Key words
Cushing's syndrome - remnant tissue - rest tissue - hypercortisolism - episodic - adrenalectomy
Introduction
Cushing’s Disease [CD, pituitary-dependent Cushing’s Syndrome (CS)]
is characterized by increased cortisol secretion from the adrenal glands due to
dysregulated secretion of ACTH by a corticotroph adenoma [1]
[2]. It
is a relatively rare disease with an estimated annual incidence of 2–3 new
cases per year per million [3] and primarily
affects women between the ages of 20 to 50 years [4]. Signs and symptoms of hypercortisolism include central obesity with
rapid weight gain, striae, hypertension, fatigue, and sleep disturbances [5]. The first line of treatment is
transsphenoidal pituitary surgery, with remission rates ranging from 42% to
97% (median=78%) when done by an experienced neurosurgeon
[6]. If the surgery is unsuccessful or CD
recurs, second-line therapeutic options include repeat transsphenoidal surgery,
medical treatment, radiation, or bilateral adrenalectomy (BLA) [7]. BLA is usually used after transsphenoidal
surgery has failed and the patient’s hypercortisolism cannot be resolved
with medical treatment. The disadvantages of BLA include the need for lifelong
glucocorticoid and mineralocorticoid replacement and the risk of the subsequent
development of adrenal crisis or Nelson’s syndrome (pituitary corticotroph
enlargement leading to hyperpigmentation following BLA) [8]
[9].
Endogenous cortisol production should cease following BLA, but there have been
several case reports of hypercortisolism and CD recurrence following this procedure
[10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15], although the rate of
recurrence is poorly characterized in the literature. Cortisol production following
complete BLA can come from one of two sources. One source, adrenal remnant tissue,
is adrenal tissue (often microscopic) left behind following surgery that continues
to secrete cortisol either immediately after surgery or following a period of
regeneration often driven by high ACTH levels. The second potential source, adrenal
rest tissue, is adrenal tissue that arises ectopically that can be from an accessory
adrenal gland that are developmental anomalies that occur when a small fragment
breaks off from the parent adrenal gland during intrauterine life, and usually
atrophy with age [16]
[17]. ACTH controls adrenal gland development
[18], regeneration [19], the differentiation of cells into a zona
fasciculata phenotype that produces cortisol [20], and cortisol synthesis and secretion [1]. Consistent with this, the ability of
adrenal remnant tissue, adrenal rest tissue, and accessory adrenal glands to grow
and upregulate cortisol secretion under ACTH secretion following adrenal gland
removal has been demonstrated in numerous animal and human studies [21]
[22]
[23]
[24]
[25].
The rate of adrenal remnant/rest tissue appears to be more common in
congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) [26],
possibly due to the high ACTH associated with the condition. One early report by
Kemink et al. [11] evaluated 37 CD patients
who had BLA surgery performed between 1962 and 1988; many of the surgeries were
performed before 1980 when BLA was the first-line treatment for CD. The authors
found that 9 patients (24%) continued having endogenous cortisol secretion
and one patient (3%) had a recurrence in the symptoms and signs of CS [11]. Later, in a review article on BLA outcomes
following CS, Ritzel et al. [8] examined
PubMed articles published between 1980 and 2012 and noted five studies (containing
236 patients in total) that reported residual cortisol secretion after an operation.
From these studies, the authors concluded that accessory adrenal tissue or adrenal
remnant tissue was found in 3–34% of patients and less than
2% had a relapse of CS [8]. However,
another more recent report that examined 21 patients with BLA between 1970 and 2012
found a 14% CS recurrence rate [27].
Due to the heretofore small number of cases of adrenal remnant/rest tissue in
patients with CS, there have been few individual case studies and even fewer
publications that characterize and compare the management of a group of patients. In
1972, Siegal et al. [13] described four
patients who experienced a CS recurrence following BLA. Given that the management of
CS, imaging techniques, and both surgical and medical treatment options have changed
dramatically since this report was published, a more contemporary study is needed to
provide guidance on the detection and management of this condition. This article
describes the evaluation and treatment of 10 patients with CD who demonstrated
adrenal remnant or rest tissue following BLA surgery, 9 of whom had recurrent
hypercortisolism.
