Key words
FertiPROTEKT - fertility protection - ovarian tissue - cryopreservation - transplantation
Introduction
Based on advancements in systemic drug (chemotherapy, targeted therapy) and locoregional
therapy (surgery, radiation therapy), the survival rate in malignant and non-malignant
diseases has significantly improved. However, the treatments frequently lead to a
partial or complete impairment of gonad function with possible germ cell loss. Therefore
it is important to counsel female patients prior to gonadotoxic therapy with regard
to preserving their fertility. By now, there are a number of fertility-protecting
techniques which offer a realistic chance of a later pregnancy. In addition to gonadal
transposition prior to radiotherapy, drug-based gonad protection using GnRH analogues
and cryopreservation of fertilised and unfertilised oocytes, the removal and cryopreservation
of ovarian tissue represents a promising option for girls and women [1], [2], [3].
The cryopreservation of ovarian tissue with subsequent transplantation is a method
of fertility preservation which can be performed very shortly before cytotoxic therapy.
It can take place at any point in the cycle and thus generally does not lead to any
delay in oncological therapy [4], [5]. Since the first births following ovarian tissue transplantation in 2004 worldwide
[6] and in 2011 in Germany [7], the method has been increasingly used in routine clinical practice. In the FertiPROTEKT network (Germany, Austria and Switzerland), 163 transplantations were performed
in 126 women by January 2018 [8]. The figures from Germany are comparable with the successes internationally. In
total, there have been more than 130 births following orthotopic transplantation of
cryopreserved ovarian tissue to date worldwide [8], [9], [10], [11], [12]. The birth rate is currently approximately 30 – 35% and it can be assumed that this
will increase further through optimisation of cryopreservation and surgical technique
[13]. The transplantation of cryopreserved ovarian tissue is thus an established option
for fertility protection for oncological patients [14], [15], [16].
The concept paper presented here is intended to provide recommendations for action
for the removal, transport, cryopreservation and transplantation of ovarian tissue
in German-speaking reproductive medical centres and thus at centres of the FertiPROTEKT network. This is to ensure the quality of the cryopreservation and transplantation
of ovarian tissue at the individual centres with the objective of offering an optimal
and consistent standard.
These are not recommendations in the sense of a guideline but rather a joint decision
by leading experts on the subjects of removal, cryopreservation and transplantation
of ovarian tissue. For this reason, the nomenclature does not correspond to the recommendation
classifications of a guideline.
Removal of Ovarian Tissue
Removal of Ovarian Tissue
From whom and up to which age should ovarian tissue be removed?
The chances for a later pregnancy are greater the higher the ovarian reserve is, that
is, the follicular density in the cryopreserved and transplanted ovarian tissue [17], [18]. The Edinburgh criteria indicate an age limit of 35 years [19], while other international publications mention a maximum age of 40 years [20]. In a publication by van der Ven et al., the pregnancy rates following transplantation
of ovarian tissue were 33% in women who were under age 35 at the time of cryopreservation,
in comparison to 18% in women who were over age 35 at the time of cryopreservation.
In women over age 40, no pregnancy was able to be achieved [8].
The cryopreservation of ovarian tissue can also be performed on pre- and peripubertal
girls [21]. There are case reports indicating that an induction of puberty can be achieved
through the transplantation of prepubertal ovarian tissue [22], [23]. In addition, there is a case report of a birth following transplantation of cryopreserved
premenarchal tissue [24]. This shows that transplantation following prepubertal cryopreservation of ovarian
tissue can lead to pregnancies. However, in this regard, it must be borne in mind
that the patient was already 13 years old with the onset of thelarche at the time
the tissue was removed [24]. In addition, there is a press release of a birth following transplantation of ovarian
tissue which had been cryopreserved prior to menarche at the age of 9 years [25]. The indication for cryopreservation of ovarian tissue in pre- and peripubertal
girls is currently still unclear and requires an individual assessment of the type
of therapy and also of the gonadotoxic dose [1].
