Analysis of Data Associated with Seemingly Temporal Clustering of a Rare Disease

Abstract:

Three statistical tests aimed at detecting temporal clustering within a given short series of diagnoses are presented. These tests are based on a standardized time interval between consecutive diagnoses. Two of the tests (the Cuscore and the Sets tests) are derived from sequential monitoring techniques which are sensitive to temporal clustering within the data set. The third test (R test) is not sequential and its sensitivity is focused on the average increase in the overall rate of the disease rather than on clustering within the series. Power curves are presented for conditions related to the intensity level of the subtle epidemic, the cluster size and the number of diagnoses. None of the techniques showed highest efficiency over all the specified conditions. The R test is the most efficient when the relative risk is 2 or less, and the Cuscore test is the most efficient method when the relative risk is ≥2.5.

Keywords

Cuscore - Sets Technique - Subtle Epidemic

• REFERENCES

• 1 Stielber T. LANL dumped untreated N-waste. Albuquerque Journal. August 4 1991
• 2 Modan B, Blumstein Z, Luxenburg O, Novi-kov I, Shemer J. A potential risk of cancer in central laboratory. Stat Med 1986; 15: 759-63.
• 3 Chen R. A surveillance system for congenital malformations. J Am Stat Ass 1978; 73: 323-7.
• 4 Chen R, Mantel N, Connelly RR. A monitoring system for chronic diseases. Meth Inform Med 1982; 21: 86-90.
• 5 Wolter C. Monitoring intervals between rare events: A cumulative score procedure compared with Rina Chen's sets technique. Meth Inform Med 1987; 26: 215-9.
• 6 Cox DR, Oakes D. Analysis of Survival Data. London, New York: Chapman and Hall; 1984
• 7 Vianna NJ, Greenland P, Brady J, et al. Hodgkin's disease: Cases with features of a community outbreak. Ann Intern Med 1972; 77: 169-80.
• 8 Raubertas R. An analysis of disease surveillance data that uses the geographic locations of the reporting units. Stat Med 1989; 8: 267-71.
• 9 Chen R, Connelly RR, Mantel N. Analyzing post alarm data in a monitoring system, in order to accept or reject the alarm. Stat Med 1993; 12: 1807-12.
• 10 Chen R. Detection of Cancer Subtle “Epidemics” in Small Communities (Ph.D Thesis). Sackler School of Medicine, Tel Aviv University; 1996
• 11 Chen R. Exploratory analysis as a sequel to suspected increased rate of cancer in a small residential or workplace. Stat Med 1996; 15: 807-16.