Long-term Outcome of Operative or Nonoperative Treatment of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Rupture -Is Sports Activity a Determining Variable?

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the long-term clinical outcome of operative versus nonoperative treatment of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency and to define its relationship with sports activity. Forty-six patients (37 male, 9 female, mean age, 33.6 ± 8.0 years) who underwent open ACL reconstruction using patellar tendon autograft and 25 patients (18 male, 7 female, mean age, 32.3 ± 9.9 years) who were treated nonoperatively were evaluated by the same two examiners at 5 - 7 and 10 - 13 years following injury. The evaluations included objective and subjective scoring (Lysholm, OAK, IKDC), instrumented testing (Cybex, KT 1000), radiographic evaluation, and assessments of sports activity, with respect to type, frequency and associated symptoms. According to Lysholm, OAK and IKDC scores, the operative group performed significantly (p < 0.05) better and was able to maintain increased involvement in sports, although both groups participated less over time. However, risks for degenerative joint changes were similar for both the operative and the nonoperative group. A significant (p < 0.05) correlation between participation in high-risk pivoting sports, such as soccer or basketball and osteoarthritic changes could be found for the nonoperative group, only. Sports activity represents an important variable not only affecting the outcome, but also influencing treatment decisions following ACL injuries.

Key words:

Anterior cruciate ligament injury, sports activity, treatment decision, outcome.

References

• 1 Casteleyn P P. Management of anterior cruciate ligament lesions: surgical fashion, personal whim or scientific evidence. Study of medium- and long-term results?.  Acta Orthop Belg. 1999;  65 327-339
• 2 Daniel D M. lnstrumented measurement of anterior knee laxity in patients with acute anterior cruciate ligament disruption.  Am J Sports Med. 1985;  13 401-407
• 3 Daniel D M, Stone M L, Dobson B E, Fithian D C, Rossman D J, Kaufman K R. Fate of the ACL-injured patient. A prospective outcome study.  Am J Sports Med. 1994;  22 632-644
• 4 Daniel D M, Fithian D C, Stone M L, Dobson B E, Luetzow W F, Kaufman K R. A ten-year prospective outcome study of the ACL-injured patient. OREF Clinical Research Award paper. Atlanta; 63rd Annual American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons Meeting February 1996
• 5 Fairbank T J. Knee joint changes after meniscectomy.  J Bone Joint Surg. 1948;  30B 664-670
• 6 Fetto J F, Marshall J L. The natural history and diagnosis of anterior cruciate ligament insufficiency.  Clin Orthop. 1980;  147 29-38
• 7 Fink C, Hoser C, Benedetto K P. Sportfähigkeit nach vorderer Kreuzbandruptur - Operative versus nicht operative Therapie.  Akt Traumatol. 1993;  23 371-375
• 8 Fink C, Hoser C, Benedetto K P. Arthroseentwicklung nach Ruptur des vorderen Kreuzbandes.  Unfallchirurg. 1994;  97 357-361
• 9 Frank C B, Jackson D W. The science of reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament.  J Bone Joint Surg. 1997;  79A 1556-1577
• 10 Giove T P, Miller S J, Kent B E, Sanford T L, Garrick J G. Non operative treatment of the torn anterior cruciate ligament.  J Bone Joint Surg. 1983;  65A 184-192
• 11 Hefti F, Müller W, Jakob R P, Staübli H U. Evaluation of knee ligament injuries with the IKDC form.  Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 1993;  1 226-234
• 12 Johnson R J, Eriksson E, Haggmark T, Pope M H. Five- to ten-year reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament.  Clin Orthop. 1984;  183 122-140
• 13 Jomha N M, Borton D C, Clingeleffer A J, Pinczewski L A. Long term osteoarthritic changes in anterior cruciate ligament reconstructed knees.  Clin Orthop. 1999;  358 188-193
• 14 Kannus P, Järvinen M. Conservatively treated tears of the anterior cruciate ligament. Long-term results.  J Bone Joint Surg. 1987;  68-A 1007-1012
• 15 Kipfer W C, Ballmer P M, Stäubli H U. Rekonstruktion mit der modifizierten Technik der Ligamentum-patellae Plastik nach Clancy: Analyse der Dreijahresergebnisse. In: Jakob RP, Stäubli HU (eds) Kniegelenk und Kreuzbänder. Berlin; Springer Verlag 1990: 399-411
• 16 Lysholm J, Gillquist J. Evaluation of knee ligament surgery results with special emphasis on use of a scoring scale.  Am J Sports Med. 1992;  10 150-154
• 17 McDaniel J W, Dameron T B. Untreated ruptures of the anterior cruciate ligament.  J Bone Joint Surg. 1980;  62A 696-705
• 18 Müller W, Biedert R, Hefti F, Jakob R P, Munzinger U, Stäubli H U. OAK knee evaluation. A new way to assess knee ligament injuries.  Clin Orthop. 1988;  232 37-50
• 19 Noyes F R, Mooar P A, Matthews D S, Buttler D L. The symptomatic anterior cruciate-deficient knee. Part 1. The long-term functional disability in athletically active individuals.  J Bone Joint Surg. 1983;  65A 154-162
• 20 Noyes F R, Mangine R E, Barber S. Early knee motion after open and arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.  Am J Sports Med. 1987;  15 149-160
• 21 Outerbridge R E. The etiology of chondromalacia patellae.  J Bone Joint Surg. 1961;  43B 752-757
• 22 Shelbourne K D, Whitaker H J, McCarroll J R, Rettig A C, Hirschman L D. Anterior cruciate ligament injury. Evaluation of intra-articular reconstruction of acute tears without repair. Two to seven year follow-up of 155 athletes.  Am J Sports Med. 1990;  18 484-489
• 23 Shelbourne K D, Rettig A C, Hardin G, Williams R I. Miniarthrotomy versus arthroscopic-assisted anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with autogenous patellar tendon graft.  Arthroscopy. 1993;  9 72-75
• 24 Wojtys E M, Huston L J. Neuromuscular performance in normal and anterior cruciate ligament-deficient lower extremities.  Am J Sports Med. 1994;  22 89-104