Keywords polyploidy - liver regeneration - liver injury - liver repopulation - ploidy conveyor
Hepatocytes, the primary functional cells of the liver, are characterized by variations
in nuclear content. Most hepatocytes have single pairs of each chromosome (diploid
hepatocytes), but many have extra chromosome sets (polyploid hepatocytes). The function
of diploid and polyploid hepatocytes is poorly understood. However, recent work demonstrated
that both diploid and polyploid hepatocytes contribute to liver growth and regeneration,
but diploids are capable of accelerated growth. Thus, diploid hepatocytes play a dominant
role in liver maintenance (as they replace aging cells), replacement of damaged hepatocytes
after injury, and even in the development of liver cancer. Deciphering how diploid
and polyploid hepatocytes are regulated and function is essential for developing new
therapies for liver disease treatment.
Chromosome Variations in the Liver
Chromosome Variations in the Liver
Cellular ploidy refers to the number of complete chromosome sets in a cell. Most mammalian
cells are diploid and contain homologous pairs of each chromosome, but there are also
cells with higher chromosomal content. Polyploid cells have increased sets of chromosomes
beyond the diploid state. In humans, diploid cells (2n) have 23 chromosome pairs for
a total of 46 chromosomes, while polyploid cells can have 92 (4n, tetraploid), 184
(8n, octaploid), or even greater numbers of chromosomes. Polyploidy is frequently
associated with genomic instability and cancer but is also found in healthy mammalian
tissues, including cardiac myocytes, megakaryocytes, giant trophoblasts, skeletal
muscles, and hepatocytes.[1 ]
[2 ]
[3 ] Polyploidy is distinct from numerical aneuploidy, where a cell loses or gains individual
chromosomes (2n ± 1). Whole-organism aneuploidy is typically detrimental, impairing
development and function, but somatic aneuploidy is more complex. While aneuploidy
is considered a hallmark of cancer, there are exceptions.[4 ]
[5 ]
[6 ] For example, aneuploidy is associated with tumor suppression in fibroblasts from
individuals with Down's Syndrome through reduced proliferation.[6 ]
[7 ] Thus, the consequences of polyploidy and aneuploidy depend on the mechanism of formation
and tissue type.
Hepatocytes are characterized by remarkable chromosomal variations that include polyploidy
and aneuploidy. Polyploidy was recognized in the liver over a century ago, and hepatocytes
have since emerged as some of the best-characterized mammalian polyploid cells.[8 ] The liver is highly polyploid, with polyploid hepatocytes comprising more than 90%
of the hepatocyte population in adult mice and 25 to 50% in humans.[9 ]
[10 ] Numerical aneuploidy is also observed in liver tissue, where 5 to 50% of hepatocytes
are aneuploid, depending on how aneuploidy is measured, in healthy mouse and human
liver tissues.[11 ]
[12 ] Notably, this hepatic aneuploidy randomly affects all chromosomes, generating a
genetically diverse population.[12 ] Chromosomal variations have a wide-ranging impact on hepatocyte identity and function.[12 ]
[13 ] Several recent and extensive reviews describe the mechanisms of hepatic polyploidy
and the functions of ploidy populations in homeostasis and disease.[14 ]
[15 ] This review will focus primarily on the distinct roles of diploid and polyploid
hepatocytes during homeostasis and regeneration.
Mechanisms of Hepatocyte Control
Mechanisms of Hepatocyte Control
The Ploidy Conveyor
Hepatic polyploidy is classified by the DNA content per nucleus (nuclear ploidy) and
the number of nuclei per cell (cellular ploidy).[15 ] For example, a tetraploid cell could have a single 4n nucleus or two 2n nuclei ([Fig. 1 ]). Polyploidization occurs by several cellular mechanisms, including endoreplication,
mitotic slippage, and cellular fusion, but physiological polyploidization of hepatocytes
predominately occurs by acytokinetic mitosis.[15 ]
[16 ]
[17 ] Hepatocytes are exclusively diploid at birth and undergo gradual physiological polyploidization
during postnatal development. First, a subset of proliferating diploid hepatocytes
fail to complete cytokinesis, producing binucleate tetraploid daughter cells.[18 ]
[19 ] Second, both the mono- and binucleate subsets of hepatocytes will continue to undergo
DNA replication and mitosis, either with complete cytokinesis (generating mononucleate
diploid or polyploid cells) or with acytokinetic mitosis (generating binucleate polyploid
cells). This way, diploid, tetraploid, octaploid, and even higher ploidy state hepatocytes
are produced, with polyploid hepatocytes existing in mononucleate and binucleate forms.
