Heritability of a Quantitative and Qualitative Protease Inhibitor Polymorphism in Nicotiana attenuata

Abstract

Many plant species contain chemical defenses that protect them against herbivores. Despite the benefit of these chemical defenses, not all individuals contain high levels of these compounds. In the native tobacco Nicotiana attenuata we found that plants from three natural populations differed considerably in their ability to produce trypsin protease inhibitors (PIs), which are defensive proteins that reduce herbivore damage to plants. Plants from a Utah (U) population produced high levels, whereas plants from Arizona (A) contained no detectable PI levels. Californian (C) plants had intermediate levels. The PI-producing U and C plants thus differ quantitatively from each other, whereas they both differ qualitatively from PI-deficient A plants. Here we analyze how PI production is inherited in N. attenuata with the ultimate goal of better understanding how the quantitative and qualitative differences between the three populations have evolved. Using a series of classical crossing designs, we determined that the ability to produce PIs is inherited as a dominant Mendelian trait. PI-deficient plants contain two non-functional recessive alleles, whereas heterozygous plants or homozygous dominant plants both are able to produce PIs. Similarly, the level of constitutive PIs may be determined by its genotype, either by an interaction between a functional and a non-functional allele in heterozygotes, or by a factor on the PI allele itself in homozygous C plants. Based on these data and on previous studies with A and U plants we postulate that the PI-deficient A plants may have originated from a mutant that lost its ability to produce PIs. The fitness loss due to reduced herbivore resistance may be offset by the fitness gain associated with increased competitive ability, a trade-off which may maintain this mutation in the Arizona population.

Key words

Defense polymorphism - diallel cross - functional allele - heritability - Mendelian trait - natural selection

