Key words
endothelin - hypertension - cardiovascular - marine natural products - microorganisms
- ecology
Introduction
More than three decades of research on marine natural products have exposed their
potential as antimicrobial, antiviral, antiparasitic, anticancer, anti-inflammatory,
neuroprotective, and immunomodulatory agents [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6]. However, very little is known about their cardioprotective potential [5], [6]. Cardiovascular disorders remain the main cause of mortality, morbidity, and health
care burden worldwide [7]. The endothelin system is a key player in many conditions associated with cardiovascular
disorders including hypertension, heart failure [7], [8], [9], and atherosclerosis [10]. The current literature regarding the screening of marine natural products for cardioprotection
focuses on well validated targets such as the angiotensin converting enzyme of renin-angiotensin-aldosteron
[11] and the endothelin receptors [12], [13], [14], [15]. The emerging data suggest that marine microorganisms are a suitable source of bioactive
lead compounds. In this review, we focus on marine natural products targeting the
inhibition of the endothelin system, their origin, their mechanism of action, and
their ecological relevance. Other marine natural products with cardiovascular activity
will also be briefly discussed.
The Endothelin System and Its Drug Targets
The Endothelin System and Its Drug Targets
Endothelin-1 (ET-1) is a potent vasoconstrictor and the predominant compound of the
endothelin family with the highest clinical relevance [16]. The biosynthesis of ET-1 starts with the large precursor protein of 212 amino acids
(AA) called preproendothelin–1 (PPET1), which is encoded by the ET-1 gene (EDN1) in
the human chromosome 6 ([Fig. 1]). Removal of a short secretory sequence generates proendothelin-1 (proET-1, 195
AA) [16]. In the cytosol, proET-1 is then cleaved by a furin-like endopeptidase producing
the 38 AA-peptide precursor big ET-1 [17]. This inactive fraction is next converted to ET-1 by endothelin converting enzyme-1
(ECE-1) which cleaves the Trp21–Val22 bond in the carboxylterminal of big ET-1 [18]. Big ET-1 can also be cleaved by human chymase and neutral endopeptidase (NEP) to
produce ET-1 [19]. The activation of EDN1 expression may be mediated by angiotensin II (Ang II), catecholamines,
cardiothropin-1, thrombin, growth factors, cytokines, free radicals, insulin, hypoxia,
shear stress, lipoproteins, cyclosporine, as well as by the same ET-1 ([Fig. 1]) [20], [21].
Fig. 1 Molecular overview of the endothelin system and the main drug targets for its inhibition.
Abbreviations: Akt, protein kinase B; Ang II, angiotensin II; big ET-1, big endothelin-1;
Ca2+, calcium; CA, catecholamines; CaM, calmodulin; CAP, c-Cbl-associated protein; CK,
cytokines; CT-1, cardiothropin-1; CY, cyclosporine; DAG, diacylglycerol; ET-1, endothelin-1;
ETA, endothelin receptor A; ETB, endothelin receptor B; EDN1, endothelin-1 gene; ECE, endothelin converting enzyme;
eNOS, endothelial nitric oxide synthase; GF, growth factors; GTP, guanosine 5′-triphosphate;
HX, hypoxia; IP3, inositol 1,4,5-triphosphate; IP3R, inositol 1,4,5-triphosphate receptor;
INS, insulin; LPP, lipoproteins; mRNA, messenger ribonucleic acid; MAPK, mitogen-activated
protein kinases; NEP, neutral endopeptidase; NO, nitric oxide; NP, natriuretic peptide;
PAK, p21-activated kinase; PG, prostaglandins; PI3K, phosphoinositide 3-kinase; PLC,
phospholipase C; PPET1, preproendothelin-1; proET-1, proendothelin-1; SS, shear stress;
THR, thrombin. (Color figure available online only.)
ET-1 mediates its effects by means of two G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs), namely
ETA, responsible for vasoconstriction and cell proliferation, and ETB, mainly responsible for vasodilatation, inhibition of cell growth and fluid retention,
and ET-1 clearance [21]. ET-1 acts as an autocrine/paracrine mediator, with similar affinity for both receptors
[20]. When ET-1 interacts with the ETA receptor, a G protein hydrolyzes phospholipase C to form diacylglycerol (DAG) and
inositol 1,4,5-triphosphate (IP3). IP3 increases cytoplasmic calcium (Ca2+) throuth activation of its receptors and transmembrane Ca2+ channels located on the endoplasmic reticulum resulting in vasoconstriction ([Fig. 1]) [22]. DAG can also lead to activation of proto-oncogenes including those involved in
the MAPK cascade [22].
