Depression - Anxiety - Stress Disorders - Post-Traumatic - Military Personnel - Sleep
INTRODUCTION
Sleep plays a central role in maintaining psychological and physical well-being in
military staff and veterans. The close link between sleep disturbances and mental
health disorders is a key concern among military members as they face several environmental
stressors and challenges. This has potentially exposed military staff at an increased
risk for sleep predicaments compared to civilians[1]. They are several factors to justify sleep disturbances among military staff from
which exposure to combat stress[2]-[5], frequent shift work, frequent changes in duty assignments, and changes in duty
station are more significant[6],[7]. Inadequate sleep in military personnel is shown to hinder their operational readiness,
effectiveness, and safety through impaired attention/concentration, judgment, responsiveness,
and decision making as key substrates of their cognitive performance[8],[9]. On the other hand, insufficient sleep corresponds to an increased risk of cardiovascular
disease, obesity, and diabetes[10],[11]. Moreover, there is a compelling body of evidence suggesting that insufficient sleep
results in diminished pain threshold, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depression,
anxiety, and robust symptoms following a traumatic brain injury (TBI)[12]. Aggravation of such mental-health disorders are in turn associated with chronic
medical and often psycho-somatic conditions such as cardiovascular diseases, hypertension,
and asthma[13],[14].
Given the above, both sleep predicaments and mental health disorders are known to
team-up with impaired functionality, increased healthcare utilization, as well as
increased health-related costs and reduced quality of life[15]-[18]. Based on a recent investigation, sleep problems over post-deployment in the Afghanistan
war were related to the probable mental illness symptoms[19],[20]. Short sleep among redeployed operation Iraqi freedom soldiers were significantly
associated with a dramatic increase in symptoms of PTSD, depression, panic syndrome,
and high-risk behaviors such as alcohol, tobacco misuse and suicidal attempts[21]. The high rate of comorbid sleep disturbances along with mental disorders among
active duty service members and veterans signifies the necessity for continued focused
research on this specific topic.
The present systematic review has been an attempt to evaluate the association between
sleep disturbances and mental health outcomes in active-duty service members and veterans.
The term ‘sleep disorders’ represents short and insufficient sleep, poor sleep quality,
insomnia, sleep apnea and nightmares. Studies have ubiquitously indicated that sleep
disturbance is a notable risk factor, which predisposes military staff to specific
mental disorders including PTSD, depression, and anxiety-related symptoms.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The present systematic review included studies that examined the association of sleep
disturbance with mental disorders including PTSD, depression, and anxiety in active
duty service members and veterans. This study was conducted in accordance with the
recommendations laid down by the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic
Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guideline. The approach comprised a 27-item checklist and
a four-phase flow diagram to retrieve selected documents.
Systematic information retrieval was performed in Scopus, PubMed and Web of Science
academic databases. Search terms were combined using the Boolean operators ‘and’ between
categories and ‘or’ within categories ([Table 1]). For PubMed, MeSH (Medical Subject Headings) terms were also used.
Table 1
Search strategy (Boolean operators ‘or’ and ‘and’ between columns).
|
Sleep disturbances
|
Mental disorder
|
Military personnel
|
|
Sleep disturbances, sleep disorder, sleep difficulties
|
Mental disorder, mental health
|
Military personnel, army personnel, armed forces personnel
|
Notes: CAPS = Clinician administered PTSD scale, DSM-IV Version; PHQ = Patient health
questionnaire; PCL-C = PTSD Checklist, civilian version; SCIDI/P = Structured clinical
interview for DSMIV-TR axis I disorders; PSQI-A = Pittsburgh sleep quality index-addendum;
PCL-M = PTSD checklist, military version; BDI-II = Beck depression inventory-II; PSG
= Polysomnography; CIDI-SC = Composite international diagnostic interview screening
scales; SRIP = Self-rating inventory for PTSD; SCL-90 = Dutch version of the symptom
checklist; PDHA = Post-deployment health assessment; PDHRA = Post-deployment health
reassessment; PC-PTSD = Primary care PTSD screen; GAD-7 = Generalized anxiety disorder
screener; GSI = Global symptom index; SCL = Symptom Checklist-90-Revised; K10 = Kessler
psychological distress scale 10; HADS = Hospital anxiety and depression scale; ICD-9
= International classification of diseases; DTS = Davidson trauma scale; SAS = Self-rating
anxiety scale; DSI-SS = Depressive symptom inventory suicidality subscale.