Subjects and Methods
The Institutional Review Board (IRB) of Charles R. Drew University of Medicine and
Science deemed that retrospective review of the collected data was exempt from
formal IRB review, in accordance with federal regulations (45CFR 46.101[b]).
The biochemical evaluation for patients with CS consisted of multiple measurements of
24-h urinary free cortisol (UFC) and 17-hydroxycorticosteroids, and measurements of
nighttime salivary and serum cortisol. Many of the patients were reported in our
prior publications [28]
[29]
[30].
All patients had persistent hypercortisolemia despite one or more transphenoidal
pituitary surgeries. All patients had complete BLAs performed laparoscopically
through a retroperitoneal approach, which is associated with similar outcomes as a
transperitoneal lateral approach [31]
[32], with 6 of the 10 patients having this
procedure performed by MC. The other four patients were operated by surgeons with
extensive experience with adrenal surgeries.
The 10 patients in this study were treated by the senior author (TCF) from
2006–2020. During this time, 51 patients seen by TCF underwent BLA. Six of
these patients developed adrenal remnant tissue following surgery, thus the
incidence or remnant/rest tissue following BLA can be estimated at
12% (6/51). These six patients are included in this study, and the
remaining four patients in the study (P1, P4, P5, and P7) were referred to TCF after
their adrenalectomy with subsequent suspicion of adrenal remnant tissue. The other
45 patients who underwent bilateral adrenalectomy were on stable, physiological
glucocorticoid replacement and did not report symptoms of hypercortisolism.
We measured morning serum cortisol, nighttime serum cortisol, nighttime salivary
cortisol, and 24-h UFC on at least three occasions for 10 patients suspected of
having endogenous cortisol production. Patients who could safely refrain from
glucocorticoid replacement (or were already off glucocorticoid replacement) for
testing were told to do so. Patients at risk of developing adrenal insufficiency
were given physiological dexamethasone replacement (0.5–1 mg per
day, which does not cross-react with cortisol assay) to avoid adrenal insufficiency
for 2–3 days prior to and during testing for endogenous cortisol
production. All hormones were measured by Esoterix Endocrinology
(Calabasas Hills, CA, USA). Salivary, plasma, and UFC were measured by HPLC MSMS
(high pressure liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometry detection) after
solvent extraction. For 0800 plasma cortisol measurement, the 95% tolerance
interval (normal range) as reported by Esoterix Endocrinology is
221–524 nmol/l, with an assay sensitivity of
27.6 nmol/l [33]. The range of
nighttime salivary is 0.3–2.5 nmol/l and the range of 24-h
UFC in women is 27.6–93.8 nmol/day. There was no
cross-reactivity in the cortisol assay with dexamethasone or fludrocortisone.
Results
Surgical results
The adrenals with capsules were removed en bloc and the pathology of all
patients showed enlarged adrenal glands with focal nodular cortical hyperplasia.
[Table 1] shows clinical data from 10
female patients who developed adrenal remnant or rest tissue following BLA. One
patient had rest tissue in her ovary in addition to remnant tissue in her
adrenal bed; the other nine patients had remnant tissue found or suspected in
their adrenal beds. None of the patients had accessory adrenal glands. Since
these patients had complete BLAs, their endogenous cortisol secretion should
have been undetectable when measured when on either dexamethasone or no cortisol
replacement. However, following surgery the patients had detectable cortisol
levels, confirming the presence of endogenous cortisol production, with 9
patients developing symptoms and signs of recurrent hypercortisolism.
Table 1 Data from patients with adrenal remnant or rest tissue
following bilateral adrenalectomy.
