Knowledge-Based Decision Support for Diagnosis and Therapy: On the Multiple Usability of Patient Data

Abstract:

Expert systems in medicine are frequently restricted to assisting the physician to derive a patient-specific diagnosis and therapy proposal. In many cases, however, there is a clinical need to use these patient data for other purposes as well. The intention of this paper is to show how and to what extent patient data in expert systems can additionally be used to create clinical registries and for statistical data analysis. At first, the pitfalls of goal-oriented mechanisms for the multiple usability of data are shown by means of an example. Then a data acquisition and inference mechanism is proposed, which includes a procedure for controlling selection bias, the so-called knowledge-based attribute selection. The functional view and the architectural view of expert systems suitable for the multiple usability of patient data is outlined in general and then by means of an application example. Finally, the ideas presented are discussed and compared with related approaches.

Key-Words:

Decision Support - Diagnosis - Therapy - Expert Systems - Clinical Registries - Attribute Selection

• REFERENCES

• 1 Ledley RS, Lusted LB. Reasoning Foundations of Medical Diagnosis. Science 1959; 130: 9-21.
• 2 Buchanan BG, Shortliffe EH. ed Rule-Based Expert Systems – the MYCIN Experiments of the Stanford Heuristic Programming Project. Reading, Ma: Addison-Wesley Publ Comp; 1984
• 3 Clancey WJ, Shortliffe EH. ed Readings in Medical Artificial Intelligence – the First Decade. Reading, Ma: Addison-Wesley Publ Comp; 1984
• 4 Haux R. Expertensysteme in der Medizin. Habilitation Thesis, University of Technology Aachen. 1987
• 5 de Dombal FT. Computer-Aided Decision Support – the Obstacles to Progress. Meth Inform Med 1987; 26: 183-4.
• 6 de Lotto I, Stefanelli M. ed Proceedings of the First International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence in Medicine. Amsterdam: North-Holland Publ Comp; 1985
• 7 Fox J, Fieschi M, Engelbrecht R. ed AIME 87 – Proceedings of the European Conference on Artificial Intelligence in Medicine. Berlin: Springer Verlag; 1987
• 8 Jesdinsky HJ. Diagnose-Modelle in der Medizin. Meth Inform Med 1972; 11: 48-59.
• 9 Reichertz PL. Expertensysteme und das medizinische Umfeld. In Hommel G, Schindler S. ed GI – 16. Jahrestagung. Berlin: Springer Verlag; Vol II 1986: 465-9.
• 10 Rienhoff U, Piccolo U, Schneider B. ed Expert Systems and Decision Support in Medicine. Berlin: Springer Verlag; 1988
• 11 Schwartz WB, Patil RS, Szolovits P. Artificial Intelligence in Medicine – where do we stand?. New Engl J Med 1987; 316: 685-8.
• 12 Szolovits P. ed Artificial Intelligence in Medicine. Boulder, Co: Westview Press; 1982
• 13 Victor N. Probleme des Einsatzes entscheidungstheoretischer Methoden in der medizinischen Diagnostik. In Brauer W. ed GI – 11. Jahrestagung. Berlin: Springer Verlag; 1981: 557-67.
• 14 Wagner G, Tautu P, Wolber U. Problems of Medical Diagnosis – a Bibliography. Meth Inform Med 1978; 17: 55-74.
• 15 Reichertz PL. Hospital Information Systems – Past, Present, Future-Keynote address, Medical Informatics Europe ‘84, Brussels. 1984: 10-13. Sept (manuscript)
• 16 Reichertz PL. Preparing for Change: Concepts and Education in Medical Informatics. Comput Meth Programs Biomed 1987; 25: 89-102.
• 17 van Bemmel JH. Decision Support in Medicine. In Rienhoff U, Piccolo U, Schneider B. ed Expert Systems and Decision Support in Medicine. Berlin: Springer Verlag; 1988: 3-19.
• 18 van Bemmel JH. Medical Data, Information, and Knowledge. Meth Inform Med 1988; 27: 109-10.
• 19 Dambrosia JM, Ellenberg JH. Statistical Considerations for a Medical Data Base. Biometrics 1980; 36: 323-32.
