Keywords
diamniotic twin - neonatal outcomes - late preterm births - moderately preterm births
Late preterm births (LPTBs), which constitute more than 70% of all preterm deliveries
(240/7 to 366/7 weeks' gestation),[1] have recently garnered increased attention due to consistent demonstration of higher
than previously expected neonatal morbidity and mortality in this group. In fact,
this has led to the classification of preterm deliveries into very preterm birth (VPTB,
240/7 to 316/7 weeks), moderately preterm births (MPTB, 320/7 to 336/7 weeks), and LPTBs (34°/7 to 366/7 weeks).[2]
[3]
[4] In an effort to decrease the prevalence of LPTB, there has been increased focus
on the obstetric indications leading to these deliveries. Also, MPTB infants have
significant prematurity-related morbidities of all preterm births in the United States.[17]
Unfortunately, these efforts have predominantly involved singleton pregnancies, and
there remains a paucity of data regarding obstetric indications leading to LPTB in
twin gestations. The morbidity associated with preterm births (PTBs) coupled with
the increasing rates of twin gestations and their associated preterm deliveries make
this an important public health concern. Consequently, the objective of this study
was to compare neonatal outcomes in twin pregnancies following MPTB, LPTB, and term
birth in diamniotic twin pregnancies and to identify obstetric indications leading
to early nonspontaneous delivery.
Methods and Materials
We conducted a retrospective cohort analysis of all twin deliveries at our institution
between January 1, 1991, and January 1, 2011. Approval from the Committee for the
Protection of Human Subjects Institutional Review Board at the University of Connecticut
Health Center was obtained prior to data collection.
Inclusion criteria were twin gestation with two live-born infants and delivery after
320/7 weeks of gestation. Exclusion criteria included cases complicated by pregnancies
with major congenital malformations, Rh alloimmunization, monoamniocity, and twin-to-twin
transfusion syndrome. Subjects were categorized as MPTB (delivery between 320/7 and 336/7 weeks), LPTB (delivery between 340/7 and 366/7 weeks), and term birth (TB, delivery after 370/7). The TB group served as the referent population.
Demographic data were abstracted from the prenatal and inpatient records. Gestational
age, chorionicity, and amnionicity were determined from prenatal records. In cases
of uncertain last menstrual period, ultrasound-determined gestational age was used.
Obstetric variables of interest included gestational hypertension and preeclampsia,
gestational and pregestational diabetes, and treatment with antenatal corticosteroids
and/or magnesium sulfate were abstracted from the prenatal and inpatient records.
Neonatal outcomes of interest were defined as respiratory distress syndrome based
on the clinical findings of respiratory distress and chest X-ray findings of a diffuse
reticulogranular pattern with air bronchograms[5]; days of mechanical ventilation and/or continuous or intermittent positive airway
pressure; intraventricular hemorrhage based on the Papile classification of cranial
ultrasound findings of blood in the germinal matrix or ventricular system with or
without ventricular dilatation[6]; necrotizing enterocolitis based on Bell's classification (stage II and above)[7]; periventricular leukomalacia as diagnosed by cerebral ultrasound findings of increased
echogenicity and cystic lesions in the periventricular white matter[8]; retinopathy of prematurity (ROP) based on pediatric ophthalmologic exam using the
international classification of ROP[9]; bronchopulmonary dysplasia diagnosed by the presence of chronic respiratory distress
with an oxygen requirement beyond 28 days of life, accompanied by characteristic chest
roentgenogram findings[10]; early culture-proven sepsis defined as positive bacterial culture from samples
obtained within the first 3 days of life; and length of hospitalization based on final
discharge to a nonmedical facility. The composite neonatal adverse respiratory outcome
was defined as respiratory distress syndrome and/or bronchopulmonary dysplasia. The
composite neonatal adverse nonrespiratory outcome included early onset culture-proven
sepsis, necrotizing enterocolitis, ROP, intraventricular hemorrhage, or periventricular
leukomalacia.