Hepatic polyploidy is also reversible, where polyploid hepatocytes produce daughter
cells with one-half ploidy that can subsequently re-polyploidize.[9 ]
[20 ] The process of hepatic polyploidization, ploidy reversal, and re-polyploidization
is described as the “ploidy conveyor” ([Fig. 1 ]).[9 ]
[21 ]
Fig. 1 The ploidy conveyor model of hepatocytes. Diploid hepatocytes are mononucleate with
a single 2n nucleus. Polyploid hepatocytes can be mono- or binucleate, where tetraploids
have a pair of 2n nuclei or a single 4n nucleus, octaploids have a pair of 4n nuclei
or a single 8n nucleus, and so on. The ploidy conveyor model incorporates hepatic
ploidy flexibility as hepatocytes proliferate. Acytokinetic cell division increases
hepatic ploidy (physiological polyploidization), while multipolar cell division reduces
hepatic ploidy (ploidy reversal).
Physiological Polyploidization and Ploidy Reversal
Hepatic polyploidization begins during postnatal development, coinciding with the
weaning phase in rodents.[22 ] This period is characterized by significant shifts in feeding patterns, alterations
in hormone levels, and changes in metabolic pathways that impact key polyploidization
regulators. For example, insulin signaling changes dramatically during weaning and
is a key factor in generating binucleate hepatocytes.[23 ] In rats, impaired insulin signaling reduced the formation of binucleate tetraploid
hepatocytes, while increasing insulin increased the formation of tetraploid hepatocytes.[22 ]
[23 ] The cellular effects of insulin are mediated by the PI3K/AKT pathway, which antagonize
RHOA and negatively regulate actin cytoskeleton polarization ([Fig. 2A ]). Also, highly expressed during postnatal development, E2F7 and E2F8 are transcription
factors influencing polyploidization through cell cycle regulation. Specifically,
E2F7 and E2F8 antagonize E2F1 and negatively regulate cytokinesis genes; thus, loss
of E2F7 and E2F8 promotes successful cytokinesis of proliferating diploid hepatocytes.[24 ]
[25 ] Mice with a liver-specific double knockout of E2f7 and E2f8 have livers that exhibit normal function through 6 to 9 months but are significantly
depleted of binucleate and polyploid hepatocytes.[24 ]
[25 ]
[26 ]
[27 ] MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are another regulator of hepatocyte polyploidization. miR-122
is the most abundant miRNA in adult livers, with expression in mice spiking during
postnatal development. miR-122 affects polyploidization by negatively regulating procytokinesis
genes (RhoA , Mapre1 , and Iqgap1 ), which impairs the formation of the centralspindlin complex and inhibits cytokinesis.[28 ]
[29 ]
Mir122 knockout mice are significantly depleted of polyploid hepatocytes.[29 ] Hepatocyte polyploidization is also regulated by the PIDDosome complex. The PIDDosome
is a multiprotein complex activated by extra centrosomes in polyploid cells that induces
p21 and restricts proliferation and hyperpolyploidization.[14 ]
[30 ]
[31 ]
[32 ] The absence of the PIDDosome leads to unrestrained polyploidization and hyperpolyploidy,
interestingly contributing to tumor resistance.[32 ] Finally, several other genes have been associated with altered cell cycle regulation
and changes in hepatocyte ploidy (FoxO3 , Cdk1 , etc.), but their roles in liver polyploidization are poorly defined.[33 ]
[34 ]
Fig. 2 Mechanisms of hepatic polyploidization and ploidy reversal. (A ) Physiological polyploidization begins when a hepatocyte completes a cell cycle without
cytokinesis, generating a binucleate cell. The formation of a binucleate tetraploid
hepatocyte by a diploid hepatocyte is shown. This process is regulated by multiple
networks, including insulin, miR-122, and E2F7/E2F8 that disrupt contractile ring
formation, furrow ingression, and abscission. For example, RHOA, which promotes cleavage
furrow ingression, is inhibited by insulin and miR-122. Similarly, miR-122 and E2F7/E2F8
inhibit the centralspindlin complex (comprised of ECT2, RACGAP1, and KIF23) that regulates
cleavage furrow ingression and abscission. Once formed, polyploid hepatocytes have
supernumerary centrosomes. Supernumerary centrosomes activate the PIDDosome, resulting
in p21 expression and attenuating hyperpolyploidization and proliferation. (B ) Ploidy reversal occurs when a polyploid hepatocyte undergoes multipolar mitosis
to generate daughter cells with reduced nuclear content. In the example shown, a tetraploid
hepatocyte (mononucleate or binucleate) progresses through the cell cycle with a bipolar
mitosis to generate two tetraploid nuclei. Successful cytokinesis produces two mononucleate
tetraploid hepatocytes, while cytokinesis failure generates a single binucleate octaploid.
In contrast, multipolar mitosis (three-way nuclear segregation is shown, but four-way
segregation is possible) generates three nuclei. Successful cytokinesis produces two
diploid (or near-diploid) hepatocytes and a mononucleate tetraploid (or near-tetraploid)
hepatocyte. Cytokinesis failure produces one or more polyploid hepatocytes. Signals
that control hepatic multipolar cell division are poorly described. (C ) Pathological polyploidy occurs by altered cell cycling when a hepatocyte alternates
between the growth phase (G) and DNA synthesis (S) without mitosis. Signals regulating
pathological polyploidy are poorly defined. However, oxidative stress-induced DNA
damage can inhibit the CyclinB1/CDK1 complex and block mitosis entry, leading to successive
rounds of G and S phases, forming mononucleate hepatocytes with highly polyploid nuclei.
