Crisis of Meaning and Medical Informatics Education: A Burden and/or a Relief?

Abstract:

Starting with the quotation by Paul Ricoeur: Man needs love indeed; he needs justice still more; but most of all he needs meaning, this paper states that in this present situation medical education does not prepare students to deal with human needs, neither their own nor those of their patients. This is due to the almost exclusive devotion to hard sciences, contaminated by unscientific ideological drift, which tends to negate subjectivity and to suppress any significance of human destiny. Although medical informatics, by definition, eliminates meaning and knowledge, it can - if properly used as a complement and not as a competitor of human intelligence - help to renovate medical education, introduce true humanistic dimensions, and restore the element of human subjectivity.

Key-Words:

Medical Informatics - Artificial Intelligence - Humanism - Scientism

• REFERENCES

• [1] Philippe Anne. Un Eté Près de la Mer. Paris: Gallimard.
• [2] Gauguin Paul. Museum of Fine Arts. Boston Mass.
• [3] Grémy F. Informatics and medical education: Training, culture, humanism. Tijdschrift voor Medische Informatica 1988; 1: 11-15.
• [4] Ricoeur P. Signe et Sens. Paris: Encyclopedia Universalis.
• [5] Arsac J. La Machine à Penser. Paris: Seuil 1987
• [6] Monod J. Le Hasard et la Nécessité. Paris: Seuil 1970
• [7] Bernard J. Grandeurs et Tentations de la Médecine. Paris: Buchet-Chastel 1973
• [8] Laplantine F. Anthropologie de la Maladie. Paris: Fayard 1987
• [9] Popper K. L’Univers Irrésolu. Paris: Hermann 1984
• [10] Prirogine I, Stengers I. Entre le Temps et VEternité. Paris: Fayard 1988
• [11] Morin E. La Méthode - La Nature de la Nature. Paris: Seuil 1977
• [12] Atlan H. A Tort et Raison - Intercritique de la Science et du Mythe. Paris: Seuil 1988
• [13] Henry M. La Barbarie. Paris: Grasset 1987
• [14] Laplane D. La Mouche dans le Bocal - Essai sur la Liberte de I’Homme Neuronal. Paris: Plon 1988
• [15] Grémy F. Persons and computers in medicine and health. Meth Inf Med 1988; 27: 3-9.
• [16] Feigenbaum EA. Auto knowledge: from file server to knowledge server. In: Salamon R, Blum B, Jörgensen M, eds. MED INFO 86. Amsterdam: North Holland Publ Comp 1986
• [17] Grémy F. Human meaning of medical informatics: reflections on its future and trends - Dedicated to Peter Reichertz. Med Inform 1989; 14: 1-11.
• [18] Searle JR. Minds, Brains and Sciences. London: British Broadcasting Corp 1984
• [19] Dreyfus HL, Dreyfus SE. Mind over Machine. Oxford: Blackwell 1986
• [20] Heidegger M. Der Satz vom Grund. Pfullingen: Günther Neske 1957
• [21] Kayser D. A computer scientist’s view of meaning. In: Torrance SB, ed. The Mind and the Machine. Chichester: Ellis Horwood 1984
• [22] Paillard J. L’Ordinateur et le Cerveau : Un Contraste Saisissant. Association Française de Cybemétique et Technique 1987: 4-9.
• [23] Vincent JD. Biologie des Passions. Paris: Odile Jacob 1986
• [24] Morin E. Penser VEurope. Paris: Gallimard 1987