Stimulation of ETB receptors leads to activation of phosphoinositide 3-kinase (PI3K) and downstream
activation of protein B kinase/Akt. The PI3K/Akt pathway is responsible for activation
of endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS), where nitric oxide (NO) antagonizes ET-1
synthesis via inhibition of PPET1 transcription. ETB receptors mediate the release of other vasodilators like prostaglandins and the endothelium-derived
hyperpolarizing factor [23].
The deleterious effects of ET-1 can be prevented by different mechanisms. They include
suppression of the expression of EDN1, translation of proET-1, and activation of ECE
and endothelin receptors [24], [25].
Endothelin-1 gene inhibitors
There is a specific gene that encodes for each precursor of the mature isoforms of
the endothelin family [21]. These genes are susceptible to inhibition by diverse factors. For instance, EDN1
expression may be inhibited by endothelium-derived NO, nitrovasodilators, natriuretic
peptides, heparin, and prostaglandins ([Fig. 1]) [20], [21], as well as high shear stress [26].
Endothelin converting enzyme, neutral endopeptidase and chymase inhibitors
Among the metalloproteases that may cleave big ET-1 to produce ET-1 are pepsin, cathepsin
D, and thiol proteases [26], which are sensitive to inhibition by phosphoramidon [27]. Another ECE inhibitor is R568 [28], a calcimimetic substance that induces changes in the synthesis of endothelial vasoactive
factors. In addition, NEP is an important enzymatic target which may be inhibited
by both phosphoramidon and thiorphon. The combination of NEP/ECE inhibition, as in
SLV 306 (daglutril), is a recent approach to reduce adverse effects produced by NEP
inhibition [29].
Endothelin receptor antagonists
Effective antagonism of endothelin receptors has been achieved by compounds like bosentan
(non-selective ETA/ETB), BQ-123 (selective ETA), BQ-788 (selective ETB) [24], [30], sitaxentan (selective ETA), atrasentan (selective ETA), ambrisentan (selective ETA), and darusentam (selective ETA) [24]. Selective antagonism of the ETA receptor has been effective for treating pulmonary arterial hypertension [24]. Potential underlying mechanisms include reducing pulmonary artery pressure, inhibiting
vascular remodeling, improving exercise capacity and pulmonary haemodynamics, and
reducing the Borg dyspnea index [21].
Although non-selective ETA/ETB receptor antagonism effectively decreases blood pressure, it causes vasoconstriction
by blockade of tonic endothelial ETB-receptor-mediated stimulation of NO and prostacyclin generation and affects the clearance
of circulating ET-1 ([Fig. 1]) [24]. Thus, the selection between selective and non-selective antagonism of endothelin
receptors depends on the individual patient response.
Marine Natural Products as Inhibitors of the Endothelin System
Marine Natural Products as Inhibitors of the Endothelin System
A number of marine natural products of diverse chemical structures have been found
to possess cardiovascular activities. These include small peptides produced by enzymatic
hydrolisis of marine proteins, chitosan derivatives, and phlorotanins which inhibit
the angiotensin converting enzyme [11]; xestoquinone ([Fig. 2], 1), a pentacyclic quinone with inotropic activity and capacity to inhibit Na/K-ATPase
[31] obtained from Xestospongia sapra; D-polymannuronic sulfate ([Fig. 2], 2) obtained from brown algae that increase NO and decrease plasma levels of Ang II
and ET-1 [32]; and xestospongin C ([Fig. 2], 3) an alkaloid from Xestospongia exigua, spongosine ([Fig. 2], 4) a nucleoside from Cryptotethia crypta
[34], 12-epi-scalaradial ([Fig. 2], 5) a sesterpene from Hyrtios erecta
[33], and eledoisin ([Fig. 2], 6), a peptide from Eledone sp.
[35] with hypotensive activity.
Fig. 2 Marine and soil derived natural products with cardiovascular actions. (Color figure
available online only.)
