Combining Health Data Uses to Ignite Health System Learning

Summary

Objectives: In this paper we aim to characterise the critical mass of linked data, methods and expertise required for health systems to adapt to the needs of the populations they serve – more recently known as learning health systems. The objectives are to: 1) identify opportunities to combine separate uses of common data sources in order to reduce duplication of data processing and improve information quality; 2) identify challenges in scaling-up the reuse of health data sufficiently to support health system learning.

Methods: The challenges and opportunities were identified through a series of e-health stakeholder consultations and workshops in Northern England from 2011 to 2014. From 2013 the concepts presented here have been refined through feedback to collaborators, including patient/citizen representatives, in a regional health informatics research network (www.herc.ac.uk).

Results: Health systems typically have separate information pipelines for: 1) commissioning services; 2) auditing service performance; 3) managing finances; 4) monitoring public health; and 5) research. These pipelines share common data sources but usually duplicate data extraction, aggregation, cleaning/preparation and analytics. Suboptimal analyses may be performed due to a lack of expertise, which may exist elsewhere in the health system but is fully committed to a different pipeline. Contextual knowledge that is essential for proper data analysis and interpretation may be needed in one pipeline but accessible only in another. The lack of capable health and care intelligence systems for populations can be attributed to a legacy of three flawed assumptions: 1) universality: the generalizability of evidence across populations; 2) time-invariance: the stability of evidence over time; and 3) reducibility: the reduction of evidence into specialised subsystems that may be recombined.

Conclusions: We conceptualize a population health and care intelligence system capable of supporting health system learning and we put forward a set of maturity tests of progress toward such a system. A factor common to each test is data-action latency; a mature system spawns timely actions proportionate to the information that can be derived from the data, and in doing so creates meaningful measurement about system learning. We illustrate, using future scenarios, some major opportunities to improve health systems by exchanging conventional intelligence pipelines for networked critical masses of data, methods and expertise that minimise data-action latency and ignite system-learning.

Keywords

Health data reuse - secondary uses - meaningful use - learning health systems - adaptive health systems - intelligence pipelines - health-care evidence - population health

 

