KEY WORDS
De-gloved penile inversion flap - male to female embryonic equivalents-based sex reassignment
surgery - transgenders - transwomen - vaginoplasty
INTRODUCTION
Gender Dysphoria (GD) is seen in some diversified individuals who have varying degrees
of disgruntlement of their anatomical, phenotypic sex, and genderness. In addition,
they have intense desire to possess secondary sexual properties of the opposite sex.
GD is a unique human condition that is classified behaviorally but treated medically
by hormones and surgery. In 2010, the World Professional Association for Transgender
Health (WPATH)[[1]] declared GD to be dissociated from functional and psychological disorders. This
has led to a vast change in the social and political scenario for the GD worldwide.
The treatment includes self-rehabilitation through a multidisciplinary team approach
and the traditional triadic sequence; the final step of which being sex reassignment
surgery in this complete human transformation.[[2]]
In 1966, the influential book by Benjamin, The Transsexual Phenomenon,[[3]] made many clinicians aware of the potential benefits of sex reassignment surgery.
In 1973, the diagnosis of “GD syndrome” was introduced by Fisk[[4]] to define the distress resulting from conflicting gender identity and sex of assignment.
“Transsexualismus,” the term was coined by Magnus Hirschfeld in 1923. The term “transsexualism”
first appeared officially in the widely used Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders Edition in 1980.[[5]] In the recent edition, the term transsexualism was replaced by the term GD.
The feeling of incongruence between phenotypic sex and psychological recognition of
self-gender is termed GD. Transsexualism is the most extreme form of this disorder.
Meerwijk and Sevelius in their meta-analysis study published in 2017 revealed in the
USA that 390/100,000 adults are estimated to be transgender.[[6]] No definite figures are available for India,[[7]] but transgender population is palpably on the rise.
Androgen produced by the male fetus brings about changes in the fetal brain, which
are essential for the development of male gender identity. Gender identity is reinforced
by the gender role the child is exposed to, in the early years.
Transsexuals, however, identify themselves with the psychological sex, which is opposite
to their physical sex, and hence feels trapped in the wrong body. Recent research
indicates that genetic factors, as well as fetal neurodevelopment, contribute to this.
Many sexually dimorphic nuclei have been found in the hypothalamus.[[8]] One of these is the central subdivision of Bed nucleus of Stria Terminalis.[[9]] In human males, the volume of this nucleus and its number of neurons is twice compared
to females. In transwomen, it was similar to female controls.
This article explores an anatomical approach of converting and harmonizing the external
genitalia according to the mind of these transwomen.
Aims and objectives
The aims and objectives of the study are to evaluate the esthetic and functional outcome
of male-to-female embryonic equivalents-based sex reassignment surgery (MTFEEbSRS)
using the institutional scoring system [[Table 1]].
Table 1
The clinical details of operated transwomen
|
Serial number of transwomen
|
Age
|
HIV status
|
Length of neovagina created (cm)
|
Complications#
|
Secondary procedure
|
Institutional Score of esthetic outcome*
|
Institutional score of functional outcome**
|
|
#All these were minor complications managed conservatively except SR in one individual.
*The following institutional grading system was used for the assessment of esthetic
outcome assigned at the end of an average follow up period of 18 months. Grade 1:
Poor outcome-Hyper pigmented/hypo pigmented widened scar; Ill-defined introitus; severely
distorted submerged clitoris; severely contracted neo-vaginal pouch. Grade 2: Intermediate
outcome-Scars hypertrophic; introitus moderately defined; moderately projected clitoris
on the crural mount; Mild to moderately contracted neo-vaginal pouch. Grade 3: Excellent
outcome-Imperceptible scar merged in the esthetic subunits of external genitalia;
well-defined introitus; desired clitoral projection at the proximal end of the introitus
commissure, hooded by the scrotal flap and degloved penile flap junction; capacious
vaginal introitus. **The following institutional grading system was used for the assessment
of functional outcome assigned at the end of an average follow up period of 18 months.
Grade 1: Poor outcome-Painful clitoris and scars with no ergogenic response; poor,
distorted urinary stream with external urethral meatal stenosis; inadequate Severely
contracted vagina causing dyspareunia. Grade 2: Intermediate outcome-esthetic clitoris
with inadequate ergogenic response; able to micturate in squatting position but distorted
urinary stream with wetting of perineum; pain free; mildly contracted neo-vagina.
