One-Pot Organocatalytic Direct Asymmetric Synthesis of γ-AminoAlcohol Derivatives

Córdova Armando. Synlett  2003,  1651 

The Scripps Research Institute, 10550 North Torrey Pines Road, La Jolla, CA 92037, USA
Addendum by the Editors of SYNLETT and the Publisher concerning the above-mentioned paper, which was

Received: May 21^st, 2003

Published online: August 25^th, 2003

Published in print: September 2^nd, 2003

A recent publication in Chemical and Engineering News (March 12^th, 2007, Volume 85, Number 12, pp. 35-38: ­”Giving Proper Credit, Ethics violations by a chemist in Sweden highlight science’s unpreparedness to deal with ­misconduct") has reported about the circumstances of the above-mentioned publication in Synlett.The author of the Synlett publication, Armando Córdova, is now affiliated with the Faculty of Science at the University of Stockholm, Sweden. An investigation of Professor Córdova was conducted by chemistry Professors Olov Sterner and Torbjörn Frejd of Lund University, Sweden. The Synlett publication was based on a manuscript sent in December 2002 to, but rejected by, The Journal of the ­American Chemical Society and in its earlier form it had the three authors Armando Córdova, James Turner, and Carlos Barbas III. The almost identical manuscript was sent subsequently to Tetrahedron Letters on February 17^th, 2003, with only Professor Córdova as the author. Although it was accepted for publication, it was retracted after intervention by Professor Carlos Barbas III (The Scripps Research Institute), who was Professor Córdova’s supervisor when he was affiliated with the Scripps Research Institute.Professor Córdova then submitted the manuscript to Synlett on May 21^st, 2003. The paper was accepted and published on August 25^th, 2003. Professor Carlos Barbas III has informed the Editors of Synlett and the Publisher that this ­publication is not an authorized contribution from the Scripps Research Institute.The report of Professors Olov Sterner and Torbjörn Frejd concludes:

”It is clear that Professor Córdova behaved unethically concerning the Synlett paper."It is much to the regret of the Editors and the Publisher of Synlett that the paper has been published in Synlett.