Controversies in Cervical Spine Imaging in Trauma Patients

ABSTRACT

The subject of cervical spine imaging for trauma patients has generated significant controversy over the past decade and a half. This review considers three aspects of this controversy. The first examines the indications for cervical imaging, focusing on the factors that determine whether trauma patients are at high or low risk for cervical injury. The second discusses the uses of radiography and computed tomography as the main screening diagnostic examination. In addition to the roles of each modality in this evaluation process, other factors such as efficacy of diagnosis, time requirements for study, and cost will be discussed. The final section explores the methods currently used to “clear” the cervical spine in comatose patients.

KEYWORDS

Cervical spine - trauma - imaging indications - radiography indications - efficacy - cost - computed tomography - indications - dose

REFERENCES

• 1 Stiell I G, Greenberg G H, McKnight R D et al.. Decision rules for the use of radiography in acute ankle injuries. Refinement and prospective validation.  JAMA. 1993;  269 1127-1132
• 2 Stiell I G, Greenberg G H, Wells G A et al.. Derivation of a decision rule for the use of radiography in acute knee injuries.  Ann Emerg Med. 1995;  26 405-413
• 3 Mirvis S E, Diaconis J N, Chirico P A, Reiner B I, Joslyn J N, Militello P. Protocol-driven radiologic evaluation of suspected cervical spine injury: efficiency study.  Radiology. 1989;  170 831-834
• 4 Vandemark R M. Radiology of the cervical spine in trauma patients: practice pitfalls and recommendations for improving efficiency and communication.  AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1990;  155 465-472
• 5 Hanson J A, Blackmore C C, Mann F A, Wilson A J. Cervical spine injury: a clinical decision rule to identify high-risk patients for helical CT screening.  AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2000;  174 713-717
• 6 Hoffman J R, Mower W R, Wolfson A B, Todd K H, Zucker M I. Validity of a set of clinical criteria to rule out injury to the cervical spine in patients with blunt trauma.  N Engl J Med. 2000;  343 94-99
• 7 Stiell I G, Wells G A, Vandemheen K L et al.. The Canadian c-spine rule for radiography in alert and stable trauma patients.  JAMA. 2001;  286 1841-1848
• 8 Daffner R H, Brown R R, Goldberg A L. A new classification for cervical vertebral injuries: influence of CT.  Skeletal Radiol. 2000;  29 125-132
• 9 American College of Radiology Expert Panel on Musculoskeletal Imaging .ACR Appropriateness Criteria for Suspected Cervical Spine Trauma Reston, VA; American College of Radiology 2003
• 10 Nuñez Jr D B, Ahmad A A, Coin G C et al.. Clearing the cervical spine in multiple trauma victims: a time-effective protocol using helical CT.  Emerg Radiol. 1994;  1 273-278
• 11 Nuñez Jr D B, Zuluaga A, Fuentes-Bernardo D A, Rivas L A, Becerra J L. Cervical spine trauma: how much more do we learn by routinely using helical CT?.  Radiographics. 1996;  16 1307-1318
• 12 Blackmore C C, Ramsey S T, Mann F A, Deyo R A. Cervical spine screening with CT in trauma patients: a cost-effectiveness analysis.  Radiology. 1999;  212 117-125
• 13 Berne J D, Velmahos G C, El-Tawil Q et al.. Value of complete cervical helical computed tomographic scanning in identifying cervical spine injury in the unevaluable blunt trauma patient with multiple injuries: a prospective study.  J Trauma. 1999;  47 896-903
• 14 Lawrason J N, Novelline R A, Rhea J T, Sacknoff R, Kihiczak D, Ptak T. Can CT eliminate the initial portable lateral cervical spine radiograph in the multiple trauma patient? A review of 200 cases.  Emerg Radiol. 2001;  8 272-275
• 15 Li A E, Fishman E K. Cervical spine trauma: evaluation by multidetector CT and three-dimensional volume rendering.  Emerg Radiol. 2003;  10 34-39
• 16 Ptak T, Kihiczak D, Lawrason J N. Screening for cervical spine trauma with helical CT: experience with 676 cases.  Emerg Radiol. 2001;  8 315-319
• 17 Daffner R H, Sciulli R, Rodriguez A. Cervical CT vs. radiography for cervical spine trauma screening. A two-year experience. Presented at The American Roentgen Ray Society, Annual Meeting May 19, 2005 New Orleans, LA;
• 18 Daffner R H. Cervical radiography for trauma patients: a time-effective technique?.  AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2000;  175 1309-1311
• 19 Daffner R H. Cervical helical CT for trauma patients: a time analysis.  AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2001;  177 677-679
• 20 Saini S, Seltzer S E, Bramson R T. Technical cost of radiologic examinations: analysis across imaging modalities.  Radiology. 2000;  216 269-272
• 21 Forman H P. Cost value, and price: what is the difference and why care?.  Radiology. 2001;  218 25-26
• 22 Saini S, Sharma R, Levine L A, Barmson R T, Jordan P F, Thrall J H. Technical cost of CT examinations.  Radiology. 2001;  218 172-175
• 23 Rybicki F, Nawfel R D, Judy P F et al.. Skin and thyroid dosimetry in cervical spine screening: two methods for evaluation and a comparison between a helical CT and radiographic trauma series.  AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2002;  179 933-937
• 24 Abel M S. Occult Traumatic Lesions of the Cervical Vertebrae St. Louis; Warren H. Green, Inc 1971
• 25 Pollack Jr C V, Hendey G W, Martin D R. Use of flexion-extension radiographs of the cervical spine in blunt trauma.  Ann Emerg Med. 2001;  38 8-11
• 26 Brady W J, Moghtader J, Cutcher D, Exline C. Young. ED use of flexion-extension cervical spine radiography in the evaluation of blunt trauma.  Am J Emerg Med. 1999;  17 504-508
• 27 Dwek J R, Chung C B. Radiography of cervical spine injury in children: are flexion-extension radiographs useful for acute trauma?.  AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2000;  174 1617-1619
• 28 Davis J W, Parks S N, Detlefs C L et al.. Clearing the cervical spine in obtunded patients: the use of dynamic fluoroscopy.  J Trauma. 1995;  39 435-438
• 29 Sees D W, Cruz L RR, Flaherty S F. The use of bedside fluoroscopy to evaluate the cervical spine in obtunded trauma patients.  J Trauma. 1998;  45 768-771
• 30 Davis J W, Kaups K L, Cunningham M A. Routine evaluation of the cervical spine in head-injured patients with dynamic fluoroscopy: a reappraisal.  J Trauma. 2001;  50 1044-1047
• 31 Griffiths H J, Wagner J, Anglen J, Bunn P, Metzler M. The use of forced flexion/extension views in the obtunded trauma patient.  Skeletal Radiol. 2002;  31 587-591