Multiple overlapping pathways define the networks regulating polyploidy. For instance,
the actin cytoskeleton (specifically RHOA) is destabilized by insulin and miR-122
activity.[29 ]
[35 ] The centralspindlin complex, necessary for cytokinesis, is inhibited by miR-122
and E2F7/E2F8 signaling.[24 ]
[29 ] Similarly, the expression of PIDDosome complex members, Pidd1 and Casp2 , is negatively regulated by E2F7 and E2F8.[36 ]
In contrast to physiological polyploidy, the signals regulating ploidy reversal are
poorly defined.[9 ]
[17 ]
[20 ] Polyploid hepatocytes have extra centrosomes and form multipolar mitotic spindles
early in mitosis. Centrosomes typically cluster to produce bipolar mitosis with two-way
nuclear segregation. However, in some cases, the multipolar spindle persists, leading
to multipolar cell division and the generation of daughter cells with one-half DNA
content. For example, multipolar cell division by a tetraploid hepatocyte can form
more than two nuclei, including those with diploid or near-diploid content, and successful
cytokinesis generates diploid daughter hepatocytes ([Fig. 2B ]).
In summary, hepatocyte ploidy is incredibly dynamic. Physiological polyploidization
primarily occurs through acytokinetic mitosis regulated by a complex network, including
E2F family members, miR-122, and PIDDosome signaling. Ploidy reversal occurs by multipolar
cell division of a polyploid hepatocyte, leading to the birth of diploid hepatocytes.
The integration of physiological polyploidization and ploidy reversal is discussed
below.
Pathological Polyploidization
An excessive accumulation of hepatic polyploidy has been linked to metabolic and oxidative
stress. Mouse models of nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) and patients with
nonalcoholic steatohepatitis exhibit increased levels of polyploid hepatocytes and
significant enrichment in mononucleate cells with high nuclear content.[35 ] This distinctive ploidy distribution, termed pathological polyploidy , contrasts with physiological polyploidization that occurs during postnatal development.
Oxidative damage is the primary driver of ploidy alterations in NAFLD. Hepatic oxidative
damage results in a DNA damage response and inhibition of the CyclinB1/CDK1 complex,
which is necessary for mitosis entry ([Fig. 2C ]). As a result, hepatocytes undergo atypical cell cycles where they replicate DNA,
transiently arrest in G2, skip mitosis, and then re-enter the cell cycle. This cycle
repeats, causing mononucleate polyploid hepatocytes to become even more polyploid.
The function of these highly polyploid hepatocytes is uncertain, and further investigation
is needed to establish whether they contribute to disease progression or resistance.[37 ]
Ploidy and Liver Function
Ploidy and Liver Function
Spatial Organization
In addition to their nuclear heterogeneity, hepatocytes have diverse functions. The
liver is organized into repeating hexagonal liver lobules divided into three zones
based on their orientation around the vessels.[38 ]
[39 ]
[40 ]
[41 ] Blood enters the tissue via the portal tract (periportal region = zone 1), flows
through the liver sinusoids in the midzone region (zone 2), and drains into the central
vein (pericentral region = zone 3), creating a gradient of oxygen, nutrients, and
hormones that allows hepatocytes in different zones to have unique gene expression
patterns and functions. For example, hepatocytes in the oxygen and nutrient-rich environment
of zone 1 perform metabolic functions like beta-oxidation, gluconeogenesis, urea and
protein synthesis, and lipid metabolism. Zone 2 serves as a primary source for new
hepatocytes during homeostasis and regeneration.[42 ] Finally, hepatocytes in zone 3 perform glycolysis, xenobiotic biotransformation
reactions, and glutamine synthesis.[42 ]
[43 ]
[44 ] Since the expression of many hepatocyte-specific genes is restricted to certain
zones, the spatial distribution of diploid and polyploid hepatocytes may provide clues
to their specialized functions.
Multiple studies have examined the distribution of ploidy populations within the liver
lobule, but the conclusions vary widely ([Table 1 ]). First, Tanami et al investigated the location of diploid and polyploid hepatocytes
within the liver lobule. The ploidy state was determined by chromosome counting with
DNA fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) along with membrane staining to distinguish
mono- and binucleate cells. The location of each cell was determined based on the
proximity to the central vein. Rapid polyploidization was observed 3 to 4 weeks after
birth with enrichment of polyploids in the midlobule zone.[45 ] Second, Katsuda et al evaluated gene expression of zonal markers in rat hepatocytes
separated by ploidy and performed bulk microarray analysis and single-cell quantitative
reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (sc-qRT-PCR).[46 ]
[47 ] They found genes associated with zone 3 (Glul , Cyp7a1 , Slc1a2 ) were enriched in diploid hepatocytes. In contrast, zone 1 (Alb , G6pc , Tat ) genes were more highly expressed by polyploids, suggesting that diploid and polyploid
hepatocytes localize to pericentral and periportal areas, respectively. Third, ploidy
and zonation were investigated at the nuclear level using single-nuclear RNA-seq (snRNA-seq).
