Keywords
Animal model - C1-esterase inhibitor - coagulation - contact activation system - thrombosis
Introduction
C1-esterase inhibitor (C1–INH), a plasma glycoprotein with a molecular weight of 104
kDa, belongs to the protein family of serine protease inhibitors (serpins) which regulate
the activity of serine proteases by inhibiting their catalytic activity ([1]). As the only known inhibitor of the activated serine proteases C1s and C1r, C1–INH
inhibits the classical pathway of the complement system. Furthermore, C1–INH is a
major inhibitor of the contact activation system due to its ability to inhibit the
activated serine proteases factor XIIa (FXIIa), factor XIa (FXIa), and plasma kallikrein
([2], [3]). Deficiency in C1–INH leads to the clinical manifestation of hereditary angioedema
(HAE), which is characterised by episodes of acute angioedema attacks in subcutaneous
or submucosal tissues such as the skin, larynx, or visceral organs ([4]). Subtypes of HAE are characterised by genetically reduced synthesis of C1–INH (type
I), functional deficiency of C1–INH (type II), or FXII mutations (type III), resulting
in increased bradykinin release upon stimulation of the contact activation system
([5]). HAE attacks can be treated effectively by administering exogenous C1–INH ([4], [5]). Due to its inhibitory effects on the complement and the contact activation systems,
C1–INH substitution restores normal haemostatic function and inhibits the excessive
formation of vasoactive peptides such as bradykinin, which mediate the formation of
angioedema.
Even though treatment with C1–INH purified from pooled human plasma has been demonstrated
to be safe for many years ([6], [7]), there have been recent reports suggesting increased risk of thromboembolic complications
associated with the use of C1–INH ([8], [9]), particularly beyond the approved clinical indications and doses. During off-label
administration of C1–INH to neonates and infants undergoing cardiopulmonary bypass
surgery at doses up to 500 IU/kg, i. e. 25 times higher than recommended for HAE patients,
to prevent capillary leakage, occasionally lethal thromboembolic complications in
the upper venous system were observed. These adverse events were believed to be at
least partly associated with C1–INH treatment due to its inhibitory effects on the
fibrinolytic system ([6], [10]). However, it should be noted that the induction of thrombosis in neonates under
surgery is highly complex. Central venous lines, surgically traumatised vessels, alteration
of coagulation by extracorporeal circulation, and the immature haemostatic system
of the newborn could considerably contribute to a thrombotic risk.
Horstick et al. ([11]) examined the cardioprotective effects of C1–INH using a pig model of coronary artery
occlusion and reperfusion, and reported protective effects of C1–INH at low doses
(< 100 IU/kg). However, adverse effects were observed at higher doses (≥100 IU/kg),
including clot formation (inhibiting blood aspiration from non-heparinised intravenous
[i. v.] catheters) and increased thrombin-antithrombin (TAT) levels. Another investigation
into the potential thrombogenicity of a C1–INH product using a rabbit stasis model
for venous thrombosis concluded that C1–INH presents a thrombogenic risk with a threshold
of between 100 and 200 IU/kg and a non-observed adverse effect level (NOAEL) of ≤
50 IU/kg ([12]). In contrast, Tassani et al. ([13]) demonstrated a clinical benefit of administering C1–INH at a dose of 100 IU/kg
in neonates undergoing arterial switch operations.
A recent retrospective data analysis based on reports from the United States Food
and Drug Administration’s Adverse Event Reporting System database resulted in 10 confirmed
cases of C1–INH product-associated thrombotic events in HAE patients using recommended
doses ([14]). However, the analysis did not allow any causal relationship between the investigated
drug treatment and adverse events to be established. Despite the possibility that
the thrombotic events associated with the specific C1–INH product may be related to
the use of catheters or underlying risk factors ([9]), further studies on the potential risk associated with C1–INH treatment are warranted.
To support the safety of a recombinant C1–INH product, Relan et al. ([15]) evaluated the effects of C1–INH treatment on coagulation and fibrinolysis in a
randomised clinical trial in symptomatic HAE patients. Infusion of the recombinant
C1–INH did not affect parameters reflecting activation of the coagulation and fibrinolytic
systems, such as levels of TAT, D-dimers, or plasmin-antiplasmin (PAP) complexes,
with the exception of the activated partial thromboplastin time (aPTT), which was
prolonged, and of prothrombin fragment 1+2 (F1+2) levels, which were decreased. However,
the baseline levels of F1+2, TAT, D-dimers, and PAP complexes were already elevated,
and aPTT was low to normal in the majority of these patients prior to recombinant
C1–INH treatment, indicating activation of both coagulation and fibrinolysis in HAE
patients. These data are supported by observations by Cugno et al. ([16]), who had previously suggested activation of the coagulation cascade in HAE patients
during attacks. Overall, Relan et al. ([15]) observed no thromboembolic events in HAE patients following recombinant C1–INH
treatment at doses up to 100 IU/kg.
Interestingly, antithrombotic effects were observed in a murine model of ischaemic
stroke upon C1–INH treatment ([17]), as well as in several preclinical thrombosis models, upon inhibition ([18], [19]) or genetic deletion ([20], [21]) of C1–INH target molecules, i. e. FXII and FXI.
