Keywords: spinocerebellar ataxias - severity of illness index - postural balance
Palavras-chave: ataxia espinocerebelar - índice de gravidade da doença - equilíbrio postural
Spinocerebellar ataxias (SCAs) are a large, complex group of neurodegenerative diseases
characterized by progressive cerebellar ataxia with oculomotor abnormalities, dysarthria,
pyramidal and extrapyramidal signs, pigmentary retinopathy, peripheral neuropathy
and cognitive dysfunction, among other manifestations[1 ],[2 ]. More than 40 types of SCA have been identified to date, including SCA type 2 (SCA2),
which is caused by a CAG trinucleotide repeat expansion on chromosome 12q23-24.1[1 ].
The third most common form of SCA in Brazil is SCA2. Symptoms typically begin in the
third decade of life and are associated with worse disease prognosis when they appear
early[1 ].
Clinical manifestations of the disease include action and rest tremor, polyneuropathy,
upper motor neuron impairment and parkinsonism, which may predominate in some cases[3 ]. A balance deficit is one of the most characteristic signs of SCA and one of the
main factors directly affecting posture and functionality4 . Increased disease severity implies greater impairment of postural balance and functionality,
and increased risk of falls[4 ],[5 ].
An annual increase in the Scale for the Assessment and Rating of Ataxia (SARA) score
of between 1.40 and 1.49 has been reported in patients with SCA26,7 , but progression of functional loss and loss of balance have not yet been extensively
described.
The aim of this study was, therefore, to assess functionality and balance in individuals
with SCA2 and to correlate these with disease severity and duration.
METHODS
This was a retrospective, descriptive, cross-sectional study and was approved by the
Committee for Ethics in Research at the Hospital de Clínicas, Federal University of
Paraná (HC-UFPR) (CAAE: 48399915.7.0000.0096, ref. no.: 1.280.919).
The study sample was non-probabilistic and comprised men and women who were being
followed up at the ataxia outpatient unit in the movement disorders unit at the Hospital
de Clínicas, Federal University of Paraná.
Inclusion criteria were: being at least 18 years old; having a clinical diagnosis
of SCA2; having a positive genetic test for SCA2 or having a family member who had
a positive genetic test for SCA2; and taking coenzyme Q10 (100-500 mg/day) regularly.
Individuals who had any musculoskeletal disorders that could affect their balance
or functionality or who had other concomitant neurological disease (non-ataxic manifestations)
were excluded.
Sixteen patients who had been diagnosed with SCA2 and had complete medical records
were included in the study.
The following information was collected: age, gender, diagnosis, age of onset of ataxic
symptoms, disease duration, disease severity, balance and functional-independence
scores, and number of CAG repeats.
Balance was assessed on the Berg balance scale, which has 14 items and a maximum score
of 56. Scores of less than 46 indicate a high risk for falls[8 ].
Functional independence was assessed using the Functional Independence Measure (FIM),
which assesses motor and cognitive domains. Scores vary from 18 to 126, and a high
score indicates good functional independence.
The FIM measures disability in patients with functional limitations due to various
causes and quantifies their need for assistance when performing motor and cognitive
tasks associated with activities of daily living. The validated Brazilian version
was published in 2004. The instrument is used in interviews with the patient and/or
the patient's care-giver. In this study, it was only used with the patient[9 ].
Independence for instrumental activities of daily living was assessed on the Lawton
scale[10 ], which consists of seven items and has a total score ranging from 7 (dependence
on others to help carry out activities) to 21 (complete independence). The Lawton
scale is an appropriate instrument to assess abilities that are considered more complex
than the basic activities of daily living, such as shopping, doing housework and using
transportation, and is useful for identifying a person's functional ability at a given
time and how this improves or deteriorates over time[11 ]. The severity of ataxia was assessed on the SARA scale.
All the scales used in this study were translated into Portuguese and validated for
Brazil[12 ],[13 ],[14 ],[15 ],.
Statistical analysis
The descriptive analysis was based on the mean and standard deviation of the scores
for severity, balance, instrumental activities of daily living and functionality.
Correlations between parametric data were investigated using the Pearson correlation
coefficient and Biostat* 5.0 for Windows. The Shapiro-Wilk test was used to test for
normality. Analysis of variance, applied to regression, was used to test for a relationship
between disease duration and severity, functionality and balance.
The scale of magnitudes for effect statistics proposed by Hopkins was used to interpret
the correlation coefficients: < 0.1 = trivial; 0.1 to 0.29 = small; 0.30 to 0.49 =
moderate; 0.50 to 0.69 = large; 0.70 to 0.90 = very large; > 0.90 = nearly perfect.