References

• 1 Atkinson A. H., Heath R. L., Simpson R. J., Clarke A. E., Anderson M. A.. Proteinase inhibitors in Nicotiana alata stigmas are derived from a precursor protein which is processed into five homologous inhibitors.  Plant Cell. (1993);  5 203-213
• 2 Baldwin I. T.. Methyl jasmonate-induced nicotine production in Nicotiana attenuata: Inducing defenses in the field without wounding.  Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata. (1996);  80 213-220
• 3 Baldwin I. T., Schmelz E. A.. Immunological “memory” in the induced accumulation of nicotine in wild tobacco.  Ecology. (1996);  77 236-246
• 4 Baldwin I. T., Staszak-Kozinski L., Davidson R.. Up in smoke: I. Smoke-derived germination cues for postfire annual, Nicotiana attenuata .  Torr. Ex. Watson. J. Chem. Ecol.. (1994);  20 2345-2371
• 5 Bergelson J., Purrington C. B.. Surveying patterns in the cost of resistance in plants.  American Naturalist. (1996);  148 536-558
• 6 Bode W., Huber R.. Natural protein proteinase inhibitors and their interaction with proteinases.  Eur. J. Biochem.. (1992);  204 433-451
• 7 Bolter C. J., Dicke M., Van Loon J. J. A., Visser J. H., Posthumus M. A.. Attraction of Colorado potato beetle to herbivore-damaged plants during herbivory and after its termination.  J. Chem. Ecol.. (1997);  23 1003-1023
• 8 Bolter C. J., Latoszek Green M., Tenuta M.. Dependence of methyl jasmonate- and wound-induced cysteine proteinase inhibitor activity on nitrogen concentration.  J. Plant Physiol.. (1998);  152 427-432
• 9 Bradford M. N.. A rapid and sensitive method for the quantization of microgram quantities of protein using the principle of dye binding.  Analytical Biochemistry. (1976);  72 248-254
• 10 Elle E., van Dam N. M., Hare J. D.. Cost of glandular trichomes, a “resistance” character in Datura wrightii Regel (Solanaceae).  Evolution. (1999);  53 22-35
• 11 Glawe G. A., Zavala J. A., Kessler A., van Dam N. M., Baldwin I. T.. Ecological costs and benefits are correlated with trypsin proteinase inhibitor production in Nicotiana attenuata. .  Ecology. (2003);  84 79-90
• 12 Goodspeed T. H.. The genus Nicotiana. Origins, relationships and evolution of its species in the light if their distribution, morphology and cytogenetics. Verdoorn, F., ed. Chronica Botanic, An International Collection of Studies in the Method and History of Biology and Agriculture Vol. 16. Walthan, Mass., USA; Chronica Botanica Company (1954): 427-430
• 13 Hayden K. J., Parker I. M.. Plasticity in cyanogenesis of Trifolium repens: inducibility, fitness costs and variable expression.  Evolutionary Ecology Research. (2002);  4 155-168
• 14 Heath R. L., Barton P. A., Simpson R. J., Reid G. E., Lim G., Anderson M. A.. Characterization of the protease processing sites in a multidomain proteinase inhibitor precursor from Nicotiana Alata. .  Eur. J. Biochem.. (1995);  230 250-257
• 15 Heath R. L., McDonald G., Christeller J. T., Lee M., Bateman K., West J., Vanheeswijck R., Anderson M. A.. Proteinase inhibitors from Nicotiana alata enhance plant resistance to insect pests.  J. Insect Physiol.. (1997);  43 833-842
• 16 Johnson R., Narvaez J., An G., Ryan C.. Expression of proteinase inhibitors I and II in transgenic Tobacco plants: effects on natural defense against Manduca sexta larvae.  Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. (1989);  86 9871-9875
• 17 Jongsma M. A., Bakker P. L., Stiekema W. J.. Quantitative determination of serine proteinase inhibitor activity using a radial diffusion assay.  Analytical Biochemistry. (1993);  212 79-84
• 18 Jongsma M. A., Bakker P. L., Visser B., Stiekema W. J.. Trypsin inhibitor activity in mature tobacco and tomato plants is mainly induced locally in response to insect attack, wounding and virus infection.  Planta. (1994);  195 29-35
• 19 Jongsma M. A., Bolter C.. The adaptation of insects to plant protease inhibitors.  J. Insect Physiol.. (1997);  43 885-895
• 20 Karban R., Baldwin I. T.. Induced Responses to Herbivory. Chicago, Illinois, USA; University of Chicago Press (1997)
• 21 Kendrew J., Lawrence E.. eds. .The Encyclopedia of Molecular Biology. Oxford; Blackwell Science Ltd (1994)
• 22 Koiwa H., Bressan R. A., Hasegawa P. M.. Regulation of protease inhibitors and plant defense.  Trends in Plant Science,. (1997);  2 379-384
• 23 Maynard Smith J.. Evolutionary Genetics. 2nd. ed. Oxford; Oxford University Press (1998)
• 24 Schittko U., Preston C. A., Baldwin I. T.. Eating the evidence? Manduca sexta larvae can not disrupt specific jasmonate induction in Nicotiana attenuata by rapid consumption.  Planta.. (2000);  210 343-346
• 25 Seigler D. S.. Cyanide and cyanogenic glycosides. Rosenthal G. and Berenbaum, M. R., eds. Herbivores. Their interaction with secondary metabolites. Vol. I. The chemical participants. San Diego; Academic Press (1991): 35-77
• 26 van Dam N. M., Baldwin I. T.. Cost of jasmonate-induced responses in plants competing for limited resources.  Ecology Letters. (1998);  1 30-33
• 27 van Dam N. M., Hare J. D.. Biological activity of Datura wrightii glandular trichome exudate against Manduca sexta larvae.  J. Chem. Ecol.. (1998 a);  24 1529-1549
• 28 van Dam N. M., Hare J. D.. Differences in distribution and performance of two sap-sucking herbivores on glandular and non-glandular Datura wrightii. .  Ecological Entomology. (1998 b);  23 22-32
• 29 van Dam N. M., Hare J. D., Elle E.. Inheritance and distribution of trichome phenotypes in Datura wrightii. .  Journal of Heredity. (1999);  90 220-227
• 30 van Dam N. M., Horn M., Mares M., Baldwin I. T.. Ontogeny constrains the systemic proteinase inhibitor response in Nicotiana attenuata. .  J. Chem. Ecol.. (2001);  27 547-568
• 31 van Dam N. M., Vrieling K.. Genetic variation in constitutive and inducible pyrrolizidine alkaloid levels in Cynoglossum officinale. .  L. Oecologia. (1994);  99 374-378
• 32 van der Meijden E.. Plant defence, an evolutionary dilemma: Contrasting effects of (specialist and generalist) herbivores and natural enemies.  Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata. (1996);  80 307-310
• 33 Viette M., Tettamani C., Saucy F.. Preference for acyanogenic white clover (Trifolium repens) in the vole Arvicole terrestris. .  II. Generalization and further investigations. J. Chem. Ecol.. (2000);  26 101-122
• 34 Vrieling K., De Jong T. J., Klinkhamer P. G. L., van der Meijden E., van der Veen Van Wijk C. A. M.. Testing trade-offs among growth, regrowth and anti-herbivore defences in Senecio jacobaea. .  Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata. (1996);  80 189-192
• 35 Zhang Z. P., Baldwin I. T.. Transport of (2 - ¹⁴C)jasmonic acid from leaves to roots mimics wound-induced changes in endogenous jasmonic acid pools in Nicotiana sylvestris. .  Planta. (1997);  203 436-441

Section Editor: M. Koornneef