Grade 3: Excellent outcome-Excellent ergogenic response; able to pass urine in the
squatting posture with good stream; adequate and well serviceable vagina. E: Edema,
MC: Mild collection, MI: Mild Infection, SR: Scrotal flap reduction, HIV: Human Immunodeficiency
virus
|
|
1
|
22
|
−
|
9
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
2
|
31
|
+
|
8.7
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
3
|
36
|
−
|
11.5
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
4
|
26
|
+
|
12
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
5
|
24
|
−
|
9.5
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
6
|
40
|
−
|
7.5
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
7
|
30
|
+
|
10
|
E
|
SR
|
2
|
2
|
|
8
|
33
|
+
|
8
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
9
|
25
|
−
|
10.5
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
10
|
33
|
+
|
9
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
11
|
24
|
−
|
10
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
12
|
41
|
−
|
12
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
13
|
28
|
+
|
9.5
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
14
|
32
|
−
|
10.5
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
15
|
29
|
−
|
12
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
16
|
26
|
+
|
11
|
MI+MC+E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
17
|
39
|
−
|
10.5
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
18
|
35
|
+
|
9.8
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
19
|
27
|
+
|
9
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
20
|
21
|
−
|
8.6
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
21
|
33
|
+
|
10
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
22
|
34
|
−
|
8.5
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
23
|
38
|
+
|
9.8
|
MI+MC+E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
24
|
32
|
−
|
8
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
25
|
39
|
+
|
10.2
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
26
|
24
|
+
|
12
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
27
|
32
|
+
|
9.2
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
28
|
28
|
−
|
10
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
29
|
35
|
−
|
9
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
30
|
30
|
+
|
9.5
|
E
|
None
|
3
|
3
|
|
Average
|
31.5
|
|
9.8
|
|
|
2.9
|
2.9
|
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Thirty transwomen who had undergone MFEEbSRS between October 2012 and March 2016 were
retrospectively studied [[Table 1]]. Preoperative counseling and pertinent legal issues were explained, and informed
consent was obtained from each transwoman. Institutional Ethical Committee permission
was obtained for this study.
Tools used for the assessment of esthetic and functional outcome
Institutional scoring system for the evaluation of esthetic and functional outcome
was used and each transwoman was assigned a score at the end of the follow-up period
by two independent plastic surgeons, and the average was obtained [[Table 1]].
-
Age of the patients ranged from 21 to 42 years (average of 31.5 years)
-
There were no comorbid conditions associated with the patients except that 15 individuals
tested positive (for human immunodeficiency virus I and II), but their CD4 count was
>400 cells/mm3.
Inclusion criteria
-
30 Transsexuals who fulfilled the Benjamin criteria[[3]] and had undergone male to female SRS were only included in the study
-
Individuals who had completed the prescribed period of cross-living and hormonal therapy
-
Individuals with stable mental status, assessed by psychiatrists
-
Those who wanted to have a serviceable vagina.
Exclusion criteria
-
Patients who had undergone SRS previously following any other technique
-
Retroviral (HIV)-positive patients with CD4 count <400 cells/mm3
-
Other psychiatric illness.
Preoperative preparations
Patients were examined [[Figure 1]] to rule out local surgical or medical problems (i.e., hydrocele, hernia, and fungal
infections). Routine investigations and additional investigations were:
Figure 1: Preoperative
-
Liver function tests
-
Serum lipid profile
-
Coagulation profile, which included bleeding time, clotting time, prothrombin time
(INR ratio <1.5), and platelet count (>100,000/mm3) (as these individuals were on hormone therapy)
-
They were screened for sexually transmittable diseases. Retroviral (HIV)-positive
patients were subjected to CD4 count to ensure that it is >400 cells/mm3. Details of hormone treatment taken by the patients were recorded.
Operative procedure
All patients were operated under spinal anesthesia. Universal precautions were strictly
followed. Patient in lithotomy position, lower abdomen, perineum, and both thighs
were prepared and draped. Prepuce was retracted. Circular marking was done around
the corona glandis, at the junction of the glans penis and the prepuce. Another hemicircular
marking was placed on the ventral surface of the penis at the junction of the penis
and the scrotum. From the mid-point of this marking an incisional marking was carried
out along the median raphe of the scrotum up to its posterior end. Tumescent (1:200,000
adrenalin in normal saline) was injected in all the markings. The incision was started
first in the corona glandis area, and the whole penile body skin was de-gloved by
dissecting in a plane deep to the Bucks fascia and superficial to the tunica albuginea.