A level of significance of p < 0.05 was used.
RESULTS
Of the 16 patients evaluated, 75% (n = 12) were male. Mean age was 45.43 ± 10.41 years,
and mean age at onset of symptoms was 35 ± 8.72 years. Mean disease duration was 9.12
± 4.61 years, mean disease severity (SARA score) 11.4 ± 4.65, mean balance score on
the Berg scale 37.25 ± 15.61, mean FIM score 115.37 ± 9.64 and mean score on the Lawton
scale 17.25 ± 4.09. Disease duration, SARA, Lawton, FIM and Berg scores and number
of CAG repeats for each patient are shown in [Table 1 ].
Table 1
Disease duration and functional independence, disease severity and balance scores
for each patients.
Patient
Gender
Current age
Disease duration (years)
SARA
Lawton
FIM
Berg
CAG repeats
1
F
36
2
4.5
21
125
54
22/52
2
M
30
3
9
21
124
48
20/39
3
M
36
3
3
21
126
56
–
4
F
46
4
9
21
123
54
21/38
5
M
46
5
10
18
121
47
16/48
6
M
45
8
7
9
108
32
22/40
7
M
65
10
7.5
21
118
47
23/54
8
M
40
10
12
21
122
47
20/48
9
M
40
10
13
14
104
16
22/58
10
M
54
11
13
15
109
32
22/48
11
M
49
11
12.5
21
126
46
–
12
M
44
11
18
17
118
23
20/37
13
M
42
12
12.5
17
115
40
20/46
14
F
55
13
18.5
11
100
9
22/37
15
M
33
15
18
12
96
5
–
16
F
66
18
15
16
111
28
22/56
F: female; M: male; SARA: total SARA (Scale for the Assessment and Rating of Ataxia;
FIM: Functional Independence Measure) score; Berg: total score on the Berg scale;
FIM: total score on the Functional Independence Measure scale; Lawton: total score
on the Lawton independence for instrumental activities of daily living (ADL) scale.
There was a strong negative correlation between scores on the SARA and Lawton scales
(r = −0.0561), a strong negative correlation between SARA scores and FIM scores (r
= −0.6402), a strong negative correlation between SARA scores and Berg scores (r =
−0.7188), a strong positive correlation between Lawton scores and FIM scores (r =
0.8963), a strong negative correlation between Lawton scores and Berg scores (r =
−0.8340) and an almost perfect correlation between FIM scores and Berg scores (r =
0.9674). The results of the correlation tests between the SARA, Berg, FIM and Lawton
scores are shown in [Table 2 ].
Table 2
Correlation between SARA, Berg, FIM and Lawton scores, p > 0.05*.
Variable
SARA
Berg
FIM
Lawton
SARA
1
Berg
(r) = −0.7188*
1
(p) = 0.0017
FIM
(r) = −0.6402*
(r) = 0.9674*
1
(p) = 0.0075
(p) = < 0.0001
Lawton
(r) = −0.5061*
(r) = −0.8340*
(r) = −0.8963*
1
(p) = 0.0454
(p) = < 0.0001
(p) = < 0.0001
SARA: Scale for the Assessment and Rating of Ataxia; FIM: Functional Independence
Measure
Linear regression revealed a significant relationship between disease duration and
the SARA score (p = 0.0002), FIM score (p = 0.0051), Berg balance score (p = 0.0036)
and Lawton score (p = 0.0402). These results are shown in the [Figure ] and interpreted in [Table 3 ].
Figure Relationship between disease duration and (A) disease severity (SARA), (B) balance
(Berg) and (C) functionality (FIM and Lawton).SARA: Scale for the Assessment and Rating
of Ataxia; FIM: Functional Independence Measure
Table 3
Interpretation of the results of the linear regression analysis.
Variable
Interpretation
Disease duration vs. SARA
A 0.7996-point increase in SARA score can be expected for a year increase in disease
duration
Disease duration vs. FIM
A 1.38-point decrease in FIM score can be expected for a year increase in disease
duration
Disease duration vs. Berg
A 2.3034-point decrease in Berg score can be expected for a year increase in disease
duration
Disease duration vs. Lawton
A 0.4582-point decrease in Lawton score can be expected for a year increase in disease
duration
SARA: Scale for the Assessment and Rating of Ataxia; FIM: Functional Independence
Measure.
