Structure-Activity Relationship of Transfection-Modulating Saponins – A Pursuit for the Optimal Gene Trafficker

Abstract

The ability of certain triterpenoid saponins to modulate the endosomal release during the process of endocytosis and to ensure a nontoxic and efficient transfection recently led to an exceptional interest in the field of nonviral gene delivery. In vitro and in vivo studies demonstrated promising results in terms of tumor growth inhibition after the delivery of a suicide gene such as saporin and dianthin. With that, the question arises which structural features are necessary or advantageous to achieve an effective endosomal escape. Former studies described certain important characteristics a potent saponin should have. Particularly SA1641 (Gypsophila paniculata) and SO1861 (Saponaria officinalis) played an utmost important role to get a first insight into the structure-activity relationship. However, a number of issues such as the purpose of functional groups on the aglycon and the substitution of sugars and their modification remain unsolved and their value needs to be specified. By conducting a screening of several diverse saponins in terms of their transfection improving ability, we aimed to examine these questions in more detail and get a better understanding of the relevant features. The transfection of Neuro-2A-cells with GFP-DNA containing peptide-based nanoplexes provided a reliable method in order to compare the activity of the saponins. With that, we were able to provide new and essential insights regarding the structure-activity relationship of transfection-modulating saponins and give an idea of how a highly potent saponin for future gene therapies may look like.

Key words

triterpenoids - saponins - sapofection - Gypsophila elegans - Saponaria officinalis - Caryophyllaceae

• References

• 1 Hebestreit P, Melzig MF. Cytotoxic activity of the seeds from Agrostemma githago var. githago . Planta Med 2003; 69: 921-925
• 2 Weng A, Thakur M, von Mallinckrodt B, Beceren-Braun F, Gilabert-Oriol R, Wiesner B, Eichhorst J, Bottger S, Melzig MF, Fuchs H. Saponins modulate the intracellular trafficking of protein toxins. J Control Release 2012; 164: 74-86
• 3 Thakur M, Mergel K, Weng A, von Mallinckrodt B, Gilabert-Oriol R, Durkop H, Melzig MF, Fuchs H. Targeted tumor therapy by epidermal growth factor appended toxin and purified saponin: an evaluation of toxicity and therapeutic potential in syngeneic tumor bearing mice. Mol Oncol 2013; 7: 475-483
• 4 von Mallinckrodt B, Thakur M, Weng A, Gilabert-Oriol R, Durkop H, Brenner W, Lukas M, Beindorff N, Melzig MF, Fuchs H. Dianthin-EGF is an effective tumor targeted toxin in combination with saponins in a xenograft model for colon carcinoma. Future Oncol 2014; 10: 2161-2175
• 5 Hebestreit P, Weng A, Bachran C, Fuchs H, Melzig MF. Enhancement of cytotoxicity of lectins by Saponinum album . Toxicon 2006; 47: 330-335
• 6 Weng A, Manunta MD, Thakur M, Gilabert-Oriol R, Tagalakis AD, Eddaoudi A, Munye MM, Vink CA, Wiesner B, Eichhorst J, Melzig MF, Hart SL. Improved intracellular delivery of peptide- and lipid-nanoplexes by natural glycosides. J Control Release 2015; 206: 75-90
• 7 Sama S, Jerz G, Schmieder P, Woith E, Melzig MF, Weng A. Sapofectosid – Ensuring non-toxic and effective DNA and RNA delivery. Int J Pharm 2017; 534: 195-205
• 8 Sama S, Woith E, Walther W, Jerz G, Chen W, Hart S, Melzig MF, Weng A. Targeted suicide gene transfections reveal promising results in nu/nu mice with aggressive neuroblastoma. J Control Release 2018; 275: 208-216
• 9 Melzig MF, Hebestreit P, Gaidi G, Lacaille-Dubois MA. Structure-activity-relationship of saponins to enhance toxic effects of agrostin. Planta Med 2005; 71: 1088-1090
• 10 Bachran C, Sutherland M, Heisler I, Hebestreit P, Melzig MF, Fuchs H. The saponin-mediated enhanced uptake of targeted saporin-based drugs is strongly dependent on the saponin structure. Exp Biol Med (Maywood) 2006; 231: 412-420
• 11 Böttger S, Westhof E, Siems K, Melzig MF. Structure-activity relationships of saponins enhancing the cytotoxicity of ribosome-inactivating proteins type I (RIP-I). Toxicon 2013; 73: 144-150
• 12 Sama S, Jerz G, Schmieder P, Joseph JF, Melzig MF, Weng A. Plant derived triterpenes from Gypsophila elegans M. Bieb. enable non-toxic delivery of gene loaded nanoplexes. J Biotechnol 2018; 284: 131-139
• 13 Jia Z, Koike K, Nikaido T. Major triterpenoid saponins from Saponaria officinalis . J Nat Prod 1998; 61: 1368-1373
• 14 Lu Y, Van D, Deibert L, Bishop G, Balsevich J. Antiproliferative quillaic acid and gypsogenin saponins from Saponaria officinalis L. roots. Phytochemistry 2015; 113: 108-120
• 15 Weng A, Jenett-Siems K, Schmieder P, Bachran D, Bachran C, Gorick C, Thakur M, Fuchs H, Melzig MF. A convenient method for saponin isolation in tumour therapy. J Chromatogr B Analyt Technol Biomed Life Sci 2010; 878: 713-718
• 16 Haddad M, Miyamoto T, Ramezani M, Lacaille-Dubois MA. New triterpene saponins from Acanthophyllum pachystegium . Helv Chim Acta 2004; 87: 73-81