Secondary Benefits from Tinnitus Retraining Therapy: Clinically Significant Increases in Loudness Discomfort Level and Expansion of the Auditory Dynamic Range

ABSTRACT

In this report, the authors highlight clinically significant improvements in sound tolerance observed over the past decade among patients who were enrolled in tinnitus retraining therapy (TRT) at the University of Maryland Tinnitus and Hyperacusis Center. Pretreatment and TRT follow-up audiometric threshold, loudness discomfort level (LDL), and dynamic-range (DR) data are documented for (1) a group of 68 tinnitus patients who presented with primary complaints of sound intolerance, and (2) a second group of 70 patients who reported only tinnitus (and no sound tolerance problems). TRT-related increases in sound tolerance are (1) due to increases in LDLs and occur independently of changes in audiometric threshold, which were invariant with treatment; (2) statistically significant in tinnitus patients with and without sound tolerance problems, and with and without hearing loss; (3) observed among 81% of the patients with sound tolerance complaints and 44% of the patients who reported primary tinnitus; (4) independent of audiometric frequency over the range 1000 to 8000 Hz; and (5) seemingly independent of TRT treatment duration, which is consistent with recent experimental evidence of a rapid treatment effect (within the first month of TRT). The TRT treatment effects were clinically meaningful, offering new opportunities for expanding the auditory DR and improving sound tolerance in the general hearing-impaired population. The mechanism responsible for the plasticity underlying these treatment effects is uncertain, but appears consistent with a centrally mediated auditory gain control process. Sound tolerance problems were overpredicted among the authors' sample of tinnitus-only patients when existing objective audiometric criteria were used. This finding promoted the development of a new predictive model for sound tolerance problems, which is described in a companion report.

KEYWORDS

Tinnitus retraining therapy - loudness discomfort level - auditory dynamic range - tinnitus - hyperacusis