The tunica albuginea with the embedded deep dorsal vein of the penis flanked on each
side by the dorsal artery and nerve of the penis was maintained on the dorsum of the
penis during this dissection. This was relatively avascular plane and can be easily
achieved with a combination of sharp and blunt dissection. The hemi-circle incision
at the penoscrotal junction was deepened to the level of tunica albuginea. The incision
was further extended up to the posterior scrotal skin, halving the scrotum into two
parts. High orchiectomy was carried on either side at the level of the external superficial
inguinal ring, preserving the scrotal flaps, which contained the skin, dartos, and
Colles fascia [[Figure 2]]. The body of the penis with the glans was delivered in a retrograde fashion through
the hemi-circular incision leaving the de-gloved penile skin, which was subsequently
inverted, from the glandular end [[Figure 3]]. The superficial external pudendal artery formed the vascular basis of the pedicled
inverted penile tube flap, which also retained its innervation from branches of the
dorsal nerve of penis.
Figure 2: Intra-operative picture showing high orchiectomy
Figure 3: Intra-operative picture showing the de-gloved penile flap
Dissection was started at the junction between the body of the penis and the root
of the penis by dissecting away the distal fibers of the bulbospongiosus just distal
to the transition of bulb of penis to the corpus spongiosum. Working on the tunica
albuginea and dissecting between the ventral surfaces of the conjoint septum of corpora
cavernosa, proximal 1.5 cm length of the corpus spongiosum was isolated by dividing
it from the rest of the body of the penis [[Figure 4]].
Figure 4: Intra-operative picture showing separation of corpus spongiosum from the corpora
cavernosa
0.75 cm × 0.75 cm × 0.50 cm of glans in the dorsal median plane was harvested along
with a long strip of tunica albuginea enclosing the central deep dorsal vein of the
penis flanked on either side by the dorsal artery of penis and dorsal nerve of penis.
This surgical step was based on good vascular communication between the arteries of
the bulb with the dorsal artery of the penis at the corona glandis.[[10]] Both the corpora with the conjoint septum was ligated in continuity and divided
at the level of the transition from crus to corpus to create a crural mount [[Figure 5]]. The small glandular erectile tissue was recruited on the long strip of the tunica
albuginea vascular pedicle was fixed over this crural mount after removing the rest
of the body of the penis and the glans. This formed the neo-clitoridis, which was
the embryological equivalent of glans penis (both are the embryonic derivatives of
gonadal tubercle) [[Figures 6]
[7] and [Table 2]].
Figure 5: Intra-operative picture showing base fashioned from the crura of the corpora cavernosa
cranial to catheterised bulbar urethra for reduced clitoral flap
Figure 6: Intraoperative picture showing marking for the harvest of reduced neo-clitoridis
based on the dorsal penile pedicle
Figure 7: Intraoperative picture showing harvest of reduced glans clitoridis on the dorsal
pedicle in progression
Table 2
Embryonic equivalents observed by the author
|
Undifferentiated gonads (exists up to 6 weeks of embryonic life)
|
Male derivative
|
Female derivative
|
MTFEEbSRS technique
|
|
MTFEEbSRS: Male to female embryonic equivalents-based sex reassignment surgery
|
|
Genital tubercle
|
Glans penis
|
Glans clitoridis
|
Reduced glans on dorsal penile pedicle
|
|
Urethral folds
|
Corpus spongiosum and penile skin
|
Labia minora and introitus
|
De-gloved unfurled proximal penile skin forms the introitus and labia minora
|
|
Urogenital sinus
|
Bulbar urethra, prostatic urethra, membranous urethra
|
Female urethra
Sino vaginal bulb-develops as an off shoot, establishes connection with the distal
end of the fused mesonephric duct to form the vagina and the fornices
|
External urethral meatus is derived from the distal portion of the bulbar urethra
De-gloved inverted penile tube, which is the equivalent of ectodermal growth of the
urogenital sinus, is used for the creation of neo-vagina
|
|
Labioscrotal swelling
|
Scrotum
|
Labia majora
|
Reduced scrotal flaps forms the labia majora
|
Dissection was done in the posterior midline of the urogenital diaphragm posterior
to the bulb of the penis by dividing the central tendinous portion of superficial
and deep transverse perinei muscles and dissecting through the perineal body posterior
to the membranous urethra and the prostate up to the medial most fibers of the levator
ani (levatores prostate). This existed as a normal dehiscence beyond the superficial
fascia of the deep perineal pouch. This dissection creates a space for the neovaginal
pouch.
