Key words:
multiple endocrine neoplasia type 1 - adenomas - variant
Introduction
Multiple endocrine neoplasia type 1 (MEN1; OMIM 131100) is a rare hereditary
autosomal dominant disorder with an incidence of 1/30 000–50 000
[1]. It is characterized by the occurrence
of parathyroid adenomas (95%), pituitary adenomas (30–40%),
and gastrointestinal pancreatic neuroendocrine neoplasia (40–70%)
[2]. MEN1 is caused by an inactivating
variant of the MEN1 (OMIM 613733) gene, which is located on chromosome 11q13
and encodes a 610-amino acid protein called menin [3]. Menin is a scaffold protein that interacts with other intracellular
molecules including JunD, NFκB, and Smad3, which are involved in
transcriptional regulation, genome stability, cell division, and proliferation [3]. More than 1200 germline variants in the
MEN1 gene have been identified including frame-shift variants
(42%), missense/nonsense variants (39.5%), splicing variants
(10.5%), large deletions (2.5%), and in-frame deletions or
insertions (5.5%) [4]. There is no
specific hotspot but MEN1 variants are distributed across the entire gene.
MEN1 is a tumor-suppressor gene and MEN1 patients have a heterozygous
germline variant in the gene that acts as the first ‘hit.’
Subsequently, somatic variant leads to the loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in the tumor
suppressor role for menin, which is consistent with the Knudson’s two-hit
hypothesis [5].
Approximately 10–25% of MEN1 patients may lack variants in the
MEN1 gene [4]. Recently, a germline
variant in the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor (CDNK)1B/p27 tumor
suppressor gene was identified in a family that presented with pituitary tumors,
parathyroid adenoma, renal angioleiomyoma, and testicular cancer [6]. The MEN1-like syndrome attributed to these
variants was named MEN4 [7]
[8]. However, only 19 cases of MEN4 including
16 different variants have been reported. In addition, 2% of the patients
may have variants in the CDKN family, such as CDKN1A, CDKN2B,
and CDKN2C, which overlap with the clinical manifestations of MEN1 [4]
[8].
In our study, we explored the clinical and genetic characteristics of four MEN1
patients. We identified four heterozygous MEN1 germline variants (c.564delC,
c.1268G>A, IVS5+5delG, and c.1546_1547insC), two novel somatic
variants (c.249_252delGTCT and c.313_314insC) and LOH for IVS5+5delG and
c.564delC in tumor tissues from the MEN1 patients.
Patients and Methods
Ethical statement
We conducted this study with four MEN1 patients. We collected the peripheral
blood as well as surgically resected parathyroid and thymic tumor tissue from
the patients. Further, peripheral blood samples from the pedigree and 100
unrelated healthy controls were also collected. All procedures were in
accordance with the World Medical Association’s Declaration of Helsinki.
We obtained approval for this study from the Institutional Ethics Committee of
the Third Xiangya Hospital. We also obtained written informed consent from all
the subjects enrolled in this study.
Patient’s data
Patient #1
Patient #1 was a 32-year-old woman suffering from amenorrhea for 5 years. She
had a history of nephrolithotomy. Laboratory tests revealed hypercalcemia,
hypophosphatemia, and high parathyroid hormone (PTH) levels. Further, her
parathyroid ultrasonography indicated bilateral parathyroid adenoma and
urinary ultrasonography suggested multiple bilateral kidney stones. Magnetic
resonance imaging (MRI) revealed a microadenoma, which was presumed to be a
prolactinoma due to hyperprolactinemia. Abdominal computed tomography (CT)
revealed a left adrenal nodule with a size of 0.7×0.4 cm. Her mother
had been diagnosed with MEN1, including parathyroid adenoma, pituitary
prolactinoma, and insulinoma. A MEN1 diagnosis was made because she had
MEN1-associated tumors and a first-degree relative with MEN1 ([Table 1]). She underwent subtotal
parathyroidectomy (3.5 glands). The pathological findings were consistent
with parathyroid adenoma. Calcium and Vitamin D supplements were given and
the prolactinoma was treated with 0.5 mg cabergoline twice a week as
bromocriptine showed poor efficacy.