Against this background, we conducted a preclinical study designed to complement previous
investigations and to provide further insight into the effects of C1–INH on the coagulation
system, as well as to further assess the risk of thrombotic complications following
administration of high doses of human plasma-derived C1–INH.
Materials and methods
Additional details of the methods are included in the Supplementary Material (available
online at www.thrombosis-online.com).
Animals and anaesthesia
Three to 4 months old Chinchilla Bastard (CHB) or New Zealand White (NZW) rabbits
were used. Except for plasma sampling for pharmacokinetic analysis, all treatments
were conducted upon anaesthesia induced by ketamine and xylazine.
Activity of C1-esterase and coagulation FXIa and FXIIa
Purified C1–INH obtained from pooled human plasma (Berinert®, CSL Behring, Marburg, Germany) was injected i. v. at a dose of 200 IU/kg to CHB
rabbits, and blood samples were collected at different time points. C1–INH activity
levels were analysed based on the inhibition of human C1-esterase activity (Berichrom® C1-In-hibitor, Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics Products, Marburg, Germany). Using
the same method, C1–INH activity was determined following i. v. infusion of cumulative
doses of 100, 400, and 800 IU/ kg C1–INH or equal volumes of isotonic saline (0.9
% sodium chloride) to CHB rabbits.
The activity of FXIa or FXIIa was assessed in plasma from CHB rabbits treated with
cumulative doses of C1–INH or equal volumes of isotonic saline, based on aPTT measurement
using the BCS® XP system (Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics Products).
Comparison of effects of C1-INH on coagulation in rabbit and human plasma in vitro
C1–INH efficacy was assessed, following addition of 10, 15, 20, 40, 60, and 80 IU/ml
C1–INH or equal volumes of saline into rabbit plasma or standard human plasma (SHP),
based on measurements of FXIa and FXIIa activity, aPTT and PT using the BCS® XP system (Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics Products).
Venous and arterial thrombosis
In vivo models of venous thrombosis
Venous thrombosis was investigated in NZW rabbits using the Wessler model ([22]) modified by Giles et al. ([23]). Venous stasis was induced for 30 min following single i. v. administrations of
isotonic saline, Feiba® NF 500 E (Factor Eight Inhibitor Bypassing Activity, Baxter, Unterschleissheim, Germany)
at doses of 5, 10, 25, 50, or 100 IU/kg and C1–INH at doses of 200, 400, and 800 IU/kg.
Thrombus score and thrombus wet weight were assessed, as described in the Supplementary
Material (available online at www.thrombosis-online.com).
Thrombus wet weight was also assessed after 3 hours (h) of venous stasis which was
induced at the end of the administration of C1–INH cumulative doses (100, 400, and
800 IU/kg) or equal volumes of isotonic saline. Prior to each infusion and after the
last infusion, blood samples were drawn for analysis of coagulation markers (see “In vitro coagulation assays”).
In vivo model of arterial thrombosis
C1–INH (800 IU/kg) or an equal volume of isotonic saline were infused to CHB rabbits.
Thereafter, arterial thrombosis was induced using a modification of the method originally
described by Reimann-Hunziger ([24]) and Kurz et al. ([25]). Shortly, both femoral arteries were treated with 70 % ferric chloride (FeCl3) for 60 minutes (min) while arterial occlusion was assessed for up to 90 min, using
a flow module TS420 and perivascular flow probes (Transonic Systems Inc., Ithaca,
NY, USA).
In vitro coagulation assays
The assessment of coagulation by in vitro assays was performed following either i. v. treatment of CHB rabbits at cumulative
doses of C1–INH (100, 400, and 800 IU/kg) or equal volumes of isotonic saline, as
described in “In vivo models of venous thrombosis” or addition of C1–INH to rabbit plasma, SHP, or washed
platelets derived from rabbit whole blood.
Thrombus formation and fibrinolysis using thromboelastography
Overall clot formation was assessed by determination of throm-boelastographic parameters
(clot formation time [CFT], clotting time [CT], maximum clot firmness [MCF]) using
the Rotem® 05 system (Tem International, Munich, Germany). Coagulation of citrated whole blood
from C1–INH or isotonic saline treated CHB rabbits was activated by use of INTEM,
EXTEM, or NATEM.
Fibrinolysis was induced by addition of tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) (0.1 µg/ml;
Actilyse®, Boehringer Ingelheim, Biberach, Germany) to rabbit whole blood from C1–INH or isotonic
saline treated CHB rabbits, followed by addition of EXTEM; the lysis index 60 (LI60)
was measured.
Platelet aggregation
Platelets were activated within heparinised whole blood (5 IU/ml heparin; Ratiopharm,
Ulm, Germany) from CHB rabbits treated with C1–INH or isotonic saline, by addition
of either collagen (COLtest, 100 µg/ml) or adenosine diphosphate (ADP) (ADPtest, 0.2
mM). Platelet aggregation was assessed using impedance aggregometry (Multiplate Analyzer
5.0, Instrumentation Laboratory, Munich, Germany).
