Key-words:
Coronavirus - coronavirus disease 2019 - neurosurgery
Introduction
A new disease which started with pneumonia-like symptoms in December of 2019 in Wuhan
China, soon started to impact the whole world.[[1]],[[2]],[[3]],[[4]] Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has now spread to most countries and territories,
with confirmed 2,995,758 cases and 204,987 deaths according to the WHO situation report
of April 29, 2020.[[5]] Iran with 92,584 confirmed cases and 5877 deaths has been substantially affected
by the disease.[[5]] The disease is particularly pressing in hospitals and health-care facilities. According
to the national health system recommendations, hospitals halted their routine activities
and most hospital beds have been assigned to COVID-19 patients.[[6]]
COVID-19 epidemic is still ongoing with a number of cases rapidly rising all over
the world. Given predictions related to the anticipated spread of COVID19, we should
be ready to provide care for neurosurgical patients while the epidemic is ongoing.[[7]] Here, we share our experience with 10 neurosurgical cases with confirmed COVID-19.
Materials and Methods
Study population
Surgeons from eight referral neurosurgical departments in Tehran, Iran, were asked
to fill a predefined electronic form containing information regarding neurosurgical
patients who were diagnosed with COVID-19. First, they all agreed to fill the form,
and the total number of eligible cases was calculated to be 24, but only two centers
completed the form by the time the deadline was reached on April 20, 2020.
We identified 10 adults from two hospitals (Shariati Hospital, Tehran University of
Medical Sciences and Firoozgar General Hospital, Iran University of Medical Sciences)
who needed neurosurgical care and was diagnosed with COVID-19. The diagnosis of COVID-19
was based on chest imaging findings and reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction
of a nasopharyngeal swab for coronavirus and an infectious disease specialist and
a pulmonologist confirmed the diagnoses. Using a predefined electronic form demographic
data, clinical signs and symptoms, type of neurosurgical care, lab and radiologic
data were obtained. Furthermore, one of the residents from each department completed
the form for patients' coexisting conditions. We did not get informed consent, and
this was waved by ethics review boards of both centers, and researchers only collected
anonymized data.
Statistical analysis
The electronic form automatically generated a spreadsheet which was then used for
analyzing the data in the Microsoft Excel 2019. We are reporting descriptive statistics
as medians and interquartile ranges and categorical variables as count and percentage.
Results
Patients characteristics
COVID-19 was first diagnosed on February 24, 2020, in these two hospitals. During
the period from February 24, 2020, to April 15, 2020, ten patients in these two hospitals
were diagnosed with COVID-19. [[Table 1]] shows the patients' characteristics. In Shariati hospital, one patient was scheduled
for surgery before elective surgeries were halted and during the surgery, she developed
a decline in O2 saturation and shortness of breath after she was extubated. In Firoozgar
hospital, one patient who had been under intensive care unit (ICU) care for a long
time was diagnosed with COVID-19. Only one patient was admitted to hospital for respiratory
symptoms and several days after admission, she developed neurological symptoms and
was consulted for surgery. All other patients came to the hospital with either traumatic
events or neurosurgical symptoms. The age of the patients ranged from 21 to 75 years
and 70% were males. Before the diagnosis of COVID-19 cough and shortness of breath
were most common symptoms. [[Table 2]] summarizes the laboratory data and imaging findings of the patients. Abnormalities
on chest radiography or computed tomography (CT) were found in all patients.{Table
1}{Table 2}
Table 1: Clinical characteristic of neurosurgical cases with confirmed coronavirus disease.2019
(n=10)
Table 2: Imaging findings and laboratory data of neurosurgical cases with confirmed coronavirus
disease.2019 (n=10)
Treatment and outcomes
Of 10 patients, eight underwent neurosurgical interventions in this period and one
patient had the previous craniotomy and was cared for in ICU for about a month before
he was diagnosed with COVID-19 [[Table 3]]. Surgeons did not report any unexpected complications during their surgeries except
in two cases there was an unusual decrease in O2 saturation during the operation.