We categorized the indication for LPTB using current recommendations endorsed by the
American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG)[11] or published expert opinion (level III evidence). Spontaneous (noniatrogenic) causes
of preterm delivery included cases of either premature rupture of membranes or preterm
labor with intact membranes. Iatrogenic deliveries (indicated) were further categorizes
as follows: deliveries based on obstetric indications supported by ACOG guidelines
and /or expert opinion (level III evidence and expert opinion) were defined as evidence-based
(EB), and deliveries based on obstetric indications not supported by either of these
were labeled non-EB (NEB; [Table 1]). All the NEB deliveries with no clear reason defined as elective.
Table 1
Categorization of indications for iatrogenic delivery
|
Evidence-based
|
Non-evidence-based
|
|
Severe preeclampsia/eclampsia/HELLP syndrome
|
Mild preeclampsia/gestational hypertension
|
|
Nonreassuring fetal status
|
IUGR with normal testing and adequate interval growth
|
|
Acute abruption
|
Oligohydramnios
|
|
Prior classical cesarean delivery
|
|
Placenta previa
|
|
Cholestasis of pregnancy
|
|
No clear indication (elective)
|
Abbreviations: HELLP syndrome, hemolysis, elevated liver enzymes, low platelet count;
IUGR, intrauterine growth restriction.
Each twin was treated as one observation in the analysis. We created three categories
of delivery time and compared other variables across these categories. We used analysis
of variance to compare parametric continuous variables and Kruskal-Wallis test to
compare nonparametric continuous variables across categories of delivery time. To
compare the distribution of categorical variables between groups of delivery time,
chi-square test or Fisher exact test was used. Risk of having a respiratory or nonrespiratory
outcome, was assessed in MPTB and LPTB neonates relative to term neonates, after adjustment
for antenatal corticosteroid and magnesium sulfate treatment, using multiple logistic
regression models. We additionally adjusted our models for maternal age, diabetes,
chronic hypertension, prior preterm birth, and in vitro fertilization. In this study,
the unit of analysis is a twin. To account for a potential nonindependence of twin
outcomes, we also used generalized estimating equation models. A significance level
of 0.05 was used to reject the null hypothesis. Data was analyzed using SAS version
9.2.
Results
Of the 747 twin deliveries during the study period, 453 sets met the inclusion criteria
with 22.7% (n = 145) MPTB, 32.1% (n = 206) LPTB, and 15.9% (n = 102) term births ([Fig. 1]).
Fig. 1 Proportion of twin pairs delivering moderately preterm, late preterm, and term births
in the study.
Maternal factors were similar among the three groups except for older age among women
who delivered at term ([Table 2]). There were no neonatal deaths in the three groups. The rates of the adverse neonatal
outcomes as defined by composite outcomes (respiratory and nonrespiratory) were significantly
higher in those twins with MPTB and LPTB compared with term births ([Table 3]). The relative risk of neonatal adverse outcomes (composite respiratory and nonrespiratory
outcomes) increased progressively from MPTB to LPTB to TB with and without adjustment
for other confounding factors ([Tables 4A] and [4B]). Neonatal characteristics and the specific short-term neonatal outcomes of their
906 infants are shown in [Table 5].
