Clinical Negligence Claims in Pediatric Surgery in England: Pattern and Trends

Abstract

Aims of the Study We hypothesized that there has been an increase in the number of successful litigation claims in pediatric surgery in England. Our aim was to report the incidence, causes, and costs of clinical negligence claims against the National Health Service (NHS) in relation to pediatric surgery.

Materials and Methods We queried the NHS Litigation Authority (NHSLA) on litigation claims among children undergoing pediatric surgery in England (2004–2012). We decided a priori to only examine closed cases (decision and payment made). Data included year of claim, year of payment of claim, payment per claim, paid-to-closed ratio, and severity of outcome of clinical incident.

Results Out of 112 clinical negligence claims in pediatric surgery, 93 (83%) were finalized—73 (65%) were settled and damages paid to the claimant and 20 (18%) were closed with no payment, and 19 (17%) remain open. The median payment was £13,537 (600–500,000) and median total cost borne by NHSLA was £31,445 (600–730,202). Claims were lodged at a median interval of 2 (0–13) years from time of occurrence with 55 (75%) cases being settled within the 3 years of being received. The commonest reasons for claims were postoperative complications (n = 20, 28%), delayed treatment (n = 16, 22%), and/or diagnosis (n = 14, 19%). Out of 73, 17 (23%) closed claims resulted in case fatality.

Conclusion Two-thirds of all claims in pediatric surgery resulted in payment to claimant, and the commonest reasons for claims were postoperative complications, delayed treatment, and/or diagnosis. Nearly a quarter of successful claims were in cases where negligence resulted in case fatality. Pediatric surgeons should be aware of common diagnostic and treatment shortfalls as high-risk areas of increased susceptibility to clinical negligence claims.

Keywords

litigation - clinical negligence claim - National Health Service Litigation Authority - pediatric surgery - children

• References

• 1 No authors listed. NHSLA. The NHS Litigation Authority Factsheet 1: Background information, 2011. Available at: http://www.nhsla.com/ . Accessed August 14, 2013
• 2 No authors listed. NHSLA. The NHS Litigation Authority Factsheet 3: Claims information, 2012. Available at: www.nhsla.com/ . Accessed August 14, 2013
• 3 No authors listed. NHSLA. The NHS Litigation Authority Factsheet 2: Financial information, 2012. Available at: www.nhsla.com/ . Accessed August 14, 2013
• 4 Sen G, Keene J, Raine J. An analysis of successful litigation claims in childhood fatalities in England. Eur J Pediatr 2012; 171 (11) 1657-1660
• 5 Goldenberg SD, Volpe H, French GL. Clinical negligence, litigation and healthcare-associated infections. J Hosp Infect 2012; 81 (3) 156-162
• 6 Mathew RG, Ferguson V, Hingorani M. Clinical negligence in ophthalmology: fifteen years of National Health Service litigation authority data. Ophthalmology 2013; 120 (4) 859-864
• 7 Gulati A, Herd MK, Nimako M, Anand R, Brennan PA. Litigation in National Health Service oral and maxillofacial surgery: review of the last 15 years. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2012; 50 (5) 385-388
• 8 Raine JE. An analysis of successful litigation claims in children in England. Arch Dis Child 2011; 96 (9) 838-840
• 9 Gossage JA, Forshaw MJ. Prevalence and outcome of litigation claims in England after laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Int J Clin Pract 2010; 64 (13) 1832-1835
• 10 Alkhaffaf B, Decadt B. 15 years of litigation following laparoscopic cholecystectomy in England. Ann Surg 2010; 251 (4) 682-685
• 11 Markides GA, Subar D, Al-Khaffaf H. Litigation claims in vascular surgery in the United Kingdom's NHS. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg 2008; 36 (4) 452-457
• 12 Dobbie AE, Cooke MW. A descriptive review and discussion of litigation claims against ambulance services. Emerg Med J 2008; 25 (7) 455-458
• 13 Vijh R, Anand V. Malpractice litigation in patients in relation to delivery of breast care in the NHS. Breast 2008; 17 (2) 148-151
• 14 Roy PG, Soonawalla ZF, Grant HW. Medicolegal costs of bile duct injuries incurred during laparoscopic cholecystectomy. HPB (Oxford) 2009; 11 (2) 130-134
• 15 Oliver D, Killick S, Even T, Willmott M. Do falls and falls-injuries in hospital indicate negligent care–and how big is the risk? A retrospective analysis of the NHS Litigation Authority Database of clinical negligence claims, resulting from falls in hospitals in England 1995 to 2006. Qual Saf Health Care 2008; 17 (6) 431-436
• 16 Ali N. A decade of clinical negligence in ophthalmology. BMC Ophthalmol 2007; 7: 20
• 17 McNeill A. Neurological negligence claims in the NHS from 1995 to 2005. Eur J Neurol 2007; 14 (4) 399-402
• 18 Savage JR, Weiner GM. Litigation in otolaryngology - trends and recommendations. J Laryngol Otol 2006; 120 (12) 1001-1004
• 19 Regan F, Murphy MF. National Health Service Litigation Authority claims for 'wrong blood' episodes. Transfus Med 2003; 13 (2) 99-100
• 20 Campbell WB, France F, Goodwin HM. Medicolegal claims in vascular surgery. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 2002; 84 (3) 181-184
• 21 Oyebode F. Clinical errors and medical negligence. Med Princ Pract 2013; 22 (4) 323-333
• 22 Mead J. National Health Service Litigation Authority: 10 years on. Clin Med 2006; 6 (1) 57-60
• 23 Harvey IM, Roberts CJ. Clinical guidelines, medical litigation, and the current medical defence system. Lancet 1987; 1 (8525) 145-147
• 24 Quam L, Fenn P, Dingwall R. Medical malpractice in perspective. II–The implications for Britain. Br Med J (Clin Res Ed) 1987; 294 (6587) 1597-1600