Above- and Belowground Trophic Interactions on Creeping Thistle (Cirsium arvense) in High- and Low-Diversity Plant Communities: Potential for Biotic Resistance?

Abstract

The capacity of local communities to control introduced plants is called biotic resistance. Biotic resistance has been almost exclusively tested for plant competition and aboveground herbivores and pathogens, while neglecting root herbivores and soil pathogens. Here, we present biotic resistance by above- and belowground herbivores in concert, and relate the abundance of the plant enemies to the species diversity of the local plant communities. The study was carried out in a 7-year-old biodiversity field experiment. We used creeping thistle (Cirsium arvense) as a model, and quantified sap-sucking herbivores: aboveground aphids, their antagonists, and root-feeding nematodes. As plant diversity treatments, we used field plots sown with high (15 plant species, HSD) or low (4 plant species, LSD) diverse seed mixtures in 1996 and that were not weeded. Creeping thistle became established spontaneously at the start of the experiment. In 2002, in HSD plots, 90 % of the plant community was made up by 11 species, compared to seven species in LSD plots. No differences were found for C. arvense abundance or biomass. Aboveground, three aphid species were found on C. arvense-Uroleucon cirsii, Aphis fabae, and Macrosiphum euphorbiae, but the latter was found only in low densities. Significantly more aphid species were found on individual plants in HSD plots. Moreover, in HSD plots, on average 10 % of aphids were parasitized, while no parasitism was observed in LSD plots. In the root zone of C. arvense, significantly more nematodes were found in HSD than in LSD plots, and a significantly higher proportion of those nematodes were plant parasites. The dominant plant parasitic nematode in both treatments was Paratylenchus. We conclude that biotic resistance by natural enemies may be enhanced by plant species diversity, but that above- and belowground sap-sucking herbivores do not necessarily have to respond similarly to the diversity of the surrounding plant community.

Aphis fabae - Macrosiphum euphorbiae - nematode - Paratylenchus - Uroleucon cirsii.

