Recognising Vascular Causes of Leg Complaints in Endurance Athletes. Part 1: Validation of a Decision Algorithm

Abstract

Flow limitations in the iliac arteries of endurance athletes during exercise were previously ascribed solely to intravascular lesions. We postulate that functional kinking of the arteries can also result in flow limitations. However, the diagnostic tools in routine practice are not effective in diagnosing such flow limitations in a substantial proportion of athletes, mainly because these diagnostic tools do not measure in the provocative situations. Ninety-two symptomatic legs in 80 endurance athletes were examined with newly developed, sports-specific vascular tests. Thirty-five asymptomatic cyclists matched for working capacity served as the control subjects. Legs were classified as vascular or non-vascular following a decision algorithm, based upon the results of these diagnostic tests, excluding orthopaedic causes by the effects of specific treatment. Independently of this clinical classification, an alternative method was applied to find stable characteristics in the total patient group using factor analysis. This characterisation was based on scores on 14 test variables deriving from diagnostic tests that were not used in the decision algorithm, thus avoiding dependency between the clinical categorisation and the statistical categorisation. The hypothesis was that these characteristics were sufficiently sensitive to classify patients with vascular and non-vascular complaints. If so, these characteristics should correspond with the one derived from the decision algorithm. Following the decision algorithm, 58 legs (63 %) were classified as vascular, 29 (32 %) as non-vascular and 5 (5 %) as inconclusive. The latter were considered non-vascular. In a substantial proportion of the vascular patients, kinking of the iliac arteries was identified as the major cause of flow limitation. The characteristics derived from factor analysis proved to classify 87 % in agreement with the decision algorithm (kappa 0.56). The agreement is sufficient for validation of the clinical classification. The algorithm can therefore be applied in clinical situations to diagnose endurance athletes with flow limitations due to both intravascular lesions and kinking of the arteries.

Endurance exercise - iliac artery - endofibrosis - echo-Doppler - claudication - diagnostic test

