ABSTRACT
ABSTRACT
Study design: Retrospective cohort study.
Background: Several studies focus on the long-term results of anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) surgeries, but little information exists regarding how various patient-related, procedure-related, and payer-related variables may affect postoperative hospital length of stay (LOS).
Objective: To determine what factors, if any, contribute to increased hospital LOS in patients who have had an ACDF.
Methods: Retrospective cohort study of 108 consecutive patients who underwent elective ACDF at a Midwest academic medical center. Extensive preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative data were abstracted and analyzed to identify prognostic factors for an increased LOS. Multivariate analysis was performed to analyze the effects of patient and hospital characteristics on hospital LOS.
Results: 103 patients met inclusion and exclusion criteria. The mean LOS for patients undergoing ACDF was 1.98 (± 1.6) days. Only 29% of patients had one level fused. The mean blood loss during surgery was 87.4 ± 99.6 mL. One subject lost 700 mL of blood. Complications, though rare, included uncontrolled postoperative pain (13%), cardiac (6%), pulmonary (4%), and urinary (3%). Covariates included in the final model were age, sex, cardiac complication, urinary complication, and pulmonary complication. Factors that contributed to increased LOS and their associated adjusted mean days were: ≥ 50 years of age (2.5 ± 1.2 days), female gender (2.3 ± 1.2 days), and three particular types of complications. The complications that had the largest effect on increased LOS from least to most severe were cardiac (3.5 ± 1.3 days), urinary (4.7 ± 1.3 days), and pulmonary (5.3 ± 1.3 days).
Conclusions: The information presented in this study may be useful for patients, clinicians, and insurance companies, including precertification and case-management services. Our results can be instrumental in designing future prospective studies using more detailed analyses with more patients, more surgeons, and multiple institutions.
STUDY RATIONALE AND CONTEXT
STUDY RATIONALE AND CONTEXT
Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) is indicated for radiculopathy, myelopathy, or neck pain unrelieved by nonsurgical means. Garvey et al [1] found that 78% of the patients who presented with symptoms attributed them to a motor vehicle injury or work-related injury, leaving 22% with an unknown etiology of symptoms with no injury involved. Many studies have looked at long-term outcomes of patients who have undergone ACDF, and found a high rate of patient satisfaction [1]. There may be complications, some of which can result in a longer hospital stay; however, we found no studies that included the contribution of perioperative complications to an increased length of stay (LOS). Already identified in other studies are variables that contribute to LOS and recovery time; we analyzed these variables in our study for correlation to LOS, which also plays a role in patient satisfaction and procedure outcome.
OBJECTIVE
OBJECTIVE
To determine what factors, if any, contribute to increased postoperative hospital stay in patients who have had an ACDF.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study design:
Retrospective cohort study using the quota-sampling method for record selection. Records were listed of all patients having had elective ACDF by one attending neurosurgeon, beginning with those who had surgery the month prior to institutional review board application submission. From this list we worked backward with the goal of gathering data from 108 consecutive charts, a cohort number considered adequate to obtain clinically useful results.
Inclusion criteria:
-
Age ≥ 18 years; nontrauma patient, no other physical injuries
-
Admitted to the hospital after surgery
-
Unresponsive to at least 6 weeks of conservative treatment and / or presented with progressive symptoms of nerve root or spinal cord compression
-
Underwent elective ACDF for: (1) myelopathy, radiculopathy, myeloradiculopathy; (2) stenosis, spinal cord compression, spinal cord change; (3) herniated nucleus pulposus (HNP), degenerative disc disease, spondylosis, osteophytic complexes; and (4) foraminal stenosis
Exclusion criteria:
-
Age < 18 years; trauma patient with other physical injuries
-
Emergent admission with nonelective surgery
-
Evidence of adjacent segment stiffness secondary to pathology, such as diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis, ankylosing spondylitis, congenital abnormality, or rheumatoid arthritis
Patient population:
Intervention:
-
Anterior approach to perform a discectomy and decompress the affected spinal level. Either autograft or allograft bone was placed in the intervertebral space to stimulate healing and eventual fusion between the end plates. A metal plate was affixed to the adjoining vertebrae to stabilize the construct, maintain neck lordosis, and allow for optimal bone healing and fusion.
