Some Guiding Principles in Emerging Models of Voice Therapy for Children

Abstract

Voice disorders are the most common communication disorder across the life span, affecting more than five million school-aged children annually in the United States alone. Although such disorders are commonly associated with benign pathology, medically malicious conditions cannot be ruled out without proper medical examination by an otolaryngologist. Many children with voice disorders are otherwise healthy. However, some are not. Moreover, children with voice problems of any origin often experience distinctly negative consequences in quality of life and academic participation as a result of them. Regrettably, this population is badly underserved by speech-language pathology. In this article, possible reasons are suggested, among them the relative unattractiveness of traditional therapy that emphasizes voice conservation using a Skinnerian paradigm. Alternatives are presented in terms of foundational principles of biomechanics, biology, and learning and factors affecting children's compliance with health care directives, which may help to shape the next generation of pediatric voice therapies. The article concludes with discussion of challenges surrounding voice therapy in the school setting and possible solutions.

Keywords

Pediatric voice therapy - phonotrauma - biomechanics - biology - learning - compliance

• References

• 1 Akif Kiliç M, Okur E, Yildirim I, Güzelsoy S. The prevalence of vocal fold nodules in school age children. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 2004; 68: 409-412
• 2 McNamara AP, Perry CK. Vocal abuse prevention practices. Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch 1994; 25: 105-111
• 3 Carding PN, Roulstone S, Northstone K ; ALSPAC Study Team. The prevalence of childhood dysphonia: a cross-sectional study. J Voice 2006; 20: 623-630
• 4 Maddern BR, Campbell TF, Stool S. Pediatric voice disorders. Otolaryngol Clin North Am 1991; 24: 1125-1140
• 5 De Bodt MS, Ketelslagers K, Peeters T , et al. Evolution of vocal fold nodules from childhood to adolescence. J Voice 2007; 21: 151-156
• 6 Ramig LO, Verdolini K. Treatment efficacy: voice disorders. J Speech Lang Hear Res 1998; 41: S101-S116
• 7 Smith E, Kirchner HL, Taylor M, Hoffman H, Lemke JH. Voice problems among teachers: differences by gender and teaching characteristics. J Voice 1998; 12: 328-334
• 8 Sander EK. Arguments against the aggressive pursuit of voice therapy for children. Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch 1989; 20: 94-101
• 9 Hirschberg J, Dejonckere PH, Hirano M, Mori K, Schultz-Coulon HJ, Vrticka K. Voice disorders in children. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 1995; 32 (Suppl) S109-S125
• 10 Hartnick CJ. Validation of a pediatric voice quality-of-life instrument: the pediatric voice outcome survey. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2002; 128: 919-922
• 11 Merati AL, Keppel K, Braun NM, Blumin JH, Kerschner JE. Pediatric Voice-Related Quality of Life: findings in healthy children and in common laryngeal disorders. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 2008; 117: 259-262
• 12 Connor NP, Cohen SB, Theis SM, Thibeault SL, Heatley DG, Bless DM. Attitudes of children with dysphonia. J Voice 2008; 22: 197-209
• 13 Marcus L, Kieman B, Barkmeier-Kraemer J. The association of a preschool voice education program with changes in yelling frequency. Semin Speech Lang 2013; 34: 103-115
• 14 Castrogiovanni A. Incidence and prevalence of communication disorders and hearing loss in children—2008 edition. 2008 . Available at: http://www.asha.org/research/reports/children.htm . Accessed February 21, 2013
• 15 Kahane JC, Mayo R. The need for aggressive pursuit of healthy childhood voices. Language, Speech, and Hearing Servies in Schools 1989; 20: 102-107
• 16 Hoffman Ruddy B, Lewis V, Sapienza C. The role of the speech-language pathologist in the schools for the treatment of voice disorders: working within the framework of the individuals with disabilities education improvement act. Semin Speech Lang 2013; 34: 55-62
• 17 Ruddy BH, Sapienza CM. Treating voice disorders in the school-based setting: working within the framework of IDEA. Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch 2004; 35: 327-332