Table 2
Maternal characteristics
|
MPTB (145 twin pairs)
|
LPTB (206 twin pairs)
|
TB (102 twin pairs)
|
p value
|
|
Maternal age, y (SD)
|
29.6 (5.8)
|
31 (6.1)
|
32.8 (6)
|
<0.0001
|
|
Mean gestational age at delivery, wk (SD)
|
33 (0.6)
|
35.3 (0.9)
|
37.8 (0.6)
|
<0.0001
|
|
Prior preterm births (%)
|
11 (7.6)
|
23 (11.2)
|
5 (4.9)
|
0.0331
|
|
Prior term births (%)
|
65 (44.8)
|
82 (39.8)
|
46 (45.1)
|
0.2975
|
|
Start BMI (SD)
|
25.9 (6.2)
|
26.2 (6.6)
|
25 (5.7)
|
0.1622
|
|
Smoking (%)
|
13 (9.0)
|
11 (5.3)
|
7 (6.9)
|
0.1729
|
|
Race (%)
|
|
|
|
0.3457
|
|
Caucasian
|
115 (79.3)
|
167 (81.1)
|
72 (70.6)
|
|
|
African-American
|
3 (2.1)
|
5 (2.4)
|
7 (6.9)
|
|
|
Hispanic
|
13 (9.0)
|
14 (6.8)
|
10 (9.8)
|
|
|
Other
|
14 (9.6)
|
20 (9.7)
|
13 (12.7)
|
0.2834
|
|
Diabetes (%)
|
13 (9.0)
|
25 (12.1)
|
6 (5.9)
|
0.0529
|
|
CHTN (%)
|
19 (13.1)
|
37 (18.0)
|
12 (11.8)
|
0.0524
|
|
IVF (%)
|
9 (8.8)
|
32 (15.5)
|
17 (11.7)
|
0.0343
|
|
Mono-Di twins (%)
|
30 (20.7)
|
35 (17.0)
|
16 (15.7)
|
0.2938
|
Abbreviations: BMI, body mass index; CHTN, chronic hypertension; IVF, in vitro fertilization;
LPTB, late preterm birth; Mono-Di twins, monochorionic-diamniotic twins; MPTB, moderately
preterm birth; TB, term birth; SD, standard deviation.
Note: Results are mean ± standard deviation or n (%).
Table 3
The composite neonatal adverse outcomes
|
MPTB (290 neonates)
|
LPTB (412 neonates)
|
TB (204 neonates)
|
p value
|
|
Respiratory outcome (%)
|
50 (17.2)
|
35 (8.5)
|
1 (0.5)
|
<0.0001
|
|
Nonrespiratory outcomes (%)
|
29 (10.0)
|
16 (3.9)
|
2 (1)
|
<0.0001
|
Abbreviations: LPTB, late preterm birth; MPTB, moderately preterm birth; TB, term
birth.
Note: Results are n (%). Primary respiratory outcomes: respiratory distress syndrome and bronchopulmonary
dysplasia. Primary nonrespiratory outcomes: early onset culture-proven sepsis, necrotizing
enterocolitis, retinopathy of prematurity, intraventricular hemorrhage, periventricular
leukomalacia.
Table 4A
Relative risk of adverse neonatal outcomes among LPTB and MPTB twin gestations compared
with TB twin gestations
|
Composite neonatal outcomes
|
Delivery time
|
OR (95% Wald confidence limits)
|
|
|
Crude
|
Adjusted[a]
|
Adjusted[b]
|
|
Respiratory
|
|
LPTB vs. TB
|
18.8 (2.6–138.6)
|
17.6 (2.4–129.7)
|
16.7 (2.2–123.4)
|
|
MPTB vs. TB
|
42.3 (5.8–308.8)
|
35.2 (4.7–261.9)
|
29.9 (4–223.9)
|
|
Nonrespiratory
|
|
LPTB vs. TB
|
4.1 (0.9–17.9)
|
4.7 (1.1–20.6)
|
4.3 (1–19)
|
|
MPTB vs. TB
|
11.2 (2.6–47.5)
|
17.6 (4.1–76.5)
|
18.4 (4.2–81.3)
|
Abbreviations: LPTB, late preterm birth; MPTB, moderate preterm birth; TB, term birth.
Note: Primary respiratory outcomes: respiratory distress syndrome, and bronchopulmonary
dysplasia. Primary nonrespiratory outcomes: early onset culture-proven sepsis, NEC,
necrotizing enterocolitis; ROP, retinopathy of prematurity; intraventricular hemorrhage,
periventricular leukomalacia.
a Adjusted for antenatal corticosteroid use and administration of magnesium sulfate.
b Additionally adjusted for maternal age, diabetes, chronic hypertension, prior preterm
birth, and in vitro fertilization.