Joint Decision
The cryopreservation of ovarian tissue should be performed prior to the start of gonadotoxic
therapy in girls and women only up to the age of 40 years. Ovarian cryopreservation
can also be considered on a case-by-case basis in prepubertal girls, taking the gonadotoxic
therapy and the risks of the surgical procedure into account.
On which chemotherapy and from which level of risk for premature ovarian insufficiency
(POI) should ovarian tissue be removed?
The cryopreservation of ovarian tissue is recommended for women in whom the preservation
of ovarian function is directly or indirectly threatened due to an underlying oncological,
haematological, or other illness [4]. This particularly applies in the case of upcoming gonadotoxic chemotherapy or radiation
in the lesser pelvis.
The removal and cryopreservation of ovarian tissue should in particular be offered
to all women with a high and intermediate risk of premature ovarian insufficiency
(POI). However, even in women with a low risk of permanent amenorrhea, this option
should be discussed with the patient. In doing so, it should be taken into account
that a risk of POI of ≤ 20% means that one out of every five women who receives one
of these chemotherapy regimens is at risk of suffering POI. The ovariotoxic effect
of various chemotherapeutic agents and radiation can be found in the tables ([Tables 1] and [2]) of the S2k guideline “Fertility preservation in oncological therapies” [1].
Table 1 Ovariotoxic effect of various chemotherapeutic agents [1].
|
Risk
|
Regimen/substance
|
|
High risk (> 80% risk of permanent amenorrhoea)
|
-
CMF, CEF, CAF, TAC × 6 in women ≥ 40 years
-
Conditioning for stem cell transplantation (particularly alkylating-agent-based myeloablative
conditioning with busulfan, cyclophosphamide, melphalan)
-
BEACOPP × 6 – 8 in women > 35 years
|
|
Intermediate risk (40 – 60% risk of permanent amenorrhoea)
|
-
CMF, CEF, CAF, TAC × 6 in women 30 – 39 years
-
AC × 4 in women ≥ 40 years
-
AC or EC × 4 → taxane
-
BEACOPP × 6 – 8 in women 25 – 35 years
-
CHOP × 6 in women ≥ 35 years
-
Therapy typical for bone and soft tissue sarcomas
|
|
Low risk (< 20% risk of permanent amenorrhoea)
|
-
CMF, CEF, CAF, TAC × 6 in women ≤ 30 years
-
AC × 4 in women ≤ 40 years
-
BEACOPP × 6 – 8 in women < 25 years
-
ABVD × 2 – 4
-
CHOP × 6 in women < 35 years
-
CVP
-
Therapy typical for AML (anthracycline/cytarabine)
-
Therapy typical for ALL (multi-agent)
-
FOLFOX in women ≤ 40 years
|
|
Very low or no risk of permanent amenorrhoea
|
-
Methotrexate
-
Fluorouracil
-
Vincristine
|
Table 2 Gonadotoxicity in the case of radiation of the ovary and risk of ovarian insufficiency
(modified according to [26]).
|
Effective sterilising dose (ESD)
|
Ovarian radiation dose (Gy)
|
|
No relevant effects
|
0.6
|
|
No relevant effects at < 40 years
|
1.5
|
|
0 years
|
20.3
|
|
10 years
|
18.4
|
|
20 years
|
16.5
|
|
30 years
|
14.3
|
|
40 years
|
6
|
Joint Decision
The cryopreservation of ovarian tissue should be offered when there is a high or intermediate
risk and – on a case-by-case basis – also when there is a low risk of premature ovarian
insufficiency due to gonadotoxic therapy.
How should the tissue be removed?
The gold standard for the removal of ovarian tissue is laparoscopy. A laparotomy should
only be performed if this is necessary within the scope of the underlying oncological
diseases. In the case of removal of ovarian tissue, chromopertubation should be performed
under certain conditions (see [Fig. 1]). If unilateral tubal occlusion is seen, the ovarian tissue should be taken on this
side in order to preserve the potentially still functioning ovarian tissue on the
side with the patent tube. If no POI occurs, an optimal site is available there later
for a transplantation. However, it should preferably be ensured that ovarian tissue
is not taken on the side of a corpus luteum or a preovulatory follicle or in the case
of existing ovarian cysts, since the follicular density of the ovarian tissue to be
cryopreserved may be limited here and the cortex quality in any case.
