Underweight in Ski Jumping: The Solution of the Problem

Abstract

Underweight is becoming increasingly prevalent in many sports. Among world class ski jumpers, the body mass index BMI has decreased by 4 units since 1970. The BMI ignores different body properties of individuals. Particular care should be taken in groups with unusual leg length to avoid classifying them inappropriately as thin or overweight (WHO). The improved measure MI (mass index) for relative body weight overcomes this shortcoming. Anthropometric data of ski jumpers was collected during the Olympic Games in Salt Lake City (2002; participation 81 %, n = 57), during the Summer Grand Prix in Hinterzarten (2000; participation 100 %, n = 92), and during the World Cup in Planica (2000; n = 56). The BMI and the MI were determined. The MI considers the individual leg length: A person with longer legs than average has an MI > BMI, and vice versa: MI = 0.28 m/s² (m: mass in kg, s: sitting height in meters). BMI classes of ski jumpers in the season 2004/2005 were calculated from their official individual ski length limitation which is a function of their BMI. BMI means were 19.84 in Planica, 19.58 in Hinterzarten, and 19.43 kgm^-2 in SLC. Lowest BMI was 16.4 kgm^-2. The percentage of underweight ski jumpers (BMI < 18.5 kgm^-2) decreased from 22.8 % at the Olympic Games 2002 to 8.7 % in the season 2004/2005 due to the new ski jumping regulations. The ratio s/h = C (s = sitting height, h = height, C = cormic index) ranged from 0.49 to 0.57. Accordingly, the MI values (which are leg length corrected BMI values according to MI = BMI (C¯/C)^k with k = 2 and C¯ = 0.53) deviated remarkably from BMI values. For the 49 cases with BMI or MI or both below 18.5 kgm^-2, the classification to be underweight or not changed in 69 % when the MI was used instead of the BMI. Underweight or overweight is not only a question of cut-off points; the measure used determines the classification accuracy. A substantial improvement of weight analyses in sports medicine, public health, and general medicine as well can be obtained by using the MI instead of the BMI.

Anorexia athletica - underweight - body mass index - mass index - ski jumping

References

• 1 Becker A E, Grinspoon S K, Klibanski A, Herzog D B. Current concepts: eating disorders.  New Engl J Med. 1999;  340 1092-1098
• 2 International Ski Federation .Book III, Ski Jumping. The International Ski Competition Rules, approved by the 44th International Ski Congress, Miami (USA),. 2004 § 413
• 3 Müller W, Platzer D, Schmölzer B. Scientific approach to ski safety.  Nature. 1995;  375 455
• 4 Müller W, Platzer D, Schmölzer B. Dynamics of human flight on skis: improvements on safety and fairness in ski jumping.  J Biomech. 1996;  29 1061-1068
• 5 Müller W, Schmölzer B. Computer simulated ski jumping: the tightrope walk to high performance. In: IV World Congress Biomechanics (WCB), Proceedings CD. University of Calgary, Canada, Faculty of Kinesiology. 2002
• 6 Müller W. A scientific approach to address the problem of underweight athletes: a case study of ski jumping. Sixth IOC World Congress on Sport Sciences 2002.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2002;  34 124
• 7 Müller W. Body weight and performance in ski jumping: the low weight problem and a possible way to solve it. In: Proceedings of the Seventh IOC World Congress on Sport Sciences, 2003; 43D. Athens. 
• 8 Norgan N G. Population differences in body composition in relation to the BMI.  Eur J Clin Nutr. 1994;  48 10-27
• 9 Schmölzer B, Müller W. The importance of being light: aerodynamic forces and weight in ski jumping.  J Biomech. 2002;  35 1059-1069
• 10 Schmölzer B, Müller W. Individual flight styles in ski jumping: results obtained during Olympic Games competitions.  J Biomech. 2005;  38 1055-1065
• 11 Sudi K. Anorexia athletica.  Nutrition. 2004;  20 657-661
• 12 Sullivan P F. Mortality in anorexia nervosa.  Am J Psychiat. 1995;  152 1073-1074
• 13 Sundgot-Borgen J. Eating disorders in female athletes.  Sports Med. 1994;  17 176-188
• 14 Vaverka F. Somatic problems associated with the flight phase in ski-jumping.  Studia i monografia AWF we Wroclawiv. 1994;  40 123-128
• 15 Vaverka F. Research reports, Olomouc personal communication. 1987 and 1995. 
• 16 WHO Expert Consultation . Appropriate body-mass index for asian populations and its implications for policy and interventions strategies.  Lancet. 2004;  363 157-163
• 17 WHO Expert Consultation . Physical status, use and interpretation of anthropometry.  Technical Report Series. 1995;  No. 834 364
• 18 WHO Expert Consultation . Physical status, use and interpretation of anthropometry.  Technical Report Series. 1995;  No. 834 355