Endometriosis and Subfertility: Is the Relationship Resolved?

ABSTRACT

There are many arguments to support the hypothesis that there is a causal relationship between the presence of endometriosis and subfertility. These arguments are reviewed in this article and include: (1) an increased prevalence of endometriosis in subfertile women compared with women of proven fertility; (2) a reduced monthly fecundity rate (MFR) in baboons with mild to severe (spontaneous or induced) endometriosis compared with those with minimal endometriosis or a normal pelvis; (3) a trend toward a reduced MFR in infertile women with minimal to mild endometriosis compared with women with unexplained infertility; (4) a dose-effect relationship: a negative correlation between the r-AFS stage of endometriosis and the monthly fecundity rate and crude pregnancy rate; (5) a reduced monthly fecundity rate and cumulative pregnancy rate after donor sperm insemination in women with minimal-mild endometriosis compared with those with a normal pelvis; (6) a reduced MFR after husband sperm insemination in women with minimal to mild endometriosis compared with those with a normal pelvis; (7) a reduced implantation rate per embryo after IVF in women with moderate to severe endometriosis compared with women with a normal pelvis; and (8) an increased monthly fecundity rate and cumulative pregnancy rate after surgical removal of minimal to mild endometriosis.

KEYWORDS

Minimal - mild - moderate - severe endometriosis - subfertility - monthly fecundity rate - cumulative pregnancy rate

REFERENCES

• 1 D'Hooghe T M, Bambra C S, Koninckx P R. Cycle fecundity in baboons of proven fertility with minimal endometriosis.  Gynecol Obstet Invest . 1994;  37 63-65
• 2 D'Hooghe T M, Bambra C S, Raeymaekers B M. et al . A prospective controlled study over 2 years shows a normal monthly fertility rate (MFR) in baboons with stage I endometriosis and a decreased MFR in primates with stage II-IV disease.  Fertil Steril . 1996;  66 809-813
• 3 D'Hooghe T M. Clinical relevance of the baboon as a model for the study of endometriosis.  Fertil Steril . 1997;  68 613-625
• 4 D'Hooghe T M, Debrock S. Endometriosis, retrograde menstruation and peritoneal inflammation in women and in baboons.  Hum Reprod Update . 2002;  8 84-88
• 5 Eskenazi B, Warner M L. Epidemiology of endometriosis.  Obstet Gynecol Clin North Am . 1997;  24 235-258
• 6 Wheeler H M. Epidemiology of endometriosis-associated infertility.  J Reprod Med . 1989;  34 41-46
• 7 Koninckx P R, Meuleman C, Demeyere S, Lesaffre E, Cornillie F J. Suggestive evidence that pelvic endometriosis is a progressive disease, whereas deeply infiltrating endometriosis is associated with pelvic pain.  Fertil Steril . 1991;  55 759-765
• 8 Corson S L, Cheng A, Gutmann J N. Laparoscopy in the “normal” infertile patient: a question revisited.  J Am Assoc Gynecol Laparosc . 2000;  7 317-324
• 9 Balasch J, Creus M, Fabregeus F. et al . Visible and non-visible endometriosis at laparoscopy in fertile and infertile women and in patients with chronic pelvic pain: a prospective study.  Hum Reprod . 1996;  11 387-391
• 10 Gruppo Italiano per lo Studio dell' Endometriosi. Prevalence and anatomical distribution of endometriosis in women with selected gynaecological conditions: results from a multicentric Italian study.  Hum Reprod . 1994;  9 1158-1162
• 11 Berube S, Marcoux S, Langevin M, Maheux R, and the Canadian Collaborative Group on Endometriosis. Fecundity of infertile women with minimal or mild endometriosis and women with unexplained infertility.  Fertil Steril . 1998;  69 1034-1041