The inverted glandular end of the pedicled penile tube flap was closed with absorbable
sutures. Two stout sutures were passed through this closed end, and these were anchored
to either pillar of the levatores prostate close to the apex of the perineal body.
Moreover, thus neovaginal pouch was created [[Figures 8]
[9]].
Figure 8: Intraoperative picture showing pocket creation by dissection through the perineal
body for the neo-vagina
Figure 9: Intraoperative picture showing reconstructed neovaginal pouch, which is fixed to
the levatores prostate at its apex
When the neovaginal pouch was created, the proximal unfurled penile skin was automatically
drawn and applied over neo-clitoridis and corpus spongiosal stump. Carefully dissecting
on any one side of the superficial dorsal vein of the penis (These ports are created
on one side of superficial dorsal vein of penis and superficial external pudendal
vessels which travel in the midline which are the pedicle for the inverted penile
flap. Therefore, the pedicle has to be protected during the port creation. Failure
to do so may precipitate necrosis of the neovaginal vault, without causing injury
to the pedicle, two ports were created, one for the delivery of the neo-clitoridis
proximally and the other for the creation of neo-external urethral meatus (inferior
to the neo-clitoridis). Through the inferior port, which was a vertical slit of size
1.75 cm on an average incorporating two triangular flap of penile skin the corpus
spongiosum/bulb stump was delivered [[Figure 10]]. 18F Foleys catheter was inserted, and the bulb was inflated to retain it in position.
The stump was obliquely divided to create a large circumference, flush with the draped
penile skin [[Figure 11]]. The stump was spatulated at 12 o'clock and 6o'clock positions to receive the triangular
flap [[Figure 10]]. The oblique division of the urethral stump and the triangular skin flap interdigitation
prevents neo-external urethral meatal stenosis. The rest of the urethra was fixed
to the skin by absorbable sutures through full thickness bites through the urethra
and the skin.
Figure 10: Intraoperative picture showing inverted penile flap just before neo-external urethroplasty
(left). Schematic diagram showing rising of triangular flaps in the proximal unfurled
penile skin, which is to cover the introitus (intermediate) (Right) interdigitation
of the triangular flaps at 12 and 6 o'clock position back cut in the neo-urethra
Figure 11: Intraoperative picture showing oblique division of the bulbar urethra after mobilization
Based on the superficial external pudendal vessel supply, anteriorly and superiorly
based reduced scrotal flaps are brought on to either side of the folded penile skin
to create the labia minora folds and the introitus. Apices of the reduced scrotal
flaps were sutured to the inverted penile skin tube from 3 to 9 o'clock, through the
6 o'clock position. The inverted unmarred vaginal skin formed the 3–9 o'clock through
the 12 o'clock opening of the neovagina. In addition, medialising penile skin provides
hood for the neo clitoris [[Figure 12]]. Perfect hemostasis was secured. Few Segmullar drains were kept in the suture lines
[[Figure 13]]. Cottony fluffy supporting T-Bandages were applied. Custom-made finger glove stuffed
with wet cotton was used to splint the neovagina for the initial 5 days only. This
was followed by regular saline washes and repeated splinting with custom-made splint
from British dental compound for 21 days in toto. In unmarried transwomen were instructed
to use custom-made splint for 3 months.
Figure 12: Schematic diagram showing the Author's technique of providing the hood to the neo-clitoris
Figure 13: Immediate postoperative picture
Bath and ambulation were allowed in the 3rd postoperative day. Short step gait, avoiding abduction was advised. Foley catheter
was removed on the 10th day. They were discharged between days 10 and 14.
They were observed by two independent plastic surgeons at the end of 3, 6, and 12
months [[Figure 14]]. The follow-up period ranged from 9 to 25 months; the mean follow-up period is
17.5 months. Computations of functional and esthetic scores were done for each of
them. Transwomen satisfaction was separately analyzed. The author's operative technique
is essentially reverse embryogenesis explained in [Table 2].