Initials
|
Remnant or rest tissue
|
Pituitary surgeries (n)
|
Time to recurrence (years)
|
Age at recurrence (years)
|
Glucocorticoid replacement (mg/d) at time adrenal
remnant or rest tissue suspected
|
Fludrocortisone replacement (mg/d) at time adrenal
remnant or rest tissue suspected
|
Imaging*
|
Treatment*
|
Medical treatment (mg/d)
|
P1
|
Remnant
|
2
|
2
|
25
|
5 (hydro)
|
–
|
CT/csPET MRI
|
EtOH
|
–
|
P2
|
Remnant suspected
|
1
|
3
|
19
|
0.6 (dex)
|
0.2
|
MRI
|
EtOH
|
100ke
|
P3
|
Remnant and rest
|
1
|
0
|
36
|
10 (hydro)
|
0.1
|
CT
|
4-Adrenal Surgeries, Surgery to remove ovarian mass
|
–
|
P4
|
Remnant suspected
|
1
|
3
|
42
|
2.5 (hydro)
|
0.1
|
CT
|
Adrenal Surgery
|
–
|
P5
|
Remnant suspected
|
3
|
3
|
38
|
–
|
–
|
NP59
|
Pituitary surgery with Gamma Knife
|
–
|
P6
|
Remnant
|
1
|
8
|
60
|
20 (hydro)
|
0.3
|
CT
|
Adrenal remnant surgery
|
–
|
P7
|
Remnant
|
1
|
3
|
40
|
20 (hydro)
|
0.1
|
CT
|
Adrenal remnant surgery
|
–
|
P8
|
Remnant
|
1
|
0
|
26
|
−
|
0.05
|
CT
|
2-Adrenal Surgery
|
1000mi/800ke
|
P9
|
Remnant
|
1
|
6
|
50
|
−
|
0.2
|
CT
|
RFA, Adrenal remnant surgery
|
–
|
P10
|
Remnant suspected
|
1
|
2
|
38
|
10 (hydro)
|
0.2
|
PET/CT
|
Adrenal remnant surgery
|
4500mi
|
*Bold text indicates successful
imaging/treatment. csPET: Cosyntropin-stimulated
18F-fluoro-2-deoxy-d-glucose positron emission
tomography/computed tomography; CT: CT scan; Dex: Dexamethasone;
EtOH: Ethanol ablation therapy; Hydro: Hydrocortisone; Keto:
Ketoconazole; mi: Mitotane; NP59: 131I-Labeled
6β-iodomethyl-19-norcholesterol; : No treatment; RFA:
Radiofrequency ablation.
Hormonal replacement
At the time recurrence was confirmed, only 3 patients (P6, P7, and P9) were
taking physiologically appropriate levels of glucocorticoid replacement. The
other patients had either greatly reduced or stopped replacement doses to
minimize their hypercortisolism symptoms. This was a key sign that endogenous
cortisol production was occurring. Three patients (P5, P8, and P9) were able to
stop their glucocorticoid replacement and did not develop symptoms associated
with adrenal insufficiency. P9 did require full glucocorticoid replacement
following adrenal remnant removal. In contrast, 8 patients were taking
physiologically appropriate levels of mineralocorticoid replacement at the time
of recurrence confirmation. This consisted of fludrocortisone replacement
titrated to achieve a sitting plasma renin activity in the normal range,
yielding daily dosing between 0.05 mg and 0.3 mg. Serum
potassium levels were normal in all patients. The remaining two patients did not
require fludrocortisone replacement. In one patient (P5), adrenal remnant tissue
was making sufficient amounts of both glucocorticoids and mineralocorticoids,
which was balanced by prior pituitary surgery and radiation. She did not need
exogenous glucocorticoid or mineralocorticoid replacement. Following adrenal
remnant removal, patient P9 appeared cured of her endogenous cortisol production
and required physiological glucocorticoid and mineralocorticoid replacement.
As shown in [Table 2], despite BLA
surgery, all 10 patients had detectable cortisol measurements, with 9 out of 10
patients having detectable cortisol measurements in at least two different types
of assessment. As can be seen in [Table
2], nighttime serum and salivary measurements were often much higher
than morning levels, suggesting a dysregulation in cortisol secretion from the
adrenal remnant tissue. This corresponded to several patients reporting symptoms
of hypercortisolism at night, including insomnia, without symptoms of adrenal
insufficiency in spite of subphysiological glucocorticoid replacement.
Table 2 Detection of exogenous glucocorticoid secretion
following bilateral adrenalectomy.