• 12 Liu D TY, Hitchcock A. Endometriosis: its association with retrograde menstruation, dysmenorrhoea and tubal pathology.  Br J Obstet Gynaecol . 1986;  93 859-864
• 13 Moen M H. Endometriosis in women at interval sterilization.  Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand . 1987;  66 451-454
• 14 Kirshon B, Poindexter A N, Fast J. Endometriosis in multiparous women.  J Reprod Med . 1989;  34 215-217
• 15 Mahmood T A, Templeton A. Prevalence and genesis of endometriosis.  Hum Reprod . 1991;  6 544-549
• 16 Moen M H, Muus K M. Endometriosis in pregnant and non-pregnant women at tubal sterilization.  Hum Reprod . 1991;  6 699-702
• 17 Rawson J MR. Prevalence of endometriosis in asymptomatic women.  J Reprod Med . 1991;  36 513-515
• 18 Waller K G, Lindsay P, Curtis P, Shaw R W. The prevalence of endometriosis in women with infertile partners.  Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol . 1993;  48 135-139
• 19 Sangi-Haghpeykar H, Poindexter A N. Epidemiology of endometriosis among parous women.  Obstet Gynecol . 1995;  85 983-992
• 20 Jansen R PS, Russell P. Nonpigmented endometriosis: clinical, laparoscopic and pathologic definition.  Am J Obstet Gynecol . 1986;  155 1160-1163
• 21 Stripling M, Martin D, Chatman D. et al . Endometriosis after tubal ligation.  J Reprod Med . 1985;  30 939-941
• 22 Martin D C, Hubert G D, Vander Zwaag R, El-Zeky F A. Laparoscopic appearances of peritoneal endometriosis.  Fertil Steril . 1989;  51 63-68
• 23 Cornillie F J, Oosterlynck D, Lauweryns J M, Koninckx P R. Deeply infiltrating pelvic endometriosis: histology and clinical significance.  Fertil Steril . 1990;  53 978-990
• 24 Strathy J H, Molgaard C A, Coulam C B, Melton III J L. Endometriosis and infertility: a laparoscopic study of endometriosis among fertile and infertile women.  Fertil Steril . 1982;  38 667-672
• 25 Fakih H N, Tamura R, Kesselman A, DeCherney A H. Endometriosis after tubal ligation.  J Reprod Med . 1985;  30 939-941
• 26 Dodge S T, Pumphrey R S, Miyizawa K. Peritoneal endometriosis in women requesting reversal of sterilization.  Fertil Steril . 1986;  45 774-777
• 27 Trimbos J B, Trimbos-Kemper G CM, Peters A AW, van der Does D C, van Hall V E. Findings in 200 consecutive asymptomatic women having a laparoscopic sterilization.  Arch Gynecol Obstet . 1990;  247 121-124
• 28 Clement P B. Pathology of endometriosis.  Pathol Annu . 1990;  25 245-295
• 29 Moen M H, Halvorsen T B. Histologic confirmation of endometriosis in different peritoneal lesions.  Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand . 1992;  71 337-342
• 30 Walter A J, Hentz J G, Magtibay P M, Cornella J L, Magrina J F. Endometriosis: correlation between histologic and visual findings at laparoscopy.  Am J Obstet Gynecol . 2001;  184 1407-1413
• 31 Matorras R, Rodriguez F, Pijoan J I. et al . Women who are not exposed to spermatozoa and infertile women have similar rates of stage I endometriosis.  Fertil Steril . 2001;  76 923-928
• 32 D'Hooghe T M, Bambra C S, Raeymaekers B M, Koninckx P R. Increased incidence and recurrence of recent corpus luteum without ovulation stigma (luteinized unruptured follicle-syndrome?) in baboons (Papio anubis, Papio cynocephalus) with endometriosis.  J Soc Gynecol Invest . 1996;  3 140-144
• 33 Schenken R S, Asch R H, Williams R F, Hodgen G D. Etiology of infertility in monkeys with endometriosis: luteinized unruptured follicles, luteal phase defects, pelvic adhesions, and spontaneous abortions.  Fertil Steril . 1984;  41 122-130
• 34 Taylor P J, Collins J A. Unexplained Infertility. Oxford: Oxford University Press 1992: 158
