Key words
ExtraCorporeal Membrane Oxygenation (ECMO) - ExtraCorporeal Life Support (ECLS) -
cardiopulmonary bypass - CT angiography - imaging pitfalls
Introduction
Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation is becoming increasingly established as an emergency
treatment in patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) and/or cardiovascular
failure. Depending on the type of cannulation, the support of gas exchange and thus
pulmonary function (ECMO = extracorporeal membrane oxygenation) or cardiac function
for circulatory support (ECLS = extracorporeal life support) is partially or completely
taken over.
Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation was developed in the 1970 s [1]. A significant increase in ECMO treatment was triggered by confirmation of a survival
advantage in the CESAR study (conventional ventilatory support versus ECMO for severe
adult respiratory failure) [2] and by the H1N1 virus pandemic in 2009 [3]. In 2014, over 14,000 adult patients at 251 centers worldwide were registered at
the extracorporeal life support organization (ELSO) for ECLS therapy. The number has
more than doubled in the last 10 years. The survival rates were 65 % in the case of
solitary respiratory failure, 56 % in the case of cardiac failure and 39 % after reanimation
[4].
Since ECMO/ECLS therapy and also the primary diseases requiring therapy have a high
complication rate, patients often undergo diagnostic imaging during their intensive
care stay. Radiologists can be confronted with this issue bedside in the intensive
care unit in the case of ultrasound and projection radiography as well as in the case
of computed tomography (CT) and, less frequently, angiography. Knowledge of the ECMO/ECLS
systems being used and the hemodynamic changes due to the extracorporeal circulation
and of possible artificial contrast enhancement phenomena is therefore essential for
examination planning and image interpretation.
ECMO and ECLS systems: Design and variants
ECMO and ECLS systems: Design and variants
An ECMO or ECLS system generally includes an extracorporeal blood circuit with a venous
outflow cannula and a venous or arterial inflow cannula. The deoxygenated blood is
pumped by a centrifugal pump through a membrane oxygenator and is enriched with oxygen
while carbon dioxide is removed. The oxygenated blood is returned to the systemic
circulation via the inflow cannula [5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[9]. There are two different methods depending on the type of cannulation [10]
[11]:
Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO)
The veno-venous support system serves in the case of isolated severe hypoxemic respiratory
distress to ensure vital gas exchange and is referred to as "classic" ECMO therapy
(syn.: vv-ECMO) [12]
[13]. The blood that is removed venously and is oxygenated and decarboxylated extracorporeally
is returned to the venous system or the right atrium. Systemic blood flow and blood
pressure are ensured by heart function regardless of the extracorporeal flow so that
sufficient cardiac pump function is a requirement [5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[14]
[15].
In femoroatrial ECMO, the venous outflow cannula is placed transfemorally in the inferior
vena cava ideally below the branches of the hepatic veins. The diameter – usually
between 21 and 29 French in adults – determines the maximum achievable flow rate that
is usually 60 ml/kg KG/min (80 ml/kg KG/min in children, and 100 ml/kg KG/min in newborns).
The blood is returned through the superior vena cava into the right atrium. In the
femorofemoral variant, the outflow cannula is positioned in the distal inferior vena
cava. The blood is returned through the ipsilateral or contralateral femoral vein
into the right atrium. In both variants, it must be ensured that the tip of the inflow
cannula is pointing in the direction of the tricuspid valve so that recirculation
of the blood through the extracorporeal circuit is minimized ([Fig. 1]). Alternatively, it is possible to use a double lumen cannula (13 – 31 Fr) that
is positioned through the internal jugular vein and the right atrium with the tip
in the inferior vena cava [6]
[12]
[13]
[16]
[17].
Fig. 1 ECMO venous outflow cannula in the inferior vena cava and inflow cannula placement
through the superior vena cava in the right atrium, illustration A and radiographic correlation B. Positive enteric contrast after use as prokinetic agent. Pneumonia.
Extracorporeal life support (ECLS)
In the case of treatment-refractory cardiac failure or combined heart-lung failure,
veno-arterial support is used to maintain systemic perfusion. This is referred to
as ECLS therapy [10]
[12]
[13]. The term veno-arterial ECMO therapy (va-ECMO) is often used as a synonym in the
clinical routine as well as the literature.