In addition, washed platelets were spiked with C1–INH at concentrations of 3.125 IU/ml
to 50 IU/ml (reflecting C1–INH plasma levels following i. v. doses of approximately
100 to 1,600 IU/kg) (n=2). Platelet aggregation was then measured using the APACT
4 system (Rolf Greiner BioChemica, Flacht, Germany) following activation with rabbit
thrombin (0.1 IU/ml; Sigma Aldrich, Munich, Germany).
Activated partial thromboplastin time and prothrombint ime
Blood samples were drawn from CHB rabbits treated with C1–INH or isotonic saline.
APTT was determined following intrinsic activation, and prothrombin time (PT) was
determined, following extrinsic activation, using the BCS® XP analyser (Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics Products).
Thrombin generation
The thrombin generation assay (TGA) was conducted using calibrated thrombinography
(Thrombinoscope, Maastricht, the Netherlands) in plasma samples from the C1–INH or
isotonic saline treated animals, upon intrinsic or extrinsic activation. The thrombin
calibrated automated thrombograms (dF/dt vs time) were used to determine the TGA parameters:
peak thrombin levels, lag-time, and endogenous thrombin potential (ETP).
Thrombin-antithrombin complexes
TAT complexes were determined in blood samples drawn from CHB rabbits treated with
C1–INH or isotonic saline, using a TAT enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) kit
(Cusabio Biotech, Wuhan, China) according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
In addition, TAT complexes were determined in plasma samples obtained during the assessment
of arterial thrombosis as described in “In vivo model of arterial thrombosis”.
Prothrombin fragment 1+2
F1+2 levels were determined in plasma samples obtained during the assessment of arterial
thrombosis as described in “In vivo model of arterial thrombosis”, using a F1+2 ELISA Kit (Cusabio), according to the
manufacturer’s instructions.
Statistical analysis and data presentation
Data from each dose of C1–INH were compared with corresponding data from the control
group, using test statistics for two independent samples. Pre-dose data were accounted
for by using analysis of covariance models, if possible. In that case, the estimated
treatment effects were derived from the statistical model. P–values below 0.05 were
termed statistically significant. Details on the statistical analysis can be found
in the Supplementary Material (available online at www.thrombosis-online.com).
Results
Evaluation of the pharmacokinetic and pharmaco-dynamic properties of C1–INH in rabbits
The pharmacological activity of plasma-derived human C1–INH was compared between rabbit
and human, based on the inhibition of FXIa and FXIIa activities, as well as aPTT and
PT measurements in vitro. To this end, rabbit plasma or SHP were spiked with increasing concentrations of
C1–INH, which correspond to in vivo exposures of 400 to 800 IU/kg and above. Similar concentration-dependent effects
of C1–INH on FXIIa inhibition between rabbit-and human-derived plasma were observed
(Suppl. [Figure 1A], available online at www.thrombosis-online.com), while C1-INH mediated FXIa inhibition was stronger in human plasma compared to
rabbit plasma (Suppl. [Figure 1B], available online at www. thrombosis-online.com), indicating that the pharmacodynamics of C1–INH were at least
partially comparable between rabbits and humans. Interestingly, in this assay, in
rabbit plasma a 1.49-fold higher FXII- and a 3.8-fold higher baseline FXI activity
compared to human plasma were found (data not shown) which is in line with Karges
et al. ([26]). Additionally, aPTT and PT were analysed in rabbit- and human-derived plasma. As
expected, no influence of C1-INH on PT was found whereas rabbit aPTT was even stronger
affected by increasing concentrations of C1-INH compared to human aPTT values (Suppl.
[Figure 1C–D], available online at www.thrombosis-online.com). Furthermore, efficacy of C1-INH regarding the inhibition of human and rabbit contact
system activation was demonstrated via Western blotting of high-molecular weight kininogen
(HMWK) cleavage (Suppl. [Figure 2], available online at www.thrombosis-online.com). Here, a similar dose-response in the inhibition of HMWK cleavage upon activation
of the kallikrein-kinin system was found in both rabbit and human plasma following
addition of C1-INH in vitro. These data clearly demonstrate the pharmacological activity of C1–INH in rabbit
plasma.
The assessment of the in vivo exposure and pharmacokinetic behaviour of plasma-derived human C1–INH in rabbits
was based on measurements of C1-esterase inhibition.
Following i. v. administration of a single dose of 200 IU/kg, an initial rise in C1–INH
activity to 737 % of endogenous normal (SHP) levels was measured, corresponding to
a 14-fold increase from baseline (►[Figure 1A]). Maximum C1–INH activity levels dropped by 8 % and 24 %, at 2 h and 3 h post-dose,
respectively, and reached baseline levels after 168 h (Day 7). In addition, a terminal
half-life of 1.4 ± 0.2 days, an overall exposure (area under the curve [AUC]) of 6.3
± 0.8 day × IU/ml and clearance of 39 ± 4 ml/kg/day were determined (means ± standard
deviation [SD]).
Figure 1: Pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic properties of C1-esterase inhibitor
(C1–INH) in rabbits. C1–INH activity was assessed by measuring the inhibition of C1-esterase activity
(A), at various time points upon administration of 200 IU/kg C1–INH and (B) upon administration
of cumulative doses of C1–INH or equal volumes of isotonic saline. Values are expressed
as percentage of C1–INH activity in standard human plasma (norm). C) Coagulation factors
XIa (FXIa) and XIIa (FXIIa) activity levels were measured in rabbit plasma following
administration of cumulative doses of C1–INH or equal volumes of isotonic saline.