Initials
|
Glucocorticoid replacement at time of testing
|
Morning serum cortisol (nmol/l)
|
24-h UFC (nmol/d)
|
Night time salivary cortisol (nmol/l)
|
Midnight serum cortisol (nmol/l)
|
P1
|
Dexamethasone
|
BDL
|
BDL, 6.6
|
19.0
|
BDL
|
P2
|
Dexamethasone
|
91.0, 386
|
|
5.2, 19.0, 2.6, 4.1
|
|
P3
|
Dexamethasone
|
224
|
|
|
248, 304, 359
|
P4
|
Dexamethasone
|
91.0, 80.0, 66.2, 71.7, 88.3
|
16.8, 4.7
|
18.2, 5.0, 4.7, 3.0, 1.6
|
|
P5
|
Dexamethasone
|
607, 99.3, 141, 199
|
497
|
|
|
P6
|
No replacement
|
|
5.0
|
12.1, 19.0
|
|
P7
|
Dexamethasone
|
2.8
|
|
4.1, 0.8, 1.1, 1.4
|
|
P8
|
No replacement
|
|
BDL
|
|
364, 477
|
P9
|
No replacement
|
|
|
9.8
|
|
P10
|
Dexamethasone
|
38.6, 116, 135, 331
|
16.0
|
|
|
BDL: Below detectable limit.
DHEAS levels, measured in patients who are either not taking DHEA or withheld
DHEA for several days prior to testing, varied considerably. In six patients,
serum DHEAS levels were below the detection limit
(0.27 μmol/l), in two patients they were in the normal
range (<6.2 μmol/l), in one patient they were
elevated, and no measurement was performed for one patient.
Adrenal remnant tissue imaging
High-resolution CT scans was the primary means to localize adrenal remnant or
rest tissue; possible adrenal tissue was localized in all 8 patients. The
identified tissue was usually seen in the adrenal bed but was also found near
the aorta, just behind the adrenal artery (P3) and in the posterior upper
pancreas (P8). Although masses identified by CT were removed from all patients,
surgery directed at the lesions seen on imaging was only successful in three
patients (P6, P7, and P9). All other surgeries yielded tissue of negative
pathology that represented fat necrosis (P2, P3, and P4), benign lymph nodes
(P8), or ganglionic neural tissue (P10) with continued endogenous cortisol
secretion.
Both PET and MRI scans were used once, and the PET scan was not successful in
localizing the adrenal remnant tissue. In one patient (P3), abdominal imaging
showed an ovarian mass that was then removed. The pathology of the ovarian
tissue did not show adrenal tissue. Some of the patient’s
hypercortisolism-related symptoms improved following surgery, but she still
experienced endogenous cortisol secretion. Thus, it is likely she had both
adrenal rest tissue (ovary) and remnant tissue (adrenal bed). Only one patient
(P1) had adrenal remnant tissue identified using MRI, which was successfully
treated with ethanol ablation. CT-guided ethanol ablation (P1) and CT-guided
radio frequency ablation (P9) were each used on one occasion, with only the
ethanol ablation being successful [34].
[Figure 1a] shows the CT scan of patient
P1, showing adrenal remnant tissue measuring 11.2 mm by 4.5 mm.
[Figure 1b] shows a posterior
approach for ethanol ablation of the adrenal remnant tissue.
Fig. 1
a CT with contrast of adrenal remnant tissue measuring
11.2 mm by 4.5 mm. b CT posterior approach for
ethanol ablation of residual adrenal tissue.
Discussion
Adrenal remnant prevalence and comparison to literature
In the present study, we characterized 10 patients who were found to have
endogenous cortisol secretion following a BLA for CD that was not successfully
treated with pituitary surgery. All patients had complete BLA performed
laparoscopically via a retroperitoneal approach, but the development of adrenal
remnant or rest tissue probably occurred independent of this surgical technique.
Our 12% rate of adrenal remnant/rest tissue causing hypercortisolism was
similar to the 3–34% rate yielded by a literature review (5
studies, 236 patients) and the 2% rate who had a CS relapse, as reported
by Ritzel et al. [8] Our rate is in
agreement with a report by Morris et al. [27] who found recurrence in 3 of 21 (14%) patients who were
treated with steroidogenesis inhibitors and BLA for their ACTH-dependent CS.
Although their report was attributed to inexperience of the surgeon with the
particular BLA surgical technique used (i. e., posterior
retroperitoneoscopic adrenalectomy), the study obtained a similar rate of
recurrence of endogenous cortisol production as seen in the present study.