Fig. 1 Algorithm for the removal of ovarian tissue.
The ovarian tissue should be detached using scissors without electrical coagulation
[27], [28], [29]. Haemostasis of the wound surface should be performed on the remaining ovary without
forming additional areas of necrosis. There are no evidence-based studies available
on the various techniques (coagulation, sutures) ([Fig. 2]).
Fig. 2 Removal of ovarian tissue via laparoscopy (photo from Department of Obstetrics and
Gynaecology, Erlangen).
The surgical risks of removing ovarian tissue are low [27], [28], [29]. There is an increased risk of infections and bleeding which is only dependent on
the oncological disease. The removal of ovarian tissue is anticipated to involve one
complication per 500 laparoscopies which necessitates surgical revision [30].
A histological examination of a reference sample of the ovarian tissue taken to rule
out malignant cells and to identify follicles (a tissue fragment from the ovarian
tissue taken measuring at least 2 × 2 mm) should be performed and documented by the
centre at which the ovarian tissue was removed. The risks of ovarian metastasis and
the resultant consequences can be found in the S2k guideline “Fertility preservation
in oncological diseases” [1].
Joint Decision
-
The gold standard for the removal of ovarian tissue is laparoscopy.
-
A laparotomy should only be performed if this is necessary within the scope of the
underlying oncological disease.
-
The ovarian tissue should be detached using scissors and sources of bleeding should
only be coagulated in a targeted manner afterwards (punctate coagulation).
-
Histology to rule out malignant cells in the ovarian tissue (at least 2 × 2 mm) must
be performed by the centre at which the ovarian tissue was removed.
How much ovarian tissue should be taken?
At least ½ to ⅔ of the ovary should be taken antimesenterically [27], [28], [29] ([Fig. 2]). Bilateral removal at the ovaries should be considered to be an exception (for
example, in the case of bilateral ovarian cysts). Due to the small amount of material,
biopsies should not be performed [27], [28], [29]. However, the patient should also be informed of the possibility for a unilateral
ovariectomy, particularly in the case of a high risk of POI. Data show that after
a unilateral ovariectomy, menopause can occur approximately one year earlier [31].
Joint Decision
At least ½ to ⅔ of an ovary (preferably without ovarian pathologies) should be removed.
Bilateral removal should be performed only in exceptional cases. Biopsies are not
recommended.
Transport of Ovarian Tissue
Transport of Ovarian Tissue
How and at which temperature should ovarian tissue be transported after removal and
prior to cryopreservation?
Those facilities which do not have possibilities for performing cryopreservation of
ovarian tissue themselves can send the ovarian tissue for tissue processing to specialised
centres with an affiliated cryobank [32].
For most organ and tissue transport (for example, kidney, liver), low temperatures
are generally selected. The data regarding the transport of ovarian tissue are limited.
In the few investigations conducted, the transport temperature varied between 4 – 37 °C
(10 – 13). Most studies show that the best conditions are found in the case of low
temperatures, around 4 °C. Low temperatures ensure that the cellular metabolism is
decreased in the corresponding tissue/organ. In this connection, the need for and,
at the same time, the consumption of oxygen are also reduced.
There are suitable transport contains with special pairs of cold packs for the transport
of ovarian tissue. The transport container ensures continuous cooling of the tissue
during transport at 4 °C and is provided by the respective cryobank ([Fig. 3]).
Fig. 3 Transport container for ovarian tissue.
Joint Decision
Prior to cryopreservation, ovarian tissue should be transported chilled (4 – 8 °C)
in special transport containers.
How long can ovarian tissue be transported prior to cryopreservation (transport period)?
The transport box can be shipped during the day via daytime courier service or overnight
via express courier service. The maximum transport time of the tissue without a significant
loss of follicles anticipated is currently not yet sufficiently proven. Investigations
show that hypothermia of the ovarian tissue during various transport periods can last
up to 24 hours without lasting damage to the follicular reserve [33], [34], [35], [36].