C1–INH values were normalised to pre-dose and corresponding isotonic saline values.
For A-C: Dots and bars show means ± SD. **P=0.0024, ***P< 0.0001.
Cumulative doses of 100 IU/kg (0 to 5 min), 400 IU/kg (5 to 15 min), and 800 IU/kg
(15 to 30 min) of C1–INH resulted in a dose-dependent increase in C1–INH activity
ranging between 238 ± 31 % and 1587 ± 184 % of endogenous normal levels at 100 and
800 IU/kg compared with 32 ± 7 % at pre-dose (means ± SD; ►[Figure 1]B). At the highest dose level tested, this translates to a 49.6-fold increase in
C1-INH activity. In comparison, volume-adjusted treatment with isotonic saline resulted
in a dilution effect observed as a reduction of C1–INH activity levels from 32 % to
21 % of endogenous normal levels.
Measurements of FXIa and FXIIa activities demonstrated the pharmacodynamic activity
of human plasma-derived C1–INH in rabbits. Administration of cumulative doses of C1–INH
to CHB rabbits resulted in a dose-dependent inhibition of FXIa and FXIIa activity
compared with isotonic saline treatment (►[Figure 1C]). The inhibition was statistically significant, reaching levels of 78 % (p< 0.0001)
of isotonic saline for FXIa and 66 % (p=0.0024) of isotonic saline for FXIIa at a
dose of 400 IU/kg, as well as 62 % (p< 0.0001) for FXIa and 59 % (p< 0.0001) for FXIIa
at a dose of 800 IU/kg (analysis of covariance of log-transformed data).
Assessment of the prothrombotic potential of C1-INH in vivo
As shown in ►[Figure 2] A and B, treatment of NZW rabbits with isotonic saline or C1–INH at doses up to
800 IU/kg following 30 min of venous stasis, did not induce any thrombus formation.
In contrast, i. v. administration of Feiba®, which was used as a positive control, resulted in a dose-dependent increase in thrombus
formation reaching statistical significance (p< 0.05) at doses of 25 to 100 IU/kg
for thrombus score and at 100 IU/kg for thrombus wet weight.
Figure 2: Effects of C1-esterase inhibitor (C1–INH) on venous thrombosis in rabbits
in vivo
. Thrombus score (A) and thrombus wet weight (B) were measured following single administrations
of isotonic saline, Feiba®, or C1–INH and 30 min of venous stasis. Bars show means ± SD. *P< 0.05. C) Thrombus
wet weight was measured following 3 h of venous stasis in rabbits treated with cumulative
doses of C1–INH up to 800 IU/kg or equal volumes of isotonic saline. Bars show means
± SD.
Prolongation of venous stasis time to 3 h led to non-occlusive thrombus formation,
even in animals treated with isotonic saline (23.3–106.1 mg thrombus wet weight).
Even under these experimental conditions, administration of C1–INH at a high dose
(i. e. 800 IU/kg) did not result in any potentiation of venous thrombus formation
(►[Figure 2C]). The mean thrombus wet weight was slightly but not statistically significantly
lower after C1–INH administration (47.2 mg) compared with isotonic saline (66.0 mg).
Since the modified Wessler models applied above only address potential prothrombotic
activity of C1–INH during venous stasis, its effect was further assessed using a rabbit
model of FeCl3-induced arterial thrombosis. Interestingly, treatment of CHB rabbits with 800 IU/kg
C1–INH led to an inhibition of arterial thrombus formation. Occlusion rates were up
to 2.2-fold lower upon C1–INH treatment compared with isotonic saline, suggesting
a rather antithrombotic role for C1–INH under these experimental conditions (►[Figure 3]; p=0.08 for the log-rank test applied to mean time until occlusion of both arteries
per animal).
Figure 3: Effects of C1-esterase inhibitor (C1–INH) on arterial thrombosis in rabbits
in vivo
. A single dose of 800 IU/kg C1–INH or an equal volume of isotonic saline was administered
to rabbits followed by induction of arterial occlusion via FeCl3 in each arteria femoralis.
Occlusion rate was calculated as percentage distribution of arteries showing full
occlusion over time.
In vitro assessment of C1-INH effects on coagulation
Effects of C1-INH on activated partial thromboplastin time and prothrombin time
Plasma from rabbits treated with cumulative C1–INH doses up to 800 IU/kg showed an
increased aPTT from 21 seconds (sec) at pre-dose to 84 sec at 400 IU/kg C1–INH. At
800 IU/kg, an aPTT of 92 sec could only be measured in one animal, while the aPTTs
for the remaining animals were above the cut-off value of 160 sec. Therefore, the
aPTT was set to 160 sec for these animals (►[Figure 4A]). The prolongation of aPTT following C1–INH treatment was statistically significant
compared with isotonic saline for all cumulative doses: 100 IU/kg (p=0.035), 400 IU/kg
(p< 0.001), and 800 IU/kg (p< 0.001) (Wilcoxon test) and corresponding to the initial
in vitro spike experiments (Suppl. [Figure 1C], available online at www.thrombosis-online.com). No relevant effect of C1–INH treatment was observed on PT (data not shown) which
ranged between 9.9 sec and 10.3 sec (mean values), with differences between C1–INH
and isotonic saline treatments smaller than 0.15 sec at all doses (p>0.5; analysis
of covariance). These values were also in line with results obtained in the in vitro spike assay (Suppl. [Figure 1D], available online at www.thrombosis-online.com).