• 35 Evers J LH. The role of surgery in the treatment of pelvic endometriosis in subfertile patients.  Middle East Fertil J . 1999;  4 19-21
• 36 Marcoux S, Maheux R, Bérubé S, and the Canadian Collaborative Group on Endometriosis. Laparoscopic surgery in infertile women with minimal or mild endometriosis.  N Engl J Med . 1997;  337 217-222
• 37 Thomas E J, Cooke I D. Successful treatment of asymptomatic endometriosis: does it benefit infertile women?.  BMJ . 1987;  294 1117-1119
• 38 Telimaa S, Puolakka J, Ronnberg L, Kaupilla A. Placebo-controlled comparison of danazol and high-dose medroxyprogesterone acetate in the treatment of endometriosis.  Gynecol Endocrinol . 1987;  1 13-23
• 39 Overton C E, Lindsay P C, Johal B. et al . A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study of luteal phase dydrogesterone (Duphaston) in women with minimal to mild endometriosis.  Fertil Steril . 1994;  62 701-707
• 40 Mahmood T A, Templeton A. The impact of treatment on the natural history of endometriosis.  Hum Reprod . 1990;  5 965-970
• 41 Fedele L, Parazzini F, Radici E. et al . Buserelin acetate versus expectant management in the treatment of infertility associated with endometriosis: a randomized clinical trial.  Am J Obstet Gynecol . 1992;  166 1345-1350
• 42 Olive D L, Stohs G F, Metzger D A, Franklin R R. Expectant management and hydrotubations in the treatment of endometriosis-associated infertility.  Fertil Steril . 1985;  44 35-42
• 43 Garcia C R, David S S. Pelvic endometriosis: infertility and pelvic pain.  Am J Obstet Gynecol . 1977;  129 740-745
• 44 Schenken R S, Malinak L R. Conservative versus expectant management for the infertile patient with mild endometriosis.  Fertil Steril . 1982;  37 183-186
• 45 Seibel M M, Berber M J, Weinstein F G, Taymor M L. The effectiveness of danazol on subsequent fertility in minimal endometriosis.  Fertil Steril . 1982;  38 534-538
• 46 Portuondo J A, Echanojauregui A D, Herran C, Alijarte I. Early conception in patients with untreated mild endometriosis.  Fertil Steril . 1983;  39 22-25
• 47 Rodriguez-Escudero F J, Negro J L, Corcosstegui B, Benito J A. Does minimal endometriosis reduce fecundity?.  Fertil Steril . 1988;  50 522-524
• 48 Hull M E, Moghissi K S, Magyar D F. et al . Comparison of different treatment modalities of endometriosis in infertile women.  Fertil Steril . 1987;  47 40-45
• 49 Badawy S ZA, El Bakry M M, Samuel D, Dizer M. Cumulative pregnancy rates in infertile women with endometriosis.  J Reprod Med . 1988;  33 757-760
• 50 Acosta A A, Buttram Jr C V, Besch P K, Franklin R R, Vanderheyden J D. A proposed classification of pelvic endometriosis.  Obstet Gynecol . 1977;  42 19-25
• 51 American Fertility Society. Revised American Fertility Society classification of endometriosis.  Fertil Steril . 1985;  43 351-352
• 52 Hughes E G. The effectiveness of ovulation induction and intrauterine insemination in the treatment of persistent infertility: a meta-analysis.  Hum Reprod . 1997;  12 1865-1872
• 53 Omland A K, Tanbo T, Dale P O, Abyholm T. Artificial insemination by husband in unexplained infertility compared with infertility associated with peritoneal endometriosis.  Hum Reprod . 1998;  13 2602-2605
• 54 Nuojua-Huttunen H S, Tomas C, Bloigu R, Tuomivaara L, Martikainen H. Intrauterine insemination treatment in subfertility. An analysis of factors affecting outcome.  Hum Reprod . 1999;  14 698-703
• 55 Jansen R PS. Minimal endometriosis and reduced fecundability: prospective evidence from an artificial insemination by donor program.  Fertil Steril . 1986;  46 141-143
