Keywords:
Aged - General Practitioners - Knowledge - Attitudes - Dementia
Palavras-chave:
Idoso - Clínicos Gerais - Conhecimento - Atitude - Demência
INTRODUCTION
The aging of the population has led to a substantial rise in the number of older people
with cognitive decline and dementia. By 2050, there will be an estimated 152 million
persons with dementia globally[1]. Every year, another 10 million people will develop dementia, of which 6 million
are from low- to middle-income countries, such as Brazil[1],[2]. The estimated global cost of the condition in 2015 was 818 billion USD, a figure
set to rise to 2 trillion USD by 2030[3],[4].
Dementia is a syndrome whose main risk factor is age. In most cases, the disease is
progressive and marked by cognitive decline, which impacts the individual's independence
and autonomy[5]. Alzheimer's disease (AD) accounts for 50–70% of all dementia cases[6]. Although AD dementia is a clinical condition with major personal, family and social
impacts and no curative treatment, early detection is believed important because diagnosis
allows patients and their carers to discuss future care plans, helping to reduce psychic
distress and costs[7],[8],[9],[10].
In many countries, including Brazil, general practitioners (GPs) play a central role
in the health of older people and especially in detecting individuals with dementia.
However, the literature shows that dementia is underdiagnosed in primary care, delaying
diagnosis and leading to unfavourable outcomes for patients and their relatives[11],[12],[13]. A systematic review showed that the main barrier to GPs establishing a diagnosis
is lack of training and education on dementia. Moreover, lack of training leads to
doubts and limited confidence among clinicians in confirming a dementia diagnosis
and managing symptoms[14]. Other studies have shown that unclear guidelines on screening for cognitive decline,
misunderstandings regarding drug therapy, and difficulties talking with patients and
their relatives about the disease and its complications, can preclude early diagnosis
of dementia in primary care[15],[16],[17].
Since 1988, following the creation of the Brazilian National Health System (SUS),
primary care has become the main entry point to the public health system. Currently,
73% of older people are treated solely by the SUS and most of them receive care provided
by GPs[18],[19]. Studies on dementia detection involving medical students and physicians on the
first year of medical residency programs in Brazil have shown the need to provide
more in-depth education and training in the detection and diagnosis of cognitive impairments
in older people[20],[21],[22]. This lack of training may be due to the teaching method used by medical schools,
which until recently, focused on training students about serious illnesses involving
hospital inpatients, with little emphasis on outpatient treatment, i.e., primary care.
However, recent curriculum models now engage students in primary care practice. Nevertheless,
studies point to the need for continuous teaching and training of newly graduated
physicians in the practice of medicine, given the rapid demographic and epidemiological
shifts that have taken place in the last few years. This limited professional training
in internal medicine has prompted the present study assessing the knowledge and attitudes
in dementia held by GPs from a primary care service of a city in the interior of São
Paulo State, Brazil.
METHODS
Study design and setting
A quasi-experimental intervention study was conducted involving six lectures (60 minutes
each) about dementia and/or a presentation script. The lectures were delivered, and
the scripts were written by a geriatrician with experience in dementia (VFSM). The
lectures/presentation script covered the definition, epidemiology, diagnosis and management
of dementia syndromes. Before and after the intervention, the participating physicians
completed two quizzes about knowledge of and attitudes towards dementia[18]. The coordination of the health system of Botucatu held monthly meetings from 2
pm to 5 pm with GPs from the primary care service to deliver updates on health topics
to these professionals. The primary care service of the city of Botucatu comprises
4 basic health units (UBS), 2 health centres (CS), 2 polyclinics and 12 family health
units (USF). All 40 GPs of the city of Botucatu primary health service were invited
to take part in the study, most of whom were newly graduated physicians.