The venously drained, extracorporeally oxygenated blood is returned to the aorta while
avoiding the pulmonary circulation. The systemic blood flow is thus comprised of the
extracorporeal ECLS volume and the ejection fraction of the left ventricle [5]
[6]. In the case of poor pulmonary and cardiac function, the oxygen supply in the aortic
arch, the coronary arteries, and the supraaortic vessel branches is limited and can
be optimized by an increase in the ECLS flow rate. However, based on the increased
aortic resistance, this can result in increased impairment of left ventricular function
[1]
[14].
ECLS can be connected peripherally as well as centrally [7]
[10]
[12]
[13]
[16]:
In the case of peripheral ECLS, venous drainage is performed via the inferior vena
cava or the superior vena cava. The blood is returned to the aorta typically in a
retrograde manner via the femoral artery with the cannula positioned in the descending
thoracic aorta. Alternatively the subclavian artery or the axillary artery can also
be used. The diameters of commonly used inflow cannulas are between 18 and 24 French.
In the case of central ECLS, the cannula is positioned in the right atrium and the
aorta after thoracotomy. It is accordingly full of complications but provide maximum
cardiac support ([Fig. 2]).
Fig. 2 Schematic representation of the femorofemoral peripheral ECLS A. Peripheral ECLS with arterial cannula in the axillary artery (red arrow) and venous
drainage cannula in the superior vena cava (blue arrow) B. Central ECLS with venous cannula in the right atrium (blue arrow) and arterial cannula
in the ascending aorta (yellow arrow); the part of the arterial tract proximal to
the aorta is made of Dacron and is not radiopaque C.
[Table 1] summarizes the clinically relevant information on ECMO– and ECLS–Systems.
Table 1
Summary of clinically relevant information on ECMO- and ECLS-Systems.
|
outflow cannula
|
inflow cannula
|
function
|
|
cannulation site
|
tip position
|
cannulation site
|
tip position
|
|
ECMO
(syn. VV-ECMO)
|
femoral vein
|
inferior vena cava
|
cervical vein
femoral vein
|
superior vena cava
right atrium
|
gas exchange
|
|
ECLS
(syn. VA-ECMO)
|
femoral vein
|
inferior vena cava
superior vena cava
|
axillary/subclavian artery
carotid artery
femoral artery
thoracic bypass
|
thoracic aorta
|
gas exchange
circulatory support
|
Complications
ECMO/ECLS therapy is associated with a high mortality rate specified as being between
47 % and 61 % in a metaanalysis [18]. Whether and to what extent this is to be attributed to the general condition of
the patient and the patient's comorbidities or to technical and therapy-associated
procedures remains unclear.
Systemic reaction to extracorporeal surfaces
In the initial days after connection of the ECMO/ECLS, the critical disease of the
patient and the contact of the blood with the large, non-endothelial foreign surfaces
of the extracorporeal system result in a systemic, complement-mediated, inflammatory
reaction and activation of coagulation and fibrinolysis [6]
[7]. This can be expressed in the form of increased vasodilation with pleural effusion,
ascites, and anasarca as well as worsening of acute pulmonary failure. Restrictive
fluid therapy in the initial days improves pulmonary function. Plain radiographs of
the thorax show initial worsening of pulmonary function with increasing interstitial-alveolar
pulmonary edema to the complete presentation of "white lung" ([Fig. 3]). Clinical examination and an ultrasound of the abdomen confirm anasarca and ascites
[9]
[19].
Fig. 3 Initial worsening of pulmonary function ("white lung") during ECMO therapy B; inflow cannula – white arrow, outflow cannula – black arrow.
A differentiation is made between technical and patient-related systemic complications
in the case of the following additional risks [9]
[20].
Cannula positioning
When positioning the ECMO/ECLS cannulas, vessel injury with dissection or bleeding
can occur. Local puncture-related complications can typically be diagnosed bedside
via ultrasound.
Cannula position
Projection radiography is used to ensure that the cannulas are in the correct position.
Therefore, depending on the cannulation site, both chest X-rays and plain films of
the abdomen are necessary [16]
[19].
