Reproducibility of the effects of homeopathically potentised Argentum nitricum on the growth of Lemna gibba L. in a randomised and blinded bioassay

Background: A previous study reported a significant statistical interaction between experiment date and treatment effect of Argentum nitricum 14x–30x on the growth rate of duckweed (Lemna gibba L.). The aim of the present study was to investigate the stability of the test system and intra-laboratory reproducibility of the effects found.

Methods: Duckweed was treated with A. nitricum potencies (14x–30x) as well as succussed and unsuccussed water controls. The outcome parameter area-related growth rate for day 0–7 was determined by a computerised image analysis system in two series of independent randomised and blinded experiments. Systematic negative control (SNC) experiments were carried out to investigate test system stability. Statistical analysis was performed with full two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and protected Fisher's Least Significant Difference (LSD) test.

Results: In the first repetition series we found a significant treatment effect (p = 0.016), while in the second series no effect was observed. The negative control experiments showed that the experimental system was stable. An a posteriori subgroup analysis concerning gibbosity revealed the importance of this growth state of L. gibba for successful reproduction of the statistically significant interaction in the original study; flat: no interaction (p = 0.762); slight gibbosity: no interaction (p = 0.356); medium gibbosity: significant interaction (p = 0.031), high gibbosity: highly significant interaction (p = 0.005).

Conclusions: With the original study design (disregarding gibbosity status of L. gibba) results of the original study could not be reproduced sensu stricto. We conclude that the growth state gibbosity is crucial for successful reproduction of the original study. Different physiological states of the test organisms used for bioassays for homeopathic basic research must carefully be considered.

Highlights

• Duckweed (Lemna gibba) reacts to potentized Argentum nitricum.

• Gibbosity of L. gibba is crucial for reactivity to potentized preparations.

• Variability is an interesting outcome parameter in homeopathic basic Research.