Table 4B
Relative risk of adverse neonatal outcomes among late and moderate preterm birth Twin
gestations compared with term twin gestations (calculated using generalized estimating
equation models to account for a nonindependence of twin outcomes)
|
Composite neonatal outcomes
|
Delivery time
|
OR (95% Wald confidence limits)
|
|
|
Crude
|
Adjusted[a]
|
Adjusted[b]
|
|
Respiratory
|
|
LPTB vs. TB
|
18.3 (2.6–128.6)
|
14.9 (2.1–108.4)
|
13.7 (1.8–101.8)
|
|
MPTB vs. TB
|
41 (5.9–286.5)
|
29.3 (3.7–232.3)
|
24 (3–193.6)
|
|
Nonrespiratory
|
|
LPTB vs. TB
|
4 (0.9–17.6)
|
5.6 (1.2–27.4)
|
5.5 (1.1–27.6)
|
|
MPTB vs. TB
|
11 (2.6–46.8)
|
20.8 (3.9–110.3)
|
22.3 (3.9–127.8)
|
Abbreviations: LPTB, late preterm birth; MPTB, moderate preterm birth; TB, term birth.
Note: Primary respiratory outcomes: respiratory distress syndrome, and bronchopulmonary
dysplasia. Primary nonrespiratory outcomes: early onset culture-proven sepsis, NEC,
necrotizing enterocolitis; ROP, retinopathy of prematurity; intraventricular hemorrhage,
periventricular leukomalacia.
a Adjusted for antenatal corticosteroid use and administration of magnesium sulfate.
b Additionally adjusted for maternal age, diabetes, chronic hypertension, prior preterm
birth, and in vitro fertilization.
Table 5
Neonatal characteristics and individual outcomes
|
MPTB (290 neonates)
|
LPTB (412 neonates)
|
TB (204 neonates)
|
p value
|
|
Birth weight, g (SD)
|
1,894.3 (327.6)
|
2,329.1 (430.2)
|
2,749.6 (380.7)
|
<000.1
|
|
Female gender (%)
|
140 (48.3)
|
228 (55.3)
|
112 (54.9)
|
0.1314
|
|
RDS, n (%)
|
50 (17.2)
|
33 (8.0)
|
1 (0.5)
|
<0.0001
|
|
Early sepsis, n (%)
|
22 (7.5)
|
13 (3.1)
|
1 (0.5)
|
0.0001
|
|
NEC, n (%)
|
2 (0.6)
|
3 (0.7)
|
0 (0)
|
0.6190
|
|
BPD, n (%)
|
7 (2.4)
|
5 (1.2)
|
0 (0)
|
0.0545
|
|
ROP, n (%)
|
3 (1.0)
|
0 (0)
|
0 (0)
|
0.0439
|
|
IVH, n (%)
|
|
I and II
|
3 (1.0)
|
0 (0)
|
0 (0)
|
|
|
III and IV
|
1 (0.3)
|
0 (0)
|
1 (0.5)
|
0.0303
|
|
Apgar 5 min < 7, n (%)
|
8 (2.7)
|
7 (1.7)
|
1 (0.5)
|
0.1764
|
|
MV, n (%)
|
55 (18.9)
|
31 (7.5)
|
2 (1.0)
|
<0.0001
|
|
CPAP, n (%)
|
109 (37.6)
|
81 (19.6)
|
5 (2.4)
|
<0.0001
|
|
NICU admission, n (%)
|
290 (100.0)
|
262 (63.6)
|
17 (8.3)
|
<0.0001
|
|
Median length of NICU, d (range)
|
20 (4–101)
|
13 (1–56)
|
5 (2–113)
|
<0.0001
|
|
PVL
|
0 (0)
|
0 (0)
|
0 (0)
|
NA
|
Abbreviations: BPD, bronchopulmonary dysplasia; CPAP, continuous or intermittent positive
airway pressure; IVH, intraventricular hemorrhage; LPTB, late preterm birth; MPTB,
moderate preterm birth; MV, mechanical ventilation; NA, not applicable; NEC, necrotizing
enterocolitis; NICU, neonatal intensive care unit; PVL, periventricular leukomalacia;
RDS, respiratory distress syndrome; ROP, retinopathy of prematurity; SD, standard
deviation; TB, term birth.