The majority of natural products capable of inhibiting the endothelin system have
been obtained from microorganisms and plants of terrestrial origin. Since the discovery
of the cyclic pentapeptide BE-18257B ([Fig. 2], 7) in the bacteria Streptomyces misakiensis
[36], which originated the first selective endothelin ETA receptor antagonist BQ-123 [37], more attention has been given to finding endothelin antagonists within microorganisms.
Bacteria
Following the discovery of BE-18257B, two more binding inhibitors of endothelin receptors
were identified in soil-born Streptomyces, i.e., the benzo[α]anthraquinones WS009 A and B ([Fig. 2], 8–9) ([Table 1]) [38]. Blastorbacter sp. has been the one bacteria obtained from sea water, from which the non-peptide metalloprotease
inhibitor B90063 ([Fig. 2], 10) has been obtained [39]. B90063 inhibits both ECE and NEP, preventing the generation of ET-1 ([Table 1]). Other inhibitors of ECE were the benzo[α]naphthacene quinones WS79089 A, B, and C ([Fig. 2], 11–13) ([Table 1]) obtained from the soil-born Streptosporangium roseum 79 089 ([Fig. 2]) [40].
Table 1 Natural products from microorganisms and marine sponges acting as inhibitors of the
endothelin system.
|
Compound
|
Number of structure
|
Chemistry
|
ORGa
|
Species
|
Origin
|
MMOAb
|
IC50 (µM)
|
Ref.
|
|
a ORG: type of organism. BA: Bacteria; EU: Eubacteria; FU: Fungi; PO: Porifera. b MMOA: molecular mechanism of action. ETA/ETB: receptor binding inhibition of [125I]ET-1; ETs: undetermined endothelin receptors; ECE: inhibition of endothelin converting
enzyme; NEP: inhibition of neutral endopeptidase; ARA: receptor mediated arachidonic
acid release. c UN: undetermined
|
|
BE-18257B
|
7
|
cyclic pentapeptide
|
BA
|
Streptomyces misakienses
|
Soil
|
ETA
|
3.0
|
[36]
|
|
WS009 A
|
8
|
benz[α]anthraquinone
|
BA
|
Streptomyces sp. 89 009
|
Soil
|
ETs
|
5.8
|
[38]
|
|
WS009 B
|
9
|
benz[α]anthraquinone
|
BA
|
Streptomyces sp. 89 009
|
Soil
|
ETs
|
67.0
|
[41]
|
|
B-90063
|
10
|
pyridone
|
BA
|
Blastobacter sp. SANK 71 894
|
Sea water
|
ECE/NEP.
|
1.0/66.0
|
[39]
|
|
WS79089 A
|
11
|
benzo[α]naphtacen quinone
|
EU
|
Streptosporangium roseum 79 089
|
Soil
|
ECE
|
0.7
|
[40]
|
|
WS79089 B
|
12
|
benzo[α]naphtacen quinone
|
EU
|
Streptosporangium roseum 79 089
|
Soil
|
ECE
|
0.1
|
[40]
|
|
WS79089 C
|
13
|
benzo[α]naphtacen quinone
|
EU
|
Streptosporangium roseum 79 089
|
Soil/
|
ECE
|
3.4
|
[40]
|
|
Stachybocin A
|
14
|
drimane sesquiterpene
|
FU
|
Stachybotrys sp. M 6222
|
Soil
|
ETA/ETB
|
13.0/7.9
|
[41]
|
|
Stachybocin B
|
15
|
drimane sesquiterpene
|
FU
|
Stachybotrys sp. M 6222
|
Soil
|
ETA/ETB
|
12.0/9.5
|
[41]
|
|
Stachybocin C
|
16
|
drimane sesquiterpene
|
FU
|
Stachybotrys sp. M 6222
|
Soil
|
ETA/ETB
|
15.0/9.4
|
[41]
|
|
Spirodihydro-benzofuranlactam VI
|
17
|
drimane sesquiterpene
|
FU
|
Stachybotrys chartarum
|
Soil
|
ETA
|
1.5
|
[45]
|
|
RES-1149-1
|
18
|
drimane sesquiterpene
|
FU
|
Aspergillus sp. RE-1149
|
UNc
|
ETA/ETB
|
25.8/1.6
|
[46]
|
|
RES-1149-2
|
19
|
drimane sesquiterpene
|
FU
|