Exclusion of an article were based on the following criteria: (i) studies focusing
only on the mental health status or sleep disturbances among military members; (ii)
studies that examined the effects of any stimulation or pharmacological and psychological
interventions on sleep complaints and mental disorders among military members.
Furthermore, investigations focusing on the impact of sleep disturbances on specific
mental disorders including PTSD, depression and anxiety were included, while those
addressing mental health risk behaviors like suicide, substance and alcohol abuse
were disregarded.
RESULTS
From a total of 335 publications retrieved, 91 duplicates, 17 reviews, and 198 non-relevant
records were excluded. Subsequently, 29 studies met the inclusion criteria ([Figure 1]). In addition, from the 29 isolated studies, a total of 12 documents were examining
the relationship between sleep disturbances and PTSD symptoms, 4 studies were describing
the prediction role of sleep in context to the combination of PTSD, depression and
anxiety symptoms, while 3 records assessed the effect of sleep complaints and resultant
depression. Between the lines, 7 studies evaluated the association between sleep disturbances
and mental health disorders. Few records were found to be exclusively devoted to evaluating
the effect of sleep disorders on the development of depression and anxiety symptoms.
Summary of the reviewed studies is represented in [Table 2]. Additionally, main findings regarding the association between sleep complaints
and mental health disorders, specifically PTSD, depression, and anxiety symptoms are
articulated in the present review.
Table 2
Summary of the enrolled studies.
|
Study
|
Type of study
|
No of participants
|
Population
|
Method of sleep disorder assessment
|
Method of mental disorder assessment
|
|
Acheson et al. (2019)[1]
|
Cohort
|
2,404
|
Marines and Navy Corpsmen deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan
|
Sleep disturbances by BDI insomnia; CAPS average hours of sleep; CAPS difficulty falling
or staying asleep and 6 items from the CAPS serving as indicators of the construct
‘re-experiencing symptoms’
|
CAPS
|
|
Gehrman et al. (2013)[22]
|
Cohort
|
15,204
|
Active service
|
Sleep item from the PCL-C and PHQ for insomnia symptoms
|
17-item PCL-C and PHQ-9
|
|
Swinkels et al. (2013)[23]
|
Cross-sectional
|
1,640
|
U.S. Afghanistan/Iraq era veterans
|
PSQI-A
|
SCIDI/P
|
|
Koffel et al. (2013)[24]
|
Longitudinal
|
522
|
U.S. National guard soldiers deployed to Iraq
|
Sleep-related items within the BDI-II referring to loss of energy
|
CAPS, PCL-C at pre-deployment and the PCL-M at post-deployment
|
|
Taylor et al. (2014)[25]
|
Cross-sectional
|
3,175
|
U.S. active duty and reserve Navy personnel
|
Self-reported sleep measures
|
DSM-IV and PHQ
|
|
McLay et al. (2010)[26]
|
Retrospective
|
1,887
|
U.S. military
|
PCL-M
|
PCL-M
|
|
Wright et al. (2011)[27]
|
Longitudinal
|
659
|
Active duty soldiers
|
Insomnia severity index
|
PHQ, PCL,
|
|
Mysliwiec et al. (2013)[28]
|
Cross-sectional
|
110
|