Three-month-old mouse hepatocytes were lysed, and nuclei were sorted based on the
DNA content. Sequencing revealed that nuclei with 4n content were enriched 1.3-fold
in the expression of zone 3 genes.[48 ] It is difficult to determine how nuclear expression patterns translate to hepatic
populations since 2n nuclei are found in diploid and binucleate tetraploid hepatocytes,
and 4n nuclei are found in mononucleate tetraploids and binucleate octaploid hepatocytes.
Fourth, evaluation of incomplete cytokinesis, a readout of polyploidization, among
hepatocytes in the periportal and pericentral regions of developing rat livers revealed
similar proportions of binucleate polyploid hepatocytes in both zone 1 and zone 3.[19 ] Next, Bou-Nader et al investigated the location of polyploids in human hepatic lobules
using a nuclear-intensity staining approach and found that polypoid hepatocytes are
equivalently distributed across all zones.[10 ] Finally, in a very recent study, Yang et al performed single-cell RNA-sequencing
(scRNA-seq) and snRNA-seq on mice developing prenatally and postnatally.[49 ] They found preferential expression of periportal (zone 1) genes by diploid hepatocytes,
suggesting the localization of diploids to the periportal region.
Table 1
Conflicting reports of the zonal distribution of diploid and polyploid hepatocytes
Report
Species
Age
Tissue Processing
Ploidy determination
Zonation determination
Finding
Tanami et al[45 ]
Mouse
2 mo
Liver sections (frozen)
Chromosome counting by DNA FISH and membrane staining
Proximity to Zone 3 (central vein)
Polyploid hepatocytes enriched in Zone 2
Katsuda et al[46 ]
Rat
5 to 14 wk
Hepatocytes isolated from digested liver
FACS-isolation of diploid, tetraploid, and octaploid hepatocytes
Expression of zonal genes using bulk microarrays and sc-qRT-PCR
Polyploid hepatocytes enriched in Zone 1; diploid hepatocytes enriched in Zone 3
Richter et al[48 ]
Mouse
3 mo
Nuclei from frozen liver
FACS-isolation of diploid and tetraploid nuclei
Expression of zonal genes using snRNA-seq
Tetraploid nuclei enriched in Zone 3
Margall-Ducos et al[19 ]
Rat
10 to 25 d
Tissue sections (FFPE)
Cytokinesis failure as a marker of polyploid hepatocytes during postnatal development
Proximity to Zone 1 (PEPCK1) and Zone 3 (GS)
Polyploid hepatocytes equally distributed across all zones
Bou-Nader et al[10 ]
Human
24-86 y
Liver sections (FFPE)
Nuclear measurements (diameter, intensity)
Proximity to Zone 3 (GS)
Polyploid hepatocytes equally distributed across all zones
Yang et al[49 ]
Mouse
Embryonic day 17.5 to 2 mo
Hepatocytes isolated from digested liver
FACS isolation of diploid, tetraploid, and octaploid hepatocytes; nuclei isolated
form sorted cells
Expression of zonal genes using scRNA-seq and in nuclei by snRNA-seq
Diploid hepatocytes enriched in Zone 1
Abbreviations: FACS, fluorescence-activated cell sorting; FFPE, formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded;
FISH, fluorescence in situ hybridization; GS, glutamine synthetase; sc-qRT-PCR, single-cell
quantitative reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction; scRNA-seq, single-cell
RNA sequencing; sn-RNAseq, single-nuclear RNA sequencing.
The abundance of contradictory data is striking and may be caused by differences in
the tissues examined and techniques used to determine ploidy and zonation. The inherent
variation in ploidy levels among species (mice, rats, and humans) introduces substantial
variation in overall ploidy levels and possibly ploidy distribution. The age-dependent
nature of ploidy, with cells exhibiting dynamic changes throughout postnatal development
and adulthood, represents a significant source of variability. Using various methodological
approaches, from nuclear intensity-based tissue assessments and DNA FISH to single-cell
and single-nuclear RNA-seq approaches, introduces unique biases. Studying the spatial
distribution is challenging, and it remains to be seen how diploid and polyploid hepatocytes
are definitively arranged with the liver. It is clear, however, that diploids and
polyploids reside in all zones, and further work is needed to fully understand the
spatial differences reported by others and whether such changes affect liver function.
To definitively resolve these issues, a multipronged approach may be necessary, including
(1) spatial transcriptomics to discern the precise lobule location and cellular activity
of hepatocytes; (2) identification of ploidy populations by nuclear fluorescence intensity
and chromosome counting by DNA FISH; and (3) discrimination between mononucleate and
binucleate hepatocytes with a membrane marker. This approach, allowing the simultaneous
detection of the geographic location and ploidy levels of all hepatocytes, could be
applied to multiple species during homeostasis and injury, facilitating a deeper understanding
of the roles played by diploid and polyploid hepatocytes.
