Background and Study Aims: The endoscopic hemostatic method has been introduced as a safe and effective mechanical approach to hemostasis for upper gastrointestinal bleeding related to Mallory-Weiss syndrome (MWS). However, the indications for when to use endoscopic treatment are debatable because many patients need only medical observation. The study was designed to evaluate the necessity and efficacy of endoscopic hemostasis in upper gastrointestinal bleeding related to MWS.
Patients and Methods: From July 1994 to May 2000, we conducted a clinical trial in 76 patients who were found by endoscopy to have active bleeding (I, spurting; II, oozing), protruding visible vessels (III), and/or adherent clots (IV). Two study periods can be differentiated: in the first 3 years endoscopic treatment (n = 30) was prospectively analyzed and in the final 3 years medical treatment (n = 46) was analyzed in both cases to compare the outcome in MWS bleeding II-IV. In the first study period, in addition, endoscopic treatment was randomised to an injection method, using a mixture of hypertonic saline and epinephrine (HSE) (n = 14) and a hemoclipping or band ligation method (n = 16).
Results: Rebleeding was observed in four of 14 patients who had received endoscopic hemostasis with HSE injection and one of 46 patients who had been managed with medical treatment. No rebleeding was found following hemoclipping or band ligation. While all rebleeding was in bleeding stigmata of the I (1) and II (4) grades, there was no rebleeding in protruding visible vessels (III) or in adherent clots (IV), regardless of treatment methods.
Conclusions: Our results suggested that endoscopic hemostasis is not necessary in patients without active bleeding stigmata, and the mechanical hemostatic method is more effective than HSE injection in patients with active bleeding stigmata.
References
-
1
Bharucha A E, Gostout C J, Balm R K.
Clinical and endoscopic risk factors in the Mallory-Weiss syndrome.
Am J Gastroenterol.
1997;
92
805-808
-
2
Graham D Y, Schwartz J T.
The spectrum of the Mallor-Weiss tear.
Medicine.
1977;
57
307-318
-
3
Knauer M C.
Mallory-Weiss syndrome: Characterization of 75 Mallory-Weiss lacerations in 528 patients with upper gastrointestinal hemorrhage.
Gastroenterology.
1976;
71
5-8
-
4
Sugawa C, Benishek D, Walt A J.
Mallory-Weiss syndrome: a study of 224 patients.
Am J Surg.
1983;
145
30-33
-
5
Sugawa C, Steffes C P, Nakamura R. et al .
Upper gastrointestinal bleeding in a urban hospital. Etiology, recurrence and prognosis.
Ann Surg.
1990;
212
521-527
-
6
Bubrick M P, Lundeen J W, Onstad G R. et al .
Mallory-Weiss syndrome: analysis of 59 cases.
Surgery.
1980;
88
400-405
-
7
Hastings P R, Peters K W, Cohn I.
Mallory-Weiss syndrome.
Am J Surg.
1981;
142
560-566
-
8
Sanches Bueno F, Garcia Marcilla J A, Molina Martinez J et al.
El sindrome de Mallory-Weiss como factor etiologico en la hemorrhagia digestiva alta. Revision de 142 casos.
Rev Esp Enf Digest.
1990;
78
197-200
-
9
Lum D F, Mcquaid K, Lee J G.
Endoscopic hemostasis of nonvariceal nonpeptic ulcer hemorrhage.
Gastrointest Endosc Clin N Am.
1997;
7
657-670
-
10
Batalla R, Llach J, Salemeron J M. et al .
Endoscopic sclerotherapy in upper gastrointestinal bleeding due to the Mallory-Weiss syndrome.
Am J Gastroenterol.
1994;
89
2147-2150
-
11
Levenson S D, Koch J, Cello J P.
Mallory-Weiss tear impact of endoscopic therapy (abstract).
Gastrointest Endosc.
1993;
39
282
-
12
di Felice G.
The current role of endoscopy in Mallory Weiss syndrome.
Surg Endosc.
1991;
5
24-27
-
13
Macedo G, Carvalho L, Ribeiro T.
Endoscopic sclerotherapy for upper gastrointestinal bleeding due to Mallory-Weiss syndrome.
Am J Gastroenterol.
1995;
90
1364-1365
-
14
Laine L.
Multipolar electrocoagulation in the treatment of active upper gastrointestinal tract hemorrhage.
N Engl J Med.
1987;
316
1613-1617
-
15
Chung I K, Hahm J S, Kim H S. et al .
Comparison of the hemostatic efficacy of the endoscopic hemoclip method with hypertonic saline-epinephrine injection and a combination of the two for the management of bleeding peptic ulcers.
Gastrointest Endosc.
1999;
49
13-18
-
16
Chung I K, Kim E J, Lee M S. et al .
Bleeding Dieulafoy's lesion and the choice of endoscopic method: comparing the hemostatic efficacy of mechanical and injection methods.
Gastrointest Endosc.
2000;
52
721-724
-
17
Kovasc T OG, Jensen D M.
Endoscopic diagnosis and treatment of bleeding Mallory-Weiss tears.
Gastrointest Endosc Clin N Am.
1991;
1
387-400
-
18
Jensen D M, Kovacs T O, Machicado G A. et al .
Prospective study of the stigmata of hemorrhage and endoscopic or medical treatment for bleeding Mallory-Weiss tears (abstract).
Gastrointest Endosc.
1992;
38
235
-
19
Binmoeller K F, Thonke F, Soehendra N.
Endoscopic hemoclip treatment for gastrointestinal bleeding.
Endoscopy.
1993;
25
167-170
-
20
Scapa E.
Treating gastrointestinal bleeding with endoscopic hemoclips.
Surg Laparosc Endosc.
1997;
2
94-96
-
21
Wong R M, Ota S, Katoh A, Yamauchi A. et al .
Endoscopic ligation for nonesophageal variceal upper gastrointestinal hemorrhage.
Endoscopy.
1998;
30
774-777
-
22
Abi-Hanna D, Williams S J, Gillespie P E, Bourke M J.
Endoscopic ligation for nonvariceal nonulcer gastrointestinal hemorrhage.
Gastrointest Endosc.
1998;
48
510-514
II-Kwun Chung, M.D.
Division of Gastroenterology · Department of Internal Medicine · Soonchunhyang University Chonan Hospital
23-20 Bongmyung-dong · Chonan · Choongnam, 330-100 · South Korea ·
Fax: + 82-41-5745762
Email: euschung@sparc.schch.co.kr