• 56 Hammond M G, Jordan S, Sloan C S. Factors affecting pregnancy rates in a donor insemination program using frozen semen.  Am J Obstet Gynecol . 1986;  155 480-485
• 57 Toma S K, Stovall D W, Hammond M G. The effect of laparoscopic ablation or danocrine on pregnancy rates in patients with stage I or II endometriosis undergoing donor insemination.  Obstet Gynecol . 1992;  80 253-256
• 58 Bergqvist A, D'Hooghe T M. Mini symposium on pathogenesis of endometriosis and treatment of endometriosis-associated subfertility.  Hum Reprod Update . 2002;  8 79-83
• 59 Garrido N, Navarro J, Garcia-Velasco J. et al . The endometrium versus embryonic quality in endometriosis-related infertility.  Hum Reprod Update . 2002;  8 95-103
• 60 Al Azemi M, Lopez B A, Steele J. et al . Ovarian response to repeated controlled stimulation in IVF cycles in patients with ovarian endometriosis.  Hum Reprod . 2000;  15 72-75
• 61 Diaz I, Navarro J, Blasco L. et al . Impact of stage III-IV endometriosis on recipients of sibling oocytes: matched case-control study.  Fertil Steril . 2000;  74 31-34
• 62 Simon C, Guttierez A, Vidal A. et al . Outcome of patients with endometriosis in assisted reproduction: results from in-vitro fertilization and oocyte donation.  Hum Reprod . 1994;  9 725-729
• 63 Arici A, Oral E, Bukulmez O. et al . The effect of endometriosis on implantation: results from the Yale University in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer program.  Fertil Steril . 1996;  65 603-607
• 64 Fedele L, Bianchi S, Marchini M. et al . Superovulation with human menopausal gonadotrophins in the treatment of infertility associated with minimal or mild endometriosis: a controlled randomized study.  Fertil Steril . 1992;  58 28-31
• 65 Tummon I S, Asher L S, Martin J RB, Tulandi T. Randomized controlled trial of superovulation and insemination for infertility associated with minimal or mild endometriosis.  Fertil Steril . 1997;  68 8-12
• 66 Nowroozi K, Chase J S, Check J H, Wu C H. The importance of laparoscopic coagulation of mild endometriosis in infertile women.  Int J Fertil . 1987;  32 442-444
• 67 Paulson J D, Asmar P, Saffan D S. Mild and moderate endometriosis. Comparison of treatment modalities for infertile couples.  J Reprod Med . 1991;  36 151-155
• 68 Tulandi T, Mouchawar M. Treatment-dependent and treatment-independent pregnancy in women with minimal and mild endometriosis.  Fertil Steril . 1991;  56 790-791
• 69 Arumugam K, Urquhart R. Efficacy of laparoscopic electrocoagulation in infertile patients with minimal or mild endometriosis.  Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand . 1991;  70 125-127
• 70 Olive D L, Martin D C. Treatment of endometriosis-associated infertility with CO₂ laser laparoscopy: the use of one- and two-parameter exponential models.  Fertil Steril . 1987;  48 18-23
• 71 Rosen G F. Treatment of endometriosis-associated infertility.  Infertil Reprod Med Clin North Am . 1992;  3 721-730
• 72 Hughes E G, Fedorkow D M, Collins J A. A quantitative overview of controlled trials in endometriosis-associated infertility.  Fertil Steril . 1993;  59 963-970
• 73 Gruppo Italiano per lo Studio dell' Endometriosi. Ablation of lesions or no treatmen in minimal-mild endometriosis in infertile women: a randomized trial.  Hum Reprod . 1999;  14 1332-1334
• 74 American Society for Reproductive Medicine. Revised ASRM classification for endometriosis: 1996.  Fertil Steril . 1997;  67 817-821
• 75 D'Hooghe T M, Bambra C S, Isahakia M, Koninckx P R. Intrapelvic injection of menstrual endometrium causes endometriosis in baboons (Papio cynocephalus, Papio anubis).  Am J Obstet Gynecol . 1995;  173 125-134