U.S. military personnel
|
PSG
|
PCL-M
|
|
Taylor et al. (2016)[7]
|
Cross-sectional
|
4,101
|
Active duty service members
|
Insomnia severity index
|
PCL-M
|
|
Brownlow et al. (2017)[29]
|
Cross-sectional
|
29,674
|
Military soldiers
|
Brief insomnia questionnaire
|
CIDI-SC, PCL
|
|
Wang et al. (2019)[30]
|
Prospective
|
4645
|
U.S. Army soldiers
|
Brief insomnia questionnaire
|
PCL and CIDI-SC
|
|
Hansen et al. (2018)[31]
|
Cohort
|
438
|
Army national guard soldiers
|
Insomnia severity index
|
The primary care-post-traumatic stress disorder screen
|
|
Liempt et al. (2013)[33]
|
Prospective cohort
|
453
|
NATO-International security assistance force
|
SRIP, SCL-90
|
SRIP
|
|
Steele et al. (2017)[34]
|
Cross-sectional
|
972
|
U.S. Navy sailors and marines
|
Self-report survey
|
PCL, PHQ
|
|
Macera et al. (2013)[35]
|
Prospective
|
29,640
|
U.S. Navy and Marine Corps
|
PDHA
|
PDHA, PDHRA, PC-PTSD
|
|
Osgood et al. (2019)[36]
|
Cross-sectional
|
2420
|
Soldiers
|
Self-report survey
|
PCL-C, PHQ-8, GAD-7
|
|
Lewis et al. (2009)[37]
|
Pilot
|
152
|
Australian Vietnam war veterans
|
PSQI
|
PCL
|
|
Hughes et al. (2018)[38]
|
Cross-sectional
|
1,118
|
U.S. military veterans
|
PSQI, PSQI-A
|
GSI, SCL
|
|
Hunt et al. (2016)[39]
|
Prospective
|
1636
|
U.K. Armed forces
|
PCL-C, GHQ-12
|
PCL-C, GHQ-12
|
|
Kim et al. (2016)[40]
|
Cross-sectional
|
5,764
|
Korea armed forces
|
Self-reported questionnaire
|
K10
|
|
Hougsnæs et al. (2017)[41]
|
Retrospective
|
3403
|
Norwegian soldiers
|
Insomnia severity index
|
PCL-M-17, HADS
|
|
Seelig et a. (2010)[20]
|
Longitudinal cohort
|
41,225
|
Service members, reserve/guard personnel, veterans
|
PHQ, PCL-C
|
PCL-C
|
|
Soreca et al. (2019)[42]
|
Cross-sectional
|
33,818
|
U.S. military veterans
|
Breathing-related sleep disorder of ICD-9
|
ICD-9
|
|
Ulmer et al. (2015)[43]
|
Cross-sectional
|
1,238
|
Veterans and active duty military personnel
|
PSQI, SCL-90, DTS
|
SCID-I
|
|
Wang et al. (2020)[44]
|
Cross-sectional
|
489
|
Military officers and soldiers
|
PSQI
|
SAS
|
|
Chou et al. (2016)[45]
|
Cross-sectional
|
720
|
Taiwanese army, air force, marines and military police
|
PSQI
|
BDI
|
|
Tonon et al. (2020)[46]
|
Cross-sectional
|
236
|
Male recruits in compulsory military service
|
PSQI
|
BDI
|
|
Hom et al. (2016)[47]
|
Prospective
|
2596
|
U.S. Army recruiters
|
Insomnia severity index
|
DSI-SS
|
Figure 1 Diagram of systematic search strategy and retrieval of the records.
Post-traumatic stress disorder
In a prospective longitudinal cohort of 2,404 Marines and Navy corpsmen, Acheson et
al. (2019)[1] reported a significant relationship between sleep disturbances on the pre-deployment
and latent PTSD symptomology. Additionally, a combat-stress severity showed a small
arbitrary effect for such correlations[1]. Pre-deployment short sleep duration (<6h) and insomnia significantly contributed
to the developing new-onset PTSD symptoms in a large, population-based cohort study.
Also, increased odds (approximately 2 times) of developing PTSD were observed in the
military personnel who reported combat-related trauma[22].