Joint Decision
The transport of ovarian tissue up to 24 hours prior to cryopreservation is possible.
Which transport medium should be used?
Various transport media are described by different working groups in the literature
[35], [36], [37], [38]. There are no adequate investigations which show which transport medium is most
suitable. In the case of organ and tissue transplants, Custodiol® is a certified and approved medium which must be used under chilled conditions (4 – 8 °C)
[39].
Joint Decision
Custodiol® or a comparable medium should be used under chilled conditions (4 – 8 °C) as a transport
medium.
Cryopreservation of Ovarian Tissue
Cryopreservation of Ovarian Tissue
Slow freezing vs. vitrification?
In general, two freezing techniques are used in reproductive medicine: the slow freezing
method, a cryopreservation method with equilibration, and vitrification, a freezing
method without equilibration [32]. Both methods are used worldwide in the cryopreservation of ovarian tissue. In routine
practice, because of the better pool of data available, the slow-freezing method is
currently recommended [1], [5], [40]. Apart from two published births following transplantation of vitrified ovarian
tissue, the tissue in the case of all other births was slowly frozen [41], [42]. The future significance of vitrification cannot yet be estimated due to the current
data and validations are needed for universal clinical use [43].
Slow freezing with cooling rates of 0.3 °C/min requires the use of freezers. In a
computer-controlled slow-freezing method, the samples are cooled down according to
a modified programme [44] such that they can subsequently be stored indefinitely in a nitrogen gas phase (at
− 190 °C). Clear identification of the stored samples must be ensured, for example,
through the use of the single European code or a comparable coding system.
Joint Decision
Based on the better pool of data available, ovarian tissue should at present be cryopreserved
in routine practice with the established slow-freezing method.
How should the ovarian tissue be processed?
According to the standards of an IVF laboratory, a suitable room with a sterile class
II laminar air flow unit in which surgical preparation can take place should be available
for processing the ovarian tissue prior to freezing. In the case of chilled preparation,
the ovarian medulla is to be carefully dissected away from the ovarian cortex and
in doing so, a thin portion of residual stroma should be left to ensure that there
is an optimal starting point for neovascularisation of the transplants later [43]. Depending on the size and quality, pieces of ovarian tissue measuring 3 × 2 × 1 mm
up to a maximum of 4 × 8 × 1 mm should be cut from the prepared cortex ([Fig. 4]). The size of the pieces should be listed in the transplantation record.
Fig. 4 Cut ovarian tissue pieces.
Joint decision
-
The ovarian tissue should be processed in a suitable room under a sterile class II
laminar air flow.
-
The ovarian tissue pieces should measure between 3 × 2 × 1 mm up to a maximum of 4 × 8 × 1 mm.
The size of the ovarian tissue pieces should be listed in the transplantation record.
Which freezing medium should be used?
The choice of the cryoprotective used is an important point which is largely responsible
for whether cryopreservation is successful. Glycerine, ethylene glycol, DMSO and propanediol
in combination with corresponding carrier media and a protein supplement are available
for this [34], [36], [45], [46]. Using the cryoprotectives ethylene glycol, propanediol or DMSO, similarly good
survival rates of the germ cells as well as intact tissue morphologies and cell structures
are demonstrated following cryopreservation and subsequent thawing; glycerine performed
the worst in investigations [34], [36], [45], [46]. Internationally, DMSO is the most frequently used and best established cryoprotective
for ovarian tissue [41], [47], [48].
Joint Decision
DMSO or, alternatively, ethylene glycol can be used as a cryoprotective.
Vitality testing of the ovarian tissue?
The prepared ovarian tissue is examined for quality assurance prior to cryopreservation
and also during preparation for a transplantation in the case of premature ovarian
failure following cytotoxic therapy. The examinations ensure that the removal of the
tissue, its transport/processing and also the cryopreservation and thawing have not
led to any relevant damage to the tissue – likewise, a possible cortex potential (number
of primordial follicles in a particular area) of each patient is individually determined.
