Surgery for Petroclival Meningiomas: A Comprehensive Review of Outcomes in the Skull Base Surgery Era

ABSTRACT

Skull base surgery has evolved to a point that its focus is now shifting to outcome analysis. To do so for petroclival meningiomas is difficult. The rarity of the tumor, different treatment philosophies, and variations in reporting complicate the outcome analysis. With this limitation in mind, we analyzed the literature on this disease and report the combined outcomes in a unified fashion in hopes that it will serve as a starting point for further prospective analysis. Data was extracted from all available reports on MEDLINE/PubMed published in English. All studies were retrospective and uncontrolled. The majority of studies represent the experience of a single surgeon at a single institution. Of the 19 studies with detailed demographic and outcome data, no data met criteria for meta-analysis. A total of 1000 patients were reported. The mean age of the patients was 50 years. The male to female ratio is 1:3. GTR (gross total resection) was reported in 49% of patients. Thirty-four percent of patients experienced some neurological deficit in the early postoperative period (<3 months). The most common morbidities reported were cranial nerve deficits (34.4% [range: 20 to 79%]) with facial nerve injury accounting for 19%, followed by motor deficits (14%), infection rates (1.6%), CSF leaks (5%), hemorrhage (1.2%), and hydrocephalus (1%). Death within 1 year of surgery was reported for 1.4% of patients. Once considered untreatable, petroclival meningiomas can now be approached relatively safely. There, however, still remains an ~34% morbidity with the most common being cranial nerve. Despite this, >75% of patients return to independence at 1 year, many of which will resume employment. The nature of this study limits the conclusions that can be drawn; however, it provides some generalizations that may help guide patient questions regarding treatment outcomes.