• 20 Feinstein A. The Role of Observational Studies in the Evaluation of Therapies. Stat Medicine 1984; 3: 341-5.
• 21 Laszlo J. Health Registry and Clinical Data Base Technology: with Special Emphasis to Cancer Registries. J Chron Dis 1985; 38: 67-78.
• 22 Mantel N. Cautions in the Use of Medical Databases. Stat Medicine 1983; 2: 355-62.
• 23 Szolovits P. Types of Knowledge as Basis for Reasoning in Medical Al Programs. In de Lotto I, Stefanelli M. ed Proceedings of the First International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence in Medicine. Amsterdam: North-Holland Publ Comp; 1985: 209-26.
• 24 Hickam DH, Shortliffe EH, Bischoff MB, Scott AC, Jacobs CD. The Treatment Advice of a Computer-Based Cancer Chemotherapy Protocol Advisor. Ann Internal Med 1985; 103: 928-36.
• 25 Wetter T. Ein modallogisch beschriebenes Expertensystem, ausgeführt am Beispiel von Ohrenerkrankungen. Doctoral thesis, University of Technology Aachen. 1984
• 26 Heinen P, Reusch H, Richter MM, Wetter T. Formal Description of Objects, Processes and Levels of Expert Reasoning. In Stoyan H. ed GWAI-85, 9th German Workshop on Artificial Intelligence. Berlin: Springer Verlag; 1986: 285-94.
• 27 Richter MM. Architecture and Applications of Expert Systems. In Haux R. ed Expert Systems in Statistics. Stuttgart: Fischer Verlag; 1986: 9-24.
• 28 Haux R. Zur Problematik der Integration von Expertensystemen in Krankenhausinformationssysteme. In Hommel G, Schindler S. ed GI – 16. Jahrestagung. Berlin: Springer Verlag; Vol II 1986: 565-79.
• 29 Haux R, Höfener J, Ingenerf J, Repges R, Richter MM, Mösges R, Schmelzer B, Schlöndorff G. Knowledge-Based Therapy Support for Laryngeal Tumour Diseases: Design and Structure of the ESTHER System. In Rienhoff U, Piccolo U, Schneider B. ed Expert Systems and Decision Support in Medicine. Berlin: Springer Verlag; 1988: 225-34.
• 30 Höfener J. Entwicklung von Inferenzstrategien zur Verknüpfung von Daten- und Wissensbanken, ausgeführt am Beispiel von Kehlkopftumorerkrankungen. Diploma thesis, University of Technology Aachen. 1987
• 31 Schmelzer B, Mösges R, Schlöndorff G, Haux R, Höfener J, Repges R, Richter MM. Eine Daten- und Wissensbank zur Unterstützung des HNO-Arztes bei malignen Tumoren des Kehlkopfes. Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology 1987; 244 Supplement II 196-7.
• 32 Codd EF. Extending the Database Relational Model to Capture More Meaning. ACM Trans Database Syst 1979; 4: 397-434.
• 33 Haux R, Winter A. Universal Relation Assumptions in a Modified RM/T Data Model. Submitted for publication.
• 34 Goldberg A. SMALLTALK-80 – the Interactive Programming Environment. Reading, Ma: Addison-Wesley Publ Comp; 1984
• 35 Politakis R, Weiss SM. Using Empirical Analysis to Refine Expert System Knowledge Bases. Artif Intelligence 1984; 22: 23-48.
• 36 Pryor TH, Gardner RM, Clayton PD, Warner HR. The HELP System. J Med Systems 1983; 7: 87-102.
• 37 Kent DL, Shortliffe EH, Carlson RW, Bischoff MB, Jacobs CD. Improvements in Data Collection through Physician Use of a Computer-Based Chemotherapy Consultant. J Clin Oncology 1985; 3: 1409-17.
• 38 Hyödynmaa S, Kolari P, Näriäinen K, Ojala A, Rantanen J, Saranummi N. Decision Support System in Oncology. In Rienhoff U, Piccolo U, Schneider B. ed Expert Systems and Decision Support in Medicine. Berlin: Springer Verlag; 1988: 65-8.
• 39 Puppe B, Puppe F. A Knowledge Representation Concept Facilitating Construction and Maintenance of Large Knowledge Bases. Meth Inform Med 1988; 27: 10-16.
• 40 Spiegelhalter DJ. Handling Uncertainty in Medical Expert Systems. IASC Selected Papers, Proceedings of the 45th Session of the International Statistical Institute. Voorburg, NL: IASC; 1985: 211-29.