Figure 4: Effects of C1-esterase inhibitor (C1–INH) on activated partial thromboplastin
time (aPTT) and thrombin generation in rabbits. Rabbits were injected with cumulative doses of C1–INH or equal volumes of isotonic
saline and blood samples were drawn. A) APTT was measured following intrinsic activation
(cut-off at 160 sec). Dots show means ± SD. B-C) Peak thrombin levels (B) and lag-time
to thrombin formation (C) were measured by calibrated thrombography upon intrinsic
activation. For A-C: *P=0.035, ***P< 0.001. Peak thrombin levels (D) and lag-time
to thrombin formation (E) were measured by calibrated thrombography upon extrinsic
activation. All data are statistically not significant with P≥ 0.05. For B-D: Bars
show means ± SD.
Effects of C1-INH on thrombin generation
Administration of up to 800 IU/kg C1–INH to rabbits revealed inhibitory effects of
C1–INH on thrombin generation after intrinsic activation, reflected by changes in
peak thrombin levels and lagtime (►[Figure 4B and C]). Compared with isotonic saline, peak thrombin levels were significantly reduced
(p< 0.001) after treatment with C1–INH by 29 % (100 IU/kg), 61 % (400 IU/kg), and
66 % (800 IU/kg) (analysis of covariance of log-transformed data for all TGA parameters;
►[Figure 4B]). Lag-time was significantly prolonged (p< 0.001) by 1.5-fold (100 IU/kg C1–INH),
1.8-fold (400 IU/kg C1–INH), and 2.0-fold (800 IU/kg C1–INH) compared with isotonic
saline treatment (►[Figure 4C]). In contrast, a very mild effect in the opposite direction was seen on peak thrombin
levels and lag-time upon C1–INH treatment following extrinsic activation. The effect
had borderline significance at some doses (peak thrombin levels increased by 16 %
at 800 IU/kg C1–INH and lag-time decreased by 6 % at 100 IU/kg and 800 IU/kg C1–INH,
compared with isotonic saline; p=0.05 in each case; ►[Figure 4D and E]). ETP (measured as AUC) was not significantly affected by C1–INH treatment after
intrinsic or extrinsic activation (differences between C1–INH and isotonic saline
treatment were within ± 8 %; p>0.08 for all doses; data not shown).
Effects of C1-INH on platelet aggregation
To elucidate C1–INH-mediated effects on platelet function, ADP or collagen was applied
to blood samples drawn from C1–INH or isotonic saline treated rabbits in order to
induce platelet aggregation. C1–INH administration of doses up to 800 IU/kg showed
only a slight trend towards inhibitory effects on maximum platelet aggregation in
the presence of collagen, although this was in a dose-independent manner and statistically
not significant (►[Figure 5A]). Platelet aggregation was not significantly affected by C1–INH treatment upon ADP
induction (increase of AUC between 1 % and 23 % compared with isotonic saline; p>0.3;
data not shown).
Figure 5: Effects of C1-esterase inhibitor (C1–INH) on platelet aggregation in rabbits. A) Rabbits were injected with cumulative doses of C1–INH or equal volumes of isotonic
saline and blood samples were drawn. Maximum aggregation was measured upon collagen
addition, using impedance aggregometry. Bars show means ± SD. AU=arbitrary units.
B) Washed platelets from rabbit blood were spiked with C1–INH and platelet aggregation
was induced by thrombin. Maximum aggregation was expressed as percentage of aggregated
sample volume. Dots show means.
In a thrombin-induced in vitro assay of platelet aggregation (►[Figure 5B]), platelet concentrate was spiked with C1–INH at doses up to 50 IU/ml (translating
to an in vivo dose of 1600 IU/kg) and a dose-dependent decline in thrombin-induced maximum platelet
aggregation was observed (p=0.0031, p=0.0024, and p< 0.0001 at 12.5 IU/ml, 25 IU/ml,
and 50 IU/ml, respectively, compared to isotonic saline; analysis of variance).
Effects of C1-INH on thrombus formation and fibrinolysis using thromboelastography
Upon intrinsic activation of the coagulation cascade (INTEM test), CT and CFT increased
in a dose-dependent manner between 10 % and 23 % (CT), and 13 % and 29 % (CFT) compared
with isotonic saline, at C1–INH doses of 100 IU/kg and 800 IU/kg, respectively (data
not shown). The effects at 400 IU/kg C1–INH for CT (p=0.037) and at 800 IU/kg C1–INH
for CT and CFT (p=0.013 and p=0.034, respectively) were statistically significant
(analysis of covariance of log-transformed data). MCF was not affected by C1–INH treatment
and differed within a 2.3 % range from isotonic saline levels at all doses tested
(data not shown).