Small, standardised biopsy punches from various peripheral areas are methodically
produced for this as part of the preparation of the ovarian tissue taken; following
tissue digestion and calcein-acetoxymethyl ester staining or a live-dead assay, these
punches are analysed for the number of vital primordial follicles. The concentration
of vital primordial follicles and the anti-Müller hormone level in the serum, the
antral follicle count and the age of the patient (all determined at the time that
the ovarian tissue is removed or before the start of cytotoxic therapy) are considered
to be parameters for determining the fertility reserve – but also for later determination
of the number of ovarian cortex pieces to be transplanted.
For the validation of a facility which processes ovarian tissue, the FertiPROTEKT network recommends that cryopreserving centres have their freezing technique
checked through a xenotransplantation of ovarian tissue on immunodeficient severe-combined-immunodeficiency
(SCID) mice before offering cryopreservation of ovarian tissue in routine clinical
practice. This is able to show that the follicles have a qualitative development potential/follicular
growth following cryopreservation and thawing.
Joint Decision
Vitality testing with a suitable assay should be performed before freezing and before
transplantation.
Transplantation of Ovarian Tissue
Transplantation of Ovarian Tissue
When should ovarian tissue be transplanted and up to which age?
Transplantation of ovarian tissue should take place after successful oncological therapy
in female patients with a manifest desire for a child and in the case of failure of
ovarian function, for the resumption of folliculogenesis and to lead to a pregnancy
[49]. A transplantation can be considered even in patients who still have a regular cycle
but limited ovarian reserve. Transplantation to restore longstanding ovarian function
which would, where applicable, replace necessary hormone replacement therapy should
not be primarily recommended due to the limited activity of the transplanted tissue
[50]. Prior to transplantation, especially if there is no POI and nevertheless a transplantation
is being considered, the couple should undergo a basic clarification of causes of
infertility to rule out or correct other causes of infertility or this should be included
in the further treatment planning.
The age of 45 years should not be exceeded as an age limit for a transplantation [51]. If a transplantation is to be recommended at the earliest following oncological
treatment, this should be determined depending on the underlying oncological disease
and individually together with the attending oncologists, taking the age of the patient
and the oncological prognosis into account.
Joint Decision
-
Transplantation of ovarian tissue should be performed in women with a manifest desire
for a child and failure of ovarian function (amenorrhoea/oligomenorrhoea), up to the
age of 45 years.
-
A basic clarification of causes of infertility should be performed prior to transplantation.
How should the ovarian tissue be transplanted (surgical technique and site of transplantation)?
The transplantation of ovarian tissue is generally performed via laparoscopy [27], [28], [29]. In routine clinical practice, orthotopic transplantation is primarily used. In
an orthotopic transplantation, the ovarian tissue is transplanted either in the pelvic
wall caudodorsal to the ovaries or in/on the ovary. Internationally, various orthotopic
transplantation techniques are described [27], [28], [29]. It is still unclear which of the techniques and which locations lead to the greatest
chances for pregnancy.
The better circulation in the pelvic wall and the easier surgical feasibility (and
the associated low surgical risk for the patient) are reasons for transplantation
under the pelvic peritoneum as compared to the situation in the generally significantly
atrophied ovary.
The parietal peritoneum of the ovarian fossa is incised for this purpose over a length
of approximately 0.5 – 1 cm. A subperitoneal pocket is created by blunt dissection
and the tissue pieces are implanted in the pocket. The tissue pieces should preferably
lie side by side and not on top of each other ([Fig. 5]). If the ovarian tissue is to be taken once again (for example, if there is an increased
risk of a predisposition), the tissue should be marked, for example, with titanium
clips ([Fig. 6]). Documentation of the site of transplantation should be ensured.
Fig. 5 Orthotopic transplantation of ovarian tissue in a peritoneal pocket of the pelvic
peritoneum of the ovarian fossa.
Fig. 6 Marking the transplantation site with titanium clips.
Please refer to the corresponding literature in the case of transplantation in/on
the ovary [2], [27].