Covariates:
The following covariates were collected from hospital-billing records, patient charts, and outpatient clinic records. We were limited to what had been collected.
-
Patient demographics (age, sex, weight, height, and type of insurance)
-
Medical comorbidities (cardiovascular, previous spine surgery, cancer, central nervous system, central nervous system-psychiatric, gastrointestinal, genitourinary, respiratory, degenerative disc disease / degenerative joint disease, diabetes)
-
Tobacco, alcohol, and drug use
-
Symptoms: neck pain only, radiating pain, numbness and tingling, weakness, difficulty swallowing / hoarseness, difficulty with ambulation, and duration of symptoms
-
Primary diagnosis in one of five categories:
-
myelopathy, radiculopathy, myeloradiculopathy
-
stenosis, spinal cord compression, spinal cord change
-
HNP, degenerative disc disease, spondylosis, osteophytic complexes
-
foraminal stenosis
-
previous cervical fusion
-
Surgical details (levels of fusion, operative time, estimated blood loss, and preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative medications)
-
Home medications (opioid and nonopioid pain medications, muscle relaxants, steroidal antiinflammatories, non-steroidal antiinflammatories, psychotropic, and other central nervous system medications)
-
Payer / insurance characteristics
We noted all postoperative complications reported in the medical record from mild to severe to ensure that any event that could influence hospital LOS was accounted for. The following categories of complications were available: none; new neurological deficit (new onset numbness / weakness in upper extremity (UE); dysphagia; cardiac (which included only hypertension and broadly defined cardiac or noncardiac chest pain); urinary (urinary retention, problems urinating after Foley removal); anxiety; pulmonary (decreased sats, need for O2 and aggressive pulmonary toilet, exacerbation of asthma, respiratory failure, atelectasis, pneumonia); fever; uncontrolled postoperative pain (severe pain issues, pain uncontrolled by current pain medications, admitted from emergency department for pain, increased need for pain medications).
Outcome:
Analysis:
-
Means ± standard deviations and frequency counts and rates were reported for continuous and categorical covariates, respectively.
-
We performed univariate comparisons of all variables listed in the section covariates to determine our candidate covariates for the final multivariate model. All variables that were associated with the outcome LOS with P < .05 were considered in the multivariate model.
-
We then built a systematic multivariate linear regression model by adding variables to the model in the order given in the section labeled covariates. Variables that did not have an association of P < .05 with LOS did not remain in the model.
-
The overall R2, regression coefficients, and associated P values were reported for all covariates included in the final model.
-
The adjusted mean LOS and standard deviations for each covariate were computed using the post regression command „adjust“ in Stata 9.1.
RESULTS
RESULTS
-
One hundred and three patients (95.4%) were deemed eligible and included in the final analysis (Fig [1]). There were four missing data elements for insurance information. There were no missing data for other covariates.
-
Of 103 patients included in the study, 56 (54%) were women, and the average age was 49.1 years; average height, 67.3 inches; and average weight, 87.1 kg (Table [1]).
-
Sixty-five patients (63%) had concomitant HNP; 51 (50%) had cervical spondylotic myelopathy; and 45 (44%) had cardiovascular disease; 38 (37%) of 103 patients who were current cigarette smokers smoked an average of 0.38 packs per day. Other concomitant conditions were stenosis (34%), psychiatric (24%), central nervous system (24%), gastrointestinal (24%), previous spine surgery (17%), respiratory (17%), regular alcohol use (14%), diabetes (12%), genitourinary (11%), cancer (3%), and degenerative joint disease (2%) (Table [1]).
-
Presenting symptoms included neck pain, 78 patients (76%); UE pain, 75 (73%); and unilateral UE numbness, 37 (36%). Bilateral UE numbness was a presenting symptom in 16 patients (16%), as was unilateral UE weakness. Symptom duration was long (12+ months) for 29 patients (28%); short (3.0 – 5.9 months) for 24 patients (23%); and medium (6.0 – 11.9 months) for 16 patients (16%) (Table [2]).