• 18 American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. Preferred Practice Patterns for the Profession of Speech-Language Pathology: Voice Assessment; Clinical Process. 2004 . Available at: http://www.asha.org/policy/PP2004-00191.htm#sec1.3.34 . Accessed February 21, 2013
• 19 Moran M, Pentz A. Otolaryngologists' opinion of voice therapy for vocal nodules in children. Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch 1987; 18: 172-178
• 20 Benjamin B, Croxson G. Vocal nodules in children. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1987; 96: 530-533
• 21 Gray SD, Hammond E, Hanson DF. Benign pathologic responses of the larynx. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1995; 104: 13-18
• 22 Wetmore R. Management of pediatric voice disorders. Arch Otolaryngol 2005; 131: 72
• 23 Wohl DL. Nonsurgical management of pediatric vocal fold nodules. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2005; 131: 68-70 , discussion 71–72
• 24 Silverman EM. Incidence of chronic hoarseness among school-age children. J Speech Hear Disord 1975; 40: 211-215
• 25 Smith M. Care of the child's voice: a pediatric otolaryngologist's perspective. Semin Speech Lang 2013; 34: 63-70
• 26 Roy N, Gray SD, Simon M, Dove H, Corbin-Lewis K, Stemple JC. An evaluation of the effects of two treatment approaches for teachers with voice disorders: a prospective randomized clinical trial. J Speech Lang Hear Res 2001; 44: 286-296
• 27 McAllister A, Sjolander P. Children's voice and voice disorders. Semin Speech Lang 2013; 34: 71-79
• 28 Niedzielski A, Niedzielska G, Gwizda G. Personality features of children treated due to vocal nodules. Ann Univ Mariae Curie Sklodowska Med 2002; 57: 53-57
• 29 Verdolini-Marston K, Burke MK, Lessac A, Glaze L, Caldwell E. Preliminary study of two methods of treatment for laryngeal nodules. J Voice 1995; 9: 74-85
• 30 Verdolini Abbott K, Hersan R, Hammer D, Potter Reed J. Adventures in Voice. Kankakee, IL: MultiVoiceDimensions; 2010
• 31 Titze IR. Mechanical stress in phonation. J Voice 1994; 8: 99-105
• 32 Berry DA, Verdolini K, Montequin DW, Hess MM, Chan RW, Titze IR. A quantitative output-cost ratio in voice production. J Speech Lang Hear Res 2001; 44: 29-37
• 33 Peterson KL, Verdolini-Marston K, Barkmeier JM, Hoffman HT. Comparison of aerodynamic and electroglottographic parameters in evaluating clinically relevant voicing patterns. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1994; 103 (5 Pt 1) 335-346
• 34 Verdolini K, Druker DG, Palmer PM, Samawi H. Laryngeal adduction in resonant voice. J Voice 1998; 12: 315-327
• 35 Titze IR. The physics of small-amplitude oscillation of the vocal folds. J Acoust Soc Am 1988; 83: 1536-1552
• 36 Titze IR, Verdolini Abbott K. Vocology. Salt Lake City, UT: National Center for Voice and Speech; 2012
• 37 Xu Z, Buckley MJ, Evans CH, Agarwal S. Cyclic tensile strain acts as an antagonist of IL-1 beta actions in chondrocytes. J Immunol 2000; 165: 453-460
• 38 Branski RC, Verdolini K, Sandulache V, Rosen CA, Hebda PA. Vocal fold wound healing: a review for clinicians. J Voice 2006; 20: 432-442
• 39 Verdolini Abbott K, Li NYK, Branski RC , et al. Vocal exercise may attenuate acute vocal fold inflammation. J Voice 2012; 26: 814. e1-e13
• 40 Skinner BF. About Behaviorism. New York, NY: Random House; 1976
• 41 Miller GA. The cognitive revolution: a historical perspective. Trends Cogn Sci 2003; 7: 141-144
• 42 Wulf G, Weigelt C. Instructions about physical principles in learning a complex motor skill: to tell or not to tell…. Res Q Exerc Sport 1997; 68: 362-367
• 43 Wulf G, Lauterbach B, Toole T. The learning advantages of an external focus of attention in golf. Res Q Exerc Sport 1999; 70: 120-126
• 44 Wulf G, McNevin NH, Fuchs T, Ritter F, Toole T. Attentional focus in complex skill learning. Res Q Exerc Sport 2000; 71: 229-239
• 45 Crews DJ, Landers DM. Electroencephalographic measures of attentional patterns prior to the golf putt. Med Sci Sports Exerc 1993; 25: 116-126
• 46 Mangum G . The neurophysiology of golf putting: the Mayo Clinic takes a stab at the “yips.” 2002 . Available at: http://www.puttingzone.com/Dystonia/yipsstudy.html . Accessed on April 16, 2013