Obstetric indications such as preeclampsia or gestational hypertension, and antepartum
interventions such as antenatal corticosteroid or magnesium sulfate therapy were significantly
higher in earlier gestations ([Table 6]).
Table 6
Clinical characteristics
|
MPTB (145 mothers)
|
LPTB (206 mothers)
|
TB (102 mothers)
|
p value
|
|
ACS
|
86 (59.3)
|
75 (36.4)
|
18 (17.6)
|
<0.0001
|
|
Mag sulfate
|
79 (54.4)
|
62 (30.1)
|
12 (11.7)
|
<0.0001
|
|
Preeclampsia or PIH
|
15 (10.3)
|
17 (8.2)
|
4 (3.9)
|
<0.0001
|
|
PPROM
|
48 (33.1)
|
40 (19.4)
|
0
|
<0.0001
|
|
Cesarean delivery
|
94 (64.8)
|
142 (68.9)
|
70 (68.6)
|
0.4533
|
|
V/C
|
11 (7.6)
|
10 (4.8)
|
2 (1.9)
|
0.0008
|
Abbreviations: ACS, antenatal corticosteroid; LPTB, late preterm birth; Mag, administration
of magnesium; MPTB, moderate preterm birth; PIH, pregnancy-induced hypertension; PPROM,
preterm premature rupture of membranes; TB, term birth; V/C, first twin vaginal delivery
and second cesarean delivery.
Indications for delivery in the LPTB were shown in [Table 7]. Spontaneous delivery of LPTB was 63.6% (n = 131/206) and the rate of iatrogenic delivery in this late preterm cohort was 36.4%
(n = 75/206). The majority, 66.6% (n = 50/75), of these iatrogenic deliveries were deemed NEB, giving a total of 24.2%
(50/206) NEB deliveries in LPTB group. All the elective deliveries were between 360/7 and 366/7 weeks. The mean gestational age at delivery was higher in the NEB group (36.1 weeks)
than in the EB group (35.2 weeks; p < 0.001). In the univariate analysis, neonates in the NEB group had a lower median
length of stay in the neonatal intensive care unit (14 days versus 5 days, p < 0.032). The rates of the adverse neonatal composite outcomes (respiratory and nonrespiratory)
were not significantly different between NEB and EB groups.
Table 7
Indications for LPTB in twin pregnancies (n = 206)
|
Indications
|
n (%)
|
Cause of LPTB
|
|
Spontaneous preterm labor
|
69 (33.6)
|
Spontaneous
|
|
PPROM
|
41 (19.9)
|
Spontaneous
|
|
Spontaneous preterm labor/PPROM
|
21 (10.2)
|
Spontaneous
|
|
Severe preeclampsia/eclampsia/HELLP syndrome
|
15 (7.2)
|
Iatrogenic EB
|
|
Nonreassuring fetal status
|
9 (4.4)
|
Iatrogenic EB
|
|
Mild preeclampsia/gestational hypertension
|
21 (10.2)
|
Iatrogenic NEB
|
|
Intrauterine growth restriction and/or oligohydramnios
|
13 (6.3)
|
Iatrogenic NEB
|
|
No clear indication (elective)
|
12 (5.8)
|
Iatrogenic NEB
|
|
Other indications[a]
|
5 (2.4)
|
Iatrogenic EB and NEB
|
Abbreviations: EB, evidence-based; HELLP syndrome; hemolysis, elevated liver enzymes,
low platelet count; LPTB, late preterm birth; NEB, non-evidence-based; PPROM, preterm
premature rupture of membranes.
a One abruption, one cholestasis of pregnancy, two placentae previae, one prior classical
cesarean.