After extrinsic activation (EXTEM test), CFT increased by 7 % at 400 IU/kg (p=0.46)
and 17 % at 800 IU/kg (p=0.08) C1-INH administration compared with isotonic saline,
while CT and MCF remained unaffected, showing differences in the range of 3.0 % (CT)
and 0.6 % (MCF) compared with isotonic saline levels at all doses (p>0.5) (data not
shown).
In addition, the NATEM test was used as one of the most sensitive methods assessing
effects on the coagulation cascade. Here, in the absence of extrinsic or intrinsic
activation, recalcification resulted in a prolongation of CT and CFT upon C1–INH administration.
CT was prolonged by 21 % at 100 IU/kg (p=0.13), 42 % at 400 IU/kg (p=0.03), and 92
% at 800 IU/kg (p< 0.0001) compared with isotonic saline administration (analysis
of covariance of log-transformed data; ►[Figure 6A]). Median CFT was prolonged by 40 % at 100 IU/kg (p=0.03), 100 % at 400 IU/kg (p<
0.001), and more than 100 % at 800 IU/kg (p=0.006; log-rank test) (►[Figure 6B]).
Figure 6: Effects of C1-esterase inhibitor (C1–INH) on thrombus formation in rabbits
using thromboelastography. Clotting time (CT) (A) and clot formation time (CFT) (B) were measured after recalcification
only (NATEM) of citrated whole blood from rabbits treated with cumulative doses of
C1–INH or equal volumes of isotonic saline. Horizontal lines correspond to medians.
Measurements of LI60 following induction of clot lysis by addition of tPA, in order
to assess potential inhibitory effects of C1–INH on fibrinolysis, revealed no indication
of antifibrinolytic activity of C1–INH (►[Figure 7]; p>0.2 at all doses; analysis of covariance of log-transformed data).
Figure 7: Effects of C1-esterase inhibitor (C1–INH) on fibrinolysis in rabbits. CHB rabbits were injected with cumulative doses of C1–INH or equal volumes of isotonic
saline and blood samples were drawn. Fibrinolysis was induced by addition of tPA and
upon extrinsic activation. Lysis index 60 (LI60) was measured using thromboelastography.
Bottom and top of the box represent the 25th and 75th percentile, respectively, the
band within the box represents the median, the diamond symbol represents the mean,
and the low and high ends of the whiskers represent the lowest datum still within
1.5 interquartile range (IQR) of the lower quartile, and the highest datum still within
1.5 IQR of the upper quartile, respectively.
Effects of C1-INH on TAT and F1+2 levels
After the administration of 800 IU/kg C1-INH to rabbits, no relevant changes in the
TAT and F1+2 levels were observed compared to isotonic saline treatment (data not
shown).
Discussion
Overall, C1–INH replacement therapy has been recognized as a well-established, effective,
and safe treatment for HAE acute attacks for over 20 years as well as in prophylaxis.
However, adverse events reported in association with C1–INH treatment include risk
of thromboembolic complications upon administration at both high and recommended doses
([8], [9]). Recently, few clinical and preclinical reports have provided contradictory evidence
on the possible prothrombotic potential of C1–INH treatment ([11], [13], [14]). However, no causative mechanism has been demonstrated so far and remains elusive.
Therefore, our study aimed to provide further insight into the involvement of C1–INH
in coagulatory functions and its role in thromboembolic events.
To this end, the rabbit was chosen as a suitable experimental model, providing high
sensitivity due to its high endogenous levels of coagulation factors compared with
humans or other experimental species ([26]). In our study, the pharmacokinetic behaviour of C1–INH in rabbits was in agreement
with previous observations in rabbits ([27]), and C1–INH showed pharmacody-namic efficacy, as demonstrated by a dose-dependent
inhibition of FXIa and FXIIa activities (►[Figure 1]). Based on additional in vitro experiments, the dose-response of this effect was similar between human- and rabbit-derived
plasma although more pronounced for human plasma in the case of FXIa inhibition (Suppl.
[Figure 1], available online at www.thrombosis-online.com). On the other hand, the increased effect on aPTT seen in rabbit plasma (►[Figure 1C]) may point to a stronger inhibitory effect of of C1-INH on rabbit plasma kallikrein
compared to human kallikrein. Via Western blotting using C1-INH it was found that
inhibition of contact system activation was similar between human and rabbit plasma
(Suppl. [Figure 2], available online at www.thrombosis-online.com). Furthermore, literature is available suggesting that human C1-INH has not just
strong inhibitory potency on human complement proteases C1r, C1s and MASP-1, but also
on rabbit C1s, further supporting the rabbit as a pharmacologically relevant animal
model to study the effects of human C1-INH ([28]). However, it remains to be elucidated whether human C1-INH is equally potent in
rabbits as it is in humans. Therefore, the potential differences in the contact system
between human and rabbit, including the differences between the effects of C1-INH
on FXIa inhibition and aPTT or discrepancies between FXIa and PT baseline levels as
seen in this study, have to be kept in mind when interpreting and translating data
from rabbit models to humans.