Gene Expression
The hepatic ploidy state could affect gene expression in multiple ways. It has been
hypothesized that gene expression levels increase proportionally with ploidy.[17 ] Considering polyploid hepatocytes have increased DNA compared to diploids, it is
conceivable that there is a dose-dependent effect on gene expression, leading to increased
levels of gene expression and protein synthesis in polyploid cells. For example, a
tetraploid cell has twice the amount of DNA as a diploid; thus, tetraploid hepatocytes
may increase gene expression two-fold.[17 ] This dose-dependent effect has been observed in Arabidopsis , which contains diploid and tetraploid gametic cells, where the transcriptome of
tetraploid cells is doubled compared to diploids.[50 ] It is unclear how gene dosage impacts transcriptomics in mammalian cells, but recent
studies suggest that hepatocyte ploidy does not scale with gene expression. Yang et
al performed scRNA-seq and snRNA-seq of mouse hepatocytes and found equivalent expression
of mitochondrial and housekeeping genes by diploid and polyploid hepatocytes.[49 ] Similarly, using snRNA-seq, Richter et al found a 1.4-fold increase in the median
gene number in 4n nuclei (compared to 2n nuclei), less than the predicted two-fold
difference.[48 ] These findings suggest there are mechanisms to maintain gene dosage. One mechanism
may be the silencing of supernumerary chromosomes in polyploid cells. Regulation of
supernumerary chromosomes is known to occur in females, where the extra X chromosome
is inactivated, equalizing X chromosome transcript levels between females (XX) and
males (XY).[51 ] Intriguingly, in females with four X chromosomes, two are actively transcribed while
two are silenced.[52 ] Whether polyploid hepatocytes regulate gene dosage through similar or distinct mechanisms
remains unanswered.
Hepatic ploidy populations may exhibit varying gene expression patterns that confer
specialized functions, but there is little consistency in the literature. In 2007,
Lu et al compared gene expression of mouse diploid, tetraploid, and octaploid hepatocytes
by microarray analysis and found gene expression to be broadly equivalent between
ploidy populations.[53 ] This finding is supported by the results of bulk RNA-seq in a super-polyploid murine
model (transgenic Anln knockdown), which showed no differentially expressed genes compared to control samples.[54 ] This contrasts with more recent findings from Katsuda et al.[46 ]
[47 ] Gene expression of diploid and polyploid hepatocytes in rat hepatocytes was interrogated
by either bulk microarray analysis or sc-qRT-PCR using a custom panel of 47 genes.
They showed that diploid hepatocytes were enriched with genes associated with the
progenitor cell phenotype (Axin2 , Prom1 , and Lgr5 ). However, Richter et al identified equivalent expression of progenitor markers by
diploid and polyploid nuclei.[48 ] Studies by Matsumoto et al investigated the expression of genes related to aging
by bulk RNA-seq in sorted diploid and polyploid hepatocytes from both young and aged
murine livers.[55 ] They identified hundreds of differentially expressed genes, with common trends in
both age groups. Notably, genes related to immune response were consistently downregulated
in polyploids compared to diploids, while genes associated with mitochondrial function
were consistently upregulated in polyploid hepatocytes. This contrasts with observations
by Yang et al showing equivalent expression of mitochondrial genes by diploid and
polyploid hepatocytes.[49 ]
Conflicting data make it difficult to compile a comprehensive list of differentially
expressed genes by diploid and polyploid hepatocytes. These discrepancies may arise
from variations in tissue and experimental techniques, as discussed earlier. To determine
a comprehensive and definitive list, a meta-analysis of the gene expression profiles
reported by many groups is necessary to understand their contradictory findings and
to identify common expression patterns. Overall, the data suggest that distinct functions
may exist for ploidy populations, and additional research is necessary to determine
where transcriptional or translational output varies between diploid and polyploid
hepatocytes.