If the tips of the two cannulas are too close together in veno-venous ECMO, the blood
primarily flows through the extracorporeal circuit from one cannula to the next so
that the pulmonary circulation and thus also the systemic circulation primarily receive
insufficiently oxygenated blood due to the recirculation [5]
[13]
[16]
[17] ([Fig. 4]).
Fig. 4 Femoroatrial ECMO with possible recirculation due to close proximity of the inflow
and outflow cannulas in the right atrium; inflow cannula – white arrow, outflow cannula
– black arrow.
If the arterial cannula in ECLS is positioned in the ascending aorta, the afterload
is increased so that left ventricular pump failure can occur. If the position of the
arterial cannula is too distal in the descending aorta, the oxygen supply of the coronary
arteries and the extra- and intracranial arteries can be reduced [5]. Every change in the position of cutaneously fixed cannulas in projection radiography
is suspicious for the complication of cannula dislocation [11]
[16].
After successful therapy and removal of ECLS systems, a pseudoaneurysm can form as
a complication in the region of the previous arterial puncture site. As an extremely
rare complication, torn off hose segments can remain in situ ([Fig. 5]).
Fig. 5 Postoperative complications after removal of ECLS: Pseudoaneurysm of the subclavian
artery (red arrow) A; retained arterial cannula fragment (yellow arrow) with a persisting arterial fistula
to the subclavian artery (green arrow) B.
Thrombus formation in the extracorporeal system
The most common mechanical complication is thrombus formation in the extracorporeal
circuit. Thrombi form primarily at the oxygenator or at the hose connection points,
particularly in the case of contraindicated systemic anticoagulation [5]. Thrombi can result in dysfunction of the oxygenator. However, they can also be
rinsed into the systemic or pulmonary circulation.
Rare technical complications
Technical failure of the membrane oxygenator in the case of an increase in thrombus
formation or failure of the pump can occur in the case of a long treatment duration
so that component replacement must be performed on an emergency basis [5]
[20].
Extremity ischemia
Depending on the diameter of the implanted arterial cannula, ischemia of the dependent
extremity segments can occur. An additional arterial cannula can be inserted on a
prophylactic basis for perfusion of the distal segments [5]
[19]. In addition, the risk of an arterial vascular occlusion with an increase in appositional
thrombus formation, particularly arising from existing arteriosclerosis, is increased.
In a metaanalysis, vascular complications with extremity ischemia are described in
up to 17 % of patients [21].
Bleeding
Bleeding complications are the most common complications during ECMO/ECLS therapy
[9]
[11]
[15]. The causes have a multifactorial genesis. Intensive care patients have an imbalance
between pro- and anticoagulatory factors, resulting in the presence of thrombocytopenia,
for example. The connected extracorporeal circuit results in thrombocyte activation,
an inflammatory reaction, and consumption of coagulation factors and can ultimately
result in disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC). Hemolysis is also a possible
complication. To prevent embolisms, systemic anticoagulation is necessary. The implanted
venous and/or arterial vascular accesses also have a large diameter [7]. Cannula-associated bleeding can be an indication of loosening or dislocation of
the cannulas. Oozing hemorrhage from the cutaneous or subcutaneous vessels often occurs
[15].
Primary sonographic diagnosis is performed in the intensive care unit. Fatal bleeding
can be ubiquitous. A greater occurrence of postoperative bleeding, particularly after
thoracotomy, has been observed [15]. Intracerebral bleeding is typically extensive and necessitates emergency neurosurgery.
Spontaneous bleeding into the parenchymal organs, thorax or peritoneum has been observed
([Fig. 6]). Gastrointestinal bleeding occurs in the case of esophagitis, gastritis, or gastroduodenal
ulcers. Therefore, stress prophylaxis in the intensive care unit is important. Damage
to the mucosa during intensive care treatment, e. g. during placement of a feeding
tube or tracheal cannula, can cause bleeding. Computed tomography and an absolute
emergency indication are often necessary to diagnose bleeding complications [7].
Fig. 6 Bleeding complications like hematothorax (#) A or retroperitoneal hematoma (*) during ECMO/ECLS therapy B; outflow cannula – white arrow.