In one of these patients, who did not have any respiratory complaints before surgery,
this finding led to the diagnosis of COVID-19. Three patients in this series died
during this period. Only one death could be directly related to respiratory infection
by coronavirus. This case was the same patient who was in ICU for a long time and
even before COVID-19 was suffering from respiratory problems. The cause of death in
the other two patients was a cardiovascular origin not related to COVID-19.{Table
3}
Table 3: Treatments and clinical outcomes of neurosurgical cases with confirmed coronavirus
disease-19 (n=10)
Discussion
In this case series, we present a series of 10 patients admitted to neurosurgical
units with a concurrent diagnosis of COVID-19. There were two patients who were already
admitted in these two centers when the coronavirus pandemic started. One patient was
scheduled for elective surgery and during and after surgery, she developed respiratory
symptoms. The other one was a patient who was in ICU for a long time and COVID-19
led to worsening of his respiratory symptoms. It's possible that these two patients
were infected with the disease by nosocomial transmission. Nosocomial transmission
of COVID-19 is a major concern in hospitals which can lead to super spreading of the
virus in the hospitals.[[8]] Infection prevention and control (IPC) measures, which can impact within hospital
spread of the disease, must be taken seriously. Previously in the 2003 severe acute
respiratory syndrome (SARS)-CoV outbreak, it has been shown that adhering to IPC measures
was related to within hospital transmission of the disease.[[9]],[[10]],[[11]],[[12]]
Health-care workers rely on personal protective equipment (PPE), such as gloves, face
masks, goggles, face shields, respirators, and gowns, to prevent spread of infection.
At first, our hospitals were not equipped with protective gear that staff needed for
facing coronavirus patients. PPE were scarce and many doctors and staff used unconventional
solutions for PPE. With soaring numbers coronavirus cases, doctors and other staff
were confronting a shortage of PPE. Surgical mask and nonsterile gloves which was
readily available in the operation rooms and wards could not be easily found in the
hospital. This shortage is now resolving in our centers. Before an operation on a
patient with definitive coronavirus infection or those who were suspected by an infectious
disease specialist to have the virus, N95 respirator masks and a hazmat suit (hazardous
materials suit), also known as decontamination suit, which is a piece of PPE that
consists of an impermeable whole-body garment worn as protection against hazardous
materials. Due to these suits being so warm, we could not perform long neurosurgical
procedures wearing them, so for the surgery itself we used our regular surgical gowns,
N95 respirator masks, and goggles or face shields.
It seems that the disease and what came with it has put a lot of psychological pressure
on health care workers. Neurosurgeons are not an exception in this regard. Facing
increasing contact with cases, shortage of PPE, lack of definitive treatment, fear
of infecting our families, lack of adequate support and increasing internet and media
coverage maybe some of the sources of this psychological burden. This was true for
the 2003 SARS-CoV outbreak and new data from China also supports the idea of increasing
psychological burden.[[13]],[[14]],[[15]],[[16]],[[17]]
COVID-19 has now spread all around the globe. There is no suggestion that disease
might disappear soon. It is also possible that this virus become another virus that
people face regularly.[[18]] Still, it is not clear how COVID-19 impacts course of surgeries. In our patients,
we did not encounter any unexpected events during the surgery itself. There was a
problem with ventilation in two of our patients during the surgery. Some of our patients
had signs and symptoms of the disease before the operation but some developed symptoms
after the operation. Other reports suggest high mortality in surgeries performed for
patients with COVID-19.[[19]],[[20]] Meanwhile, we must consider that the virus might suppress immune system[[21]],[[22]] and surgery might ignite the infection.
In our series, three patients died. This group consisted of two patients with severe
traumatic brain injuries and a patient with a rapidly growing recurrent brain neoplasm
(the last pathology was glioblastoma multiform; WHO Grade IV). All these three patients
were admitted to the hospital with loss of consciousness due to severe brain damage.
Two of them had traumatic events that led to intracerebral hemorrhage and subarachnoid
hemorrhage with severe brain edema. All these three patients had a GCS lower than
8 when they were admitted. They all developed bilateral ground-glass infiltration
in their chest CT scan, and pleural effusion emerged in one of them which led to clinical
suspicion of COVID-19. This suggests that patients with severe brain damage due to
neoplastic or traumatic events might at higher risk for unfavorable outcomes with
COVID-19. These three patients had poor prognosis even if they were not infected with
coronavirus and our series only consists of 10 patients, so no definitive assumptions
can be made.