Data collection
Data collection took place between August 2016 and January 2017, gathering sociodemographic
data (name, age, gender), responses to questions about time since graduation from
medical school, completion of medical residency and specialty, and also about previous
training in dementia during medical school: (“How long have you been a practicing
physician?”, “Did you have any classes on dementia during your medicine course?”,
“Have you done a Medical Residency program?”; If so, in which specialty?”, “Would
you like to have refresher courses on dementia?”).
Participants
All GPs of the primary health service of Botucatu (n=40) commenced the study. Six
physicians were excluded because they began classes but failed to complete the content
and thus did not take part in the 2nd application of instruments. Physicians wishing to take part in the study, but who
could not be away from their posts at health units, were provided with a script containing
the topics presented in the lectures. After completing the 2 quizzes in the presence
of the researcher, 10 physicians received the intervention based on this script. Thirty
days later, the same group completed the quizzes a second time.
Instruments
The instrument Knowledge and Attitudes Quiz about Dementia was developed in the United
Kingdom in 2004 with the purpose of measuring GPs’ knowledge of, confidence with and
attitudes to the diagnosis and management of dementia in primary care[16]. In 2015, these instruments were translated and culturally adapted for use in the
Brazilian setting[20]. The Knowledge Quiz contains 14 multiple-choice questions, each with five possible
answers, only one of which is correct, with all questions including the response option
“I don't know”. The instrument is divided into 3 sub-items addressing aspects of dementia
related to epidemiology (3 questions), diagnosis (8 questions) and management (3 questions).
The Attitude Quiz contains 10 sentences about physicians’ thoughts on the management
of patients with dementia, scored on a Likert-type scale with the following possible
answers: “strongly agree”, “agree”, “neither agree nor disagree”, “disagree” and “strongly
disagree”[16]. The first five sentences relate to positive attitudes: “1. Much can be done to improve the quality of life of carers of people with dementia.
2. Families would rather be told about their relative's dementia as soon as possible.
3. Much can be done to improve the quality of life of people with dementia. 4. Providing
diagnosis is usually more helpful than harmful. 5. Dementia is best diagnosed by specialist
services”, whereas the other sentences relate to negative attitudes: “6. Patients with dementia can be a drain on resources with little positive outcome.
7. It is better to talk to the patient in euphemistic terms. 8. Managing dementia
is more often frustrating than rewarding. 9. There is little point in referring families
to services as they do not want to use them.10. The primary care team has a very limited
role to play in the care of people with dementia”
[16].
Statistical analysis
The data were analysed using the IBM-SPSS 21 statistical software. Numerical variables
were expressed as mean and standard deviation, while categorical variables were expressed
as frequency and percentage. Student's t-test was used to compare means. The level of significance adopted was 0.05.
Ethics committee
This study and the free and informed consent form were analysed and approved by the
Research Ethics Committee of the Clinical Hospital of the Botucatu School of Medicine-UNESP.
RESULTS
The mean age of the sample was 33.9 (±10.2) years, where the majority (18 subjects
— 52.9%) were 20–30 years old. Race consisted of thirty-two self-declared white, one
black and one yellow. Sixteen (47%) of the physicians were female and 21 (61.8%) had
been practicing for up to 5 years. Six (17.6%) physicians aged 47–59 years had been
practicing for 18 years or longer. Of the 8 (23.5%) GPs who had undertaken medical
residency training in the overall sample, 5 were >47 years old, 1 was aged 28 years
and 2 aged 37–39 years. The majority of the sample had not undertaken medical residency
training (76.5%). With regard to the question on having received classes on dementia
during medical training, 29 (85.3%) stated “yes”. Of the participants who reported
“no”, 3 had been practicing for 1–5 years and 1 for 18 years. All of the physicians
(100%) stated that they wished to have a refresher course on dementia.