REFERENCES

• 1 Hazell J WP, Sheldrake J B. Hyperacusis and tinnitus. In: Aran J-M, Dauman R Tinnitus 91: Proceedings of the Fourth International Tinnitus Seminar. Amsterdam, The Netherlands; Kugler 1992: 245-248
• 2 Gabriels P. Hyperacusis: can we help?.  Australian J Audiol. 1993;  15 1-4
• 3 Jastreboff P J, Gray W C, Gold S L. Neurophysiological approach to tinnitus patients.  Am J Otol. 1996;  17 236-240
• 4 Gold S L, Frederick E A, Formby C. Shifts in dynamic range for hyperacusis patients receiving tinnitus retraining therapy (TRT). In: Hazell J Proceedings of the Sixth International Tinnitus Seminar 1999. London, UK; The Tinnitus and Hyperacusis Centre 1999: 297-301
• 5 McKinney C J, Hazell J WP, Graham R L. Changes in loudness discomfort level and sensitivity to environmental sound with habituation based therapy. In: Hazell J Proceedings of the Sixth International Tinnitus Seminar. London, UK; The Tinnitus and Hyperacusis Centre 1999: 499-501
• 6 Wölk C, Seefeld B. The effects of managing hyperacusis with maskers (noise generators). In: Hazell J Proceedings of the Sixth International Tinnitus Seminar. London, UK; The Tinnitus and Hyperacusis Centre 1999: 512-514
• 7 Jastreboff P J, Sheldrake J B, Jastreboff M M. Hyperacusis patients before and during tinnitus retraining therapy-audiometric categorization. Abstract presented at: the Twenty Fifth International Congress of Audiology August 27-31, 2000 The Hague, The Netherlands;
• 8 Berry J A, Gold S L, Frederick E A, Gray W C, Staecker H. Patient-based outcomes in patients with primary tinnitus undergoing tinnitus retraining therapy.  Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2002;  128 1153-1157
• 9 Gold S L, Formby C, Frederick E A, Suter C. Incremental shifts in loudness discomfort level among tinnitus patients with and without hyperacusis. In: Patuzzi R Proceedings of the 7^th International Tinnitus Seminar. Crawley, Australia; University of Western Australia 2002: 170-172
• 10 Hazell J WP, Sheldrake J B, Graham R L. Decreased sound tolerance: predisposing factors, triggers and outcomes after TRT. In: Patuzzi R Proceedings of the Seventh International Tinnitus Seminar. Crawley, Australia; University of Western Australia 2002: 255-261
• 11 Jastreboff P J, Jastreboff M M. Tinnitus retraining therapy (TRT) as a method for treatment of tinnitus and hyperacusis patients.  J Am Acad Audiol. 2000;  11 162-177
• 12 Jastreboff M M, Jastreboff P J. Decreased sound tolerance and tinnitus retraining therapy (TRT).  Aust N Z J Audiol. 2002;  24 74-81
• 13 Gold S L, Formby C, Gray W C. Celebrating a decade of evaluation and treatment: the University of Maryland Tinnitus & Hyperacusis Center.  Am J Audiol. 2000;  9 69-74
• 14 Henry J A, Schechter M A, Nagler S M, Fausti S A. Comparison of tinnitus masking and tinnitus retraining therapy.  J Am Acad Audiol. 2002;  13 559-581
• 15 Marriage J, Barnes N M. Is central hyperacusis a symptom of 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT) dysfunction?.  J Laryngol Otol. 1995;  109 915-921
• 16 Goldstein B, Shulman A. Tinnitus-hyperacusis and the loudness discomfort level test - a preliminary report.  Int Tinnitus J. 1996;  2 83-89
• 17 Phillips D P, Carr M M. Disturbances of loudness perception.  J Am Acad Audiol. 1998;  9 371-379
• 18 Anari M, Axelsson A, Eliasson A, Magnusson L. Hypersensitivity to sound.  Scand Audiol. 1999;  28 219-230
• 19 Andersson G, Lindvall N, Hursti T, Carlbring P. Hypersensitivity to sound (hyperacusis): a prevalence study conducted via the internet and post.  Int J Audiol. 2002;  41 545-554
• 20 Formby C, Gold S L. Modification of loudness discomfort level: evidence for adaptive chronic auditory gain and its clinical relevance.  Semin Hear. 2002;  23 21-34
• 21 Nelting M. Hyperacusis: an overview of international literature and clinical experience. In: Patuzzi R Proceedings of the Seventh International Tinnitus Seminar. 2nd ed. Perth, Australia; University of Western Australia 2003: 218-221
• 22 Jastreboff P J. Phantom auditory perception (tinnitus): mechanisms of generation and perception.  Neurosci Res. 1990;  8 221-254
• 23 Nelting M, Rienhoff N K, Hesse G, Lamparter U. Subjective distress from hyperacusis: a questionnaire on hypersensitivity to sound. In: Patuzzi R Proceedings of the Seventh International Tinnitus Seminar. Crawley, W.A., Australia; University of Western Australia 2002: 147-149
• 24 Vernon J A. Hyperacusis: testing, treatment and a possible mechanism.  Aust N Z J Audiol. 2002;  24 68-73
• 25 Sammeth C A, Preves D A, Brandy W T. Hyperacusis: case studies and evaluation of electronic loudness suppression devices as a treatment approach.  Scand Audiol. 2000;  29 28-36