Figure 14: Late postoperative picture
RESULTS AND OBSERVATIONS AT THE END OF FOLLOW-UP
RESULTS AND OBSERVATIONS AT THE END OF FOLLOW-UP
All the transwomen [[Table 1] and [Graphs 1]
[2]
[3]
[4]] were followed on an average of 18 months (endpoint of the study).
Graph 1: Length of Neovagina in 30 transwomen
Graph 2: Post operative complications
Graph 3: Aesthetic grading chart in thirty transwomen
Graph 4: Functional grading in thirty transwomen
-
The maximum length of neovagina created was 12 cm, with minimum being 7.5 cm with
an average of 9.8 cm [[Graph 1]]
-
The average vaginal introitus dimension was 2.75 cm
-
Postoperative edema was universally seen in all cases, but it settled uneventfully.
One transwoman had labio/scrotal flap excess deformity, and she underwent reduction
surgery after 6 months. This was the only secondary procedure in our study. Mild infection
and mild collection were encountered only in 2 transwomen (6.7%)
-
These were managed conservatively
-
No other complications were encountered.
Two independent plastic surgeons interviewed and assessed the transwomen at the end
of the follow-up, and esthetic and functional scores were obtained from them [[Table 1]].
The esthetic outcome in 30 transwomen ranged from Grade 2: Intermediate result (one
case) to Grade 3: Excellent score (in 29 cases). The average functional outcome in
30 transwomen was Grade 3 – excellent score.
Transwomen satisfaction assessment
Satisfaction of transwomen with the appearance of the labia, vulva, clitoris, and
sexual function was good to very good in 98% (5-point score from unsatisfactory, and
poor to very good was used). The frequency of sexual activities increased significantly
postoperatively for orogenital stimulation and decreased significantly for the frequency
of anal intercourse (t = −4.81; P < 0.001). Orgasmic function was reported by 85% of participants. The psychological
adjustment was good to very good, with low depression scores (another scoring given
based on the leading questions to unearth clinical depressions). Sexual satisfaction
was statistically and positively correlated with vaginal function and depth, clitoral
sensation, appearance of the vulva and labia minora, and natural lubrication and negatively
correlated with depression scores.
DISCUSSION
As affirmed by Karim[[11]] the goal of genital reassignment surgery in male-to-female transsexuals is “to
create a perineo-genital complex as feminine in appearance and function as possible
which is free of poorly healed areas, scars, and neuromas.”
Vaginoplasty in transwomen is classified into the following five categories.
-
a. Nongenital skin grafts
-
b. Penile skin as graft
-
c. Penile-scrotal skin flaps[[12]]
-
d. Nongenital skin flaps
-
e. Pedicled intestinal transplant.
In 1931, Abraham reported that in his patient, penectomy was performed 9 years after
castration.[[13]] Subsequently, the lining of a neovagina was created with a skin graft draped inside-out
over a sponge in accordance with the technique first published by Abbe[[14]] and later popularized by McIndoe and Banister.[[15]] In 1956, Fogh-Andersen was the first to report the use of a full-thickness skin
graft harvested from the penile skin to line the neovagina.[[16]] In 1957, Gillies and Millard reported the use of penile skin as a pedicled flap
for vaginoplasty.[[17]]
Modifications developed can be classified into the following three groups:
-
The inverted penile skin with a small triangular scrotal skin flaps to “break” the
circular introitus[[18]]
-
The pedicled penile skin tube may be split open to form a rectangular flap, posteriorly
pedicled scrotal skin flap[[19]]
-
The inverted penile skin tube may be applied based on an inferior pedicle.[[20]]
These flaps demonstrated lesser tendency to contract; were covered with vascularized
tissue; local innervation is provided; and the flap is virtually hairless.