• 47 Plessinger A . The effects of mental imagery on athletic performance. Available at: http://www.vanderbilt.edu/AnS/psychology/health_psychology/mentalimagery.html . Accessed February 18, 2013
• 48 Altenmüller E, Gruhn W, Parlitz D, Kahrs J. Music learning produces changes in brain activation patterns: a longitudinal DC-EEG-Study. International Journal of Arts Medicine 1997; 5: 28-34
• 49 Altenmüller E, Bangert M, Liebert G, Gruhn W. Mozart in us: how the brain processes music. Med Probl Perform Art 2000; 15: 99-106
• 50 Verdolini-Marston K, Balota DA. Role of elaborative and perceptual integrative processes in perceptual-motor performance. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn 1994; 20: 739-749
• 51 Schmidt RA, Lee TD. Motor Control and Learning: A Behavioral Emphasis. 5th ed. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics; 2011
• 52 Bilodeau EA, Bilodeau IM, Schumsky DA. Some effects of introducing and withdrawing knowledge of results early and late in practice. J Exp Psychol 1959; 58: 142-144
• 53 Lee TD, White MA, Carnahan H. On the role of knowledge of results in motor learning: exploring the guidance hypothesis. J Mot Behav 1990; 22: 191-208
• 54 Sidaway B, Ahn S, Boldeau P, Griffin S, Noyes B, Pelletier K. A comparison of manual guidance and knowledge of results in the learning of a weight-bearing skill. J Neurol Phys Ther 2008; 32: 32-38
• 55 Vander Linden DW, Cauraugh JH, Greene TA. The effect of frequency of kinetic feedback on learning an isometric force production task in nondisabled subjects. Phys Ther 1993; 73: 79-87
• 56 Weeks DL, Kordus RN. Relative frequency of knowledge of performance and motor skill learning. Res Q Exerc Sport 1998; 69: 224-230
• 57 Weeks DJ, Zekaznik H, Beyak B. An empirical note on reduced frequency of knowledge of results. J Hum Mov Stud 1993; 25: 193-201
• 58 Steinhauer K, Grayhack JP. The role of knowledge of results in performance and learning of a voice motor task. J Voice 2000; 14: 137-145
• 59 Wulf G, Schmidt RA, Deubel H. Reduced feedback frequency enhances generalized motor program learning but not parameterization learning. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn 1993; 19: 1134-1150
• 60 Winstein CJ, Schmidt RA. Reduced frequency of knowledge of results enhances motor skill learning. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn 1990; 16: 677-691
• 61 Wulf G, Schmidt RA. The learning of generalized motor programs: reducing the relative frequency of knowledge of results enhances memory. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn 1989; 15: 748-757
• 62 Schmidt RA, Wulf G. Continuous concurrent feedback degrades skill learning: implications for training and simulation. Hum Factors 1997; 39: 509-525
• 63 Shea JB. Morgan. Contextual interference effects on the acquisition, retention, and transfer of a motor skill. J Exp Psychol Hum Learn 1979; 5: 179-187
• 64 Seymour WD. Experiments on the acquisition of industrial skills. Occup Psychol 1954; 28: 77-89
• 65 Adams JA, Hufford LE. Contributions of a part-task trainer to the learning and relearning of a time-shared flight maneuver. Hum Factors 1962; 4: 159-170
• 66 Zavala A, Locke EA, Van Cott HP, Fleishman EA. The analysis of helicopter pilot performance. Washington, DC: American Institutes for Research; 1965
• 67 McCracken HD, Stelmach GE. A test of the schema theory of discrete motor learning. J Mot Behav 1977; 9: 193-201
• 68 Greene D, Lepper MR. Effects of extrinsic rewards on children's subsequent intrinsic interest. Child Dev 1974; 45: 1141-1145
• 69 Sergl HG, Klages U, Zentner A. Functional and social discomfort during orthodontic treatment—effects on compliance and prediction of patients' adaptation by personality variables. Eur J Orthod 2000; 22: 307-315
• 70 Gottlob I, Awan M, Proudlock F. The role of compliance in 2 vs 6 hours of patching in children with amblyopia. Arch Ophthalmol 2004; 122: 422-423 , author reply 424–425
• 71 Schöbinger R, Florin I, Reichbauer M, Lindemann H, Zimmer C. Childhood asthma: mothers' affective attitude, mother-child interaction and children's compliance with medical requirements. J Psychosom Res 1993; 37: 697-707
• 72 Johnson PD, Cohen DA, Aiosa L, McGorray S, Wheeler T. Attitudes and compliance of pre-adolescent children during early treatment of CLASS II malocclusion. Clin Orthod Res 1998; 1: 20-28