Knowledge about dementia
The Knowledge Quiz about dementia with response options and number of correct answers,
before and after the training intervention of presentation class and/or script is
given in [Table 1]. The mean number of correct answers before and after the training intervention was
8.35 (59.6%) and 9.97 (71.2%), respectively. The percentage of correct answers on
the epidemiology, diagnosis and management subscales before intervention were 44.1,
68.3, and 50.9% versus 57.7, 79.7, and 61.7% after intervention, respectively. Results
on Student's paired t-test for comparisons of mean correct answers on the quizzes before and after the
training showed a statistically significant difference only on the diagnosis subscale
(p<0.001) ([Table 2]).
Table 1
Knowledge Quiz about Dementia with response options and number of correct answers,
before and after training intervention, of general practitioners from the primary
care system of Botucatu city, São Paulo state.
|
Questions
|
Response options
|
Before
|
After
|
EPIDEMIOLOGY
|
A general practitioner with a list of 1,000 people aged 60 years or older can expect
to have the following number of people with dementia on the list
|
A.10
|
13 (38%)
|
13 (38.0%)
|
B.500
|
C.200
|
D.70
|
E. I don't know
|
From 65 years of age, the prevalence of dementia is expected to:
|
A. Double every 5 years
|
9 (26.4%)
|
21 (61.8%)
|
B. Double every 10 years
|
C. Double every 15 years
|
D. Double every 20 years
|
E. I don't know
|
One of the risk factors for the development of Alzheimer's disease is:
|
A. Hardening of arteries
|
25 (73.5%)
|
25 (73.5%)
|
B. Age
|
C. Nutritional deficiencies
|
D. Exposure to aluminium
|
E. I don't know
|
DIAGNOSIS
|
All of the following are potentially treatable etiologies of dementia except:
|
A. Hypothyroidism
|
24 (70.6%)
|
26 (76.5%)
|
B. Normal pressure hydrocephalus
|
C. Creutzfeldt–Jacob disease
|
D. Vitamin B12 deficiency
|
E. I don't know
|
A patient suspected of having dementia should be evaluated as soon as possible as:
|
A. Prompt treatment of dementia may prevent worsening of symptoms
|
20 (58.8%)
|
27 (79.4%)
|
B. Prompt treatment of dementia may reverse symptoms
|
C. It is important to rule out and treat reversible disorders
|
D. It is best to institutionalise a dementia patient early in the course of the disease
|
E. I don't know
|
Which of the following procedures is required to definitively confirm that symptoms
are due to dementia?
|
A. Mini-Ment al State Exam
|
7 (20.6%)
|
18 (52.9%)
|
B. Postmortem
|
C. CAT scan of the brain
|
D. Blood test
|
E. I don't know
|
Which of the following is not a necessary part of the initial evaluation of a patient
with possible dementia?
|
A. Thyroid function test
|
29 (85.3%)
|
29 (85.3%)
|
B. Serum electrolytes
|
C. Vitamin B and foliate levels
|
D. Protein electrophoresis
|
E. I don't know
|
Which of the following sometimes resembles dementia?
|
A. Depression
|
27 (79.4%)
|
26 (76.5%)
|
B. Acute confusional state
|
C. Stroke
|
D. All of the above
|
E. I don't know
|
When a patient develops a sudden onset of confusion, disorientation, and inability
to sustain attention, this presentation is most consistent with the diagnosis of:
|
A. Alzheimer's disease
|
27 (79.4%)
|
31 (91.2%)
|
B. Acute confusional state
|
C. Major depression
|
D. Vascular dementia
|
E. I don't know
|
Which of the following is nearly always present in dementia?
|
A. Loss of memory
|
28 (82.3%)
|
31 91.2%)
|
B. Loss of memory and incontinence
|
C. Loss of memory, incontinence and hallucinations
|
D. None of the above
|
E. I don't know
|
11. Which of the following clinical findings best differentiates vascular dementia
from Alzheimer's?