• 76 Olsen J, Juul S, Basso O. Measuring time to pregnancy: methodological issues to consider.  Hum Reprod . 1998;  13 1751-1756
• 77 Crosignanci P G, Vercellini P. Evidence may change with more trials; concepts to be kept in mind.  Hum Reprod . 2000;  15 2448-2450
• 78 D'Hooghe T M, Hill J A. Endometriosis. In: Berek JS, ed. Novak's Gynecology 12th ed. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins 1996: 887-920
• 79 Thomas E J, Cooke I D. Impact of gestrinone on the course of asymptomatic endometriosis.  BMJ . 1987;  294 272-274
• 80 Sutton C JG, Pooley A S, Ewen S P, Haines P. Follow-up report on a randomized controlled trial of laser laparoscopy in the treatment of pelvic pain associated with minimal to moderate endometriosis.  Fertil Steril . 1997;  68 1070-1074
• 81 D'Hooghe T M, Bambra C S, Isahakia M, Koninckx P R. Evolution of spontaneous endometriosis in the baboon (Papio anubis, Papio cynocephalus) over a 12-month period.  Fertil Steril . 1992;  58 409-412
• 82 D'Hooghe T M, Bambra C S, Raeymaekers B M, Koninckx P R. Serial laparoscopies over 30 months show that endometriosis is a progressive disease in captive baboons (Papio anubis, Papio cynocephalus).  Fertil Steril . 1996;  65 645-649
• 83 Hoshiai H, Ishikawa M, Yoshiharu S, Noda K, Fukaya T. Laparoscopic evaluation of the onset and progression of endometriosis.  Am J Obstet Gynecol . 1993;  169 714-719
• 84 Adamson G D, Hurd S J, Pasta D J, Rodriguez B D. Laparoscopic endometriosis treatment: is it better?.  Fertil Steril . 1993;  59 35-44
• 85 Guzick D S, Canis M, Silliman N P. et al . Prediction of pregnancy in infertile women based on the ASRM's revised classification for endometriosis.  Fertil Steril . 1997;  67 822-836
• 86 Osuga Y, Koga K, Tsutsumi O. et al . Role of laparoscopy in the treatment of endometriosis-associated infertility.  Gynecol Obstet Invest . 2002;  53 (suppl 1) 33-39
• 87 Hasson H M. Incidence of endometriosis in diagnostic laparoscopy.  J Reprod Med . 1976;  16 135-138
• 88 Drake T S, Grunert G M. The unsuspected pelvic factor in the infertility investigation.  Fertil Steril . 1980;  34 27-31
• 89 Peterson E P, Behrman S J. Laparoscopy of the infertile patient.  Obstet Gynecol . 1970;  36 363-367
• 90 Duignan N K, Jordan J A, Coughlan B M, Logan-Edwards R. One thousand consecutive cases of diagnostic laparoscopy.  J Obstet Gynecol Br Commonw . 1972;  79 1016-1024
• 91 Liston W A, Bradford W P, Downie J, Kerr M G. Laparoscopy in a general gynecologic unit.  Am J Obstet Gynecol . 1972;  113 672-677
• 92 Pent D. Laparoscopy: its role in private practice.  Am J Obstet Gynecol . 1972;  113 826-837
• 93 Goldenberg R L, Magendantz H G. Laparoscopy and the infertility evaluation.  Obstet Gynecol . 1976;  47 410-414
• 94 Cohen M R. Recent advances in the diagnosis of endometriosis: endoscopy. In: Greenblatt RB, ed. Recent Advances in Endometriosis. Proceedings of a Symposium, Augusta, GA, March 3-5, 1975 Princeton, NJ: Excerpta Medica 1976: 18-31
• 95 Musich J R, Behrmann S J. Infertility laparoscopy in perspective. A review of five hundred cases.  Am J Obstet Gynecol . 1982;  143 293-303
• 96 Nordenskjold F, Ahlgren M. Laparoscopy in female infertility.  Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand . 1983;  62 609-615
• 97 Chang Y S, Lee J Y, Moon S Y, Kim J G. Diagnostic laparoscopy in gynecological disorders.  Asia Oceania J Obstet Gynecol . 1987;  13 29-34
• 98 Mahmood T A, Templeton A A. The relationship between endometriosis and semen analysis: a review of 490 consecutive laparoscopies.  Hum Reprod . 1989;  4 782-785