Table 1 Clinical and genetic features of MEN1
patients.
|
Age
|
Sex
|
Family history
|
Parathyroid
|
Pituitary
|
Pancreas
|
Others
|
Germline mutation
|
Somatic mutation
|
|
Patient 1
|
32
|
F
|
Positive
|
PHPT
|
Microadenoma PRL
|
–
|
Adrenal adenoma
|
c.564delC (p.N189Mfs*35)
|
c.249_252delGTCT (p.I85Sfs*33)c.564delC
(p.N189Mfs*35)
|
|
Patient 2
|
25
|
F
|
Negative
|
PHPT
|
Microadenoma PRL
|
–
|
–
|
c.1268G>A (p.W423X)
|
unknown
|
|
Patient 3
|
38
|
M
|
Negative
|
PHPT
|
–
|
Insulinoma
|
Adrenal adenoma, thymoma
|
c.824+5delG (IVS5+5delG)
|
c.313_314insC (p.L105Pfs*12) c.824+5delG
(IVS5+5delG)
|
|
Patient 4
|
52
|
F
|
Possible
|
PHPT
|
Macroadenoma PRL
|
Neuroendocrine neoplasia
|
Adrenal adenoma
|
c.1546_1547insC (p.R516Pfs*15)
|
unknown
|
PRL: PRL-secreting adenoma; PHPT: Primary hyperparathyroidism.
Patient #2
Patient #2 was a 25-year-old woman suffering from parathyroid adenoma
for 6 months. She reported having a pituitary tumor resection at the age of
15 and the pathological results indicated a prolactinoma. Her laboratory
tests revealed hypercalcemia, high PTH levels, and nephrolithiasis. She
underwent minimally invasive parathyroidectomy. The pathological findings
were consistent with parathyroid adenoma. However, she still had persistent
hypercalcemia and high PTH levels after the operation. She underwent
subtotal parathyroidectomy 4 months later and her plasma PTH and calcium
levels were normal after the surgery, indicating the surgery was successful.
No consanguinity was found in her parents.
Patient #3
Patient #3 was a 38-year-old man who came to our hospital with episodes of
hypoglycemia lasting for 16 years. He was diagnosed with insulinoma in 2002
and underwent his first operation for insulinoma. Subsequently, he
experienced a recurrence of hypoglycemia in 2010 and hence underwent
laparoscopic distal pancreatectomy and splenectomy. However, he developed
symptoms of hypoglycemia after 2 years. His laboratory tests confirmed
persistent hypoglycemia with hyperinsulinism. A 9 mm lesion was found at the
head of the pancreas with the help of pancreatic CT. Hypercalcemia and high
PTH levels were also found. Parathyroid ultrasonography revealed bilateral
parathyroid adenomas. Pulmonary CT revealed thymoma with a size of
9.1×7.5×8.9 cm. Adrenal CT showed bilateral adrenal nodules.
A MEN1 diagnosis was made because he had three MEN1-associated tumors ([Table 1]). He underwent surgical
resection of insulinoma once again. However, the patient continued to suffer
from hypoglycemia and refused a total pancreatectomy, which was recommended
by the physicians. Thymoma resection surgery was performed in 2018. The
pathological examination suggested a thymic carcinoid with a pathology stage
of G2 for the thymoma (karyokinesis<10/10HPF, ki-67
20%). He also underwent subtotal parathyroidectomy (3.5 glands) in
2019. The pathological findings were consistent with parathyroid adenoma. No
consanguinity was found in his parents.
Patient #4
Patient #4, a 52-year-old woman, visited our hospital because of recurrent
kidney stones since 2012. Her laboratory tests revealed anemia,
hypercalcemia, high serum creatinine (Cr) and high PTH levels. Parathyroid
ultrasonography showed bilateral parathyroid adenomas. She was first
diagnosed with chronic renal insufficiency and tertiary hyperparathyroidism.