COVID-19 cases are still on rise around the world. We still do not know how it might
change neurosurgical practice in long term. There are some studies sharing their experiences
and recommendations for neurosurgical practice.[[23]],[[24]],[[25]],[[26]] However, they mostly focus on practice recommendations not patients outcomes. We
are still following the patients to unfold the long-term outcome of neurosurgical
patients with COVID-19. If this pandemic becomes chronic, it is better to think of
ways to start modified neurosurgical practice despite COVID-19 and even develop specific
guidelines for neurosurgical practice in the presence of virus. Other series on outcome
of neurosurgical patients infected with coronavirus can help us have a better assessment
and strategic planning for the situation.
To outline the lessons learned and recommendations for neurosurgical units, safeguarding
a very skilled health-care staff is the highest priority for any society and health-care
system.[[27]] According to high positive screening for COVID-19, precaution is suggested in all
patients. Nearly, all COVID-19-infected patients had clinical signs and symptoms and
diagnosis of pneumonia and had distinctive CT imaging patterns. Therefore, a chest
X-ray/chest CT scan is essential in early diagnosis and evaluation of disease course.
Therefore, the chest X-ray/CT scan is recommended for the clinical diagnosis of COVID-19
in neurosurgery units.[[28]] In addition, any time in the process of hospitalization, whenever we see any fever
or any respiratory distress or repeated cough, neurosurgery staff, residents, and
professors would consider possible COVID-19 and re-evaluation performance. The availability
of intensive care beds, ventilators, and all protective equipment is suggested.[[29]]
COVID-19 has shown a rapid spread. It is cautious to limit nonemergency neurosurgical
procedures and prioritize urgent neurosurgical treatment. When dealing with neurosurgical
emergencies, a conservative approach is recommended. When working on COVID-19 patients,
using committed PPE and obeying to specific rules is suggested. Short-time operating
procedures or minimally invasive surgery must be considered in the management of emergent
patients. The rules outline the rigorous supervision of entry/exit into emergency
room, neurosurgery department, clinics, and operating room and guidance on performing
practices safely to lessen risk spreading the virus. The reorganization of all personnel
and health system based on the numbers needed to function and quality of job is necessary.[[30]] Triage for probable COVID-19 symptoms is recommended both before hospitalization
by telephone at home and at the time of hospitalization. During hospital stay, the
reorganized team of education should instruct patients as much as possible to accelerate
their return home. Patients must be discharged under steady good quality conditions
to reduce the risk of readmission. It is wise to reduce or postpone postdischarge
controls and reorganize the health-care system for a sufficient communication for
telemonitoring released patients to lessen hospital visits.[[31]] Finally, the medical and surgical management of patients with any neurosurgical
disease must be adapted by adjusting the consultation methods, by arranging interventions
according to the prognosis of disease, taking into checking account the patient's
comorbidities.[[32]] Right now, many countries are planning to resume their routine activities. The
greatest concern when resuming full clinical care is continuation of social distancing,
have mask and glove, and cannot be so sympathetic with our patients as before.
Elective surgeries can't be postponed for long in neurosurgical patients and if this
pandemic lasts longer many of surgeries marked as elective should be resumed. We are
worried that delays in care might result in substantial burden on both patients and
health systems. Many are tolerating pain and disabilities before they can get the
treatment they need. Elective surgeries can only be resumed after a roadmap is prepared.
We should keep in mind that this pandemic is no where near the end. Therefore, it
is better to design measures to ensure patients and health-care providers safety.
If there are enough COVID-19 tests available, routing testing of elective patients
less than 48 h before the procedure is suggested. If the test is positive, possibility
of delaying surgery for at least 2 weeks must be discussed between surgery team and
the patient. If a patient is negative for COVID-19, surgery, pre- and post-operative
care can be performed as usual. It is possible that even patients with negative tests
for COVID-19, found to be positive during their admission. In these cases, if delaying
surgery is not recommended, all staff in contact with the patient must have appropriate
PPE. It is better that the patient wears a mask at all times in his/her stay at the
hospital. If the procedure is performed, the surgical room must remain empty for certain
time to allow air exchange. All equipment and supplies should be cleaned per protocol.
Based on patients' postoperative condition, they must be transported to an individual
ward room or isolated ICU bed for postoperative care. It is better to monitor employees
who were in contact with the patient for COVID-19 sign and symptoms and if possible,
they should not return to patient care unless asymptomatic for 72 h.
There are some limitations in our study. In this series, no autopsy was done on three
deceased patients to define the cause of death. We also could not collect all eligible
24 patients in these eight hospitals. We hope that long-term follow-up of these patients
and other published cases with similar condition help make COVID-19 situation in neurosurgical
practice clearer.
