Keywords
body composition - lower limb power - muscle strength - futsal - injury
Introduction
Futsal is a team sport that has more than 12 million players worldwide and is
officially recognized by the Fédération International de Football Association (FIFA)
[1]. During the game of futsal,
players are exposed to physical contact with their opponents and to high-intensity
physical demands, such as accelerations and decelerations, rapid changes of
direction, tackles and kicks [2]
[3]. A high level of physical condition is
essential for players, particularly in terms of body composition, power and muscle
strength, in order to match the various actions of the game [4]. All these factors put futsal players
at substantial risk of injury and, in fact, it has been indicated that futsal is
among the ten most injury-prone sports [5]. Currently, prospective epidemiological studies in futsal indicate
injury incidence rates ranging from 2.22 to 6.7 injuries per 1,000 hours of exposure
[6]
[7]
[8], with the majority of injuries occurring in the lower limbs [7]
[9], mainly affecting the groin, thigh, knee and ankle, and non-contact
injuries being the most commonly referred to mechanism [6].
In order to develop effective prevention programs, it is imperative that injury risk
factors are clearly identified and recognized, and the literature, although
controversial, suggests that the physical condition of players can influence and
predict the occurrence of sports injuries [10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15]. In this sense, body composition,
namely muscle mass, fat mass and body mass index (BMI), are important determinants
of physical condition, and all these parameters are related to the risk of injury
and the health of players [16]
[17]. On the other hand, power and muscle
strength are essential physical attributes in futsal and, as a general rule,
stronger and more powerful players tend to be faster and more agile [18]
[19]
[20]. The indirect
assessment of lower limb power through the Countermovement Jump (CMJ) is commonly
referred to in the literature, as it reflects the effectiveness of the neuromuscular
system in producing maximum force in the shortest possible time. With regard to
muscle strength, although the importance and effectiveness of assessing it using the
isokinetic dynamometer is recognized, the literature lacks research into futsal.
However, de Lira et al. [21] showed that
futsal players have lower extensor strength compared to soccer and beach soccer
players, although they all showed strength imbalances in the hamstring/ quadriceps
ratio (H/Q ratio).
Additionally, it is during the preseason period that sports and health professionals
focus on developing players’ physical condition in order to prepare them for the
various demands of the competitive period [22]. It is also at this stage, especially at the beginning of the sports
season, that the clinical department of each club should provide a detailed and
rigorous assessment of the players’ physical condition, including the evaluation of
body composition, lower limb power and muscle strength, with the aim of
characterizing the general state of health as well as identifying the players’
individual needs in terms of potentially modifiable injury risk factors [23]
[24]
[25]
[26]. In this way, it is possible to
anticipate the probability of injury during the competitive season, implementing
preventive and individualized training programs [24] aimed above all at optimizing
performance and minimizing the risk of injury [11]
[23]
[27].
Nevertheless, the relationship between physical condition at the start of the
preseason and the occurrence of injury in futsal seems to us to be a clear
limitation of the literature, in this sense, and as far as we know, there are no
previous studies that have investigated the relationship between body composition,
power, strength and the appearance of injury in the first few months of the sports
season. For this reason, the main aim of our study was to prospectively analyze the
influence of initial physical condition parameters (body composition, lower limb
power and isokinetic muscle strength) on the development of injury in the first
three months of the sports season in futsal players. Based on the literature, our
hypothesis is that low initial physical condition levels were associated with a
higher likelihood of sports injury in the first few months of the season [28]
[29].
Materials and Methods
Participants
This is a prospective study and the participants were recruited intentionally and
for convenience. Sixty-eight senior male futsal players (24.26±4.63 years),
selected from five Portuguese teams, took part in this study. Data was collected
from the first day of the pre-season until the end of the following 3 months
(beginning of August until November 2023). After this period, they were divided
into two groups, with injury (24.71±3.63 years) and without injury (24.06±5.04
years).
To select the sample, the inclusion criteria were all senior male players from
the respective teams duly registered at the club; all players who remained at
the club during the investigation; and the exclusion criteria were the existence
of an injury that prevented the assessment of physical condition on the first
day of the season.
Procedures and instruments
Initially, a formal and institutional contact was made with the clubs, presenting
the objectives and asking for their cooperation, after which the participants
were given a questionnaire and a term of informed consent. Next, all the players
who met the defined inclusion criteria, the evaluation procedures and purposes
of the study were explained, which respected and preserved all the ethical
principles, international norms and standards relating to the Declaration of
Helsinki and the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine, having been
approved by the institutional review board.