Likewise, in a sample of 1,640 U.S. Afghanistan/Iraq era veterans, 49% endorsed sleeping
<6h, 23% slept between 6-7h, 25% slept >7 but <9h, and only 3% slept ≥9h per night.
According to the related report, 72% of the sample had poor sleep quality. Specifically,
short (≤5h) or long (≥9h) sleep duration and poor sleep quality in this population
were attributed to increased odds of PTSD[23]. Interestingly, the preexisting daytime and nighttime sleep complaints were predicting
PTSD particularly at futuristic time points up to 2 years after deployment[24].
Based on another report, among 3,175 active duty and reserve U.S. Navy personnel deployed
to a combat zone, two-thirds declared an average of less than 6h sleep per 24h and
hence, were classified as sleep deficient. Adjusted for covariates, sleep deficit
was the main risk factor for developing PTSD (OR=10.7; 95%CI: 4.3-26.8)[25].
Similarly, findings from a retrospective cohort of 1,887 U.S. military personnel demonstrated
insomnia as the most common PTSD-provoking symptom for those returned from deployments.
In fact, while various intensities of insomnia symptoms were observed in 33% of this
population, insomnia was more severe in PTSD sufferers upon follow-up[26]. Furthermore, a longitudinal assessment of the association between insomnia and
psychological symptoms like PTSD and depression among combat veterans of the Iraq
war demonstrated that insomnia at an earlier time-point was a more-likely predictor
for PTSD symptoms rather than a later time-point[27]. In a cross-sectional study of 110 active-duty military personnel who returned from
deployment, 88.2% of subjects were diagnosed with sleep disorders. Notably, among
this population, 25.5% and 24.5% of them fulfilled the diagnostic criteria for insomnia
and OSAHS (obstructive sleep apnea-hypopnea syndrome), respectively. Further to this,
38.2% were reported to have comorbid OSAHS and insomnia. Military staff with comorbid
OSAHS and insomnia showed more symptoms compatible with PTSD compared to the control
subjects without any sleep disorder and those with OSAHS alone[28].
The prevalence of insomnia among 4,101 active-duty service members was 19.9%. The
rates of clinically significant PTSD in the U.S. Army personnel with insomnia were
higher (55.5%) than the non-insomniacs (13.5%). Reciprocally, individuals with clinically
significant PTSD were more likely to report insomnia (OR=2.39, 95%CI: 1.88-3.04)[7].
U.S. military soldiers with current PTSD had a high prevalence of insomnia complaints
(69.7%) where PTSD symptoms moderated the relationship between insomnia and memory
and concentration problems[29]. Adjusting for prior deployment history and sociodemographic characteristics, pre-deployment
insomnia among U.S. Army soldiers was related to the increased odds of PTSD following
deployment (AOR: 3.14, 95%CI: 2.58-3.82)[30].
Among soldiers with a rare history of these problems at baseline, pre-deployment insomnia
accounted for a 55% increased risk of incident PTSD[30]. In addition, amongst 438 army soldiers of the Minnesota National Guard, a prevalence
of moderate to severe levels of insomnia was reported 16.4% and 18.1%, respectively,
in those who were primarily screened positive for PTSD. In this study, PTSD was an
independent predictor for sleep problems as assessed by the insomniacs[31]. Interestingly, unlike insomnia, nightmare disorder before deployment, predicted
PTSD symptoms post-deployment.
Adding to the above, in a sample of 453 military personnel deployed to Afghanistan,
a correlation was observed between the number of OSAHS and PTSD severity for those
with PTSD. Also, according to polysomnographic registrations and blood samples, increased
sleep fragmentation, frequent nightmares, and decreased growth hormone secretion were
observed in PTSD patients[32].
Moreover, a prospective longitudinal cohort including 453 subjects demonstrated an
increased risk for the development of PTSD symptoms as a result of pre-deployment
nightmares. Nightmares prior to deployment predicted PTSD (OR=2.992; 95%CI: 1.096-8.551),
whereas insomnia complaints before deployment did not predict the same (OR=0.976;
95%CI: 0.862-1.155)[33].