She underwent minimal parathyroidectomy and the pathological examination
showed adenomatous hyperplasia of the parathyroid glands. However, she
continued to have hypercalcemia, high PTH, and high Cr levels. Later,
subtotal parathyroidectomy was performed in March 2013. In 2019, the patient
visited our hospital as she was suffering from gastrointestinal bleeding.
Her gastroscopy report revealed multiple ulcers in the gastroduodenum. The
pathological examination suggested neuroendocrine neoplasia with CgA
(++ ), syn (+), and ki-67
(<2%). She had a high gastrin-17 level but a normal insulin
release index. Abdominal CT revealed left adrenal adenoma and multiple
pancreatic tumors, which led to a high suspicion of gastrinoma. MRI revealed
the presence of a 2.0×2.5×2.5 cm large pituitary adenoma,
which was presumed to be a prolactinoma due to hyperprolactinemia. A MEN1
diagnosis was established because she had three MEN1-associated tumors
([Table 1]). An operation was not
performed as she was prone to high risk due to surgery. Instead, she
received a proton pump inhibitor, somatostatin, bromocriptine, and
hemodialysis treatment. Her father died at a young age due to
gastrointestinal bleeding. Her sister suffered from kidney stones and had
pituitary tumor resection. However, her sister declined any further
examination; it is unknown whether she had MEN1-related diseases.
MEN1and CDKN1B gene variant analysis
Genomic DNA was extracted from peripheral blood leukocytes as well as the
parathyroid and thymic tumoral tissues using standard phenol-chloroform
procedures. All exons and adjacent exon-intron sequences of the MEN1
gene (NM_130799.2) and the CDKN1B gene (NM_004064.4) were amplified
by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using the primers listed in (Table
1S). Direct sequencing of PCR products on an ABI 3730xl automated
sequencer helped in identifying the variants (Applied Biosystems, USA).
American College of Medical Genetics (ACMG) standards were used to interpret
the variants [9]. The variants were
categorized as pathogenic, likely pathogenic, variants of uncertain
significance (VUS), likely benign, or benign.
Whole exome sequencing
Because only a splice variant was found in patient #3 by Sanger sequencing
and the splice variant was not located in the first or second positions of
the splice acceptor sequence, whole exome sequencing was carried out to
exclude other genes associated with MEN1. The isolated DNA was sheared on a
Bioruptor UCD-200 (Diagenode) with a size distribution peak around 200 bp.
The KAPA Library Preparation Kit (Kapa Biosystems, KR0453) was used to
prepare the DNA libraries. Agilent SureSelectXT2 Target Enrichment
System’s guidelines were followed for the removal of non-hybridized
library molecules as well as for the hybridization of pooled libraries to
the capture probes. Illumina specifications were followed for sequencing,
sample dilution, and flow cell loading. DNA libraries were sequenced on the
HiSeq 2500 (Illumina, San Diego, CA, USA) platform as paired-end 200-bp
reads. The BWA Aligner was used to filter and align the raw data (hg19)
(http://bio-bwa.sourceforge.net/). We estimated the
causative variant to be missense, gene-disrupting, and a rare occurrence
with less than 1% frequency in the 1000 Genomes
(http://browser.1000genomes.org), Exome Aggregation
Consortium (ExAC, http://exac.broadinstitute.org/),
and Genome Aggregation Database (gnomAD,
http://gnomad.broadinstitute.org/). The potential
effects of the variants were then assessed using SIFT
(http://sift.jcvi.org), Polyphen-2
(http://genetics.bwh.harvard.edu/pph2/),
Mutation Taster (http://www.mutationtaster.org/),
Phylop, phastCons
(http://compgen.bscb.cornell.edu/phast/),
and Human Splicing Finder (http://
www.umd.be/HSF/) software.