Injuries were recorded daily by each club’s physiotherapist during the research
period (from the first day of the sports season until the end of 3 months), on a
grid drawn up for the purpose, and categorized according to the part of the body
that suffered structural and/or functional changes, the anatomical region, the
type of injury, the contact mechanism (resulting from a specific, identifiable
event) or non-contact mechanism (resulting from repeated microtraumas without a
single, identifiable event) and the severity (minimal (1–3 days), mild (4–7
days), moderate (8–28 days) and severe (more than 28 days)) [30].
The initial physical condition of each player was assessed on day 1 of each
club’s season using three laboratory instruments. First, we used a bioimpedance
scale to assess body composition (InBody 270, Biospace, California, USA) with a
tetrapolar electrode system with eight electrodes and frequencies of 20 and
100 kHz. Height was recorded with a portable stadiometer. During the assessment,
the players stood barefoot, in contact with the scale’s sensors and with their
arms about 45° away from their torso. Beforehand, the participants were informed
of some precautions such as: fasting for 4 hours before the test; abstaining
from intense physical activity 24 hours before the test; emptying the bladder
and bowels before the test [31]. The
variables considered for analysis were BMI, muscle mass (Kg) and fat mass
(Kg).
Second, the players warmed up for 5 minutes on a cycle ergometer and then had
their lower limb muscle power assessed using the maximum height reached in the
CMJ jump as this is one of the most reliable measures for assessing muscle power
[28]
[32]
[33]
[34]
[35] and we used a force platform
(ChronoJump Boscosystem) to apply the protocol. The players were asked to adopt
a vertical position, with their feet shoulder-width apart and their hands on
their waist, in order to minimize the influence of the upper limbs during the
execution of the jump. They were then encouraged to jump as high as possible
with their lower limbs in extension, as indicated by Bosco et al. [36]. Three attempts were made at the
CMJ with a short recovery interval between repetitions (10 to 20 seconds), until
they were ready to perform the next jump, and the highest jump (cm) was
recorded.
Third, we used concentric isokinetic tests with a dynamometer (System 4, Biodex
Medical Systems, Shirley, New York, USA) to assess the muscle strength of the
quadriceps and hamstrings, as indicated in other studies [37]. The players were correctly
positioned on the dynamometer with the knee and hip at 90°, the knee flexion
angle was set at 110° and 0° in extension and the weight of the limb was used to
correct for the effects of gravity. To prevent undesirable movements, three
straps were used to secure the thoracic region, the hip and the knee. For
familiarization, the players received verbal instructions on the procedures and
performed a few submaximal practice attempts, then performed five repetitions of
knee extension and flexion at a speed of 60°/s, as this is the recommended
angular velocity to recruit a greater number of muscle fibers [38]. The players were verbally
encouraged throughout the test to perform their maximum strength. We recorded
the peak concentric torque of the quadriceps and hamstrings for the dominant and
non-dominant limb. The H/Q ratio used for analysis was calculated by dividing
the peak concentric torque of the hamstrings by the peak concentric torque of
the quadriceps at the same contraction speed. We determined this variable in the
strength assessment because it plays a fundamental role in knee joint stability
and has been used to investigate functional capacity, joint stability and muscle
balance between knee flexors and extensors [39]. Furthermore, studies indicate
that an imbalance in the H/Q ratio correlates with a higher incidence of lower
limb injuries [40]. According to
some authors, values below 60% increase the likelihood of injury [26]
[41].
Statistical analysis
The data was analyzed using SPSS statistical software (v.23.0) and Shapiro-Wilk
tests were used to verify the normality of the data. The non-parametric Kruskal
Wallis test was used to compare two groups: players who developed injuries and
players who did not. In another analysis, we used binary logistic regression to
see if the physical condition variables assessed at the start of preseason could
predict the occurrence of injuries in the first three months of the sports
season.
Results
Of the total sample, 21 players developed injuries in the first three months of the
sports season, with the majority occurring in the lower limbs (26.5%), the ankle
(10.3%), thigh (10.3%) and knee (5.9%) were the most frequently injured anatomical
regions and the most common type of injury was muscle and ligament, both with 13.2%.
With regard to the mechanism of injury, non-contact was the most common and, in
terms of severity, the majority of injuries were moderate (16.2%).
[Table 1] shows that the players who
developed an injury in the first few months of the sports season performed less well
in the CMJ compared to the players without an injury, with significant differences
observed in both groups (p<0.001). As for the variables of body
composition (muscle mass, fat mass and BMI) and muscle strength (H/Q ratio), we
found no statistically significant differences between groups (p>0.05),
however, when analyzing the averages of each group, it can be seen that the injured
group showed worse results for all variables.