Steele et al. (2017)[34] examined the impact of sleep problems such as nightmares, difficulty falling asleep,
concern resulting from lack of sleep and difficulty staying asleep on the link between
combat experiences, and PTSD symptoms in a population of 972 U.S. Navy sailors. Among
such sleep problems, only nightmare disorders were found to increase PTSD symptoms[34]. In agreement with the above, a 26% interceding effect of sleep insufficiency on
the cross-link between blast-related traumatic brain injury (TBI) and PTSD was reported[35]. It has been reported that the adjusted odds for PTSD among service members screening
positive for TBI compared to those without TBI, decreased from 1.61 (95%CI: 1.21-2.14)
to 1.32 (95%CI 1.32: 0.99-1.77). A study on 2,420 soldiers during a 3-month period
after deployment to Afghanistan battlefield indicated that sleep continuity disturbances
could efficiently predict the link between combat exposure with PTSD. In fact, 9.5%,
6.5%, and 7.2% of participants met the criteria for PTSD, depression and GAD, respectively.
An indirect association between combat exposure and PTSD was stronger in military
staff with sleep duration <6 h per 24h compared to those adequate sleep quantity[36]. Clinically significant sleep disturbance assessed by the Pittsburg sleep quality
index (PSQI), was reported in all 152 Australian Vietnam war veterans with PTSD and
90% of those without PTSD. Also, more serious sleep predicaments were reported among
the veteran population with PTSD in the same study population[37].
Psychological distress and mental health problems
Anxiety disorders
Based on an observational study, the impaired sleep quality of military officers and
soldiers from remote boundaries of China has been shown as a significant predictor
for the development of anxiety symptoms. The average overall PSQI score has been reported
7 and poor sleep quality has been observed in 40.9% of the subjects. Daytime dysfunction
decreased sleep efficiency and increased sleep latency were the main symptoms of the
impaired sleep quality in this population[44].
Like that, in a large military cohort, those with insomnia symptoms who slept <6h
pre-deployment had increased odds of developing anxiety post-deployment than those
without insomnia who retained longer sleep duration (OR=4.33, 95%CI: 2.37-7.90; OR=4.14,
95%CI: 2.09-8.22)[22]. Participants with sleep deficiency (less than 6h per 24h) were at elevated risk
of a generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) (OR=9.1, 95%CI: 2.8-29.9)[25].
Notably, according to a cross-sectional cohort study involving a large sample of U.S.
Army personnel, the insomnia group was significantly more likely to have anxiety than
non-insomniacs (42.7% vs. 8.0%). After controlling demographics and comorbid problems,
anxiety was a statistically significant predictor of insomnia among military personnel
(OR=1.93, 95%CI: 1.46-2.55)[7].
In the same vein, the high prevalence of 82.6% was observed for insomnia disorders
among military soldiers with current GAD, whereby the condition reinforced the associations
between insomnia and memory/concentration problems[29].
Depression
In a study on 720 military personnel in Taiwan, the average PSQI score, the average
sleep latency and the average total sleep time were 7.26±3.45, 22.39±21.53 minutes,
and 5.91±1.3 hours, respectively. Sleep disturbances were observed in 65.1% of subjects
with a corresponding PSQI scores ≥6. In addition, a mutual relationship was found
between the PSQI score and depression. Also, among 469 personnel with PSQI score above
6, 42.4% had mild to severe depression compared to 9.6% in 24 subjects with a PSQI
score below 5[45]. Indeed, the pre-deployment daytime/nighttime sleep disturbances strongly contributed
to the prediction of depression[24]. A report indicated that both short and long sleep duration were attributed to current
major depressive disorder in veterans[23]. Deficient sleep (<6h per 24h) in individuals serving in a combat zone was a unique
perspective risk factor for probable major depressive disorder (MDD) (OR=7.5; 95%CI:
2.3-25.0)[25]. Both combat and insomnia symptoms were associated with depressive symptoms[22]. Sleep problems mediated the effect of TBI on the development of depression by 41%.