Total RNA preparation and MEN1 cDNA analysis
To determine the effect of this splice variant on the mRNA level, a high
purity Ribonucleic acid (RNA) Isolation Kit (Omega, USA) was used to isolate
total RNA from the parathyroid tumor tissues of patient #3. The isolated RNA
was reverse transcribed using the cDNA synthesis kit (ToYoBo, Japan).
Primers were chosen that could amplify MEN1 cDNA,
5′-CTTCCATTGACCTGCACACC-3′ and 5′-
CAGCCAGGTACATGTAGGGG-3′, and a 249-bp fragment was amplified. The
fragments were sequenced using the ABI 3730xl automated sequencer (Applied
Biosystems, USA).
Immunohistochemistry
Sections of parathyroid tumor were collected from MEN1 patient #1, patient
#2, and patient #3. Samples from patients with parathyroid hyperplasia
without MEN1 variants were employed as positive controls. Menin
expression in the resected tumor specimens was analyzed by
immunohistochemistry using the C-terminal anti-menin antibody (rabbit no.
ab92443, 1:150, Abcam, Cambridge, UK).
Results
MEN1 germline variant analysis
Patient #1 showed a heterozygous insertion variant, c.564delC
(p.N189Mfs*35), in exon 3 of the MEN1 gene ([Fig. 1a]). This variant was predicted to
generate a truncated protein and a premature termination codon in exon 4.
Co-segregated analysis confirmed that this variant was also found in her mother,
who had the MEN1 phenotype. According to the ACMG guidelines, this variant was
interpreted as pathogenic.
Fig. 1 Sanger sequencing chromatograms for the MEN1
germline mutations. The arrow indicates the mutation site. a A
heterozygous c.564delC mutation was identified in patient #1. b A
heterozygous c.1268G>A mutation was identified in patient #2.
c A heterozygous IVS5+5delG mutation was identified
in patient #3. d A heterozygous c.1546_1547insC mutation was
identified in patient #4.
Patient #2 showed a heterozygous nonsense variant, c.1268G>A (p.W423X),
in exon 9 of the MEN1 gene ([Fig.
1b]). This variant was predicted to change the amino acid glutamine at
position 423 to a stop codon in exon 9 and has been reported as pathogenic [10]. Co-segregated analysis showed her
father also had this variant, but he declined any further examination; it is
unknown whether he had MEN1-related diseases. According to the ACMG guidelines,
variant c.1268G>A in the MEN1 gene was interpreted as
pathogenic.
Patient #3 showed a heterozygous variant, c.824+5delG
(IVS5+5delG), in intron 5 of MEN1 ([Fig. 1c]) with Sanger sequencing. Whole
exome sequencing confirmed this variant. Co-segregated analysis showed this
variant did not exist in his parents. According to the ACMG guidelines, variant
IVS5+5delG in the MEN1 gene was interpreted as VUS. Meanwhile,
patient #3 showed a heterozygous polymorphism, c.1621G>A (p.A541T), in
exon 10 of the MEN1 gene. His father and sister had homozygous and
heterozygous c.1621G>A polymorphisms, respectively. No MEN1-related
tumors were found in his parents and sister.
Patient #4 showed a heterozygous variant, c.1546_1547insC (p.R516Pfs*15),
in exon 10 of the MEN1 gene ([Fig.
1d]). This variant might generate a truncated protein. According to
the ACMG guidelines, variant c.1546_1547insC was interpreted as pathogenic. The
IVS5+5delG and c.564delC variants were not found in 100 ethnically
matched controls. Database searches of HGMD
(http://www.hgmd.cf.ac.uk/), dbSNP
(http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/snp), and ClinVar
(http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar) indicated that
they were novel variants.
MEN1 tumor somatic variants analysis
In one of the parathyroid tumoral tissue samples from patient #1, we identified a
heterozygous c.564delC germline variant and a novel heterozygous somatic
c.249_252delGTCT (p.I85Sfs*33) MEN1 variant ([Fig. 2a]). The c.249_252delGTCT variant
might generate a truncated protein and a premature termination codon in exon 2.