Table 1 Comparison of the injured and uninjured groups in
terms of body composition, power and muscle strength
variables.
Variables
|
Injured group (n=21) M±SD
|
Non-injured group (n=47) M±SD
|
p
|
Muscle mass, Kg
|
34.79±3.84
|
35.15±4.35
|
0.87
|
Fat mass, Kg
|
13.40±6.48
|
10.07±3.09
|
0.10
|
BMI
|
24.09±3.32
|
23.38±2.22
|
0.59
|
CMJ, cm
|
24.39±5.73
|
29.52±4.38
|
0.001*
|
Peak Torque Q, D
|
234.43±37.10
|
236.84±42.61
|
0.83
|
Peak Torque Q, ND
|
234.79±31.52
|
238.09±45.09
|
0.92
|
Peak Torque H, D
|
132.32±21.20
|
133.84±26.37
|
0.85
|
Peak Torque H, ND
|
125.97±19.64
|
128.46±26.07
|
0.75
|
H/Q ratio
|
55.60±6.62
|
55.65±7.11
|
0.62
|
*p≤0.05 used in Kruskal Wallis; significant values and their
associated effects are shown in bold; N: Number of Subjects; M: Mean;
SD: Standard Deviation; BMI: Body Mass Index; CMJ: Countermovement Jump;
D, dominant; ND, non-dominant.
[Table 2] shows that, in general terms,
the model including all the independent variables was not significant [X2
(8)=7.946; p>0.05; R2 Negelkerke=0.147]. In line with the
results presented above, the players who developed an injury during the first three
months of the sports season had, on average, a worse initial physical condition with
regard to the variables studied, however, only the power of the lower limbs
expressed by the height of the CMJ was a significant predictor (OR=0.92; 95%
CI=0.88–0.99), which indicates that a lower jump height was associated with a
greater risk of injury ([Table 2]). For
every one-unit increase in the height of the CMJ, the probability of injury
decreases by around 8% (p=0.04), showing a negative association between these
variables.
Table 2 Summary of the results of the binary logistic
regression analysis: Comparison between the groups of injured and
non-injured futsal players with potential injury predictor
parameters.
Variables
|
Injured group (n=21) M±DP
|
Non-injured group (n=47) M±DP
|
Total (n=68) M±DP
|
OR
|
CI 95% for OR
|
p
|
Lower
|
Upper
|
Muscle mass, Kg
|
34.79±3.84
|
35.15±4.35
|
34.91±3.98
|
0.99
|
0.82
|
1.21
|
0.96
|
Fat mass, Kg
|
13.40±6.48
|
10.07±3.09
|
11.73±5.73
|
0.84
|
0.65
|
1.08
|
0.18
|
BMI
|
24.09±3.32
|
23.38±2.22
|
23.87±3.03
|
1.16
|
0.71
|
1.90
|
0.55
|
CMJ, cm
|
24.39±5.73
|
29.52±4.38
|
26.95±5.91
|
0.92
|
0.88
|
0.99
|
0.04*
|
Peak Torque Q, D
|
234.43±37.10
|
236.84±42.61
|
235.64±40.72
|
1.01
|
0.98
|
1.02
|
0.55
|
Peak Torque Q, ND
|
234.79±31.52
|
238.09±45.09
|
236.44±41.20
|
0.99
|
0.97
|
1.01
|
0.48
|
Peak Torque H, D
|
132.32±21.20
|
133.84±26.37
|
133.08±24.73
|
1.01
|
0.97
|
1.05
|
0.62
|
Peak Torque H, ND
|
125.97±19.64
|
128.46±26.07
|
127.21±24.15
|
1.02
|
0.97
|
1.07
|
0.29
|
H/Q ratio
|
55.60±6.62
|
55.65±7.11
|
55.61±6.72
|
1.01
|
0.92
|
1.09
|
0.93
|
Abbreviations: BMI, body mass index (weight in kilograms divided by height in
meters squared); CMJ, counter movement jump (jump height in centimeters);
H/Q ratio (strength ratio between flexors divided by extensors); Q,
quadriceps; H, hamstrings; D, dominant; ND, non-dominant; N, number of
subjects; M, mean; SD, standard deviation; OR, odds ratio; CI, confidence
interval; *Significant p-values≤0.05 are shown in bold.
Discussion
The main objective of this study was to verify whether the physical condition
parameters of futsal players assessed at the start of the pre-season would be
predictors of the occurrence of injury in the first few months of the sports season.