The author utilized the unfurled proximal pedicled penile flap for introitus covering
as well as its distal inverted portion was used as a stable lining for the well-vascularized
wall bound space created at perineal body level (neovagina). Author technique of mesializing
the unfurling proximal pedicled penile flap skin provides the hood for neoclitoris,
overcomes the exposed clitoris problem mentioned by Bouman,[[18]] Jones et al.,[[19]] Edgerton and Bull[[20]] (due to paucity of penile skin) [[Figures 12]
[13]
[14]]. In 1980, Cairns and de Villiers reported the use of a medial thigh flap for vaginoplasties
in four transsexuals who had previously undergone penile skin inversion vaginoplasty
with the inadequate result.[[21]] Huang[[22]] used two inguinopudendal flaps. The inverted penile tube flap provides a sufficient
length of neovagina in all the transwomen in this study group. The first reported
use of an intestinal transplant for vaginoplasty in a nontranssexual patient was provided
by Sneguireff[[23]] in 1892 using the rectum and Baldwin[[24]] in 1904 using the ileum. However, the technique of colocolpoplasty was first used
in transsexuals only in 1974, when Markland and Hastings used both cecum and sigmoid
transplants.[[25]] However, these intestinal transplants were associated with high amounts of troublesome
discharge and mucosal prolapse. Though the well-vascularized inverted penile pedicled
flap does not have secretions, which envisage lubrication, these were not pronounced
as a concern of transwomen in this study. Author technique of neovagina with pedicled
distal inverted penile tube flap was capacious enough repudiating the need for any
augmentation with depilated scrotal flap.[[19]] A natural-appearing clitoris with maintained erogenous sensation is the ultimate
surgical aim. Neoclitoroplasty techniques described in literature were of two types:
(a) pedicled flap neoclitoroplasty and (b) inert full thickness graft neoclitoroplasty.
The penile skin is dissected off the erectile corporal tissue. Surgically the urethra
and glans are gently lifted from the corpus cavernosum; the neurovascular bundles
are skeletonized, the glans can be inset, with care taken not to kink the neurovascular
bundle. A high rate of erogenous sensibility is maintained with this technique. Karim[[26]] reported that 57 of 59 patients retained erogenous sensibility, of this 47 were
able to reach orgasm. Edgerton et al.[[27]] and later Marten-Perolino et al.[[28]] suggested preserving all the glans penis and the neurovascular bundle with the
overlying penis cutis placed at the bottom of the neovagina. Malloy et al. used the glans to form a substitute of uterine cervix.[[29]] Meyer and Kesselring in 1980 used a small bud of corpus spongiosum covered by penile
skin.[[30]] Rubin used corpus spongiosum as vascular pedicle for constructing the neoclitoris,
but urine leakage was a complication.[[31]
[32]
[33]
[34]] Hage et al. made a neoclitoris from the glans and sculptured its final appearance during vaginoplasty
using a free composite graft of the tip of the penile glans to cover the shortened
dorsal neurovascular bundle.[[35]] Since 1992, the use of a small dorsal portion of the glans with preservation of
the dorsal penile neurovascular bundle has become the standard procedure for clitoroplasty
in male to female sex reassignment.[[33]
[34]] This technique was first described by Hinderer.[[36]
[37]] Brown applied the same technique later.[[38]] Many alternative techniques for the conffguration of a neoclitoris have been proposed
including the use of a preputial flap.[[39]] Author's anatomically conceived technique for pedicled flap neoclitoroplasty was
not only reverse embryogenesis but also based on the anastomosis between deep artery
and dorsal artery of penis at the corono glandis.[[10]] By this, the neo-clitoris, which was mounted on the conjoint crural mount, provides
good projection of clitoris and complete sensation reinforced with full erogenic capacity
(refer surgical technique). Author's technique of inverted penile flap provided intact
skin bound vaginal introitus between 3 and 9 o'clock through 12 o'clock. The confluence
of labial/scrotal flaps, perineal skin and cut proximal end of pedicled penile flap
formed the suture line from 3 to 9 o'clock position through 6 o'clock. This reduces
the scar contracture of the vaginal introitus. The expanded full preputial skin provides
adequate boxy expansion at the apex of neo-vagina. The author observed gross reduction
of scrotum to form a triangular superiorly based scrotal/labial flap provided esthetic
fourchette.