Aspergillus sp. RE-1149
|
Soil
|
ETB
|
20.0
|
[46]
|
|
Drimane 1
|
20
|
drimane sesquiterpene
|
FU
|
Aspergillus ustus var. pseudodeflectus X3811
|
Desert soil
|
ETA/ETB
|
155.0/50
|
[47]
|
|
Drimane 2
|
21
|
drimane sesquiterpene
|
FU
|
Aspergillus ustus var. pseudodeflectus X3811
|
Desert soil
|
ETA/ETB
|
80.0/55.0
|
[47]
|
|
Drimane 3
|
22
|
drimane sesquiterpene
|
FU
|
Aspergillus ustus var. pseudodeflectus X3811
|
Desert soil
|
ETA/ETB
|
65.0/21.0
|
[47]
|
|
Drimane 5
|
23
|
drimane sesquiterpene
|
FU
|
Aspergillus ustus var. pseudodeflectus X3811
|
Desert soil
|
ETA/ETB
|
50.0/70.0
|
[47]
|
|
Isochromophilone III
|
24
|
azaphilones
|
FU
|
Penicillium sclerotiorum X11853
|
Tropical forest stream
|
ETA/ETB
|
9.0/77.0
|
[13]
|
|
Isochromophilone III dechloro analogue
|
25
|
azaphilones
|
FU
|
Penicillium sclerotiorum X11853
|
Tropical forest stream
|
ETA/ETB
|
28.0/172.0
|
[13]
|
|
(8R)-7-deacetyl-O
8,8-dihydro-7-epi-sclerotiorin
|
26
|
azaphilones
|
FU
|
Penicillium sclerotiorum X11853
|
Tropical forest stream
|
ETA/ETB; ARA
|
5.0/50.0; 33.0
|
[13]
|
|
(+)-sclerotiorin
|
27
|
azaphilones
|
FU
|
Penicillium sclerotiorum X11853
|
Tropical forest stream
|
ETA/ETB
|
75.0/12.0
|
[13]
|
|
5-chloroisorotiorin
|
28
|
azaphilones
|
FU
|
Penicillium sclerotiorum X11853
|
Tropical forest stream
|
ETA/ETB
|
35.0/8.0
|
[13]
|
|
Ochrephilone
|
29
|
azaphilones
|
FU
|
Penicillium sclerotiorum X11853
|
Tropical forest stream
|
ETA/ETB
|
26.0/85.0
|
[13]
|
|
RES-1214-1
|
30
|
diphenyl ether
|
FU
|
Pestalotiopsis sp.
|
Soil
|
ETA
|
14.9
|
[51]
|
|
RES-1214-2
|
31
|
diphenyl ether
|
FU
|
Pestalotiopsis sp.
|
Soil
|
ETA
|
49.7
|
[51]
|
|
34-Sulfatobastadin 13
|
32
|
bromotyrosine
|
PO
|
Ianthella sp.
|
Sandy-rubble reef
|
ETA
|
39.0
|
[12]
|
|
Halistanol disulfate B
|
33
|
sulfated sterol
|
PO
|
Pachastrella sp.
|
Marine rocky substrate
|
ECE
|
2.1
|
[53]
|
Fungi
An interesting fact is that compounds obtained from soil-born fungi, which exhibited
endothelin receptor binding capacity, were also found in fungi from marine habitats.
This is the case of the spirocyclic drimanes stachybocin A and B ([Fig. 2], 14–15) isolated from Stachybotrys sp. M6222 found in soil [41] and Stachybotrys sp. MF347 found in driftwood [42]. Drimane sesquiterpenoids have been commonly isolated from marine-derived fungi
specially those associated with mangrove [43] and sponges [44]. Dimeric spirodihydrobenzofuranlactam compounds [41], [45] and those with the sesquiterpene drimane skeleton [46], [47] ([Fig. 2], 17–23) inhibited the binding of [125I]ET-1 to both endothelin receptors, with a consistent preference for the ETB receptor ([Table 1]).
Azaphilones are another group of fungal metabolites found to be produced in fresh
[13] and sea water [48], [49], [50]. In contrast to the above mentioned drimanes, the group of bioactive azaphilones
found in Penicillium sclerotirum X11853 inhibited the binding of [125I]ET-1 to both endothelin receptors, with a consistent preference for the ETA receptor ([Fig. 2], 24–29) ([Table 1]) [13].