Venous thromboembolisms
The risk of thrombus formation is increased during ECMO/ECLS therapy due to the above-described
inflammatory reaction with activation of the coagulation cascade [7]. Thrombi can form in the extracorporeal circuit (see above). Thrombus formation
in the venous vascular system is described in up to 10 % of patients [18]. The rinsing of thrombi into the systemic circulation can result in pulmonary artery
embolisms or stroke ([Fig. 7]). Peripheral thrombus formation is primarily diagnosed with ultrasound. Computed
tomography is needed to diagnose thrombi that have been carried to the periphery or
into the supraaortic vessels. An ischemic stroke can be treated, for example, primarily
with interventional neuroradiology via thrombectomy depending on the affected vascular
segment.
Fig. 7 Bilateral pulmonary artery embolisms (white arrows) secondary to ECMO therapy.
Left heart insufficiency and aortic stasis
In the case of limited left heart function, stasis of the arterial blood in the left
ventricle, the left ventricular outflow tract, and the ascending aorta can occur [22]. Echocardiographic exclusion of thrombi is complicated by the often postoperatively
limited acoustic window so that computed tomography is needed for further diagnosis.
However, detection of thrombi with computed tomography can also be complicated by
a possible lack of contrast enhancement of the left heart.
Neurological complications
Neurological complications frequently occur during ECMO/ECLS therapy with the incidence
in the literature fluctuating greatly (8 – 50 %) [18]
[23]. The long-term result for patients is limited by the neurological consequences [23].
Due to the systemic anticoagulation, there is an increased risk of cerebral hemorrhage
during ECMO/ECLS therapy. Cerebral infarcts arise from thrombotic or air microembolisms
or occur on a territorial basis due to large thrombi. As a result of a poor cardiac
ejection fraction or therapy-associated acidosis, the development of hypoxic brain
damage is possible. Further diagnosis via CT angiography and CT perfusion can be complicated
by the position of the cannula in ECLS.
Organ failure
With a rate of 52 %, kidney failure that requires dialysis is a common complication
[18]. This must be taken into consideration in the case of intravenous contrast agent
application during CT. Liver failure is seen as a complication in up to 16 % of patients.
Infections
The risk of infection with bacterial pneumonia (33 %) or sepsis (26 %) is often higher
due to the condition of the often critically ill patients undergoing respiratory therapy
[18].
Imaging
Initial venous cannulation is typically performed interventionally under ultrasound
guidance, while peripheral arterial cannulation can be performed interventionally
as well as surgically. The central ECLS is connected surgically during thoracotomy.
In the further course, echocardiography/ultrasound and projection radiography are
the methods of choice for determining cannula position and cannula-associated complications
in the intensive care unit.
In the case of computed tomography, attention must be paid to hemodynamic changes
caused by the extracorporeal circuit. Peripheral-venous contrast agent administration
in the drainage area of the venous outflow cannula should be avoided to reduce dilution
effects as a result of passage through the ECMO or ECLS system. Therefore, contrast
agent injection is typically performed via a central venous access in intensive care
patients.
In the case of veno-venous ECMO, the oxygenated blood is conducted through the extracorporeal
circuit in an antegrade manner into the right atrium and mixes there with the central-venously
injected contrast agent. This non-contrast-enhanced "competitive flow" can be compensated
by increasing the contrast agent volume and the contrast agent flow rate or by temporarily
reducing the ECMO flow rate. To avoid the uncertainties of contrast agent timing,
additional use of a bolus tracking mechanism in the body region to be examined is
possible. However, the start of a possibly necessary manual examination in the event
that the previously defined threshold value is not reached must be factored in [11]
[14]
[25]
[26].
When using veno-arterial ECLS, the contrast enhancement of vessels depends on the
preserved cardiac pump function [25]
[26]
[27]. The oxygenated blood from the extracorporeal circuit flows back into the aorta.