An average 9.8 cm neovagina was created in our transwomen population [[Table 1]]. When compared to the study of Amend et al.[[40]] where neovaginas of length 11 cm have been created on an average, among the German
population, this may be of mildly reduced length. This was because the anthropometry
of the Asian population and average body mass index of transwomen in our study was
23.5 with most of them having an android pelvis. This is the best possible length
that could be created in our transwomen population. with 95% of satisfaction of the
serviced vagina stands as an evidence for this. External urethral meatus stenosis
was nil in our series. This is attributed to the author's technique of oblique division
of the stump and interdigitation of the triangular flaps. There is 96% overall esthetic
satisfaction of external appearance of the genitalia. This stands evidence for the
success of the reverse embryonic approach-MTFEEbSRS that we have followed in this
study. The erectile and sensate neo-clitoral flap and sensate inverted penile tubular
flap in our cases add to the satisfaction of our transwomen. All 360° well-vascularized
penile skin tubular flaps easily adhere to the tunnel created establishing a stable
neovagina, which needs only 3 weeks of initial splinting. They are advised to have
vaginal intercourse after 3 weeks. Karim et al.[[41]] in their study advised about trimming and reduction of bulb (as it may cause the
ergogenic impingement on the vaginal introitus during intercourse), but what the author
found out was excising the bulbospongiosus muscle alone radically had the same effect
and can be executed without any bloody dissection of bulb. Therefore, less need for
prolonged splinting, more stable vagina creation, sensate introitus, and neo clitoris
adds to the more satisfactory outcome, appreciated by all our transwomen.
The wide neo-external urethral meatus, which was created through a vertical slit,
facilitate patients’ squatting urination. Moreover, this resulted in extreme relief
of their anxiety to have a feminine type of micturition. This also added to a more
satisfactory score attained in our series. Fifteen out of 30 patients (50%) in our
series were retroviral positive cases undergoing treatment for their disease. We have
followed universal precautions for all our patients, during the operative and postoperative
follow up. Due to our selection criteria to take transwomen with Cd4+ count >400 cell/mm3 none of our patients had wound failure and troublesome invasive infection in the
postoperative period. All 30 transwomen expressed satisfactory coitus with little
lubrication. None of them required any secondary procedures except for one transwoman
who required reduction of labia; rest of them did not require any secondary procedure.
Even though they were on hormone therapy, none of them developed complications such
as deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism, probably because of preoperative screening
of coagulation profile (which was normal in all cases) and early ambulation in the
postoperative period.
The “final endpoints” of genital reassignment surgery in male-to-female transsexuals
are:
-
To create a perineo-genital complex feminine in appearance and function. It should
also be free of poorly healed areas, scars, and painful neuromas. All the transwoman
in the study had an average grade 3 score [[Table 1]]
-
The urethra should be shortened in such a way that the direction of the urinary stream
is downward in the squatting position and it should be free from stenosis or fistulas.
All transwoman in our study achieved this endpoint
-
The neovagina should ideally be lined with moist, elastic, and hairless epithelium.
All had serviceable vagina
-
Sensations should be sufficient to provide satisfactory erogenous stimulus during
sexual intercourse. All transwoman in the study expressed the good sexual erogenous
stimulation during intercourse
-
Ideally, all these requirements should be met without major surgical intervention
necessitating long and distressful postoperative treatment, and addressing them should
not create new lesions or donor area morbidity. Except for one patient who required
the secondary reduction procedure for the labial excess all had achieved the desired
results in one stage transforming surgery.
The above-mentioned goals were achieved by applying genitalia embryonic equivalents
in the reconstruction of external genitalia of transwomen using inverted pedicled
penile flap for neovaginal lining.
-
Our technique of creating neourethrostomy by cutting the urethra short (about 0.5
cm in length from triangular ligament of perineum) and approximating the cut end through
a slit hole created in the penile flap just inferior to the clitoral mount enabled
the patient to direct the urinary stream downward in squatting position. A cut in
corpus spongiosum with urethra was given in a slanting direction so that a wide circumference
was available for creating neourethrostomy, thus avoiding urethral stenosis
-
Creation of clitoral mount using proximal cut ends of both corpora cavernosa under
the penile flap proximal to urethrostomy site and preservation of dorsal nerve of
the penis while dissecting out filleted penile flap provided erogenous stimulus during
intercourse.
CONCLUSION
Anatomically construed MTFEEbSRS in accordance with WPATH 2012,[[42]] shaped and harmonized body according to the mind of transwomen with lasting comfort,
reinforced with facilitated sexuality and function. Anatomical approach reinforced
with embryological equivalent reconstruction paved the way for good results. Although
our size of our study is small in size, it may serve as a useful armamentarium in
sex reassignment surgery for male or female transsexuals. From our analysis, neovagina,
which was reconstructed amidst erogenous tissue and erogenous clitoral mount, paved
adequate sexual satisfaction. Near perfect looking neo-external genitalia with urethrostomy
free from complications was obtained and this also helped the transwomen in their
complete gender identification. Their personality, lifestyle, and self-esteem improved
well.
Financial support and sponsorship
Nil.