LOH of the MEN1 locus c.564delC was detected in another two parathyroid
tumoral tissue samples ([Fig. 2b]).
Fig. 2 Sanger sequencing chromatograms of the MEN1 somatic
mutations in the surgically resected tissue samples. The arrow indicates
the mutation site. a A heterozygous c.249_252delGTCT mutation was
identified in one of the parathyroid tissues from patient #1. b
LOH of the MEN1 c.564delC mutations was detected in another two
parathyroid tissue samples from patient #1. c A heterozygous
c.313_314insC mutation was detected in the thymoma of patient #3. D: LOH
of MEN1 IVS5+5delG mutations was identified in all the
parathyroid tissues from patient #3.
In the thymoma specimen from patient #3, we identified a heterozygous
IVS5+5delG germline variant and a novel heterozygous somatic MEN1
variant, c.313_314insC (p.L105Pfs*12) ([Fig. 2c]). The c.313_314insC somatic variant might generate a
truncated protein and a premature termination codon in exon 2. In addition, the
LOH of MEN1 IVS5+5delG was identified in all parathyroid tumoral
tissue samples from patient #3 ([Fig.
2d]).
Analysis of MEN1 IVS5+5delG in silico and in vitro
The IVS5+5delG variants were predicted to be
“disease-causing,” with Phylop values of 3.654. The variant
sites were predicted and conserved with phastCons with a value of 0.99.
Additionally, Human Splicing Finder indicated this variant was the most likely
to occur.
We performed RT-PCR for MEN1 cDNA to confirm the presence of aberrant RNA
transcript splice products. Sequencing of the amplified RT-PCR products showed
the IVS5+5delG variant resulted in the skipping of exon 5 ([Fig. 3a, b]), which resulted in a
downstream stop codon with premature termination of translation.
Fig. 3 Sequence analysis of RT-PCR products for patient #3 showed
that IVS5+5delG mutation resulted in the skipping of exon 5 a
compared with normal control b.
CDKN1B gene variant analysis
No CDKN1B gene variants were found in any of the patients.
Immunohistochemistry
Menin nuclear staining in control patients with renal failure is shown in [Fig. 4a] along with reduced nuclear menin
expression in patient #1, patient #2, and patient #3 ([Fig. 4b–d]).
Fig. 4 Immunohistochemistry for menin. Parathyroid hyperplasia in
renal insufficiency without MEN1 mutation (a 20X).
Parathyroid adenoma from patient #1 (b 20X), patient #2 (c
20X), and patient #3 (d 20X).
Discussion
Menin is a nuclear protein with three nuclear localization signals (NLSs) located
in
its C-terminal region and has five putative GTPase sites [2]. In our study, we identified four
MEN1 germline variants (c.564delC, c.1268G>A, IVS5+5delG,
and c.1546_1547insC). Among them, c.564delC and c.1546_1547insC are frameshift
variants, which are predicted to result in truncated forms of menin. This leads to
partial or complete loss of the NLSs and results in loss of the ability to transfer
through the nuclear envelope [3]
[11]. The c.1546_1547insC variant has been
reported to be a potential mutational hotspot with a frequency of 2.7% in
MEN1 families [12]
[13]. The c.1268G>A variant was
previously reported in an Australian patient, who manifested lung and thymic
carcinoids, prolactinoma, non-functioning pituitary, insulinoma, and
hyperparathyroidism [10]. Considering the
young age of patient #2, close follow-up and further screening for additional
manifestations are recommended. In our study, the novel splice variant
IVS5+5delG resulted in the skipping of neighboring exons and the
introduction of premature translation stop codons. Interestingly, another
MEN1 variant IVS5+5G>A in the same locus was described as
likely pathogenic in the ClinVar database. In-silico analysis predicted it may
damage or destroy the natural donor site and lead to abnormal gene splicing, further
suggesting that the novel IVS5+5delG splice variant lies in a biologically
important region.