Meningioma - petrous - clivus - sphenopetroclival - petroclival

REFERENCES

• 1 Castellano F, Ruggiero G. Meningiomas of the posterior fossa.  Acta Radiol Suppl. 1953;  104 1-177
• 2 Martínez R, Vaquero J, Areitio E, Bravo G. Meningiomas of the posterior fossa.  Surg Neurol. 1983;  19(3) 237-243
• 3 Nishimura S, Hakuba A, Jang B J, Inoue Y. Clivus and apicopetroclivus meningiomas—report of 24 cases.  Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo). 1989;  29(11) 1004-1011
• 4 Al-Mefty O, Fox J L, Smith R R. Petrosal approach for petroclival meningiomas.  Neurosurgery. 1988;  22(3) 510-517
• 5 Bricolo A P, Turazzi S, Talacchi A, Cristofori L. Microsurgical removal of petroclival meningiomas: a report of 33 patients.  Neurosurgery. 1992;  31(5) 813-828, discussion 828
• 6 Couldwell W T, Fukushima T, Giannotta S L, Weiss M H. Petroclival meningiomas: surgical experience in 109 cases.  J Neurosurg. 1996;  84(1) 20-28
• 7 Samii M, Tatagiba M. Experience with 36 surgical cases of petroclival meningiomas.  Acta Neurochir (Wien). 1992;  118(1–2) 27-32
• 8 Seifert V, Raabe A, Zimmermann M. Conservative (labyrinth-preserving) transpetrosal approach to the clivus and petroclival region—indications, complications, results and lessons learned.  Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2003;  145(8) 631-642, discussion 642
• 9 Sekhar L N, Wright D C, Richardson R, Monacci W. Petroclival and foramen magnum meningiomas: surgical approaches and pitfalls.  J Neurooncol. 1996;  29(3) 249-259
• 10 Van Havenbergh T, Carvalho G, Tatagiba M, Plets C, Samii M. Natural history of petroclival meningiomas.  Neurosurgery. 2003;  52(1) 55-62 discussion 62-64
• 11 Bulsara K R, Al-Mefty O. Skull base surgery for benign skull base tumors.  J Neurooncol. 2004;  69(1–3) 181-189
• 12 Dany A, Delcour J, Laine E. Meningiomas of the clivus. Clinical, radiological and therapeutic study.  Neurochirurgie. 1963;  48 249-277
• 13 Hakuba A, Nishimura S, Tanaka K, Kishi H, Nakamura T. Clivus meningioma: six cases of total removal.  Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo). 1977;  17(1 Pt 1) 63-77
• 14 Carvalho G A, Matthies C, Tatagiba M, Eghbal R, Samii M. Impact of computed tomographic and magnetic resonance imaging findings on surgical outcome in petroclival meningiomas.  Neurosurgery. 2000;  47(6) 1287-1294 discussion 1294-1295
• 15 Jung H W, Yoo H, Paek S H, Choi K S. Long-term outcome and growth rate of subtotally resected petroclival meningiomas: experience with 38 cases.  Neurosurgery. 2000;  46(3) 567-574 discussion 574-575
• 16 Mathiesen T, Gerlich A, Kihlström L, Svensson M, Bagger-Sjöbäck D. Effects of using combined transpetrosal surgical approaches to treat petroclival meningiomas.  Neurosurgery. 2007;  60(6) 982-991 discussion 991-992
• 17 Samii M, Ammirati M, Mahran A, Bini W, Sepehrnia A. Surgery of petroclival meningiomas: report of 24 cases.  Neurosurgery. 1989;  24(1) 12-17
• 18 Yasargil M, Mortara R, Curcic M. Meningiomas of basal posterior cranial fossa. In: Krayenbuhl H Advances and Technical Standards in Neurosurgery. Vol. 7. Austria; Springer-Verlag 1980: 1-115
• 19 Cherington M, Schneck S A. Clivus meningiomas.  Neurology. 1966;  16(1) 86-92
• 20 Abdel Aziz K M, Sanan A, van Loveren H R, Tew Jr J M, Keller J T, Pensak M L. Petroclival meningiomas: predictive parameters for transpetrosal approaches.  Neurosurgery. 2000;  47(1) 139-150 discussion 150-152
• 21 Cho C W, Al-Mefty O. Combined petrosal approach to petroclival meningiomas.  Neurosurgery. 2002;  51(3) 708-716 discussion 716-718
• 22 Erkmen K, Pravdenkova S, Al-Mefty O. Surgical management of petroclival meningiomas: factors determining the choice of approach.  Neurosurg Focus. 2005;  19(2) E7
• 23 Cantore G, Delfini R, Ciappetta P. Surgical treatment of petroclival meningiomas: experience with 16 cases.  Surg Neurol. 1994;  42(2) 105-111
• 24 Natarajan S K, Sekhar L N, Schessel D, Morita A. Petroclival meningiomas: multimodality treatment and outcomes at long-term follow-up.  Neurosurgery. 2007;  60(6) 965-979 discussion 979-981
• 25 Bambakidis N C, Kakarla U K, Kim L J et al.. Evolution of surgical approaches in the treatment of petroclival meningiomas: a retrospective review.  Neurosurgery. 2007;  61(5, Suppl 2) 202-209 discussion 209-211
• 26 Levine Z T, Buchanan R I, Sekhar L N, Rosen C L, Wright D C. Proposed grading system to predict the extent of resection and outcomes for cranial base meningiomas.  Neurosurgery. 1999;  45(2) 221-230
• 27 Little K M, Friedman A H, Sampson J H, Wanibuchi M, Fukushima T. Surgical management of petroclival meningiomas: defining resection goals based on risk of neurological morbidity and tumor recurrence rates in 137 patients.  Neurosurgery. 2005;  56(3) 546-559 discussion 546-559
• 28 DeMonte F, Smith H K, Al-Mefty O. Outcome of aggressive removal of cavernous sinus meningiomas.  J Neurosurg. 1994;  81(2) 245-251
• 29 Goel A. Extended lateral subtemporal approach for petroclival meningiomas: report of experience with 24 cases.  Br J Neurosurg. 1999;  13(3) 270-275
• 30 Kawase T, Shiobara R, Toya S. Middle fossa transpetrosal-transtentorial approaches for petroclival meningiomas. Selective pyramid resection and radicality.  Acta Neurochir (Wien). 1994;  129(3–4) 113-120
• 31 Mayberg M R, Symon L. Meningiomas of the clivus and apical petrous bone. Report of 35 cases.  J Neurosurg. 1986;  65(2) 160-167
• 32 Zentner J, Meyer B, Vieweg U, Herberhold C, Schramm J. Petroclival meningiomas: is radical resection always the best option?.  J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1997;  62(4) 341-345
• 33 Chang S D, Adler Jr J R, Martin D P. LINAC radiosurgery for cavernous sinus meningiomas.  Stereotact Funct Neurosurg. 1998;  71(1) 43-50
• 34 Dufour H, Muracciole X, Métellus P, Régis J, Chinot O, Grisoli F. Long-term tumor control and functional outcome in patients with cavernous sinus meningiomas treated by radiotherapy with or without previous surgery: is there an alternative to aggressive tumor removal?.  Neurosurgery. 2001;  48(2) 285-294 discussion 294-296
• 35 Iwai Y, Yamanaka K, Nakajima H. Two-staged gamma knife radiosurgery for the treatment of large petroclival and cavernous sinus meningiomas.  Surg Neurol. 2001;  56(5) 308-314
• 36 Roche P H, Pellet W, Fuentes S, Thomassin J M, Régis J. Gamma knife radiosurgical management of petroclival meningiomas results and indications.  Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2003;  145(10) 883-888, discussion 888
• 37 Subach B R, Lunsford L D, Kondziolka D, Maitz A H, Flickinger J C. Management of petroclival meningiomas by stereotactic radiosurgery.  Neurosurgery. 1998;  42(3) 437-443 discussion 443-445