The adjusted odds of depressed individuals were 1.41 (95%CI: 1.11-1.80) times greater
for a sailor or marine officers with TBI compared with controls[35].
Likewise, in a sample of young men recruited in compulsory military service, the prevalence
of depressive symptoms was 18% where a significant association was found between multiple
related factors, e.g., stress, sleep quality, as well as circadian typology, and depressive
symptoms. Along those lines, the clinically significant depressive symptoms were more
prevalent among poor sleepers (PR=1.808, p=0.046)[46]. Based on another investigation, severe insomnia was the only strong predictor of
future major depressive episodes, regardless of other symptoms such as agitation and
suicidal ideation in 2,596 army recruiters[47].
In addition to this, a study of the relationships between insomnia and depression
symptoms across time periods in a sample of combat veterans also showed that insomnia
at 4 months’ post-deployment time-point was a strong predictor of depression at 12
months follow-up[27]. In a cohort study including 110 active-duty service members, 70% of subjects exhibited
mental disorders like depression, pain, PTSD, and mild TBI. Among military personnel
with comorbid OSAHS and insomnia, 71.4% were meeting the criteria for depression[28]. A higher rate of depression was observed in insomniacs rather than controls (42.4%
vs. 5.9%)[7]. Conversely, people with depression were found more likely to report insomnia (OR=2.89,
95%CI: 2.17-3.85)[7]. The comorbidity of insomnia and major depressive episode (MDE) was reported in
a sample of U.S. Army soldiers and subjects with current MDE had a high prevalence
of insomnia (85.0%). Given that, the MDE status influenced insomnia and cognitive
insufficiencies[29]. Further to that, the prevalence of depression among 438 army soldiers was 9.6%
in a study designed by Hansen et al. (2018)[31] whereby a mutual correlation was reported between sleep problems assessed in terms
of insomnia and depressive symptoms.
Summary
According to the present literature review, sleep predicaments seem to be notably
prevalent among military members potentially owing to several psychological and physical
stressors, which may likewise play a role in the pathophysiology of various mental
health disorders. Sleep disturbances are considered as precipitating and perpetuating
factors affecting psychiatric disorders and in turn, psychiatric disorders can reciprocally
exacerbate sleep disturbances. Results of included studies demonstrate that different
sleep complaints like insomnia symptoms, nightmares and problems with quantity or
quality of sleep predispose military subjects to more likely experience symptoms of
PTSD, depression and anxiety. A mediating role of sleep problems for the relationship
between combat exposure and PTSD has also been well articulated in the literature.
Daytime and nighttime sleep complaints are shown to strongly predict PTSD and depression
even after 2 years of deployment. Long and short sleep duration are also regarded
as an important marker for mental disorders and risky behaviors.
Given the above, a compelling body of evidence substantiates the importance of timely
screening and awareness of sleep complaints among active-duty service members and
veterans. Addressing the specific sleep disturbances prior to deployment may be helpful
in preventing mental health issues in this population. Moreover, as suggested by Hunt
et al. (2016)[39] since the disclosure of mental health disorders and psychological ailments in military
staff is inhibited by stigmatizing beliefs, scrutinizing possible sleep disturbances
needs to gain momentum.
As such, it seems essential to identify the most common mental health problems and
their significant predictors such as sleep disorders within the military population
to design any appropriate interventions. Future research works need to evaluate the
impact of pertinent interventions to improve sleep and subsequently enhance mental
resilience in this target group.
Concerning the limitations of the present review, it should be noted that included
studies used various definitions and measurement tools to identify sleep disturbances.
As such, it was hardly possible to perform a meta-analysis and represent the pooled
predictor effects of certain sleep disturbances on mental disorders. Most of the studies
monitored sleep and mental disorders using only self-report questionnaires. It is
evident that objective screening measures provide more accurate and reliable data.
In addition, a large number of reviewed documents had cross-sectional nature hence,
identifying any causal relationship between sleep disturbances and mental health issues
and generalization of the findings to a larger population were hardly feasible.