Fig 1 Patient sampling and selection.
Fig 1 Patient sampling and selection.
-
The mean LOS for patients undergoing ACDF was 1.98 (± 1.6) days. Twenty-nine patients (29%) had one level fused; 41, two levels (41%); 21, three levels (21%); and 8, four levels fused (8%). The average length of surgery was 3.4 (± .99) hours, and the average blood loss during surgery was 87.4 ± 99.6 mL. Patients' concomitant medications were tracked, as well as the intraoperative and postoperative medications administered in the hospital (Table [3]).
-
Individual perioperative complications were rare, the most common of which were uncontrolled postoperative pain (severe pain issues, pain uncontrolled by current pain medications, admitted from the emergency department for pain, increased need for pain medications: 13%), as well as cardiac complications (which included only hypertension and broadly defined cardiac or noncardiac chest pain: 6%), urinary complications (urinary retention, problems urinating after Foley removal: 3%), and pulmonary complications (decreased sats, need for O2 and aggressive pulmonary toilet, exacerbation of asthma, respiratory failure, atelectasis, pneumonia: 4%) (Table [4]). Most complaints of chest pain were due to neck muscles pulling on the chest wall; no actual cardiac events occurred postoperatively as verified by cardiac work-up. There were no procedure-related or wound complications, and this study did not track delayed complications in the outpatient setting.
-
The following covariates had an association of P < .05 and were included in the final multivariate regression model for hospital LOS (in days) as outcome: (Table [5])
-
Age: dichotomized at 50 years (coefficient = .851; P = .001)
-
Sex: (coefficient = − .620; P = .011)
-
Cardiac complication (coefficient = 1.58; P = .002)
-
Urinary complication (coefficient = 2.77; P < .001)
-
Pulmonary complication (coefficient = 3.45; P < .001)
-
The overall multivariate model R2 was .48. Factors that contributed to increased LOS and their associated adjusted mean days were age ≥ 50 years (2.5 ± 1.2 days), female gender (2.3 ± 1.2 days), and three particular types of complications. The three types of complications that had the largest effect on increased LOS, from least to most severe, were: cardiac (3.5 ± 1.3 days); urinary (4.7 ± 1.3 days); and pulmonary (5.3 ± 1.3 days) (Table [5]).
-
No other factors listed in the covariates section in Tables 1 – 4 were found to be significantly associated with hospital LOS. The presence of cervical spondylotic myelopathy was approaching significance (P = .068).
Table 1 Baseline demographics and general health characteristics of patients undergoing cervical fusion*.
Table 1 Baseline demographics and general health characteristics of patients undergoing cervical fusion*.
Table 2 Baseline pain and symptoms of patients undergoing
cervical fusion*.
Table 2 Baseline pain and symptoms of patients undergoing
cervical fusion*.
Table 3 Surgery-specific characteristics of patients undergoing cervical fusion*.
Table 3 Surgery-specific characteristics of patients undergoing cervical fusion*.
Table 4 Postoperative complications after cervical spine fusion.
Table 4 Postoperative complications after cervical spine fusion.
Table 5 Multivariate linear regression analysis of length of stay (in days) as outcome with all covariates that have an association of P < .05.
Table 5 Multivariate linear regression analysis of length of stay (in days) as outcome with all covariates that have an association of P < .05.
DISCUSSION
DISCUSSION
-
Individuals at our facility who had identical surgeries by the same surgeon were found to have very different LOS, with no clear-cut explanation for the difference. Most patients were discharged only one night after surgery, but others were discharged as long as five nights after surgery. We sought to identify the factors that contribute to increased LOS in postoperative patients having had ACDF, and to develop a plan to counteract and anticipate these factors to reduce LOS and to improve overall outcomes.
-
The mean LOS for patients undergoing ACDF was 1.98 (± 1.6) days. Complications, though rare, included uncontrolled postoperative pain (13%), cardiac (6%), pulmonary (4%), and urinary (3%). Because our study was not to determine overall safety of a procedure or device but rather to determine what types of events influence hospital LOS, we chose to document any event that could lead to an increased LOS, with the understanding that the event may not be considered severe. Therefore, the percentage of complications may be overestimated compared with those in other studies because our operational definitions had to be broad.
