Keywords
spinal tumors - extramedullary - neurofibroma - dumbbell - laminoplasty
Introduction
Spinal nerve root neurofibromas (NFs) can arise throughout the spine and at multiple levels, and likely represent plexiform tumors based on the involvement of multiple nerve fascicles.[1] Cervical spinal neurofibromas (SNFs) are benign, well-defined, encapsulated tumors, usually arising from the nerve roots. NFs may present either as solitary lesions or as part of a syndrome, that is, neurofibromatosis 1 (NF-1) or von Recklinghausen's disease of the skin.[2]
[3] The etiology behind solitary NF is still unknown. Marocchio et al[3] considered solitary NFs to be hyperplastic hamartomatous malformations rather than neoplastic malformations. Anatomically, neck NFs are relatively rare, with slow painless growth. NFs are usually treated by excision, especially when they are symptomatic or disfiguring.[2] Based on their location, these tumors can take the form of a dumbbell-shaped mass. The dumbbell NFs are classified into nine types on the basis of extraforaminal extension.[4]
[5] Type I (within the spinal canal) and type IIa (extension up to the intervertebral foramen) NFs are usually approached through conventional hemilaminectomy or open-door laminoplasty.[5] Type IIb and IIc NFs pose a surgical challenge because the majority of these tumors lie in the extraforaminal region. Type III tumors are those which have both dural and foraminal constrictions. The anatomical knowledge of the posterolateral neck triangle and surgical corridors is needed for maximal safe excision.[4] The variability in terms of location, extent, and size of a dumbbell cervical SNF poses unique technical challenges to the surgeon.[4] The attachment of the extramedullary part to the surrounding tissues makes dumbbell tumors much important. Surgical expertise is offered over adjuvant radiotherapy as it is a benign disease. In this article, we present a study on type IIIb tumors, the intradural and extradural–paravertebral type with a different shape.
Case Presentation
A 26-year-old woman presented at our Department of Neurosurgery, Guwahati Neurological Research Centre (GNRC), Dispur, Guwahati, Assam, with a history of swelling over the right side of the neck ([Fig. 1]). This was gradually progressing in size but with no pain, tingling and numbness, or weakness of limbs. There was no bladder and bowel disturbance either. On presentation, the patient had no deficit. The computed tomography (CT) scan of her neck showed a bilobed soft-tissue density lesion. It was noted in the right paravertebral region of the neck at the C3–C4 disk level causing widening of the right C3 neural foraminal involving the C4 exiting nerve root. The lesion was seen abutting and displacing the spinal cord laterally at the C3–C4 level. The lesion showed mild central enhancement on postcontrast study feature, suggesting nerve sheath tumor, likely NF, involving the right C4 nerve root ([Fig. 2]). Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) revealed clear widening of the right C3–C4 neural foramen. A T2 mildly hyperintense ([Fig. 3]) and T1 isointense well-defined lesion was seen in the middle third of the neck on the right lateral aspect deep to the sternocleidomastoid muscle extending through the widened neural foramen. There was an intraspinal component of the lesion measuring about 10.5 cm × 1.7 cm ([Fig. 4]) effacing the right lateral thecal sac. There was compression and displacement of the cord to the left. The component of the lesion in neck measured approximately 4.1 cm × 2.5 cm ([Fig. 5]). Postcontrast scan revealed moderate enhancement of the lesion. There was compression of the right internal jugular vein (IJV). Features were suggestive of NF arising from the right C4 existing nerve root with both intra- and extraspinal components.
Fig. 1 Intraoperative image showing the large mass on the right neck.
Fig. 2 Sagittal view of the pre-op magnetic resonance imaging showing intradural extramedullary mass.
Fig. 3 Pre-op magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
Fig. 4 Pre-op magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
Fig. 5 Pre-op magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showing extension along the root up to the neck muscle.
Discussion
SNFs are benign, well-defined, encapsulated tumors, usually arising from the dorsal nerve roots. It is commonly present in the fourth and fifth decades of life.[6] The spinal canal diameter is quite narrow and its close proximity to vertebral artery (VA) ranks cervical SNFs as a technically arduous and demanding surgery. McCormick described dumbbell SNFs as tumors with a contiguous intraspinal, foraminal, or extraforaminal spread.[7] The term “dumbbell tumors” does not refer to the dumbbell shape, but it is a conceptual term meaning tumors that connect two or more separate regions, such as intradural, epidural, and paravertebral spaces. Therefore, tumors with intradural and intraforaminal involvement and with intraforaminal and paravertebral involvement are thus considered dumbbell tumors as described by Eden.[8]
[9] Nearly 80 to 85% of these tumors remain intradural, but an unfavorable subset spreads extradurally and forms a dumbbell-shaped mass.[4] For asymptomatic SNFs that do not create pressure on the spinal cord and important nerve roots, a close clinical and radiological follow-up is suggested. But surgical tumor resection is preferred in the tumors showing rapid growth and/or causing progressive neurodeficit.[10] The gold standard treatment for NFs continues to be surgery. In the head and neck, this often presents a challenge because complete excision of these benign tumors may result in greater morbidity due to the complicated anatomy. In some cases, complete excision may require sacrifice of the nerves, causing significant functional and locoregional deficits, or result in substantial cosmetic deformity.[2]
[3]
[11] The surgical strategy for an NF located in the middle or lower cervical spine is more complicated, and selection of the most appropriate approach remains controversial.[12] Difficulties have often been encountered with complete resection of dumbbell-shaped tumors extending into the intervertebral foramen of the middle and lower cervical spine. In case of large extraspinal component extending to the neck, a double approach through the neck and other through the lamina is needed, which may be done in a single stage or two stages. The surgical strategy for cervical trident-shaped (dumbbell variant) SNFs located in the middle and lower cervical spine (the C2–C6 region) opted here was the single-stage excision of the neck component followed by laminoplasty and excision of the intradural part ([Figs. 10], [11]). Complete resection of the lesion was performed without any complication ([Figs. 12], [13]). After a vigorous survey of the literature, the case presented here seems to represent the first ever case of a solitary trident-shaped spinal neurofibroma, which was excised without any complications. The objective of this study was to present and advocate the optimal practices for such unique lesions that will help provide the best care to the patients.
Fig. 10 Post-op magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
Fig. 11 Post-op magnetic resonance imaging.
Fig. 12 Post-op magnetic resonance imaging.
Fig. 13 Post-op magnetic resonance imaging.