Patient characteristics
The most challenging aspect in both the diagnosis and treatment of patients was
the episodic and intermittent nature of cortisol secretion from adrenal remnant
tissue. This is consistent with our series in 2010 in which we found that 65 of
the 66 patients with CS had at least one normal test of cortisol status [35], a finding that was confirmed by others
[36]
[37]. Although 9 of 10 patients in our current series presented with
symptoms and signs of hypercortisolism such as weight gain (truncal and
generalized), anxiety with sleep disturbance, moon faces, tachycardia, buffalo
hump (sometimes painful), and striae, their morning serum cortisol levels were
often low and frequently below the measurable limit. Further complicating
diagnosis was the finding that these patients frequently also exhibited symptoms
of adrenal insufficiency such as morning/daytime fatigue (all patients)
and nausea with vomiting (P2, P3, P8, P9, and P10). Repeated measurements of
serum morning and nighttime cortisol, 24-h UFC, and nighttime salivary cortisol
measurements showed inappropriately normal or elevated cortisol secretion. Many
patients in this study had reversed circadian rhythm with relatively high
nighttime cortisol levels and low levels in the morning. As ACTH secretion of
the pituitary tumor may have been under regulation by dexamethasone, endogenous
cortisol might have been suppressed when testing was done on dexamethasone.
Thus, the detectable cortisol may have been higher if not on dexamethasone.
Imaging characteristics
Once the presence of endogenous cortisol secretion was confirmed, we used various
imaging techniques to localize the cortisol-secreting tissue, with use often
limited by availability or the patient’s health insurance. CT scans have
long been used in the imaging and diagnosis of adrenal causes of CS [38]
[39] and we used this imaging technique in 8 of the 10 patients to
localize their remnant tissue; possible adrenal remnant lesions in the adrenal
bed were found in 7 of 8 patients. Other imaging techniques reported for finding
such tissue include cosyntropin-stimulated
18F-fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose PET/CT
(18F-FDG-PET/CT) and 131I-labeled
6β-iodomethyl-19-norcholesterol (NP59) scans.
18F-FDG-PET/CT scans use radiolabeled glucose molecules as a
marker for tissue that has increased levels of glycolysis. This technique is
primarily used to detect malignancies [40]
[41], but can also be used
to detect metabolically active adrenal tissue [42]. In previous case reports, 18F-FDG-PET/CT
successfully localized adrenal rest tissue in a patient with CAH [43] and in a patient with Nelson’s
syndrome with persistent hypercortisolism [44]. In the present study, in patient (P2), we used a
18F-FDG-PET/CT scan to visualize potential adrenal remnant
tissue after it was clearly visualized on a CT scan. Her
18F-FDG-PET/CT scan gave only a faint signal at that
location, suggesting that the tissue seen on CT scan probably was not remnant
tissue, and destruction of this tissue via ethanol ablation would not relieve
symptoms. NP59 scanning uses a radiolabeled cholesterol that is a precursor of
cortisol and tracks its uptake in steroidogenic tissue [45]
[46]. Before it became unavailable in the United States, it was used
in patient P5, but scanning was unable to localize any potential
cortisol-producing tissue. New imaging modalities including Metomidate
PET/CT [47] and
[68Ga]-DOTATATE PET/CT [48] have the potential to localize adrenal remnant/rest
tissues.
Adrenal remnant treatment
Adrenal remnant or rest tissue, if found, can be treated by a variety of
procedures. Six patients underwent exploratory surgery in order to find and
remove the aberrant tissue found on CT scan. However, in only two patients (P6
and P7) did this lead to a successful surgical outcome, with resolution of
endogenous cortisol secretion and hypercortisolism symptoms and subsequent
return to normal glucocorticoid replacement. For the other patients (P3, P4, and
P8), aberrant tissue was removed, but adrenal tissue was not seen on pathology,
of which the pathology usually showed fat tissue. Two patients (P1 and P5) did
not need to undergo surgery to remove potential adrenal remnant or rest tissue,
with patient P1 having successful ethanol ablation and patient P5 having normal
cortisol secretion due to her prior pituitary surgery/radiation.