Previous studies have highlighted the importance of physical condition variables as
determinant predictors of the likelihood of injury occurring in soccer players [42]
[43], however, in futsal there is a notable lack of research at this level
[10].
In the present study, we found no significant differences in body composition (muscle
mass, fat mass and BMI) between the groups, and none of the variables analyzed were
directly related to the occurrence of injuries in female futsal players, and this
result is in line with previous studies which also found no relationship between
body composition and the development of injuries [10]
[44]. On the other hand, in contrast to our study, other authors have
indicated that high BMI values were associated with lower limb injuries in elite
female soccer players [45]; just as
Grant et al. [46] showed that BMI was a
predictor of injuries in female ice hockey players. Interestingly, in the Watson et
al. study, muscle mass was related to injuries at the start of the season (first
four weeks) in female college soccer players, but was not related to injuries during
the season, which is somewhat in line with our study. Since the population differs
from study to study and different methods are used to assess body composition, it is
very difficult to compare our results. According to the literature, there seems to
be a specific relationship between each sport, body composition and the risk of
injury, since, for example, higher body mass can protect against contact injuries in
Australian soccer [47]; and in the case
of American soccer, a substantial part of the players are categorized as overweight
or obese [48]. Still, this hypothesis
needs to be confirmed with more prospective studies [10].
With regard to lower limb muscle power, this is one of the most crucial skills in the
success of the game of futsal, allowing players to perform numerous explosive tasks
such as jumping, running, shooting and changing direction [49]
[50]. In our study, we found that players without injuries performed
significantly better in the CMJ at the start of the sports season compared to the
group of players who developed injuries (p<0.001), and we also found that
power was found to be an independent predictor of an 8% decrease in the likelihood
of sports injuries. This result showed a clear relationship between power and sports
injuries, i. e. the lower the height of the CMJ jump, the greater the likelihood of
injury, as had already been seen in a study similar to ours by Angoorani et al.
[10].
According to the literature, muscle strength can be a potential risk factor for
sports injuries [21]. However, like
other studies, in general terms we didn’t find any relationship between the H/Q
ratio, the peak torque of the quadriceps and hamstrings and the occurrence of
injuries in futsal players [10]. In the
present study, the average peak torque values for the extensors and flexors were
higher than those found in the study by Lira et al. [21] on futsal players, but for the
flexors they were lower than those found by Nunes et al. [51]. However, as had already been seen in
the Lira et al. [21] study, when
analyzing lower limb asymmetry based on the sample studied, most of the players
didn’t show differences greater than the recommended 10%; specifically, only 33.8%
showed bilateral deficits for the flexor muscles and 17.6% showed bilateral deficits
for the extensor muscles. However, these results do not rule out the need for
individual assessments to identify this possible risk factor for injury. From
another perspective and corroborating our study, Östenberg & Roos [52] indicated that isokinetic muscle
strength was also not considered a risk factor for sports injuries at any of the
speeds assessed (60°/s and 180°/s.). On the other hand, in a study of soccer
players, Soderman et al. [53] concluded
that a lower H/Q ratio increased the risk of lower limb injuries. Furthermore,
surprisingly, both groups (with injury and without injury) had H/Q ratio values
lower than the 60% recommended in the literature, as was the case in other studies
[24]
[26], indicating that these players were
at greater risk of injury. Therefore, the results highlight the need to introduce
strength programs for the hamstrings in both groups studied.
Despite the promising line of research that led to this study, it is necessary to
point out some limitations. First, there was a low number of injured players
included in the study compared to the number of non-injured players; and second, we
could have assessed other dimensions of physical fitness, such as balance, agility,
speed and lung capacity, in order to obtain more robust results that were closer to
reality.
Conclusions
Although there have been a few studies relating physical fitness parameters to sports
injuries, the literature remains controversial. We concluded in this study that
there were no significant differences in body composition and muscle strength
between futsal players who were injured in the first three months of the season and
players who were not injured, but there were differences in lower limb power, with
players without injuries showing better results at the start of the season. Finally,
we concluded that lower limb power was a predictor of an 8% reduction in the
likelihood of injury in the first few months of the season. We draw attention to the
need for more studies to determine the risk factors for injury in the context of
futsal, with the aim of developing prevention programs suited to the sport.
Practical implications
-
Lower limb muscle power has been shown to be an independent predictor of
injury in the first few months of the sports season in futsal players, which
is why physical trainers and physiotherapists should work in symbiosis to
improve players’ physical condition in general, and specifically muscle
power, in order to reduce the number of injuries.