|
A. Word-finding problems
|
23 (64.7%)
|
26 (76.5%)
|
B. Short-t3erm (2-minute span) visual memory loss
|
C. Stepwise disease course
|
D. Presence of depression
|
E. I don't know
|
MANAGEMENT
|
12. The effect of anti-dementia drugs is to:
|
A. Temporarily halt the disease in all cases
|
25 (73.5%)
|
29 (85.3%)
|
B. Temporarily halt the disease in some cases
|
C. Temporarily halt the disease in some cases but often causing liver damage
|
D. Permanently halt the disease in some cases
|
E. I don't know
|
13 Which statement is true concerning the treatment of dementia patients who are depressed?
|
A. It is usually useless to treat them for depression because feelings of sadness
and inadequacy are part of the diseaes
|
13 (38%)
|
11 (32.3%)
|
B. Treatments of depression may be effective in alleviating depressive symptoms
|
C. Anti-depressant medication should not be prescribed
|
D. Proper medication may alleviate symptoms of depression and prevent further intellectual
decline
|
E. I don't know
|
14. What is the function of the ABRAZ, the Brazilian association that provides patients
and carers with information?
|
A. Help people understand the disease and cope better with the symptoms and treatment
|
15 (44%)
|
22 (64.7%)
|
B. Provide outpatient medical treatment
|
C. Recruit people with dementia for research studies
|
D. All of the above
|
E. I don't know
|
Table 2
Comparison of mean correct answers on Knowledge Quiz about Dementia, before and after
training intervention, of general practitioners (n=34) from primary care system of
Botucatu, São Paulo.
Sub-items
|
Before intervention mean (SD)
|
After intervention mean (SD)
|
p-value*
|
Epidemiology
|
1.41 (±0.85)
|
1.74 (±0.82)
|
0.07
|
Diagnosis
|
5.44 (±1.80)
|
6.32 (±1.55)
|
<0.001
|
Management
|
1.53 (±0.92)
|
1.85 (±0.70)
|
0.09
|
Total correct answers**
|
8.35 (±0.74)
|
9.97 (±2.11)
|
<0.001
|
*Student's paired t-test
**out of 14.
Attitudes to dementia
The comparison of the mean responses on the Attitude Quiz is presented in [Table 3], revealing no statistically significant difference between the two applications
of the instrument, before and after intervention (p=0.059).
Table 3
Comparison of mean answers on Attitude Quiz towards Dementia, before and after training
intervention, of general practitioners (n=34) from primary care system of Botucatu,
São Paulo.
Subscales
|
Before training intervention mean (SD)
|
After training intervention mean (SD)
|
p-value*
|
Positive attitude
|
14.68 (±2.92)
|
15.03 (±2.91)
|
0.59**
|
Negative attitude
|
11.32 (±2.27)
|
12.35 (±2.20)
|
0.09#
|
*Student's paired t-test
**higher means: more positive attitudes
#higher means: less negative attitudes.
DISCUSSION
This study employed two quizzes assessing the knowledge and attitudes of physicians
about dementia. The mean total correct answers on knowledge before and after the intervention
was 8.35 (59.6%) and 9.97 (71.2%) out of 14 points, respectively. Turner et al.[16], used the same instruments in a single application to 127 GPs who had volunteered
to join a randomized clinical trial of educational interventions to improve the detection
and management of dementia. The GPs scored 67% overall on the quiz about knowledge
of dementia and 48, 74 and 73% on the epidemiology, diagnosis and management subscales,
respectively. In the present study, the GPs exhibited a lower performance, scoring
59.6 versus 67% by British GPs. Brazilian scores on the epidemiology, diagnosis and management
subscales also proved to be lower, at 44.1, 68.3 and 50.9%, respectively. The most
common mistakes in the UK study involved questions on epidemiology, whereas Brazilian
GPs erred most on epidemiology and management of dementia. However, both groups of
GPs performed best on questions about diagnosis in dementia.