DISCUSSION
This study of 16 SCA2 patients revealed significantly impaired functionality and balance.
Disease severity was correlated with worse functionality and balance scores, and greater
disease duration was correlated with greater severity, worse balance and greater functional
impairment.
Mean age at onset of symptoms in the study series was 35 years, in agreement with
the literature, in which the age of onset is reported to be between the third and
fifth decades of life[16 ]. The main symptoms of ataxia are a balance deficit and worsening gait. The disease
initially affects the legs, but as it progresses the symptoms extend to the trunk
and arms[2 ].
The mean Berg score was 37.25 ± 15.61, and minimum and maximum scores were 5 and 56.
The Berg test is objective and can identify an increased propensity for falls. Although
a lower score on this scale is associated with a greater risk of falls, the relationship
is not linear: between 56 and 54, a one-point decrease on the Berg scale is associated
with a 3% to 4% increase in the risk of falls, but between 54 and 46, a one-point
decrease on the scale is associated with a 6% to 8% increase. Below 36 there is an
almost 100% risk of falls. Hence, changes in the Berg score can lead to very different
forecasts for the probability of falls[8 ]. It is reasonable to conclude, therefore, that the risk of falls for the patients
in this study is close to 100%.
The cerebellum plays a crucial role in the control of movement, locomotion and postural
stability. Cerebellar degeneration in individuals with SCA2 can therefore affect postural
control. It has also been suggested that postural instability is one of the main signs
of SCA2 and leads to balance deficits and, consequently, limitations on the individual's
ability to perform activities of daily living[17 ].
The ability to maintain balance is an integral part of gross motor skills, and poor
balance and inadequate posture result in difficulties performing activities of daily
living[18 ]. In this series, the main functional difficulties involved locomotion (walking,
moving around in a wheel chair and going up and down stairs). The implications for
mobility are profound: more than 50% of patients with inherited neurological diseases
report having incurred injuries as a result of falls, leading to morbidity and reduced
quality of life. In addition, repeated falls instill intense fear of falling, so that
patients restrict their activities and become less independent, limiting their ability
to perform physical activities, which in turn affects their posture and gait control[19 ].
In a study that assessed balance and functionality in 44 patients with SCA, Aizawa
et al.[20 ] concluded that individuals with SCA have significant balance impairment and an increased
risk of falls and that this affects their ability to perform certain activities, such
as self-care, transfers, locomotion and instrumental activities of daily living. They
also concluded that the more severe the ataxia, the greater the balance and functional
impairment, corroborating the results of the present study.
Torrani et al.[21 ], in a study that investigated whether there was a correlation between functional
independence and balance in patients with SCA, concluded that the correlation between
functional performance and balance was significant. They found that the greater the
score on the Berg scale, the greater the FIM score. Again, their findings corroborate
the results of this study.
The relationship between the scores on the FIM and Lawton scales shows clearly that
a change in an individual's functionality directly affects his ability to perform
instrumental activities of daily living, reflecting the major impact that certain
diseases can have on patients’ lives. Independence in basic activities of daily living,
such as self-care and transferring, as well as in more complex, or instrumental, activities,
such as preparing meals and using transportation, are important markers of functionality.
Functionality, in turn, is dependent on balance, which was assessed here with the
BERG balance scale. The instruments for assessing functional ability and balance used
in this study not only allow the patient's need for care and his/her degree of independence
to be quantified, but also can be markers of disease progression over time, as observed
here. The cross-sectional nature of this study can be considered a limitation, as
longitudinal analyses with these instruments could provide information on progression
of functional disability in individual tasks.[22 ]
LeónCarrión et al.[23 ], in a study involving patients with neurological sequelae following traumatic brain
injury, reported a reduction in incapacity after an intensive multidisciplinary therapy
program. They observed improvements of over 70% in functional, cognitive, emotional
and behavioral deficits.
In a study by Lana et al,[24 ] of patients with Parkinson's disease, dimensions related to physical aspects of
the disease adversely affected patients’ quality of life and limited their activities.
As quality of life was not assessed in the present study, further studies focusing
on this issue in patients with SCA should be carried out.
Multicenter studies with a greater number of subjects diagnosed with SCA2 should also
be carried out, as well as studies using other instruments to assess functionality
in these patients and the repercussions of non-cerebellar manifestations, such as
spasticity, neuropathy and extrapyramidal signs, on functionality and balance.
In conclusion, disease duration in this series of SCA2 patients was correlated with
greater disease severity, worse balance and greater functional dependency.