At present, a potential procoagulatory role of C1-INH is being discussed. An underlying
mechanism leading to this class of adverse events observed has not been demonstrated;
however, potential antifibrinolytic effects of C1-INH have been considered. Due to
its ability to inhibit the function of FXIa, FXIIa, and kallikrein, C1–INH could potentially
elicit those procoagulatory events by interfering with downstream cascades such as
the fibrinolytic pathway (►[Figure 8A]). During fibrinolysis, plasmin is generated by plasminogen upon the action of tPA
and urokinase-like plasminogen activator (uPA); plasmin subsequently catalyses the
degradation of fibrin clots ([29]). C1–INH could interfere with plasmin production in multiple ways: directly, by
inhibiting the activity of tPA ([30]) or the cleavage of plasminogen by FXIIa ([32]), or indirectly, by inhibiting the activity of kallikrein. The latter could lead
to decreased urokinase and subsequently reduced plasminogen activation ([31]), as well as to decreased tPA levels due to reduced bradykinin production downstream
of kallikrein ([32]). The contribution of C1–INH to tPA inhibition seems to depend on the active levels
of plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 (PAI-1), and C1–INH may inhibit as little as
5 % of plasma tPA under certain active PAI-1 concentrations ([30]). Since active PAI-1 levels can vary between healthy individuals and certain patient
populations ([30]), different subjects may exhibit varying sensitivities to the potential antifibrinolytic
effects of C1–INH. However, C1–INH seems to play only a limited role in tPA inhibition.
Clinical data has demonstrated that the levels of tPA and uPA remained normal during
both remission and acute attacks of HAE patients ([33]) and increased C1–INH-tPA complexes were only observed in presence of high tPA levels
in the circulation ([3], [34]).
Figure 8: Potential pro (A) and anticoagulatory (B) effects of C1-esterase inhibitor
(C1–INH) function. C1–INH can potentially elicit procoagulatory effects (A), by inhibiting fibrinolysis
or increasing platelet activation, but also anticoagulatory effects (B), by inhibiting
thrombin formation, platelet activation, or the function of complement pathway. Dotted
arrows indicate indirect actions and continuous arrows indicate direct actions. Red
Xs indicate inhibition by C1–INH. Ca=calcium; coagulation factors Va, VIIIa, IX/IXa,
X/Xa, XI/XIa, XII/XIIa, XIII/XIIIa; HKa=cleaved kinin-free kininogen; HMWK=high-molecular
weight kininogen; MASP=mannose-binding lectin-associated serine protease; NO=nitric
oxide; PGI2=prostaglandin I2; PL=phospholipids; pro-uPA=pro-urokinase-type plasminogen
activator; TF:VIIa=TF complex with factor VIIa; tPA=tissue plasminogen activator;
TXA2=thromboxane A2; uPA=urokinase-type plasminogen activator.
Furthermore, it could be speculated from the literature that C1–INH could potentially
elicit additional procoagulatory effects by indirectly increasing platelet activation
and/or fibrin clot formation (►[Figure 8A]). Reduced bradykinin levels, due to C1–INH-mediated inhibition of kallikrein, could
likely decrease the release of prostaglandin I2 and nitric oxide from endothelial
cells, which usually exert platelet inhibitory effects, thus decreasing the barrier
for platelet activation ([35], [36]). However, this hypothesis was not further investigated or proven as part of the
present study. In addition, cleaved kinin-free kininogen was shown to compete with
fibrinogen for deposition on negatively-charged surfaces, neutrophils, and platelets
([31]). Therefore, reduced cleaved kinin-free kininogen levels, due to inhibition of FXIIa
by C1–INH, may potentially lead to reduced displacement of fibrinogen and increased
fibrin formation.
Nevertheless, despite the theoretical impact of the potential procoagulatory effects
of C1–INH described above, in the present work no such findings underlining this hypothesis
were observed. Thus, our study clearly suggests no prothrombotic risk associated with
C1–INH treatment in rabbits, even at supratherapeutic doses. In the current study,
in vivo models of thrombogenicity were employed to assess the prothrombotic potential of
C1–INH, as a sensitive readout of the interplay between blood cells, cell membranes,
vascular wall, blood flow conditions, and local or systemic conditions such as hypoxia
or acidosis. The modified Wessler test in rabbits is a well-established model of acute
and prolonged venous stasis, mimicking major aspects of deep-vein thrombosis in humans.
Following venous stasis, C1–INH doses up to 800 IU/kg did not result in any potentiation
of thrombus formation (►[Figure 2]). Interestingly, the additional application of a chemically-induced arterial thrombosis
model in rabbits revealed anticoagulatory properties for C1–INH, with doses of 800
IU/kg C1–INH resulting in a 2.2-fold reduction of total arterial occlusion compared
with isotonic saline treatment (►[Figure 3]).
The in vivo observations were further supported by a variety of in vitro assays assessing the impact of C1–INH treatment on the contact activation system,
thrombin generation, platelet aggregation, and fibrinolysis. In contrast to the theoretical
potential of C1–INH to enhance clot formation as described above, a prolongation of
CT, CFT, aPTT and lag-time of thrombin formation, and a decrease in peak thrombin
levels were observed in the presence of C1–INH upon intrinsic activation of thrombin
generation, pointing towards an anticoagulatory effect for this treatment (►[Figure 4A–C] and ►[Figure 6]). No effect of C1-INH was observed on PT (Suppl. [Figure 1D], available online at www.thrombosis-online.com) or on thrombin generation following extrinsic activation (►[Figure 4D–E]).