Ploidy and Regeneration
Ploidy and Proliferation
The liver has an incredible capacity for regeneration. Up to 90% of liver mass can
be lost, and the organ can regenerate to its original size and function.[56 ] Several ideas regarding the functional significance of polyploidy in hepatocyte
proliferation and regeneration exist. It was initially thought that polyploid hepatocytes
were terminally differentiated with little capacity for proliferation, but this idea
has been disproven.[17 ]
[57 ]
[58 ] Polyploid hepatocytes proliferate robustly after partial hepatectomy (PH), the surgical
removal of up to two-thirds of liver mass.[59 ] Moreover, extensive proliferation by polyploid hepatocytes has been observed in
vivo in liver repopulation studies using the FAH−/− model.[9 ]
[26 ]
[60 ]
[61 ]
Although diploid and polyploid hepatocytes are capable of proliferation, several studies
have demonstrated an increased proliferative capacity for diploid hepatocytes. First,
our group investigated repopulation capacity using competitive transplantation in
the FAH−/− model. To prevent changes in ploidy associated with the ploidy conveyor (i.e., polyploidization,
ploidy reversal, and re-polyploidization, [Fig. 1 ]), repopulation experiments were conducted with Ef7/E2f8 -deficient hepatocytes.[26 ]
E2f7 and E2f8 negatively regulate cytokinesis, and the deletion of E2f7 and E2f8 in the liver inhibits polyploidization, yielding livers where 80% of hepatocytes
are diploid and 20% are polyploid.[24 ]
[26 ] When E2f7/E2f8 -deficient hepatocytes (predominately diploid) and wild-type (WT) hepatocytes (predominately
polyploid) were cotransplanted into FAH−/− mice, E2f7/E2f8 -deficient hepatocytes consistently outperformed the WT hepatocytes, indicating a
robust proliferative advantage for stable diploid hepatocytes. Next, to mitigate the
potential off-target effect of E2f7/E2f8 deletion, proliferation by ploidy populations was monitored during PH-induced liver
regeneration in WT mice.[26 ] Hepatocytes were harvested over a time course after PH, and their ploidy and cell
cycle status were determined. Diploid hepatocytes entered and completed the cell cycle
faster than polyploid hepatocytes, which exhibited delayed cell cycle progression
([Fig. 3A ]). It is unclear why polyploid hepatocytes have restricted proliferation; one mechanism
may involve PIDDosome activation, leading to p21 expression and cell cycle arrest
([Fig. 2A ]).[36 ]
Fig. 3 Ploidy-influenced hepatocyte proliferation. (A ) Diploid and polyploid hepatocytes contribute to liver regeneration and repopulation.
In response to proliferative cues, diploid hepatocytes enter the cell cycle earlier
and progress through the cell cycle faster than polyploid hepatocytes, driving early
hepatocyte regeneration and repopulation. Polyploid hepatocytes enter the cell cycle
slowly, possibly due to PIDDosome/p21-mediated arrest, and can generate polyploid
daughters or diploid daughters via ploidy reversal. These diploid hepatocytes are
capable of rapid proliferation and re-polyploidization. (B ) Diploid and polyploid hepatocytes mediate hepatocyte replacement during normal aging
(homeostasis). Hepatocyte turnover occurs primarily by diploids, arising from preexisting
diploid hepatocytes or ploidy reversal by polyploid hepatocytes. (C ) Liver injury involving hepatocyte death or damage is accompanied by compensatory
proliferation. Diploid hepatocytes are the primary drivers of proliferation, although
polyploid hepatocytes can proliferate with slower kinetics, generating polyploid hepatocytes
or diploid hepatocytes (that can re-polyploidize). (D ) Diploid and polyploid hepatocytes respond differently to tumorigenic insults. Polyploid
hepatocytes, with additional copies of tumor suppressor genes, are relatively protected
against tumor initiation (shown by one of four cells becoming tumorigenic), while
diploid hepatocytes are sensitive to tumorigenesis (indicated by four of six cells
becoming tumorigenic). Upon tumor initiation, tumorigenic diploid hepatocytes are
capable of rapid proliferation, generating diploid and polyploid daughters. Tumorigenic
polyploid hepatocytes also proliferate, albeit more slowly, generating polyploid daughters
or diploid daughters (that can re-polyploidize).
Second, Heinke et al used retrospective radiocarbon (14 C) birth dating of cells to investigate physiological hepatocyte replacement in humans.[62 ] Hepatocyte nuclei from 29 human subjects aged 20 to 84 years were isolated by fluorescence-activated
cell sorting (FACS) into ploidy populations, and genomic 14 C concentrations were determined using accelerator mass spectrometry. Mathematical
modeling was applied—incorporating historic atmosphere, memory effects, and cell-cycle
dynamics—to estimate hepatocyte age and renewal rates. Human hepatocytes were found
to have ongoing and lifelong turnover that permits the liver to remain relatively
young, at an average of just 3 years old. However, the age of individual hepatocytes
is highly dependent on ploidy status. Diploid hepatocytes showed birth rates sevenfold
higher than polyploids, suggesting that human hepatocyte replacement is highly dependent
on diploid cells ([Fig. 3B ]).
Finally, Viswanathan et al studied the pathological regeneration of human hepatocytes
in vitro.[63 ] Primary human hepatocytes were cultured and treated with acetaminophen to induce
acute injury and compensatory regeneration. The ploidy state of treated hepatocytes
was determined by evaluating nuclear size and intensity. Primary human hepatocytes
under control conditions were distributed along 2n (22%), 4n (49%), and 8n+ (29%)
ploidy states. In acetaminophen-treated hepatocytes, the 2n ploidy state doubled to
44%, whereas the 4n and 8n+ classes decreased to 39 and 16%, respectively. Human diploid
hepatocytes significantly increased after acetaminophen toxicity, indicating that
diploid hepatocytes may drive compensatory regeneration in humans ([Fig. 3C ]). Together, these studies show that diploid hepatocytes, compared to polyploids,
have a strong proliferative advantage during homeostasis and liver regeneration. The
proliferative capacity of diploid and polyploid hepatocytes needs to be evaluated
in other contexts, such as chronic and acute injury models, where diploid hepatocytes
are predicted to maintain a strong proliferative advantage.