In general, it is not recommended to transplant all of the cryopreserved material
at once but rather to implant only approximately ⅓ to ½ of the available tissue in
order to have tissue in reserve in the event of repeat loss of ovarian function [1]. However, the patientʼs age in the case of an ovarian transplantation should also
be taken into account.
A natural pregnancy is possible in principle in the case of an orthotopic transplantation
under the pelvic peritoneum. Therefore in the case of an ovarian tissue transplantation,
a fertility assessment (tubal, uterine and extrauterine factors) and correction, if
necessary, should be performed [1]; that is, in the case of an ovarian tissue transplantation, it is recommended to
check the patency of the Fallopian tubes by means of “chromo”-pertubation (with NaCl)
and also to consider a hysteroscopy to rule out polyps, myomas, adhesions or chronic
endometritis. The transplantation is performed on the side on which the tube is patent
and the anatomical conditions are the most favourable ([Fig. 7]).
The risks of surgery are comparable to the risks in the case of other laparoscopic
procedures. Possible risks are secondary haemorrhage or a wound infection which occur
in < 1% of cases [27], [28], [29].
Fig. 7 Algorithm for selecting the transplantation side.
Joint Decision
-
The transplantation of ovarian tissue is performed laparoscopically.
-
In the case of a transplantation, a “chromo”-pertubation (for example, with NaCl)
should be performed.
-
Blunt preparation of a pocket is performed in the pelvic peritoneum for this purpose
and the ovarian tissue is introduced into this pocket.
-
If the ovarian tissue preparation is to be taken again later, it is recommended to
mark the transplantation site (e.g. titanium clips).
Follow-up Care of Patients Who Have Undergone Transplantation
Follow-up Care of Patients Who Have Undergone Transplantation
What follow-up care should be provided?
The ovarian function can be restored in 80 – 85% of cases through transplantations
of ovarian tissue [15]. It takes between 2 to 6 months for the transplanted ovarian tissue to show signs
of resumption of its function (drop in FSH, rise in oestradiol) [48]. A spontaneous pregnancy can be attempted if the tubes are patent and there are
no other relevant infertility factors. To increase the likelihood of conception, the
patient can be offered cycle monitoring with induction of ovulation through HCG within
the framework of intercourse at the optimal time. In the case of occluded tubes or
other infertility factors, assisted reproductive medicine techniques (IVF; ICSI) must
be used. If there is a high follicle density (antral follicle count and AMH), gonadotropin
stimulation can be considered, depending on the patientʼs age and the underlying oncological
disease, in order to accelerate conception, if applicable. Alternatively, egg cells
obtained in several spontaneous cycles or stimulated cycles can also be vitrified
so that an egg cell pool is created for later use in an assisted reproductive medicine
technique [52]. To increase the rate of implantation, particularly in the case of whole-body radiation
and radiation of the lesser pelvis, other diagnostic measures, such as diagnostic
endometrial procedures to analyse the endometrial receptivity profile, can be offered.
After one year, approximately ⅔ of the transplants are still active. The tissue transplants
which initially showed good activity are generally active for several years. The mean
length of ovarian function after transplantation is about 4 to 7 years on average,
however this depends on the number of follicles in the ovarian tissue and the age
of the woman at the time of cryopreservation [11]. If there are no signs of activity seen after approximately ½ year after transplantation,
another transplantation of cryopreserved ovarian tissue should be considered.
Joint Decision
-
Patients with amenorrhoea should be offered a monthly blood test (FSH, oestradiol,
progesterone) 8 – 10 weeks before the transplantation until signs of activity are
detected, and every two months, an ultrasound examination should be offered.
-
If there are signs of activity of the transplanted ovarian tissue, it is recommended
to perform cycle monitoring to increase the chances of pregnancy, after other causes
of infertility have been clarified.
-
In patients with causes of infertility (such as tubal infertility, reduced male fertility)
ART measures must be taken.
-
Patients who still had an active cycle prior to transplantation should be offered
monthly cycle monitoring 8 – 10 weeks after the transplantation.
-
Stimulation can be considered depending on the individual situation (follicular density,
number of attempts to conceive, tumour entity).