References

• 1 Bardgett R. D., Cook R.. Functional aspects of soil animal diversity in agricultural grasslands.  Applied Soil Ecology. (1998);  10 263-276
• 2 Bardgett R. D., Wardle D. A., and Yeates G. W.. Linking above-ground and below-ground interactions: How plant responses to foliar herbivory influence soil organisms.  Soil Biology and Biochemistry. (1998);  30 1867-1878
• 3 Bezemer T. M., Wagenaar R., Van Dam N. M., Wäckers F. L.. Interactions between above- and belowground insect herbivores as mediated by the plant defense system.  Oikos. (2003);  101 555-562
• 4 Bezemer T. M., Wagenaar R., Van Dam N. M., Van der Putten W. H., Wäckers F. L.. Above- and below-ground terpenoid aldehyde induction in cotton, Gossypium herbaceum, following root and leaf injury.  Journal of Chemical Ecology. (2004);  30 53-67
• 5 Bongers T.. De Nematoden van Nederland. Pirola Schoorl, The Netherlands (1988)
• 6 Brown V. K., Gange A. C.. Insect herbivory below ground.  Advances in Ecological Research. (1990);  20 1-58
• 7 Burrows R. L., Pfleger F. L.. Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi respond to increasing plant diversity.  Canadian Jounal of Botany. (2002);  80 120-130
• 8 Davis M. A., Grime J. P., Thompson K.. Fluctuating resources in plant communities: a general theory of invasibility.  Journal of Ecology. (2000);  88 528-534
• 9 De Deyn G. B., Raaijmakers C. E., Zoomer R. H., Berg M. P., De Ruiter P. C., Verhoef H. A., Bezemer T. M., Van der Putten W. H.. Soil invertebrate fauna enhances grassland succession and diversity.  Nature. (2003);  422 711-713
• 10 Edwards G. R., Bourdot G. W., Crawley M. J.. Influence of herbivory, competition and soil fertility on the abundance of Cirsium arvense in acid grassland.  Journal of Applied Ecology. (2000);  37 321-334
• 11 Elton C. S.. The Ecology of Invasions by Animals and Plants. London, UK; Methuen and Co. (1958)
• 12 Gange A. C.. Species-specific responses of a root- and shoot-feeding insect to arbuscular mycorrhizal colonization of its host plant.  New Phytologist. (2001);  150 611-618
• 13 Gange A. C., Brown V. K.. Effects of root herbivory by an insect on a foliar-feeding species, mediated through changes in the host plant.  Oecologia. (1989);  81 38-42
• 14 Haddad N. M., Tilman D., Haarstad J., Ritchie M., Knops J. M. H.. Contrasting effects of plant richness and composition on insect communities: A field experiment.  American Naturalist. (2001);  158 17-35
• 15 Harris P., Shorthouse J. D.. Effectiveness of gall inducers in weed biological control.  Canadian Entomologist. (1996);  128 1021-1055
• 16 Hector A., Schmid B., Beierkuhnlein C., Caldeira M. C., Diemer M., Dimitrakopoulos P. G., Finn J. A., Freitas H., Giller P. S., Good J., Harris R., Hogberg P., Huss-Danell K., Joshi J., Jumpponen A., Körner C., Leadley P. W., Loreau M., Minns A., Mulder C. P. H., O'Donovan G., Otway S. J., Pereira J. S., Prinz A., Read D. J., Scherer-Lorenzen M., Schulze E. D., Siamantziouras A. S. D., Spehn E. M., Terry A. C., Troumbis A. Y., Woodward F. I., Yachi S., Lawton J. H.. Plant diversity and productivity experiments in European grasslands.  Science. (1999);  286 1123-1127
• 17 Hooper D. U., Bignell D. E., Brown V. K., Brussaard L., Dangerfield J. M., Wall D. H., Wardle D. A., Coleman D. C., Giller K. E., Lavelle P., Van der Putten W. H., De Ruiter P. C., Rusek J., Silver W. L., Tiedje J. M., Wolters V.. Interactions between above-ground and below-ground biodiversity in terrestrial ecosystems: Patterns, mechanisms, and feedbacks.  Bioscience. (2000);  50 1049-1061
• 18 Jervis M. A., Kidd N. A. C., Fitton M. G., Huddleston T., Dawah H. A.. Flower-visiting by hymenopteran parasitoids.  Journal of Natural History. (1993);  27 67-105
• 19 Knops J. M. H., Tilman D., Haddad N. M., Naeem S., Mitchell C. E., Haarstad J., Ritchie M. E., Howe K. M., Reich P. B., Siemann E., Groth J.. Effects of plant species richness on invasion dynamics, disease outbreaks, insect abundances and diversity.  Ecology Letters. (1999);  2 286-293
• 20 Kluth S., Kruess A., Tscharntke T.. Insects as vectors of plant pathogens: mutualistic and antagonistic interactions.  Oecologia. (2002);  133 193-199
• 21 Koricheva J., Mulder C. P. H., Schmid B., Joshi J., Huss-Danell K.. Numerical responses of different trophic groups of invertebrates to manipulations of plant diversity in grasslands.  Oecologia. (2000);  125 271-282
• 22 Korthals G. W., Smilauer P., van Dijk C., Van der Putten W. H.. Linking above- and below-ground biodiversity: abundance and trophic complexity in soil as a response to experimental plant communities on abandoned arable land.  Functional Ecology. (2001);  15 506-514
• 23 Lepš J., Brown V. K., Len T. A. D., Gormsen D., Hedlund K., Kailova J.,  Korthals G. W., Mortimer S. R., Rodriguez-Barrueco C., Roy J., Regina I. S., van Dijk C., Van der Putten W. H.. Separating the chance effect from other diversity effects in the functioning of plant communities.  Oikos. (2001);  92 123-134
• 24 Malý S., Korthals G. W., Van Dijk C., Van der Putten W. H., De Boer W.. Effect of vegetation manipulation of abandoned arable land on soil microbial properties.  Biology and Fertility of Soils. (2000);  31 121-127