Ploidy and Oncogenic Proliferation
Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is the most common form of liver cancer and is associated
with high mortality and morbidity globally.[64 ] There is substantial evidence that polyploidy is associated with heightened disease
severity in many cancers, including pancreatic, cervical, and lung cancer.[15 ]
[65 ]
[66 ]
[67 ] It is tempting to propose that hepatic polyploidy might contribute to developing
HCC; however, HCCs in both patient and rodent models are highly enriched in diploid
hepatocytes.[68 ]
[69 ]
[70 ] Recent studies suggest that diploid hepatocytes drive HCC and that polyploidy protects
the liver from tumorigenesis. Zhang et al showed that polyploid hepatocytes protect
against liver cancer in the diethylnitrosamine (DEN) model.[71 ] Loss-of-heterozygosity of tumor suppressor genes, such as Mll2 , Arid1a , or Rb1 , enhances the transformation potential of diploid cells. However, additional chromosome
sets in polyploid hepatocytes effectively provide “backup” copies of tumor suppressor
genes to compensate for their loss of heterozygosity. Complementary studies by our
lab found that E2f7/E2f8 -deficient mice that are enriched with diploids form HCC better than controls, likely
through accelerated proliferation by transformed diploid hepatocytes.[26 ] Research by Lin et al corroborates these findings.[54 ] Using superpolyploid mice (transgenic Anln knockdown), diploid-enriched mice (E2f8 knockout), and controls, mice were injected with DEN and repeatedly dosed with carbon
tetrachloride to induce liver regeneration. They found increased tumor formation in
diploid-enriched livers compared to controls, while a decrease in tumor formation
was observed in superpolyploid mice. Collectively, these data support the idea that
diploid hepatocytes can drive liver cancer development, whereas polyploid hepatocytes
protect the liver from tumorigenesis by providing extra copies of tumor suppressor
genes and restricting hepatocyte proliferation ([Fig. 3D ]).
Although diploid HCCs are extensively described, polyploid HCCs have also been reported.
For example, Bou-Nader and colleagues examined the ploidy distribution in human HCCs.[10 ] Thirty-three percent of HCCs were enriched with mononuclear polyploid hepatocytes,
which correlated with poor differentiation, increased inflammation, p53 mutation,
and increased expression of proliferation genes. Matsuura et al very recently determined
the ploidy status in human HCC samples by DNA FISH and detected polyploidy in 36%
of HCCs.[72 ] Polyploid HCCs were particularly aggressive and associated with poor prognosis.
Similarly, Lin et al identified microscopic foci of preneoplastic lesions surrounded
by hyperpolyploid hepatocytes in mice treated with DEN. They suggest a possible link
between the formation of hyperpolyploidy and the early stages of HCC.[73 ] Overall, these findings underscore the intricate role of polyploidy in HCC progression,
which is likely influenced by various genetic factors and the dynamic nature of ploidy
status ([Fig. 3D ]).
Ploidy Conveyor as a Mechanism of Ploidy Flexibility
During liver growth and regeneration, the liver undergoes remarkable and dynamic chromosomal
changes. These changes are described by the ploidy conveyor model, which incorporates
polyploidization, ploidy reversal, and re-polyploidization ([Fig. 1 ]).[9 ]
[17 ] The ploidy conveyor was demonstrated by our group in 2010.[9 ] Fixed and live cell imaging was used to track cell cycling of diploid and polyploid
hepatocytes in vitro. Diploid hepatocytes were observed to polyploidize, generating
higher ploidy state daughters, while polyploid hepatocytes underwent ploidy reversal,
generating lower ploidy daughters. Proliferation by mouse diploid and polyploid hepatocytes
was also studied in vivo. Octaploid hepatocytes isolated by FACS from WT mice were
transplanted into FAH−/− mice and underwent 500 to 10,000-fold proliferation to repopulate the liver. The
ploidy distribution of donor-derived hepatocytes was assessed upon complete liver
repopulation, revealing octaploid daughter hepatocytes, as expected, and lower ploidy
daughters (tetraploid and diploid hepatocytes). Surprisingly, the donor-derived hepatocytes
were found in ratios consistent with a “normal” ploidy distribution. Together, these
studies demonstrate the dynamic nature of hepatic ploidy: proliferating diploids become
polyploid, and proliferating polyploids can become diploid.