A previous study by Jacinto et al. of 152 medical residents of a federal university
hospital in São Paulo state applied the same two quizzes used in the present study[21]. The sample comprised 40.8% (n=61) residents in neurology, psychiatry, and geriatrics
and internal medicine, and therefore probably had contact with older people with dementia
during training. The remaining residents (59.2%) specialized in surgery and clinical
subspecialties. Around 59.7% of residents embarking on their programs reported having
received good training on cognitive impairments during medical school. Another study
where 155 final-year medical students from two different universities participated,
92 (59.7%) considered that they had good training in cognitive alterations during
their undergraduate medical course and 67 (58.8%) declared having only theoretical
training[22]. However, this group of students scored an average of 6.9 (49.2%) on the Knowledge
Quiz, pointing to the need for continued education, given that the workforce in the
public health system in Brazil, akin to the UK, comprises very young doctors dealing
with the population of older people users seeking public health services[23].
The study by Downs et al.[24], assessing the effectiveness of educational interventions in improving detection
and management of dementia, concluded that GPs have difficulty detecting and managing
dementia symptoms. Two interventions showed positive results: a decision-support system
built into the electronic medical records and practice-based workshops. There were
improvements in detection and confidence of GPs in the diagnosis and management of
dementia. A similar result was seen in the present study, where primary care GPs showed
improved performance, post-training, on the epidemiology diagnosis and management
subscales. These results confirm that continued education may be effective for improving
detection of cognitive impairment and dementia in older adults in primary care.
Several barriers, for both doctors and patients, to early diagnosis of dementia in
primary care were outlined in the European Carers’ Report 2018[25]: GPs believed forgetfulness was part of normal aging and so gave little importance
in diagnosis; and also due to the fact that no curative treatment exists, regarding
patients and/or relatives, delay in seeking help at the early stage of the disease
is explained by fears of prejudice among friends, at work and also amongst health
professionals[26], where clear information is lacking on all aspects of dementia for physicians and
for individuals who are aging[26],[27].
Regarding attitudes towards dementia held by GPs, the present study showed that most
of them agreed much can be done to improve the quality of life of people with dementia
(82.3%) and of their carers (97.1%), but 50% believed dementia is best diagnosed by
a specialist. Similar results were found in the study by Turner et al.[16]. These findings are alarming because individuals are unable to get an appointment
to see a specialist following the onset of symptoms because neither patient nor relatives
took the cognitive and functional impairments seriously, believing them to be part
of normal aging. Another important finding of the study was that 20.6% strongly agreed
with the statement that treating individuals with dementia is frustrating.
In the study by Ahmad et al.,[28] assessing the attitudes, awareness and practice regarding early diagnosis of dementia
of 1011 GPs, they found that older physicians were more confident diagnosing and advising
about dementia. However, although these physicians believed early diagnosis of dementia
was beneficial, they were more likely to feel that patients with dementia can be a
drain on resources with little positive outcome. By contrast, younger physicians were
more positive and felt that much can be done to improve the quality of life of patients
with dementia[27].
The World Alzheimer Report 2017–2025 warns of the global impact of AD dementia in
the near future and emphasizes the urgent need for awareness of this problem by society,
public authorities and healthcare professionals[29].
Banerjee et al.[30] showed that programs that encourage the individual with dementia to share their
experiences with students result in the deepening of knowledge about the cognitive
decline by the student, favouring a change in attitude to deal with the manifestations
of dementia.
The study by Alzheimer's Disease International (ADI) “World Alzheimer Report 2019
— Attitudes to dementia”[31] showed that in Brazil, there is still a huge stigma and negative attitudes towards
people with dementia by health professionals and people in the community. The authors
believe that changes in attitudes to eliminate stigma about dementia should have the
direct participation of individuals with dementia. In addition, the inclusion of students
in the health field from the beginning of graduation so that they share the early
stages of the disease can be the path to ethical management in the management of dementia.
The limitations of this study included the convenience sample and small sample size,
all derived from a single location in Sao Paulo State. Future research should explore
whether the same findings can be replicated in a larger, representative sample of
GPs in Brazil.