Keywords

Homeopathy - Plants - Duckweed - Silver nitrate - Reproducibility

• References

• 1 Baumgartner S. Reproductions and reproducibility in homeopathy: dogma or tool?. J Altern Complement Med 2005; 11: 771-772.
• 2 Baumgartner S. The state of basic research on homeopathy. In: Witt C.M., Albrecht H. (eds). New Directions in Homeopathy Research. 2009. Essen: KVC Verlag; 107-130.
• 3 Bellavite P., Ortolani R., Conforti A. Immunology and homeopathy. 3. Experimental studies on animal models. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 2006; 3: 171-186.
• 4 Betti L., Trebbi G., Majewsky V. et al. Use of homeopathic preparations in phytopathological models and in field trials: a critical review. Homeopathy 2009; 98: 244-266.
• 5 Jäger T., Scherr C., Shah D. et al. Use of homeopathic preparations in experimental studies with abiotically stressed plants. Homeopathy 2011; 100: 275-287.
• 6 Majewsky V., Arlt S., Shah D. et al. Use of homeopathic preparations in experimental studies with healthy plants. Homeopathy 2009; 98: 228-243.
• 7 Witt C.M., Bluth M., Albrecht H. et al. The in vitro evidence for an effect of high homeopathic potencies–a systematic review of the literature. Complement Ther Med 2007; 15: 128-138.
• 8 Baumgartner S., Guggisberg A.G. Basophilendegranulation, dritter Akt: Homöopathie und Basophilenraktion - weniger klar, als manche das gerne hätten. Forsch Komplementarmed Klass Naturheilkd 2005; 12: 49-57.
• 9 Baumgartner S., Thurneysen A., Heusser P. Growth stimulation of dwarf peas (Pisum sativum L.) through homeopathic potencies of plant growth substances. Forsch Komplementarmed Klass Naturheilkd 2004; 11: 281-292.
• 10 Jäger T., Scherr C., Simon M., Heusser P., Baumgartner S. Effects of homeopathic arsenicum album, nosode, and gibberellic acid preparations on the growth rate of arsenic-impaired duckweed (Lemna gibba L.). ScientificWorldJournal 2010; 10: 2112-2129.
• 11 Scherr C., Simon M., Spranger J., Baumgartner S. Duckweed (Lemna gibba L.) as a test organism for homeopathic potencies. J Altern Complement Med 2007; 13: 931-937.
• 12 Scherr C., Simon M., Spranger J., Baumgartner S. Effects of potentised substances on growth rate of the water plant Lemna gibba L. Complement Ther Med 2009; 17: 63-70.
• 13 Endler P., Thieves K., Reich C. et al. Repetitions of fundamental research models for homeopathically prepared dilutions beyond 10(-23): a bibliometric study. Homeopathy 2010; 99: 25-36.
• 14 Endler P.C., Bellavite P., Bonamin L., Jäger T., Mazon S. Replications of fundamental research models in ultra high dilutions 1994 and 2015-update on a bibliometric study. Homeopathy 2015; 104: 234-245.
• 15 Baumgartner S., Shah D., Schaller J. et al. Reproducibility of dwarf pea shoot growth stimulation by homeopathic potencies of gibberellic acid. Complement Ther Med 2008; 16: 183-191.
• 16 Hamman B., Koning G., Him Lok K. Homeopathically prepared gibberellic acid and barley seed germination. Homeopathy 2003; 92: 140-144.
• 17 Majewsky V., Scherr C., Arl S.P. et al. Reproducibility of effects of homeopathically potentised gibberellic acid on the growth of Lemna gibba L. in a randomised and blinded bioassay. Homeopathy 2014; 103: 113-126.
• 18 Pieterse A.H. Physiological, morphological and anatomical aspects of gibbosity in Lemna gibba . Aquat Bot 1975; 1: 333-344.
• 19 Clathworthy J.N., Harper J.L. The comparative biology of closely related species living in the same area. 5. Inter- and Intraspecific interference within cultures odf Lemna spp. and Salvinia natans . J Exp Bot 1962; 13: 307-311.
• 20 Rejmankova E. The growth of Lemna spp. under natural and seminatural conditions. Leningrad: International Botanic Congress; 1975.
• 21 Rejmankova E. Comparison of Lemna gibba and Lemna minor from the production ecological viewpoint. Aquat Bot 1975; 1: 423-428.
• 22 Wolek J. A preliminary investigation in interactions (competition, alleopathy) between some species of Lemna, Spirodela and Wolffia . Ber Geobot Inst ETH Zürich 1974; 42: 140-162.
• 23 Elzenga J.T.M., De Lange L., Pieterse A.H. Further indications that ethylene is the gibbosity regulator of the Lemna gibba/Lemna minor complex in natural waters. Acta Bot Neerl 1980; 29: 225-229.
• 24 Färber E. Ethylene production and overcrowding in Lemnaceae. J Plant Physiol 1986; 124: 379-384.
• 25 Kandeler R. Überlebensstrategien bei Wasserlinsen. Biol Rundsch 1988; 26: 347-354.
• 26 OECD. Lemna sp. growth inhibition test. Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development; 2006.
• 27 Scherr C., Simon M., Spranger J., Baumgartner S. Test system stability and natural variability of a Lemna gibba L. bioassay. PLoS One 2008; 3: e3133.
• 28 Stock-Schröer B., Albrecht H., Betti L. et al. Reporting experiments in homeopathic basic research (REHBaR)–a detailed guideline for authors. Homeopathy 2009: 287-298.
• 29 Witt C.M., Lüdtke R., Weisshuhn T.E., Quint P., Willich S.N. The role of trace elements in homeopathic preparations and the influence of container material, storage duration, and potentisation. Forsch Komplementarmed 2006; 13: 15-21.
• 30 Baumgartner S., Heusser P., Thurneysen A. Methodological standards and problems in preclinical homeopathic potency research. Forsch Komplementarmed 1998; 5: 27-32.
• 31 Carmer S.G., Swanson M.R. An evaluation of ten pairwise multiple comparison procedures by Monte Carlo methods. J Am Stat Assoc 1973; 68: 66-74.
• 32 Endler P.C., Lüdtke R., Heckmann C. et al. Pretreatment with thyroxin (10⁻⁸ parts per weight) enhances a “curative” effect of homeopathically prepared thyroxin (10⁻¹³) on lowland frogs. Forsch Komplementarmed 2003; 10: 137-142.
• 33 Endler P.C., Pongratz W., van Wijk R., Kastberger G., Haidvogl M. Effects of highly diluted succussed thyroxine on metamorphosis of highland frogs. Berl J Res Homeopathy 1991; 1: 151-160.
• 34 Welles S.U., Endler P.C., Scherer-Pongratz W. et al. Pretreatment with thyroxin 10–8 and the effect of homeopathically prepared thyroxin 10–30 on highland frogs – a multi-researcher study. Forsch Komplementarmed 2007; 14: 353-357.
• 35 Nani D., Brizzi M., Lazzarato L., Betti L. The role of variability in evaluating ultra high dilution effects: considerations based on plant model experiments. Forsch Komplementarmed 2007; 14: 301-305.
• 36 Binder M., Baumgartner S., Thurneysen A. The effects of a 45x potency of arsenicum album on wheat seedling growth – a reproduction trial. Forsch Komplementarmed Klass Naturheilkd 2005; 12: 284-291.
• 37 Hahnemann S. Organon of medicine. 6 edn. New Delhi: B. Jain Publishers (P) Ltd.; 1987. 253 p.