To determine the extent of dynamic ploidy shifts during liver injury and regeneration,
Matsumoto et al developed lineage tracing systems.[20 ] Using Rosa-Conetti multicolor reporter mice, Cre recombination allowed the stochastic
expression of a single fluorescent protein from each Rosa-Confetti allele (GFP, YFP,
RFP, or CFP). In heterozygous Rosa-Confetti mice, diploid cells expressed one reporter
and thus were monocolored, while polyploid cells could express multiple colors due
to their additional sets of chromosomes. Cellular lineage was determined by tracking
hepatocyte fluorescence. Bicolored tetraploid hepatocytes were separated by FACS,
transplanted in FAH−/− mice, and allowed to repopulate the liver over 3 to 4 months. Analysis of repopulated
livers showed that these hepatocytes underwent ploidy reversal. For example, liver
repopulation by bicolored (YFP+ RFP + ) tetraploid hepatocytes produced 35 to 50%
monocolored daughters (YFP+ or RFP + ), consistent with chromosome loss by a ploidy
reversal mechanism. Moreover, 97% of their monocolored derivatives were polyploid.
This suggests that YFP+ RFP+ hepatocytes underwent ploidy reversal by multipolar cell
division to generate one YFP+ diploid daughter or one RFP+ diploid daughter, which,
in turn, re-polyploidized to generate monocolored polyploid hepatocytes (i.e., YFP
diploid polyploidized to form polyploid daughter cells expressing two YFP alleles).
To determine the prevalence of dynamic ploidy changes associated with the ploidy conveyor,
various chronic injury models (carbon tetrachloride, thioacetamide, and 3,5-diethoxycarbonyl-1,4-dihydrocollidine
[DDC]) were applied. Compared to uninjured mice, there were half as many bicolored
(YFP+ RFP + ) hepatocytes but twice as many monocolored cells (YFP+ or RFP + ), indicating
a ploidy reversal mechanism in response to diverse types of liver injury. Together,
these data indicate that ploidy reversal and subsequent re-polyploidization are common
features of hepatocyte proliferation, seen in each injury model examined ([Fig. 3A–C ]).[20 ]
[74 ]
Although polyploidy can protect against liver cancer, polyploid hepatocytes are not
immune to carcinogenesis (see Ploidy and Oncogenic Proliferation ). Matsumoto and colleagues again used lineage tracing models to investigate the role
of polyploidy and ploidy reversal during oncogenesis.[74 ]
[75 ] In response to induced tumorigenesis (nonalcoholic steatosis, FAH deficiency, and
thioacetamide injury), multiple tumor lineages emerged, including bicolored tumors
(derived from polyploid hepatocytes) and monocolored tumors (originally from ploidy
reversal-derived diploids). Furthermore, a direct comparison of the tumorigenic potential
of (1) ploidy reversal-competent hepatocytes and (2) experimentally induced incompetent
hepatocytes revealed up to a seven-fold increase in tumor formation by hepatocytes
capable of ploidy reversal. Thus, the data demonstrate that ploidy reversal and polyploid-derived
diploid hepatocytes are critical intermediates in the development of hepatocyte-derived
cancers. The ploidy conveyor may explain the emergence of polyploid HCCs.[10 ]
[72 ]
[73 ] It is possible that HCC initiation occurs in diploid hepatocytes lacking redundant
tumor suppressor genes; as the disease advances, some undergo polyploidization ([Fig. 3D ]).[71 ] The significance of ploidy in HCC progression and its implications for prognosis
warrants further investigation.
Concluding Remarks and a Model for Ploidy-Associated Hepatocyte Proliferation
Concluding Remarks and a Model for Ploidy-Associated Hepatocyte Proliferation
The high degree of polyploidy in human and rodent livers suggests that diploid and
polyploid hepatocytes perform specialized roles. Whether and how hepatocyte identity
(e.g., zonation, gene expression) is influenced by ploidy is poorly appreciated, and
contradictory observations in the liver must be resolved. Diploid and polyploid hepatocytes
can proliferate and generate daughters with increased or decreased ploidy. The cycle
of polyploidization, ploidy reversal, and re-polyploidization (i.e., the ploidy conveyor)
is a specialized form of hepatic plasticity that occurs frequently during hepatocyte
proliferation and injury ([Fig. 4 ]). Hepatocytes with diploid nuclear content, whether de novo diploids or derived
from polyploid hepatocytes, have an enhanced capacity to proliferate compared to hepatocytes
with polyploid nuclear content. Thus, diploid hepatocytes drive robust proliferation,
including physiological turnover, regeneration, and oncogenic proliferation.
Fig. 4 Hepatocyte ploidy influences proliferative potential. Diploid, tetraploid, and octaploid
hepatocytes can proliferate, but diploids are capable of accelerated proliferation.
The slowly proliferating polyploids can undergo ploidy reversal to form rapidly proliferating
diploid daughters. Diploid hepatocytes function as the primary drivers of hepatocyte
replacement (homeostasis), liver regeneration and repopulation, compensatory proliferation
after injury, and oncogenic proliferation in hepatocellular carcinoma. Solid purple
lines indicate polyploidization; dashed blue lines mark ploidy reversal; and black/gray arrows indicate the relative contribution to proliferation.