-
Factors that contributed to increased LOS and their associated mean days were age ≥ 50 years, female gender, and three particular types of complications. The complications that had the largest effect on increased LOS from least to most severe were cardiac, urinary, and pulmonary.
-
Castro et al [2] noted that dysphagia indicated additional time in the hospital postoperatively, but there was no indication to how much more time. This particular study was the only reference to LOS that was found. Compared with the results of Castro et al, the rate of dysphagia in our study was lower, which we attribute to meticulous surgical technique as well as deflation of the endotracheal cuff during surgery. Studies that have reviewed the long-term outcomes of ACDF surgeries list complications, but none discussed how those complications contribute to an increased LOS. Garvey et al [1] concluded that it was not possible to determine why individuals with the same anatomical findings or pathology continued to have symptoms after surgery, while others did not.
-
Factors unrelated to the medical condition can influence hospital LOS, such as type and location of hospital, type of payer, and patient characteristics [3], [4], [5], [6].
-
Factors related to the patient and condition that can influence outcome after cervical spine surgery include: comorbidity [7], [8], [9], [10]; age, severity of the neurological deficit [10]; preoperative myelopathy [11], [12], [13]; pulmonary and cardiovascular disease, hypertension, and diabetes mellitus [12], [14]; smoking, alcohol use, body mass index [11]; education level, length of surgery, number of fusion levels, dysphagia, incisional pain, urinary tract infection, septicemia, bleeding, and hypotension [2], [15], [16].
-
Clinical myelopathy, age, and comorbidity are associated with a longer hospital LOS and critical care intervention after cervical spine surgery [7], [8], [12], [17]. In our study, the presence of cervical spondylotic myelopathy was approaching significance (P = .068), but was found not to be significantly associated with hospital LOS, therefore not included in the final model and estimates.
-
Higher rates of complication are expected in patients having multilevel rather than single-level fusion because of more extensive dissection, longer operating time, and greater blood loss [17].
-
In patients who have undergone surgical decompression for cervical degenerative disc disease, the factors associated with prolonged hospitalization and the need for postoperative critical care are preexisting myelopathy, multilevel decompression, cardiovascular disease, hypertension, pulmonary disease, and diabetes mellitus [12].
Limitations of this study
-
It is difficult to establish cause-and-effect using retrospective analysis. Such findings are subject to confounding bias because of known or unknown factors that influence outcomes that are not controlled. We collected as many variables as we could that we believed might have an impact on outcome.
-
Retrospective studies are known for missing data, which can affect study validity. Only insurance data was missing in our analysis (n = 4) and these variables were not statistically significant.
-
Since these data were not collected prospectively, there is also the possibility of misclassification of admitting diagnosis and other covariates included in the analysis. Such misclassification would likely not be systematic and therefore considered nondifferential. Nondifferential misclassification generally biases associations toward the null.
-
Because we were predicting outcome after a single-treatment technique and not comparing treatment techniques, the effects of selection bias may influence generalizability (as opposed to biasing a treatment). That is, our patients may not be representative of the typical patients at other centers. That said, we enrolled a consecutive series of patients meeting the study criteria and we believe our study population represented the normal patient population that presents for ACDF.
-
Even the process of interpreting and abstracting data from hospital charts and outpatient records creates potential variability in the collected data, even if abstracted by only one researcher [18]. The quality of the information recorded may vary; however, there is no reason to believe this would be systematic.
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION
-
We found that for patients who have undergone ACDF, the prognostic factors that contribute to increased postoperative hospital LOS are older age, female gender, and three types of complications—cardiac, urinary, and pulmonary.
-
The information presented in this study may be useful for patients, clinicians, and insurance companies, including precertification and case-management services. Our results can be instrumental in designing future prospective studies using more detailed analyses with more patients, more surgeons, and multiple institutions. A prediction model using registry data could also be performed to validate or refine these observations.
