29. . Online ahead of print
• 29 Gaertner K, Frei-Erb M. A case report of burning mouth syndrome treated with individualised homeopathy. Homeopathy 2020; 109: 23-29
• 30 Ponnam HB. Facilitating healing in diabetic foot ulcers using homeopathy in a multi-disciplinary integrative approach: two evidence-based case reports. Homeopathy 2024; ; Mar 5. . Online ahead of print
• 31 Lamba P. Lichen planus treated with individualized homeopathic medicine, a case report. Altern Ther Health Med 2024; 30: 144-147
• 32 Mathur M. Pituitary microadenoma treated with individualized homeopathic medicine: a case report. Homeopathy 2020; 109: 243-247
• 33 Bani Mohammad M, Majdi Seghinsara A. Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), diagnostic criteria, and AMH. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev 2017; 18: 17-21
• 34 Clayton W, Elasy TA. A review of the pathophysiology, classification, and treatment of foot ulcers in diabetic patients. Clin Diabetes 2009; 27: 52-58
• 35 Cook D. A chronic depigmenting skin disease in a 32 year-old female. Am J Hom Med 2016; 109: 12-14
• 36 Sathye S. Evidence-based homoeopathy: a case of corneal abscess. Indian J Res Homoeopathy 2016; 10: 206-210
• 37 Fibert PM. Case report of a 16 year old youth with diagnoses of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), Asperger's syndrome and dyslexia receiving homoeopathic and tautopathic treatment. Eur J Integr Med 2015; 7: 312-317
• 38 Hahnemann S. Organon of the Art of Healing. In: Dudgeon RE, Boericke W. ed. by. Organon of Medicine 5th & 6th edition. 5th ed.. New Delhi: B Jain Publisher; 2010
• 39 Feinstein AR. The pre-therapeutic classification of co-morbidity in chronic disease. J Chronic Dis 1970; 23: 455-468
• 40 Parveen S. Homoeopathic treatment in a case of co-morbid atopic dermatitis and depressive disorder. Indian J Res Homoeopathy 2016; 10: 75-80
• 41 Mahajan A, Mahajan N, Singh A, Chopra ML. Homoeopathic treatment of a child with internet gaming disorder and atopic dermatitis: a case report. Indian J Res Homoeopathy 2024; 18: 36-43
• 42 Close S. The Genius of Homeopathy: Lectures and Essays on Homeopathic Philosophy. B. Jain Publishers; 2005
• 43 World Health Organization. Division of Mental Health. WHOQOL-BREF: Introduction, administration, scoring and generic version of the assessment: field trial version, December 1996. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization; 1996. https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/63529
• 44 Kind P, Hardman G, Macran S. UK Population Norms for EQ-5D. Centre for Health Economics, University of York. Discussion Paper 172, 1999. www.york.ac.uk/che/pdf/DP172.pdf
• 45 Jones GL, Benes K, Clark TL. et al. The Polycystic Ovary Syndrome Health-Related Quality of Life Questionnaire (PCOSQ): a validation. Hum Reprod 2004; 19: 371-377
• 46 Xue SA, de Schepper L, Hao GJ. Treatment of spasmodic dysphonia with homeopathic medicine: a clinical case report. Homeopathy 2009; 98: 56-59
• 47 Roberts HA. The Principles and Art of Cure by Homoeopathy. Reprint Edition 2008. New Delhi: B. Jain Publishers; 2009
• 48 Poole J. Case history: individualized homeopathy and severe chronic idiopathic neutropenia (SCN). Homeopathy 2010; 99: 205-209
• 49 Panchal M. A case of chronic psoriasis. Homoeopath Links 2006; 19: 22-24
• 50 Kent JT. Lectures on Homoeopathic Philosophy. Reprint Edition 2008. New Delhi: B. Jain Publishers; 2009
• 51 Văcăraș V, Nistor C, Rahovan I, Văcăraş C, Vithoulkas G. Myasthenia gravis therapy with individualized homeopathy: a case report. Clin Case Rep 2020; 8: 2464-2468
• 52 Barnett AG, van der Pols JC, Dobson AJ. Regression to the mean: what it is and how to deal with it. Int J Epidemiol 2005; 34: 215-220 [published correction appears in Int J Epidemiol 2015;44:1748]
• 53 Lee CS, Lee JH. Dynamics of clinical symptoms in patients with pandemic influenza A (H1N1). Clin Microbiol Infect 2010; 16: 389-390
• 54 Waisse-Priven S, Jurj G, Lima Thomaz LC, Tierno SA, Filho WL, Sos AB. Homeopathic treatment in resistant livedoid vasculopathy: case report. Homeopathy 2009; 98: 165-168
• 55 Mahajan N, Chaturvedi D, Alaria A, Pal G. A case report of prurigo nodularis responsive to homoeopathy. Indian J Res Homoeopathy 2020; 14: 64-69
• 56 Sharma B. A case of cervical erosion. Central Council for Research in Homoeopathy Quarterly Bulletin 2005; 27: 36-37
• 57 Rogiers P. A case of Digitalis . Homoeopath Links 2011; 24: 163-164
• 58 Geukens A. A case of MS and sterility (dysmenorrhoea). Homoeopath Links 2008; 21: 198-200
• 59 Sebastian IA. A 33 year old woman with trigeminal neuralgia – a homeopathic medicine case report. Am J Homeopathic Med 2016; 109: 62-66
• 60 Shah N. A case of idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura. Homoeopath Links 2005; 18: 146-148
• 61 HPUS Guideline for Clinical Verification. Section 4, Table 1. Accessed June 26, 2024 at: https://www.hpus.com/submitting-monograph/submitting-a-monograph/guidelines-for-clinical-verification/design-methods/
• 62 Manchanda R, Rutten L, Dogra A. et al. Psychometric validation of the modified Naranjo algorithm used in homeopathy for chronic cases. J Complement Integr Med 2021; 19: 101-109
• 63 Mahajan N, Mahajan A, Bhinda A, Salodiya S. Homoeopathic treatment of viral warts with Calcarea phosphorica . Indian J Res Homoeopathy 2020; 14: 279-286