We identified another novel somatic variant, c.249_252delGTCT, and LOH of MEN1
locus c.564delC variants in the parathyroid tumoral tissues of patient #1.
Additionally, a novel somatic variant, c.313_314insC, and LOH of MEN1
IVS5+5delG were identified in the thymoma and parathyroid tumoral tissues of
patient #3, which might indicate the pathogenic role of these variants and support
the Knudson’s two-hit mechanism for MEN1 development. All the variants
identified in our study are likely to result in a truncated protein. Therefore, we
speculated that the menin protein was absent or the expression was reduced in the
tumor. Indeed, reduced menin immunostaining was observed in the parathyroid adenoma
tissues, which further supports our hypothesis. Owing to the small sample size of
our study, the true pathogenicity of the variations still needs to be confirmed with
a larger number of clinical cases. Further functional studies, such as animal models
or cell work, are also needed to provide more evidence.
The variant p.Ala541Thr is usually considered a polymorphism, with an allelic
frequency of 15% in the general population (Hap Map Database). The potential
pathogenicity of the p.Ala541Thr variant is still controversial [14]
[15]. Nozières et al [15] compared a series of 55 patients carrying
the p.Ala541Thr variant with a group of 117 MEN1 patients carrying other MEN1
variants and found the p.Ala541Thr variant may be involved in a low-penetrance MEN1
phenotype. Further functional studies on Men1
+
/Men
–
endocrine LCT10 cells showed that the overexpression of the p.Ala541Thr
variant did not inhibit cell growth, which is similar to the effect of mutant forms
of the menin protein. However, there were some limitations in the Nozières
study; for example, family information was limited in the p.Ala541Thr group, large
MEN1 deletions and other gene (CDNK1B/p27) variants were
not excluded, and their findings were mainly based on Caucasians [15]. In our study, patient #3’s father
and sister both carried this variant but did not show any clinical manifestation of
MEN1. Considering the high frequency of the p.Ala541Thr variant in Asiatic
populations (up to 30%) [15],
additional studies are needed to investigate whether it may be pathogenic.
MEN1 penetrance is reported to be 50%, above 95%, and almost
100% at the age 20, 40, and after 70, respectively [16]. The natural progression of MEN1 is long
and hence, it is difficult to diagnose the disorder during its early stages. In our
study, all four patients were diagnosed after the involvement of multiple glands,
which leads to an unfavorable prognosis. Two of the patients received
parathyroidectomy twice and one patient suffered from recurrent insulinoma even
after undergoing surgery three times. Studies showed that MEN1-associated primary
hyperparathyroidism usually involves two or more parathyroid glands, and occurs at
a
young age [17]
[18]. MEN1-associated insulinoma recurrence is
four times more common than recurrence in individuals without MEN1 10 years after
the first presentation [19]. Thymoma occurs
only in 2.0–8.4% of MEN1 patients. However, 22% and
89% of thymic carcinoid MEN1 patients experience synchronous and
metachronous distant metastasis, and the 10-year overall survival rate is only
45% [20]. In our study, the pathology
stage of thymoma was G2 in patient #3 even though he was asymptomatic. Additionally,
adjacent lymph node metastases were detected at the time of diagnosis, thus
indicating a poor prognosis. Considering the high morbidity and mortality in MEN1,
early clinical and genetic diagnosis of patients would help in effective disease
management.
In conclusion, we have evaluated the clinical and genetic characteristics of four
patients with MEN1 and identified four heterozygous MEN1 germline variants
(c.564delC, c.1268G>A, IVS5+5delG, and c.1546_1547insC) as well as
two novel somatic variants (c.249_252delGTCT and c.313_314insC). Early recognition
of the phenotype coupled with screening for the MEN1 gene is the key to early
diagnosis and treatment of MEN1.