Discussion
In this cohort study, we sought out to estimate the increased perinatal risk associated
with MPTB and LPTB in uncomplicated diamniotic twin pregnancies and to identify obstetric
indications leading to early nonspontaneous delivery. We found that the majority of
nonspontaneous LPTBs were NEB. In fact, 24.2% of our late preterm cohort was delivered
for NEB indications, many of which could be classified as perhaps “avoidable.” Due
to the well-established morbidity associated with LPTB, coupled with the higher than
anticipated rate of NEB deliveries, our findings underscore the need for a thorough
examination of indications leading to LPTB in twin pregnancies. Indeed, our results
implicated mild preeclampsia/gestational hypertension (10.2%), intrauterine growth
restriction with reassuring antenatal testing and/or oligohydramnios (6.3%), and no
clear cause (elective; 5.8%) as leading causes for NEB LPTB.
The rate of multifetal pregnancies, specifically twin gestations, has risen in recent
years, most likely as a consequence of fertility treatments and delayed childbearing.[12]
[13] Similarly, between 1980 and 2006, the percentage of births that were preterm rose
from 9.4 to 12.7%—a rise of nearly 30%.[1]
[13]
[14] The percentage of twins delivered preterm has risen more than singletons, from 48
to 60% in the last two decades.[14] Consequently, there has been increased focus on strategies aimed at decreasing the
rate of LPTBs, with attention on the specific indications for delivery in these cases.
Similar to findings by Gyamfi-Bannerman and colleagues, the majority of nonspontaneous
LPTB in our cohort were NEB.[15] The 24.2% rate of NEB deliveries in our LPTB patients is alarming. Even EB indications
for LPTB are still only based on level III evidence/expert opinion.[11] This finding underscores the need for critical examination of all the indications
for delivery in these patients.
The concept of composite adverse respiratory and nonrespiratory outcomes has previously
been well utilized.[16] We demonstrated a progressive increase in composite neonatal morbidity in twin pregnancies
that ended with MPTB and LPTB compared with term deliveries. These findings are similar
to and support those of the twin outcome study from the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Maternal-Fetal Medicine
Units Network.[16] We found respiratory distress syndrome to be the most common individual morbidity
with a 17-fold increase among MPTB and an 8-fold increase in LPTB compared with term
twins.
Infants born moderately preterm constitute approximately 32% of all preterm births
in the United States, with significant prematurity-related morbidities.[17] In one study, 45% of these babies required assisted ventilation and had a readmission
rate within 3 months of 11.2%.[17] Similarly, we found significantly higher composite respiratory and nonrespiratory
morbidity in MPTB when compared with LPTB and TB neonates. Thus a significant portion
of neonatal intensive care unit costs can be attributed to this group of patients,
further highlighting the need to reevaluate the risks, benefits, and cost implications
of earlier delivery in this group of patients.
We also need to weigh the risk of adverse neonatal outcomes against the risk of stillbirth
that increases with gestation. Perinatal mortality among twin births declined close
to 40% between 1989 and 2000.[18] This temporal trend of increasing twin preterm birth may actually be beneficial
insofar as preventing perinatal death and may be a topic worthy of continued research.[19]
This study has some limitations that merit discussion. This study was retrospective
in design and relied on chart review to establish diagnoses. Not all the pregnancies
were dated by early ultrasound examination and as a result, the percentage of LTPBs
is likely overestimated. It is possible that some diagnoses were over- or underdiagnosed,
which has the potential to bias our results. Although we did not consider NEB deliveries
as indicated, they may have been. However, to the best of our ability, we could not
see an evidence-based reason barring expectant management. Nevertheless, this is one
of the largest studies in twin pregnancies examining the indications and outcomes
for LPTB.
Conclusions
Our data demonstrate a high rate of LPTB among twin pregnancies, with over half of
nonspontaneous early deliveries due to NEB indications. Although our morbidity data
will be helpful to providers in counseling patients, our finding of high NEB indications
underscores the need for systematic evaluation of indications for delivery in LPTB
twin deliveries. Furthermore, this may lead to more effective LPTB rate reduction
efforts.