References

• 1 Abraham P, Chevalier J M, Leftheriotis G, Saumet J L. Lower extremity disease in sports.  Am J Sports Med. 1997;  25 581-584
• 2 Abraham P, Leftheriotis G, Bourre Y, Chevalier J M, Saumet J L. Echography of external iliac artery endofibrosis in cyclists.  Am J Sports Med. 1993;  21 861-863
• 3 Abraham P, Saumet J L, Chevalier J M. External iliac endofibrosis in athletes.  Sportsmedicine. 1997;  4 221-226
• 4 Bradshaw C. Exercise related lower leg pain: vascular.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000;  32 S34-S36
• 5 Brukner P, Khan K. Clinical sportsmedicine. Mc Graw Hill book company 1993
• 6 Chevalier J M. Pathologie vasculaire du cycliste. Encycl Med Chirurg Franc 1997 675: A10-11
• 7 Chevalier J M, L'Hoste P , Bouvat E, Megret A, Saint Andre J P, Ruault P. L' éndofibrose artériele du sportif de haut niveau: formes inhabituelles.  J Traumatol Sport. 1991;  8 176-181
• 8 Desvaux B, Abraham P, Colin D, Leftheriotis G, Saumet J L. Ankle to arm index following maximal exercise in normal subjects and athletes.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1996;  28 836-839
• 9 van Deursen L LJM, Patijn J, Ockhuysen A L, Vortman B J. The value of some clinical tests of the sacro-iliac joint.  J Man Med. 1990;  5 96-99
• 10 Gunnar B, Andersson J, Deyo R A. History and physical examination in patients with herniated lumbar disks.  Spine supplement. 1996;  21 10s-19s
• 11 Jäger K A, Philips D J, Martin R L. Non invasive mapping of lower limb arterial lesions.  Ultrasound Med Biol. 1985;  11 515-521
• 12 Legemate D A, Teeuwen C, Hoeneveld H, Ackerstaff R GA, Eikelboom B C. Spectral analysis criteria in duplex scanning of aortoiliac and femoropopliteal arterial disease.  Ultrasound in Med and Biol. 1991;  17 769-776
• 13 Maitland G D. The slump test: examination and treatment.  Australian J Physiother. 1985;  31 215-219
• 14 Mundt K, Chambless L E, Burnham C B. Measuring ankle systolic blood pressure: validation of the Dynamap 1846 SX.  Angiology. 1992;  43 555-564
• 15 Potter N A, Rothstein J M. Intertestee reliability for selected clinical tests of the sacro-iliac joint.  Phys Ther. 1985;  65 1671-1675
• 16 McDonald R P. Factor analysis and related methods.  Hillsdale, New Jersey; Lawrence Erlbaum Associated Publishers 1985: 198-201
• 17 Rousselet M C, Saint-André J P, L'Hoste P , Enon B, Megret A, Chevalier J M. Stenotic intimal thickening of the external iliac artery in competition cyclists.  Hum Path. 1990;  21 524-529
• 18 Rutherford R B. Vascular surgery. WB Saunders company 2000 fifth edition
• 19 Ruurda J P, Rijbroek A, Vermeulen E GJ, Wisselink W, Rauwerda J A. Arterial insufficiency in athletes due to ‘endofibrosis'.  Ned Tijdschr Heelkd. 2000;  9 124-126
• 20 Schep G, Bender M HM, Schmikli S L, Wijn P FF. Color Doppler used to detect kinking and intravascular lesions in the iliac arteries in endurance athletes with claudication.  Eur J Ultrasound. 2001;  14 29-40
• 21 Schep G, Kaandorp D W, Bender M HM, Weerdenburg H, van Engeland S, Wijn P FF. Magnetic resonance angiography used to detect kinking in the iliac arteries in endurance athletes with claudiction.  Physiol Meas. 2001;  22 475-487
• 22 Schep G, Bender M HM, vd Tempel G, Wijn P FF, de Vries W R, Eikelboom B C. Top endurance athletes with claudication due to functional iliac obstruction; detection and treatment.  The Lancet. 2001; accepted for publication; 
• 23 Schep G, Sala H AGM, Bruyninckx C MA. Bovenbeenklachten bij wielrenners casuïstiek van een onbekende beroepsziekte (article in Dutch with English abstract).  Geneeskunde en sport. 1995;  27 182-184
• 24 Schep G, Bender M HM, Schmikli S L, Mosterd W L, Hammacher E R, Scheltinga M, Wijn P FF. Recognising the vascular cause of leg complaints in endurance athletes. Part 2: The value of patient-history, physical examination, cycling exercise test and echo-Doppler examination.  Int J Sports Med. 2002;  23 322-328
• 25 Schep G, Bender M HM, Kaandorp D, Hammacher E, de Vries W R. Flow limitations in the iliac arteries in endurance athletes. Current knowledge and directions for the future.  Int J Sports Med. 1999;  20 421-428
• 26 Schwarzer A C, April C N, Bogduk N. The sacroiliac joint in chronic low back pain.  Spine. 1995;  20 31-37
• 27 Sise J, Shackford S, Rowley R. Claudication in young adults; a frequently delayed diagnosis.  J Vasc Surg. 1989;  10 68-74
• 28 Stoffers H EJH, Kester A DM, Kaiser V, Rinkens P ELM, Knottnerus J A. Diagnostic value of signs and symptoms associated with peripheral arterial occlusive disease seen in general practice: a multivariate approach.  Med Decis Making. 1997;  17 61-70
• 29 Strandness D E, Dawson D L, van Breda A. Indirect noninvasive testing and duplex scanning. In: Strandness DE, van Breda A (eds) Vascular Diseases, Surgical and Interventional Therapy. Livingstone; Churchill 1994: 139-199
• 30 Taylor A J, Tennant W G, Batt M E, Wallace W A. Traumatic occlusion of the external iliac artery in a racing cyclist: a cause of ill defined leg pain.  Br J Sports Med. 1997;  31 155-156
• 31 Wittens C HA, Houtte H JKP, Bollen E CM, Mol J MFA. The imaging quality of angiodynography in the ilio-femoral tract.  Eur J Vasc Surg. 1990;  4 611-615