The contrast agent injected in central venous manner passes the pulmonary circulation
in the case of still (partially) maintained cardiac pump function and flows in an
antegrade manner into the aorta so that mixing of contrast-enhanced "venous" antegrade
blood and non-contrast-enhanced extracorporeal arterial blood occurs. However, if
cardiac pump performance is so limited that the contrast agent is already being conducted
in a retrograde manner through the venous drainage cannula into the extracorporeal
circuit, there is a lack of contrast enhancement of the distal pulmonary vascular
system and the left heart. The contrast agent is then conducted through the extracorporeal
circuit directly into the arterial system. In the arterial CT phase, the following
contrast enhancement phenomena can thus occur:
Arterial pseudo-filling defect
In the case of preserved cardiac pump function, the corresponding artery appears completely
hypodense due to the retrograde return of the non-contrast-enhanced arterial blood
from the extracorporeal circuit so that the impression of a vascular occlusion can
be given. This must be taken into account in particular in the case of suspicion of
a stroke since, for example, in the case of inflow into the right axillary artery,
the impression of a vascular occlusion of the common carotid artery and the vertebral
artery as well as a perfusion deficit in CT perfusion can be given ([Fig. 8]).
Fig. 8 Pseudo-filling defect of the right subclavian (*) and carotid arteries caused by
ECLS inflow in the right subclavian artery (red arrow) (A – CT angiography, B – conventional angiography). Consecutive right hemispheric perfusion deficiency marked
by reduced CBF C.
Arterial pseudomembrane
If the CT scan is started during peripheral ECLS before complete contrast enhancement
of the left heart chambers has occurred, the different densities between the non-contrast-enhanced
blood and the contrast-enhanced blood can result in a sedimentation phenomenon in
the aorta so that the impression of a dissection membrane or an intramural hematoma
can be given [27]. This phenomenon occurs in particular during inflow of the blood into the descending
aorta with consecutive retrograde flow into the ascending aorta ([Fig. 9]). This is thus to be taken into consideration in particular in the case of limited
cardiac pump function and bolus tracking with the region of interest (ROI) in the
descending thoracic aorta. In the venous or "late" phase, this phenomenon is eliminated
as a result of the recirculation and homogenization of the contrast enhancement [11]
[14]
[27].
Fig. 9 Contrast-enhanced CT with pseudo-layering (*) in the ascending aorta during arterial
phase imaging under transfemoral ECLS (white arrow) A, B.
Contrast enhancement defect of the left heart and the pulmonary vascular system
In the case of severely compromised heart function, a high extracorporeal veno-arterial
flow must maintain systemic perfusion. Due to the high (retrograde) aortic resistance,
contrast enhancement of the left heart and possibly also of the pulmonary vascular
system does not occur ([Fig. 10]). Contrast agent is drained with the venous blood through the vena cava and is returned
directly to the aorta so that it is difficult to rule out a pulmonary artery embolism
[11]
[24]
[25]
[26].
Fig. 10 Filling defect of the left heart (green arrow) caused by retrograde contrast enhancement
of the ascending aorta during ECLS therapy A, B with high extracorporeal flow rate. Pericardial hematoma compressing the right atrium
and ventricle (*) and myocardial infarction (blue arrows) C; inflow cannula – red and yellow arrows.
A reduction of the ECLS flow of the pump or a complete pause by the cardiac technician
can help to prevent arterial contrast enhancement phenomena [9]
[18]
[25] provided that the clinical condition of the patient will allow this for the duration
of the examination. Alternatively, it is possible to inject the intravascular contrast
agent directly into the arterial ECLS cannula connected to the membrane oxygenator.
However, due to potential risks, such as air embolisms, this should be viewed critically
[11]
[19]. A supplementary late phase with weaker but homogeneous contrast enhancement can
often prove the above-mentioned phenomena to be artificial. The higher radiation exposure
is usually of secondary importance compared to the risk of the acute situation [14]. Moreover, an additional ultrasound examination can help to differentiate between
an artifact and a thrombus.
In rare cases, diagnostic and therapeutic angiography can be indicated for further
diagnosis and treatment, for example in the case of stroke diagnosis and therapy.
Depending on the cannulation, flow artifacts can also occur so that an arterial pseudo-filling
defect can also be observed and should not be misinterpreted as vascular occlusion.
In the case of therapeutic interventions, the insertion of stents against the arterial
flow through the extracorporeal system is complicated by the counter-current. Unintentional
displacement of the device must be avoided.
Summary
As a result of the rise in ECMO/ECLS treatment and the associated complications, radiological
diagnosis with ultrasound, projection radiography and computed tomography has become
increasingly important. Knowledge of the different types of cannulation and hemodynamic
changes is essential for intensive care physicians, cardiac technicians and radiologists
for optimal interdisciplinary planning and interpretation of examinations.