• References

• 1 Lafond S, Charlesworth A, Roberts A.. Hospital finances and productivity: in a critical condition?. London: 2015
• 2 Neville S.. Financial crisis adds to health providers’ woes - FT.com. Financ Times 2015
• 3 Fineberg H. V. A Successful and Sustainable Health System - How to Get There from Here. N Engl. J Med 2012; 366 (11) 1020-1027
• 4 Wanless D, Appleby J, Harrison A, Patel D.. Our Future Health Secured?: A review of NHS funding and performance. London: 2007
• 5 Rigby M. Personal Health, Person-centred Health and Personalised Medicine - Concepts, Consumers, Confusion and Challenges in the Informatics World. Yearb Med Inform 2012; 7 (01) 7-15
• 6 Haycox A, Pirmohamed M, McLeod C, Houten R, Richards S. Through a glass darkly: economics and personalised medicine. Pharmacoeconomics 2014; 32 (11) 1055-1061
• 7 The Stationary Office. Health and Social Care Act 2012. UK: 2012
• 8 Friedman C, Rubin J, Brown J, Buntin M, Corn M, Etheredge L, Gunter C, Musen M, Platt R, Stead W, Sullivan K, Van Houweling D.. Toward a science of learning systems: a research agenda for the high-functioning Learning Health System. J Am Med Informatics Assoc 2014; 22 (01) 43-50
• 9 Friedman CP, Wong AK, Blumenthal D. Achieving a nationwide learning health system. Sci Transl Med 2010; 2: 57cm29
• 10 Ainsworth JD, Buchan IE. e-Labs and Work Objects: Towards Digital Health Economies. In: Mehmood R, Cerqueira E, Piesiewicz R, Chlamtac I. editors. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg; 2009: 205-216
• 11 Powell J, Buchan I. Electronic health records should support clinical research. J Med Internet Res 2005; 7 (01) e4
• 12 Valderas JM, Starfield B, Sibbald B, Salisbury C, Roland M. Defining comorbidity: implications for understanding health and health services. Ann Fam Med 2009; 7 (04) 357-363
• 13 Fortin M, Dionne J, Pinho G, Gignac J, Almirall J, Lapointe L. Randomized Controlled Trials: Do They Have External Validity for Patients with Multiple Comorbidities?. Ann Fam Med 2006; 4: 104-108
• 14 Geissbuhler A, Safran C, Buchan I, Bellazzi R, Labkoff S, Eilenberg K, Leese A, Richardson C, Mantas J, Murray P, De Moor G. Trustworthy reuse of health data: A transnational perspective. Int. J Med Inform 2013; 82: 1-9
• 15 Bechhofer S, Buchan I, De Roure D, Missier P, Ainsworth J, Bhagat J, Couch P, Cruickshank D, Delderfield M, Dunlop I, Gamble M, Michaelides D, Owen S, Newman D, Sufi S, Goble C.. Why linked data is not enough for scientists. In: Future Generation Computer Systems 2013: 599-611
• 16 Abernethy AP, Wheeler JL. True translational research: bridging the three phases of translation through data and behavior. Transl Behav Med 2011; 1 (01) 26-30
• 17 Grant SW, Hickey GL, Dimarakis I, Cooper G, Jenkins DP, Uppal R, Buchan I, Bridgewater B. Performance of the EuroSCORE models in emergency cardiac surgery. Circ Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes 2013; 6 (02) 178-185
• 18 Hickey GL, Grant SW, Murphy GJ, Bhabra M, Pagano D, McAllister K, Buchan I, Bridgewater B. Dynamic trends in cardiac surgery: why the logistic EuroSCORE is no longer suitable for contemporary cardiac surgery and implications for future risk models. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2013; 43 (06) 1146-1152
• 19 Nesta. People Powered Health: Co-Production Catalogue 2012
• 20 Lötvall J, Akdis CA, Bacharier LB, Bjermer L, Casale TB, Custovic A, Lemanske RF, Wardlaw AJ, Wenzel SE, Greenberger PA. Asthma endotypes: A new approach to classification of disease entities within the asthma syndrome. J Allergy Clin Immunol 2011; 127: 355-360
• 21 New J, Aung T, Baker P, Yongsheng G, Pylypczuk R, Houghton J, Rudenski A, New R, Hegarty J, Gibson J, O’Donoghue D, Buchan I.. The high prevalence of unrecognized anaemia in patients with diabetes and chronic kidney disease: a population-based study. Diabet Med 2008; 25 (05) 564-569
• 22 Lependu P, Iyer S V, Fairon C, Shah NH. Annotation Analysis for Testing Drug Safety Signals using Unstructured Clinical Notes. J Biomed Semantics 2012; 3 Suppl (Suppl. 01) S5
• 23 Overhage JM, Ryan PB, Schuemie MJ, Stang PE. Desideratum for evidence based epidemiology. Drug Saf 2013; 36 Suppl (Suppl. 01) S5-14
• 24 Information Governance Taskforce Privacy Impact Assessment Risk Stratification. Leeds: 2014
• 25 Khokhar RH, Chen R, Fung BCM, Lui SM. Quantifying the costs and benefits of privacy-preserving health data publishing. J Biomed Inform 2014; 50: 107-121
• 26 Kuhn KA, Knoll A, Mewes H-W, Schwaiger M, Bode A, Broy M, Daniel H, Feussner H, Gradinger R, Hauner H, Höfler H, Holzmann B, Horsch A, Kemper A, Krcmar H, Kochs EF, Lange R, Leidl R, Mansmann U, Mayr EW, Meitinger T, Molls M, Navab N, Nüsslin F, Peschel C, Reiser M, Ring J, Rummeny EJ, Schlichter J, Schmid R, Wichmann HE, Ziegler S. Informatics and medicine - from molecules to populations. Methods Inf Med 2008; 47 (04) 283-295