As an alternative to exploratory surgery, other techniques can be used to
eliminate pathological tissue. Ethanol ablation therapy is performed by placing
several small (19–22 gauge) needles under the guidance of CT, real-time
CT fluoroscopy or ultrasound, and injecting ethanol into the target tissue [49]
[50]. This causes protein denaturation leading to coagulative necrosis
and thrombosis of small vessels. This procedure was successfully performed on
one patient in this study (P1) [34] ([Fig. 1]) but was unsuccessful in another
patient (P2). Another technique is radiofrequency ablation [51], in which electrodes are placed inside
the target tissue and heated with high intensity radio waves, which leads to
tissue destruction in a manner analogous to ethanol ablation [52]. This procedure was previously done on
both adrenal beds in a patient with CS [53] and was performed on one of the patients in this study (P9),
leading to short-term resolution of hypercortisolism symptoms, which later
recurred. Additionally, pituitary surgery or radiation can be used to decrease
ACTH secretion, especially if a lesion is identified on pituitary imaging. All
of our patients underwent periodic pituitary imaging with no lesions seen, so
pituitary surgery or radiation were not performed.
While waiting to undergo surgery, or as an alternative to surgery, several drugs
can be used to treat CS [54]
[55]. Ketoconazole is a synthetic imidazole
that was once widely used as an antifungal agent. Soon after its introduction,
it was discovered that in addition to blocking fungal cytochrome P450
14α-demethylase (CYP51A1), ketoconazole blocks many human P450 enzymes
to lower steroid production [56] and was
found to be a human glucocorticoid receptors antagonist [57]
[58]. Patients using ketoconazole for CS typically need to take 400 to
1 600 mg daily for effective treatment [54]
[59]. Mitotane (o,p′-DDD; Lysodren) is another
drug that can be used in the medical treatment of CS. In addition to blocking
multiple cytochrome P450 enzymes to inhibit steroidogenesis, it is cytolytic and
chronic administration can lead to adrenal atrophy [60], making it, in theory, an ideal drug to
use with patients who have adrenal remnant or rest tissue. However, because of
its side effects, especially severe nausea, mitotane is primarily used in the
treatment of adrenal carcinomas [61], but
doses up to 4 g per day have been used to treat CS [62]. Several patients in the current series
tried mitotane, but could not tolerate it due to side effects.
Limitations
There are several limitations to this study, including the limitations inherent
in a retrospective study and the heterogeneous cases that varied with clinical
scenario. Patients underwent surgery by different surgeons. It is possible, but
unlikely, that surgical expertise led to incomplete BLA with subsequent remnant
formation. Although data were collected from all patients for morning serum
cortisol, nighttime serum cortisol, nighttime salivary cortisol, and 24-h UFC,
the tests were completed to varying degrees and had different positive values
showing detectable cortisol levels that would have been more standardized had
the study been done prospectively. NP-59 scanning, the test most likely to
identify adrenal remnant tissue, is no longer available in the United States.
Imaging techniques that could have detected the remnant tissue may not have been
used due to lack of availability or insurance issues. There may be a selection
bias since patients were referred to or treated by TCF accounting for a higher
prevalence than would be found in the population. It is also possible that we
underestimated the rate of adrenal remnant development as some patients with
endogenous cortisol production may not have had symptoms of excess cortisol
secretion and may not have sought medical attention. One of the cases was
published in the September 2011 [[63].
Conclusion
Our series showed adrenal remnant tissue occurring in about 12% of patients
who had BLA. This compares to the 21% mean incidence of Nelson’s
syndrome following BLA in a review of 24 studies with 768 patients [8]. None of our patients who underwent BLA
developed Nelson’s syndrome. Thus, an examination for both adrenal remnant
tissue development and Nelson’s syndrome should occur following BLA.
The first indication of remnant tissue occurrence is a reduction in glucocorticoid
replacement with symptoms of hypercortisolism. If this occurs, endogenous cortisol
production should be tested for by cortisol measurements using a highly specific and
sensitive assay while the patient is on dexamethasone or no glucocorticoid
replacement. Localization of adrenal remnant tissue was found to be difficult, with
a lack of specificity of imaging techniques such as high-resolution CT scans. If a
lesion is found, it can be removed by surgery, ethanol ablation, or radiofrequency
ablation, although the success of these procedures is limited. Our retrospective
study should be followed up by a large prospective study from centers that perform a
large volume of BLAs for patients with CD to determine adrenal remnant recurrence
rates, optimization of localization techniques, and treatment modalities.