• 25 Maron J. L., Vila M.. When do herbivores affect plant invasion? Evidence for the natural enemies and biotic resistance hypotheses.  Oikos. (2001);  95 361-373
• 26 Masters G. J.. The impact of root herbivory on aphid performance: Field and laboratory evidence.  Acta Oecologica. (1995);  16 135-142
• 27 Masters G. J., Brown V. K.. Plant-mediated interactions between two spatially separated insects.  Functional Ecology. (1992);  6 175-179
• 28 Masters G. J., Brown V. K., Gange A. C.. Plant mediated interactions between above- and below-ground insect herbivores.  Oikos. (1993);  66 148-151
• 29 Masters G. J., Jones T. H., Rogers M.. Host-plant mediated effects of root herbivory on insect seed predators and their parasitoids.  Oecologia. (2001);  127 246-250
• 30 May R. M.. How many species?.  Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B. (1990);  327 171-182
• 31 Mitchell C. E., Power A. G.. Release of invasive plants from fungal and viral pathogens.  Nature. (2003);  421 625-627
• 32 Moran N. A., Whitham T. G.. Interspecific competition between root-feeding and leaf-galling aphids mediated by host-plant resistance.  Ecology. (1990);  71 1050-1058
• 33 Mortimer S. R., Booth R. G., Harris S. J., Brown V. K.. Effects of initial site management on the Coleoptera assemblages colonising newly established chalk grassland on ex-arable land.  Biological Conservation. (2002);  104 301-313
• 34 Mulder C. P. H., Koricheva J., Huss-Danell K., Hogberg P., Joshi J.. Insects affect relationships between plant species richness and ecosystem processes.  Ecology Letters. (1999);  53 819-829
• 35 Novozamsky I., Houba V. J. G., Temminghof E., Van der Lee J. J.. Determination of “total” N and “total” P in a single soil digest.  Netherlands Journal of Agricultural Science. (1984);  32 322-324
• 36 Oostenbrink M.. Estimating nematode populations by some selected methods. Sasser, J. N. and Jenkins, W. R., eds. Nematology. Chapel Hill, NC; University of North Carolina Press (1960): 85-102
• 37 Root R. B.. Organization of a plant-arthropod association in simple and diverse habitats: the fauna of collards (Brassica oleraceae). .  Ecological Monographs. (1973);  43 95-124
• 38 Salt D. T., Fenwick P., Whittaker J. B.. Interspecific herbivore interactions in a high CO₂ environment: Root and shoot aphids feeding on Cardamine. .  Oikos. (1996);  77 326-330
• 39 Siemann E., Tilman D., Haarstad J., Ritchie M.. Experimental tests of the dependence of arthropod diversity on plant diversity.  American Naturalist. (1998);  152 738-750
• 40 Southwood T. R. E., Brown V. K., Reader P. M.. The relationships of plant and insect diversities in succession.  Biological Journal of the Linnean Society. (1979);  12 327-348
• 41 Spehn E. M., Joshi J., Schmid B., Alpei J., Korner C.. Plant diversity on soil heterotrophic activity in experimental grassland systems.  Plant and Soil. (2000);  224 217-230
• 42 Stanton N. L.. The underground in grasslands.  Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics. (1988);  19 573-589
• 43 Stephan A., Meyer A. H., Schmid B.. Plant diversity affects culturable soil bacteria in experimental grassland communities.  Journal of Ecology. (2000);  88 988-998
• 44 Tilman D., Wedin D., Knops J.. Productivity and sustainability influenced by biodiversity in grassland ecosystems.  Nature. (1996);  379 718-720
• 45 Van Dam N. M., Harvey J. A., Wäckers F. L., Bezemer T. M., Van der Putten W. H., Vet L. E. M.. Interactions between aboveground and belowground induced responses against phytophages.  Basic and Applied Ecology. (2003);  4 63-77
• 46 Van der Putten W. H., Mortimer S. R., Hedlund K., Van Dijk C., Brown V. K., Lěps J., Rodriguez-Barrueco C., Roy J., Len T. A. D., Gormsen D., Korthals G. W., Lavorel S., Regina I. S., Smilauer P.. Plant species diversity as a driver of early succession in abandoned fields: a multi-site approach.  Oecologia. (2000);  124 91-99
• 47 Van der Putten W. H., Vet L. E. M., Harvey J. A., Wackers F. L.. Linking above- and belowground multitrophic interactions of plants, herbivores, pathogens, and their antagonists.  Trends in Ecology and Evolution. (2001);  16 547-554
• 48 Wardle D. A., Van der Putten W. H.. Biodiversity, ecosystem functioning and above-ground-below-ground linkages. Loreau, M., Naeem, S., and Inchausti, P., eds. Biodiversity and Ecosystem Functioning: Synthesis and Perspectives. Oxford, UK; Oxford University Press (2002): 155-168
• 49 Wardle D. A., Bonner K. I., Barker G. M., Yeates G. W., Nicholson K. S., Bardgett R. D., Watson R. N., Ghani A.. Plant removals in perennial grassland: Vegetation dynamics, decomposers, soil biodiversity, and ecosystem properties.  Ecological Monographs. (1999);  69 535-568
• 50 Yeates G. W., Wardle D. A., Watson R. N.. Responses of soil nematode populations, community structure, diversity and temporal variability to agricultural intensification over a seven-year period.  Soil Biology and Biochemistry. (1999);  31 1721-1733

Section Editor: M. C. Ball