Our findings showing a potential anticoagulatory role for C1–INH are not surprising
considering the multiple functions of this protein within the contact activation and
complement cascades and the complex interplay among these pathways.
Firstly, any interference of C1–INH with the contact activation system, i. e. through
inhibition of FXIIa, FXIa, or kallikrein, could modulate vascular biology by decreasing
thrombin generation (►[3]) (►[Figure 8B]), a finding that was observed in the present study following intrinsic activation
of thrombin generation as demonstrated in [Figure 4B–C].
In addition, the observed inhibition of platelet aggregation when thrombin was used
as platelet agonist (►[Figure 5]) in the presence of C1–INH further argues against a prothrombotic role for this
treatment. These findings are partly in line with results from Copolla et al. who
hypothesised a negative regulating role of C1-INH in platelet aggregation ([37], [38]). In general, platelet activation is positively regulated by thrombin, collagen,
and thromb-oxane A2 (TXA2) ([37]). C1–INH could interfere with this process either directly, by binding to thrombin
([39], [40]) and collagen ([41]), or indirectly by downregulating bradykinin levels, leading to reduced TXA2 production
via the arachidonic acid pathway ([42]–[44]). In addition, reduced FXIIa and kallikrein activity, due to C1–INH inhibition,
may potentially affect neutrophil-platelet interactions ([45], [46]).
The potential interaction of C1-INH with thrombin may consequently enhance the fibrinolytic
system, considering the inhibitory effects of thrombin on fibrinolysis ([47]) and the decrease in thrombin generation upon C1–INH action. However, no relevant
changes in fibrinolytic activity were observed in this study upon C1–INH treatment
(►[Figure 7]).
Furthermore, C1–INH could potentially exert anticoagulatory effects via its action
on the complement system (►[Figure 8B]). C1–INH can interfere with the complement system directly, by inhibiting the activity
of the serine proteases C1s and C1r, as well as of MASP-1 (mannose-binding lectin-associated
serine protease) and MASP-2, but also indirectly, by blocking FXII autoactivation
and kallikrein. Upon cleavage of FXIIa by kallikrein, the FXIIa â-fragment is produced
which can transform the macromolecular C1qr2s2 complex into enzymatically active C1r and C1s ([48], [49]). Moreover, kallikrein can directly activate C3 and C5. Therefore, inhibition of
FXII autoactivation and kallikrein by C1–INH could lead to the downregulation of the
classical, lectin, and alternative pathways of the complement system and may consequently
suppress the stimulation of downstream procoagulatory events triggered by complement
fixation on cell surfaces ([50]) or anaphylatoxin (C3a and C5a)-mediated inflammatory responses ([51]).
Overall, C1–INH administration at supratherapeutic doses in rabbits revealed an antithrombotic
effect for this treatment. However, it should be taken into consideration that the
adverse thromboembolic events reported previously have not been observed under healthy
conditions but against a background of capillary leakage syndrome or heart insufficiencies,
which are off-label indications for C1–INH. In addition, it cannot be neglected that
C1–INH activity can be affected by co-treatments or by the status or severity of HAE.
In the first case it has been demonstrated that co-treatment with glycosaminoglycans
such as Heparins can increase C1–INH activity ([52], [53]) and the mean half-life of therapeutically administered C1–INH has been shown to
vary from 33 h up to 48 h for patients with severe HAE and patients with moderate
HAE, respectively (54).
What is known about this topic?
-
C1–INH is a potent inhibitor of the complement and contact activation systems, and
its deficiency can lead to the manifestation of hereditary angioedema. Replacement
therapy with human plasma-derived C1–INH is an efficacious and safe treatment for
this disease.
-
However, thrombotic events have been associated with the use of C1–INH at recommended
or off-label, high doses.
What does this paper add?
-
High-dose C1–INH administration to rabbits did not potentiate venous thrombosis, and
interestingly inhibited arterial thrombosis.
-
Decreased thrombin generation and platelet aggregation, as well as prolonged activated
partial thromboplastin time, clotting time, and clot formation time were observed
upon high dose administration of C1–INH.
-
C1–INH administration to healthy rabbits at high doses seems to have anticoagulatory
and antithrombotic effects, rather than a prothrombotic potential.
In summary, assessment of the prothrombotic risk of C1–INH treatment in rabbits revealed
a rather anticoagulatory role for C1–INH in this study. Venous thrombosis was not
potentiated and arterial thrombosis was inhibited upon C1–INH administration at supratherapeutic
doses. Inhibition of the contact activation system, reduced thrombin generation, and
reduced platelet aggregation were observed in blood samples of C1–INH treated animals,
further supporting the anticoagulatory potential of C1–INH. Furthermore, there was
no apparent C1–INH-mediated inhibition of fibrinolysis. Nevertheless, as the present
study was conducted in healthy rabbits, future investigations of the prothrombotic
risk of C1–INH are warranted in various clinical backgrounds reflecting the potentially
complex influences of underlying disease states in patients.