Other compounds like diphenyl ether RES-1214-1 and -2 ([Fig. 2], 30–31) obtained from soil-born Pestalotiopsis sp. also inhibited the binding of [125I]ET-1 to the ETA receptor [51].
Porifera
Although marine invertebrates, especially sponges, have been claimed as the largest
source of chemically diverse marine natural products [52], it is intriguing why information on cardiovascular activity of compounds obtained
from sponges is scarce. The literature shows that two compounds obtained from sponges
have been identified as inhibitors of the endothelin systems. The first is 34-sulfatobastadin
13 ([Fig. 2], 32), a bromotyrosine derivative which inhibited the binding of [125ET-1] to the ETA receptor [12], and the second is the novel sterol sulfate halistanol disulfate B ([Fig. 2], 33) that inhibited ECE ([Table 1]) [53].
Ecological Significance of Natural Inhibitors of the Endothelin System
Ecological Significance of Natural Inhibitors of the Endothelin System
The majority of the active natural products found within this group are drimane sesquiterpenes.
Terpenes have been thought to play a critical role in antagonistic or mutualistic
interactions among organisms. They are associated with defense mechanisms in terrestrial
as well as in marine environments. In both habitats, molecules with deterrent and
antimicrobial activity are the typical chemical defenses of sedentary, slow-moving,
or otherwise poorly defended organisms [54].
Drimane sesquiterpenes are potent antimicrobials and believed to deter feeding on
plants and sponges by acting directly on taste receptors [54]. Interestingly, taste receptors belong to the GPCR family as so the endothelin receptors
[55], [56]. Thus, it is possible that drimanes are non-selective GPCR ligands, which might
explain their ability to bind ETA and ETB. The microorganisms reviewed in this work, which produce these sesquiterpenes, are
frequently present in association with sponges, corals, and algae, thus validating
their ecological significance in the marine ecosystem.
The significance of sulfated polysaccharides as the vasoactive D-polymannuronic sulfate ([Fig. 2]) [32] in the marine environment is not completely understood. Sulfated polysaccharides
are known to be largely species-specific and involved in cell matrix interactions,
cell signaling and development [57]. They represent an enormous source of different chemical structures with the advantage
of a lower risk to patients [57].
Additionally, peptides are another group of compounds from microbes and sponges that
act on the endothelin system. These substances are believed to belong to their classical
chemical defense machinery [58], [59].
Discussion
Microorganisms are a major source for new drugs with more than 50 000 microbial natural
products playing an important role in drug discovery [60]. The majority of these have been isolated from terrestrial-borne microbes [60], possibly because they were more readily available when compared to marine microbes.
The available literature shows that the search for natural inhibitors of the endothelin
system has been done mainly in land, yielding a wide variety of chemical compounds.
Even though this search produces a biased sampling, it is exciting to note that the
results accentuate the underestimated potential of microorganisms for producing leads
with cardioprotective potential.
While the question may rise whether the inhibitory activities found for the compounds
described in this review are of therapeutic relevance or not, it is worth mentioning
that lead compounds may have considerably low activities (IC50 values in the micromolar range) and still hold the potential to become very potent
drugs after few modifications. For example, the selective ETA receptor antagonist BQ123 (IC50 = 7.3 nM) [37], is a semisynthetic product obtained from the natural product BE-18257B (IC50 = 3.0 μM) ([Table 1]).
Oceans encompass a stressful and competitive habitat with unique conditions of pH,
temperature, pressure, oxygen, light, nutrients, and salinity, all of which force
organisms to adapt both chemically and physiologically to survive in it [1], [40]. The corresponding modifications in gene regulation and metabolic pathways increase
the chances of finding unique and complex natural products that differ from organisms
living in terrestrial habitats [1], [40].
The large display of novel and complex chemical structures found in marine natural
products as well as the extension of their therapeutic applications, support the marine
environment as a promising source of new drugs. The increasing number of bioactive
natural products from marine-derived fungi presents a great challenge and sets high
expectations in finding, in these groups of organisms, new leads for the protection
of the cardiovascular system.
Acknowledgements
The authors gratefully acknowledge the National Secretariat for Science, Technology
and Innovation (SENACYT) of the Republic of Panama for financial support through the
incentive program of the National Innovation System (SNI) as well as through grants
COL08-014 and COL10-070. Thanks are also due to IFARHU from the Panamanian government,
which jointly with SENACYT awarded a scholarship to Ms. Nadir Planes.