• 27 James Manyika, Michael Chui, Brad Brown, Jacques Bughin, Richard Dobbs, Charles Roxburgh AHB Big data: The next frontier for innovation, competition, and productivity. . McKinsey Glob Inst. 2011. (May) 156
• 28 BBSRC AND MRC Review of Vulnerable Skills and Capabilities London: 2014
• 29 Thompson S, Kaptoge S, White I, Wood A, Perry P, Danesh J. Statistical methods for the time-to-event analysis of individual participant data from multiple epidemiological studies. Int J Epidemiol 2010; 39 (05) 1345-1359
• 30 Ioannidis JPA. Why most published research findings are false. PLoS Med 2005; 2 (08) e124
• 31 Pélissié Du Rausas M, Manyika J, Hazan E, Bughin J, Chui M, Said R.. Internet matters: The Net’s sweeping impact on growth, jobs, and prosperity 2011
• 32 Sundararajan A. Network Effects (Arun Sundararajan, part of the Industrial Organization of Information Technology Industries web site). [date unknown] http://oz.stern.nyu.edu/io/network.html. Accessed 2015-4-11
• 33 Brabham DC. Crowdsourcing as a Model for Problem Solving: An Introduction and Cases. Converg Int J Res into New Media Technol 2008; 14 (01) 75-90
• 34 Brynjolfsson E, Hu Y Jeffrey, Simester D. Goodbye Pareto Principle, Hello Long Tail: The Effect of Search Costs on the Concentration of Product Sales. Manage Sci 2011; 57 (08) 1373-1386
• 35 Lavalle S, Lesser E, Shockley R, Hopkins MS, Kruschwitz N. Big Data, Analytics and the Path From Insights to Value. MIT Sloan Manag Rev 2011; 52 (02) 21-32
• 36 Anderson C. The long tail: why the future of business is selling less of more. New York: Hyperion; 2006
• 37 Rose G. Sick individuals and sick populations. Int J Epidemiol 2001; 30 (03) 427-432
• 38 Thusoo Ashish, Zheng Shao, Suresh A, Dhruba Borthakur, Namit Jain, Joydeep Sen Sarma, Raghotham Murthy, Hao Liu. Data warehousing and analytics infrastructure at facebook. In: Proceedings of the 2010 ACM SIGMOD International Conference on Management of data. ACM, 2010.. 1013-1020
• 39 Sumbaly Roshan Kreps J, Sam Shah S.. The big data ecosystem at linkedin. In: Proceedings of the 2013 ACM SIGMOD International Conference on Management of Data. ACM 2013: 1125-1134
• 40 Dean J, Ghemawat S.. MapReduce: Simplied Data Processing on Large Clusters. Proc. 6th Symp Oper Syst Des Implement 2004: 137-149
• 41 Wicks P, Vaughan TE, Massagli MP, Heywood J. Accelerated clinical discovery using self-reported patient data collected online and a patient-matching algorithm. Nat Biotechnol 2011; 29 (05) 411-414
• 42 PwC. Socio-economic impact of mHealth; An assessment report for the European Union 2013
• 43 Swan M. Crowdsourced health research studies: an important emerging complement to clinical trials in the public health research ecosystem. J Med Internet Res 2012; 14 (02) e46
• 44 Wolf G.. The quantified self. TED@Cannes 2010
• 45 Guyatt G, Sackett D, Taylor DW, Chong J, Roberts R, Pugsley S. Determining optimal therapy - randomized trials in individual patients. N Engl J Med 1986; 314: 889-892
• 46 Buchan I. Informatics for Healthcare Systems. In: Walshe, Kieran, Smith, Judith, editors. Healthcare Management. McGraw-Hill International 2011: 321-336
• 47 Buchan I, Winn J, Bishop C.. A unified modeling approach to data-intensive healthcare. Fourth Paradig Data-Intensive Sci Discov Washington, DC. Microsoft Res 2009: 91-98
• 48 Hendler J, Berners-Lee T. From the Semantic Web to social machines: A research challenge for AI on the World Wide Web. Artif Intell 2010; 174 (02) 156-161
• 49 Ainsworth J, Cunningham J, Buchan I.. ELab: Bringing together people, data and methods to enhance knowledge discovery in healthcare settings. In: Studies in Health Technology and Informatics 2012: 39-48
• 50 McCartney M. Care.data: why are Scotland and Wales doing it differently?. BMJ 2014; 348: 1702
• 51 Beauchamp T, Childress J. Principles of Biomedical Ethics. 7th ed.. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2012
• 52 Open Science Collaboration. An Open, Large-Scale, Collaborative Effort to Estimate the Reproducibility of Psychological Science Perspect Psychol Sci. 2012; 7 (06) 657-660
• 53 Campbell H, Hotchkiss R, Bradshaw N, Porteous M. Integrated care pathways. BMJ 1998; 316 7125 133-137
• 54 Mirnezami R, Nicholson J, Darzi A. Preparing for precision medicine. N Engl J Med 2012; 366 (06) 489-491
• 55 Kontopantelis E, Buchan I, Reeves D, Checkland K, Doran T. Relationship between quality of care and choice of clinical computing system: retrospective analysis of family practice performance under the UK’s quality and outcomes framework. BMJ Open 2013; 3 (08) e003190
• 56 Ainsworth J, Buchan I. COCPIT: a tool for integrated care pathway variance analysis. Stud Health Technol Inform 2012; 180: 995-999
• 57 Brown B, Williams R, Ainsworth J, Buchan I. Missed opportunities mapping: computable healthcare quality improvement. Stud Health Technol Inform 2013; 192: 387-391