• 26 Fabijanska A, Rogowski M, Bartnik G, Skarzynski H. Epidemiology of tinnitus and hyperacusis in Poland. In: Hazell JWP Proceedings of the Sixth International Tinnitus Seminar. London, UK; The Tinnitus and Hyperacusis Centre 1999: 569-571
• 27 Vernon J A, Press L. Treatment for hyperacusis. In: Vernon JA Tinnitus Treatment and Relief. Needham Heights, MA; Allyn & Bacon 1998: 223-227
• 28 Henry J A, Jastreboff M M, Jastreboff P J, Schechter M A, Fausti S A. Assessment of patients for treatment with tinnitus retraining therapy.  J Am Acad Audiol. 2002;  13 523-544
• 29 Jastreboff P J. Tinnitus: the method of Pawel J Jastreboff. In: Gates G Current Therapy in Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery. St. Louis; Mosby-Year Book 1998: 90-95
• 30 Moore B JC. Perceptual Consequences of Cochlear Damage. New York; Oxford University Press 1995
• 31 Sandlin R E, Olsson R J. Evaluation and selection of maskers and other devices used in the treatment of tinnitus and hyperacusis.  Trends Amplif. 1999;  4 6-26
• 32 Jastreboff P J, Sheldrake J B, Jastreboff M M. Audiometric characterization of hyperacusis patients before and during TRT. In: Hazell J Proceedings of the Sixth International Tinnitus Seminar. London, UK; The Tinnitus and Hyperacusis Centre 1999: 495-498
• 33 Tyler R S, Conrad-Armes D. The determination of tinnitus loudness considering the effects of recruitment.  J Speech Hear Res. 1983;  26 59-72
• 34 Hazell J WP, Wood S M, Cooper H R et al.. A clinical study of tinnitus maskers.  Br J Audiol. 1985;  19 65-146
• 35 Vernon J A. Pathophysiology of tinnitus: A special case - hyperacusis and a proposed treatment.  Am J Otol. 1987;  8 201-202
• 36 Gold S L, Gray W C, Jastreboff P J. Audiological evaluation and follow-up. In: Reich GE, Vernon JA Proceedings of the Fifth International Tinnitus Seminar. Portland, OR; American Tinnitus Association 1996: 485-487
• 37 Jastreboff P J, Hazell J WP. A neurophysiological approach to tinnitus: clinical implications.  Br J Audiol. 1993;  27 7-17
• 38 Hawley M, Keaser M, Formby C. Predicting hyperacusis in tinnitus patients.  Semin Hear. 2007;  28 261-275
• 39 Gray W C, Jastreboff P J, Gold S L. Medical evaluation, diagnosis, and counseling of patients with tinnitus and hyperacusis. In: Reich GE, Vernon JA Proceedings of the Fifth International Tinnitus Seminar. Portland, OR; American Tinnitus Association 1996: 104-107
• 40 Gold S L, Gray W C, Hu S, Jastreboff P J. Selection and fitting of noise generators and hearing aids for tinnitus patients. In: Reich GE, Vernon JA Proceedings of the Fifth International Tinnitus Seminar. Portland, OR; American Tinnitus Association 1996: 313-314
• 41 Hughson W, Westlake H. Manual for program outline for rehabilitation of aural casualties, both military and civilian.  Trans Am Acad Ophthalmol Otolaryngol. 1944;  48(suppl) 1-15
• 42 Shapiro S S, Wilk M B. An analysis of variance test for normality (complete samples).  Biometrika. 1965;  52 591-611
• 43 Formby C, Sherlock L P, Gold S L. Adaptive recalibration of chronic auditory gain: interim findings. In: Patuzzi R VIIth International Tinnitus Seminar Proceedings. Perth, Australia; University of Western Australia 2002: 165-169
• 44 Formby C, Sherlock L P, Gold S L. Adaptive recalibration of chronic auditory gain. In: Santi PA Abstracts of the 26^th Annual Midwinter Meeting of the Association for Research in Otolaryngology. Mt. Royal, NJ; Association for Research in Otolaryngology February 23-27, 2003: 221
• 45 Formby C, Sherlock L P, Gold S L. Adaptive plasticity of loudness induced by chronic attenuation and enhancement of the acoustic background.  J Acoust Soc Am. 2003;  114 55-58
• 46 Silverman S R. Tolerance for pure tone and speech in normal and defective hearing.  Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 1947;  56 658-676
• 47 Byrne D, Dirks D. Effects of acclimatization and deprivation on non-speech auditory abilities.  Ear Hear. 1996;  17 29S-37S
• 48 Sherlock L P, Formby C. Estimates of loudness, loudness discomfort, and the auditory dynamic range: Normative estimates, comparison of procedures, and test-retest reliability.  J Am Acad Audiol. 2005;  16 85-100
• 49 Davis H. Audiology. Hearing and Deafness. 3rd ed. New York; Holt, Rinehart and Winston 1947: 3-6
• 50 Olsen S, Rasmussen A N, Nielsen L H, Borgkvist B V. Loudness perception is influenced by long-term hearing aid use.  Audiology. 1999;  38 202-205
• 51 Philibert B, Collet L, Vesson J-F, Veuillet E. Intensity-related performances are modified by long-term hearing aid use: a functional plasticity?.  Hear Res. 2002;  165 142-151
• 52 Hazell J WP. Tinnitus masking therapy. In: Hazell JWP Tinnitus. London, UK; Churchill Livingston 1987: 96-117